39 min · 1,018 words · 26 July 1990
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the second noble truth, true sources (karma and attachment, with attachment as the root) which cause repeated appropriation of suffering aggregates. It describes how the path, especially realization of emptiness that removes ignorance and attachment, leads to true cessation. It also notes the four truths can be practised with lesser or great vehicle motivation.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 40 min
UUID: afae73d1-244f-4a60-a475-5979aca1a4a2
Date: 1990-07-26
Words: 1,014
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:00:01-00:02:31] [non-English speech, 24 s, detected ko 0.30] Most of the happinesses that we’ve experienced are in fact examples of suffering extreme. When we’re very hungry, we haven’t eaten for a while. And initially upon eating, the food tastes quite delicious because we’re so hungry. But as we continue to eat, there will reach a point when the food will no longer be experienced as delicious as it was. In fact, if we were to continue eating, What was experienced as happiness begins to be experienced as suffering. And likewise, when we’re boarding out for a walk, we become tired. And so we sit down for a while. And at first, that experience is quite relaxing, sitting down. But if we continue to sit and sit and sit and sit, it becomes uncomfortable. And so again, we have to get up and begin moving again. So all of these pleasures, yet they’re continued to transform into something which is dissatisfactory. So these are examples of the suffering of change. So we said that the aggregates were suffering. And why is that? It’s because they are, they arise under the influence of karma and afflictive emotions and therefore they are classified, the aggregates are classified under the suffering of [end unchecked]
Therefore, they are classified the aggregates are classified under the suffering of pervasive compositional suffering
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:02:31-00:02:55] of universal conditionality or pervasive compositional suffering? So these contaminated aggregates are a true receptor? [end unchecked]
. What
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:03:04-00:04:03] [unclear, 28 s] The very effect of having such a contaminated aggregate that is to say the body predisposes us to suffering. Because we have a body, we have to. We are forced to go. [end unchecked]
we have to go through is the suffering of sometimes having to get up. Sometimes get that sit down. If we didn’t have it, these aggregates for the body, then we would
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:04:33-00:06:07] So it is the aggregate which is the basis for all physical suffering. It acts as the foundation for all physical suffering. It is the basis for the arisal of all suffering and therefore it is the nature of suffering. If we didn’t appropriate the aggregate of a human, we wouldn’t have to undergo the sufferings of a human. If we did not appropriate, for example, the anger of a dog, we would not experience the various sufferings which a dog has to go through. Again, if we did not appropriate the anger of the body of a cat, we would not be forced to go through the various sufferings of a cat. [end unchecked]
not be
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:06:07-00:06:31] It is because that we appropriate these particular types of bodies that the migrator must undergo that particular type of suffering. By having it too, we are predisposed to have two things. [end unchecked]
predisposed to have toothaches. By having an eye, we’re ex we’re predisposed to have eye
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:07:31-00:07:37] If we didn’t have a body, we would not have to go through all these various sufferings. [end unchecked]
problems. This is said to be in the nature of suffering.
That the the migrator experiences suffering in accordance with if we take the body, which they take on, which they appropriate. If we didn’t appropriate a body, we would not experience such suffering. So what we should arrive at, understanding this situation, is the thought
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:08:09-00:09:21] with the thought not to take on or appropriate another body. If we contemplate on this wealth, we will try to not appropriate a body which we see in its basis of our suffering. If we do not see this, then we’re going to think naturally in the reverse of this, in the sense that we’re going to always be seeking to appropriate a body. [non-English speech, 8 s, detected zh 0.41] [end unchecked]
So analogy of the situation would be that someone is caught by the police for having committed a crime and they’re put in jail. And while this prisoner, while in jail, begins to to see that the all the various faults of being in prison, how how how horrible it is. And seeing well all the difficulties and
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:10:15-00:11:49] There arise the thought to be to get out of prison. I got to get out of here. But on the other hand, it is, oh, this is a great place. I like this prison. With such a way of thinking, one is never going to think to be liberated or to want to be free from prison. [unclear, 14 s] with respect to our aggregates, particularly the aggregates of the body or form, that by seeing its various faults, seeing it as the foundation from which arises all suffering. The sufferings of, for example, birth, aging, disease, and death. Looking at each of these, all the various sufferings which are involved in birth, all the various sufferings. Sufferings which are involved in sickness, aging. What kind of sufferings do I have to go through when I die? [end unchecked]
we desire. We’re not able to get that which we desire, and we’re forced to undergo that which we don’t desire.
And again and again, considering the nature of this body, and that there’s no happiness with such a real happiness with such a type of body. And
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:12:17-00:13:14] And immediately there will rise a sense that I have to, now I have to take rid of this body. I have to make effort and striving for liberation. [non-English speech, 24 s, detected zh 0.58] [end unchecked]
nature of it’s impermanent. It’s not stable. It’s momentary. It but additionally, it arises by the force of karma and afflictive emotions, and it’s also selfless.
The That these are all the various faults of the body. That and therefore, it is the nature of suffering. That if I did not appropriate, the thought arises seeking not to appropriate this body in the future. And this is the development of renunciation in which there is a striving to be liberated from the body. It is said that if one does not recognize their suffering, there will never arise the striving to be liberated from it
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:14:17-00:16:55] [unclear, 26 s] So, according to a verse by Shantugela, which outlines the great benefits from thinking about contemplating suffering, that without the contemplation of suffering, there will never arise renunciation, there will never arise. the striving for liberation. And additionally, without considering the sufferings of psychic existence, there will never arise true love for others and true effort to be liberating for yourself from psychic existence and one will not be moved to abandon negative actions and to begin to cultivate positive ones. [non-English speech, 27 s, detected zh 0.68] So, is there a way that, by which we cannot, again, take on these suffering aggregates, by which we will not be forced to appropriate aggregates, the suffering aggregates again, that we are forced to take on the aggregates due to karma and attachment. By means of karma and attachment, we establish a relationship with it. [end unchecked]
.
Take on the aggregate due to karma and attachment. By the means of karma and attachment, we we establish a relationship with it, a new set of suffering aggregates. And if we eliminate these causes, then we will not have to we will not be forced to appropriate suffering aggregates again
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:17:57-00:18:01] Quoting a verse by Tom Kirky, in which he says, [end unchecked]
. How is it that we are forced to appropriate these suffering aggregates? It is due due to the force of karma and ignorance.
But but but mainly not ignorance. The root, the main cause — the root, the main, is attachment. Therefore, it is karma and attachment which are true sources. So what forces us to, again and again, appropriate these aggregates?
It is due to throwing karma
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:19:08-00:20:12] It is due to throwing karma, throwing karma which is activated by means of attachment. So rebirth of the body can be analogous to the growing of a flower. The main cause is the seed itself, but additionally by means of the seed coming into contact with water, then the flower will grow. [end unchecked]
. Just as in the
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:21:15-00:21:26] It’s due to the presence of the cause, that is the karma and attachment. [end unchecked]
case where But if just as in the case where though there is a seed, if it does not come in contact with water, there is not the growing of the flower
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:22:09-00:22:48] Likewise, though there may be karma, if it does not come in contact, if it’s not energized by attachment, then there will not occur the appropriating of the aggregates. We can eliminate the root of attachment and therefore we are able to eliminate true sources and not have to undergo the experience of suffering. [end unchecked]
. So these two are are the causes of true suffering, karma and attachment, and therefore, are true sources of suffering. In Tibetan, the word for true sources, which is being translated as true sources, has the idea of all or many, and means to arise. And therefore, it literally means that all our suffering arises again and again due to these factors, that is karma and afflictions. And the way we abandon true sources is through the cultivation of the path.
Specifically, the cultivation of the path, which is the realization of emptiness. Through the realization of emptiness, we are able to eliminate ignorance. Ignorance is the root of attachment. And by eliminating attachment, we we have abandoned true sources. And through that, will we will not be forced to appropriate aggregates in the future, and we will obtain liberation, which is a true cessation.
In this way, we attain liberation, which is the elimination of all suffering and the experience of complete happiness in terms of both physical well-being and mental well-being, which is experiencing no suffering whatsoever
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:27:00-00:27:25] So in the course of our practice, first women begin to understand the nature of suffering, and having understood the nature of suffering, begin to understand its cause. And by abandoning that cause, we can abandon that cause by means of the cultivation of true past, which is the method for the attainment of the happiness of true cessation. [end unchecked]
. Abandoning that cause, we but we will we can abandon that cause by means of the cultivation of true paths, which is the method for the attainment of the happiness of true cessation. So we don’t have much time today. We have more time, and we could go into the four aspects of true sources and the four aspects of true suffering and four aspects of true sources, four of true cessation, and four of true paths. Each of the four truths has four aspects making in total sixteen aspects with respect to the four truths. We can organize teaching the four noble truths into these two categories of that which is to be adopted and that which is to be rejected or that which is to be practiced and that which is to be abandoned, each having a twofold classification.
In terms of the abandonments, there are two in terms of cause and result. The cause being true sources and the result being true sufferings. And these are to be abandoned in terms of the practices. And then in terms of cause, these true paths are the necessary practice in terms of the four noble truths. But if one practices the four noble truths for the liberation of oneself alone, then then according to this motivation is a lesser vehicle practice.
But on the other hand, according to the motivation of practicing the four noble truths in order to attain Buddhahood for the sake of all sentient beings, then it’s the practice of the great vehicle. But it would not necessarily be the case that one practices the four noble truths
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:30:31-00:31:34] You said that they have three divisions and then you said they have four. Can you just explain them? There’s four aspects, three divisions. There’s three. Do you want me to pursue that? Let me see you read it. There, there. There soon. There soon. There soon you all get to know. [unclear, 7 s] [end unchecked]
only for liberation. The this is the the Buddha said, this is the noble truth of suffering. That is its nature. That’s that’s in terms of its nature.
Suffering is to be known. That is
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:33:21-00:36:08] [unclear, 1 s] When we recite the mantra, each of these is the recitation of the mantra. The Buddha made a threefold recitation on each of the four noble truths. He made a statement, a way of threefold statements to respect each of the four truths. [unclear, 25 s] we should try to contemplate what is to be adopted, what is to be rejected, and in accordance with that understanding practice as much as we are able to make various types of prayers of aspiration, such as, for example, that just as when the Buddha taught the Dharma, there arose spontaneously the realizations in the mind of these five disciples, may I too. [end unchecked]
there could spontaneously arise realizations in the mind of these five disciples, the
[Unchecked machine transcript 00:36:09-00:37:09] In the same way it came to realization. So he taught, if the Dhan was presented in terms of a presentation of cyclic existence and liberation, then true sources are the cause of cyclic existence, giving the result of true sufferings and age. [end unchecked]
true sources are to be abandoned, that by means of cultivating true paths, true paths being the cause of liberation, which has the result of true cessation. Yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
- Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.