Evening with V M McAndrew – 11 1999 08 26 blank

45 min · 4,784 words · 26 August 1999

Evening with V M McAndrew (Ven Margaret McAndrew)
Evening with V M McAndrew (Ven Margaret McAndrew)
Evening with V M McAndrew - 11 1999 08 26 blank
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Teaches the ten non-virtues of body, speech and mind, including idle gossip, covetousness, harmful intent and wrong views, with suggestions for meditating on them. Explains six factors that make karma heavy, the results of non-virtue, and how to accumulate merit through virtuous actions, rejoicing, daily motivation and dedication.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1999-08-26

Duration: 45 min

UUID: b276933d-cd56-40d8-b2f5-7466dde94cec

Words: 4,780

Yes. So you can actually say something quite nice in a very sarcastic tone of voice, and it can be quite upsetting to the other person. That’s another thing. Like I say, no. You’re very clever, aren’t you?

The person knows that you don’t that you’re being ironical. So it’s it’s not the words. It’s the the effect that’s the effect that’s the intention and the effect, really. So the next one is idle gossip, and the basis is something frivolous. The recognition is recognizing that the thing you want to talk about is frivolous.

The subject of idle gossip may or may not be a famous king. Anything can serve as the actual basis of idle gossip, or maybe a famous queen who never was, like or princess or whatever, like princess Diana. You know? I was just sort of thinking, yeah, there’s a lot of talk around her life and death. Anyway, yes, that’s just an example.

You know, we can sort of spend a lot of time talking about this and that politicians or film stars, whatever you like. The motivation is wanting to talk, and the delusion is one of the three poisons. And the deed is talking about the king, the army, or whatever. So think you can take your own examples there. So the completion It doesn’t say the completion.

I suppose the completion is when you finish talking or when you actually do the talking. Yes. I think it must come together there. Yes. Yes.

So, yes. So, anyway, so that’s the the four of speech. And actually, idle gossip can involve a lot of different things, not necessarily just chatter. It can involve all sorts of time wasting activities. So, also, it’s not always idle gossip when we have a bit of a chat.

It’s when we carry it beyond what’s reasonable and just go on wasting our time when we can be engaging in virtuous activities. And it’s the easiest of the the non virtues of body and speech to to fall into because for most of us anyway. It’s the lightest, it’s the one that in a sense becomes very strong because we do it again and again. And you might be interested to know that we can also carry out six of these seven non virtues of body and speech by getting other people to do them. And in actual fact, that’s worse because then, for instance, if you get somebody else to kill a sheep for you, then both of you get the full non virtue of the act of killing.

So which one do you think would be the one that you have to do by yourself that you can’t get somebody else to do for you? Right. Yes. Well, but, yes, there wouldn’t really seem to be. Okay.

So, we can do a little meditation on the four non virtues of speech, of, lying, divisive speech, insulting words, and idle gossip. That might be an interesting point actually to to try to look up or try to find out about as the completion of that one. Does it have to be heard by the other person like lies, or is it enough to just be gossiping away even if nobody’s listening to you? It seems to me that with idle gossip, it’s the fact that you’re doing it, even if nobody’s listening, that we could check it. So then the three of of mind, covetousness, harmful intent or malice, and wrong views.

So, with covetousness, the basis is somebody else’s property or possessions. But actually, Geshe Tashi Tsering said that and in fact, Pabongka Rinpoche says here, you can even covet your own possessions. So it’s not actually I think the the English word covet isn’t quite the the same as the. Sometimes it’s translated as attachment. It’s very, very strong attachment.

Either coveting or possessiveness. I think it would include covetousness of other people’s possessions and strong craving towards things that you can get, such as things that are for sale in the shops, and also very strong possessiveness about your own possessions or strong attachment. So the basis is these things, and the recognition is recognizing a particular object as being that particular object. This object, which is the basis of your covetousness, recognized as being that. And then the motive deed and final step go together because this is just an action of mind.

So it’s not like with body and speech where we have to, first of all, have the mental thought and then the mental thought and then the physical or verbal action but we have this mental action happening all at once. So the motive is thinking. It says the motive deed and final step must be assumed to be functions of the one thought. The motive is thinking, if only this or that favorable thing were mine. The delusion is one of the three poisons, and the deed is when the thought becomes stronger.

I will make it mine. And the final step is when the thought becomes stronger still, and you decide that you’ll employ some means of making the valuable object your own. So it doesn’t mean that you actually have to succeed in doing that but just that you have to have that thought. And it’s something that happens very easily if you’re going around the shops, for example. It can happen dozens of times in one shopping expedition, particularly here in the west in our supermarkets and our big shopping centers and so on or in the Adelaide market.

Or when you’re going around the shops that had food for sale, the food the food places. So yes. So the anyway, this is why they advise us to to stay away from those sorts of places, most of the time anyway, because it just makes your craving stronger. So then harmful intent. So the basis it’s just the basis of the of of harmful intentions are the same as those of insulting words.

So the basis for insulting words was either a sentient being or an inanimate object. So the motive is either wanting to inflict harm or such as wanting to to beat or kill that person or just wishing them harm, such as thinking, wouldn’t it be good if that person was ruined? Wouldn’t it be good if they got what was coming to them? Wouldn’t it be good if they got their comeuppance? You know?

We have these kinds of thoughts very easily, and this is harmful intent. So the deed is putting more effort into the thought, and the final step is deciding to harm that person, having the thought of harming them. And with wrong views, the basis must be something that exists. So this is talking about Dharma truth. So it’s about cause and effect and about the four noble truths and Three Jewels and so on.

And to have a wrong view is to have the view that these things are not nonexistent. In other words, denying their truth, denying their validity, saying that there’s no such thing or saying that there’s no such thing as past and future lives. So for long, I’m gonna take you as an example here of a Hindu Rishi who wanted to sleep with his own daughter. And so he he claimed that there were no other rebirths than this one so that he could do what he liked. And I don’t seems a bit strange if he was a Rishi that would that he would have that viewpoint.

But, anyway, I I think this does show the kind of state of mind that we can develop that we it sometimes in order to do what we want, we manage to convince ourselves that it’s alright one way or another. There are plenty of people in the world who are doing things that are wrong and convincing themselves that there’s only this life and that there’s no sort of future life in which they’ll have to face the results of their actions. So the recognition is like the other nine forms of recognition except that in this case, one does not recognize that the thing being denied is in fact true. So here, the person holding the wrong views doesn’t recognize that the that the that the truth that they’re denying is in fact the truth. If they did, they wouldn’t be holding it, of course, because it’s not concerned with what they say.

It’s concerned with what they’re thinking. So the deed is the intention to deny the thing serving as the basis, and the final step is to decide that it doesn’t exist. So is talking to his monks, of course, so he says there’s not much chance that they would actually be holding wrong views. But he says there is a danger of falling into wrong views by mixing with the wrong company by people who, he says, have only small amounts of merit. In other words, people who are holding these wrong views and who would influence you that way.

Yes. Well, it is. Yes. And it’s You think what you think? Yes.

You think it’s right. That’s what makes it so, destructive. Yes. Yes. It is.

Yes. Yes. The thing is that it has to mean actually holding these views. It’s not just having doubts about these things. If you have doubts about the Three Jewels, about karma, so on, that’s not holding wrong views.

It’s only when you hold some sort of very fixed view that you hold very tightly that is the opposite to these views. And so there is some possibility of seeing that you’re holding these wrong views if you see that you have some sort of emotional attachment to holding some sort of view that is contradictory to to what’s in the teachings. But, of course, it is a tricky one. So, okay. So we can meditate on those three.

The, the three non virtues of mind of covetousness, harmful intent, and wrong views. So then there are some points that can help us to understand what makes karma heavy or light. There are six of these points. So the first is that karma can be heavy by nature. So this is that some karmas are just naturally heavier than others, and the seven karmic actions of body and speech are arranged in order with the heaviest thirst.

Killing is the heaviest, and the the last idle gossip is the lightest. And this is based on the amount of suffering that these things cause to other beings. And killing is the thing that causes most suffering because we all cherish our life more than our possessions. So so therefore, killing is heavier than stealing. We we we prefer to have our possessions taken from us rather than our life.

Secondly, heavy because of the intention. If the intention is a very strong delusion, then this makes the the karma heavier. And, the example is that if you say insulting words, but the delusion so, that’s right. So he says, if you use, if you have a he you use non virtue which is by nature light, but you do it with an intention under a very strong delusion, then the nonvertebral becomes heavier. For example, he says if you say you say you mangy old dog to somebody out of very great anger, then it becomes heavy.

So any non virtue is heavier if it’s done out of anger and hatred, very strong anger, than if it’s done out of some other sort of delusion. Then heavy because of the deed, and that is because of the way it’s done. So for example, killing slowly is worse than just killing quickly. Also, which do you think, would be worse, killing an elephant or killing an insect? Would they be equal?

Why? That’s right. Yes. Because the elephant has a huge body, you can feel a lot more pain than the than the insect while you’re killing it. Then it can be heavy because of the basis, and this is the case of the the object that you’re doing the action towards.

For instance, your an action done towards your guru is much more karmically potent. So for instance, if it’s a negative action, saying something unpleasant to your guru or if I remember, it says casting dirty looks at your guru is one two three four five. This is the fifth. Sorry. No.

So it is the fourth. Sorry. Fourth. This is the fourth. Yes.

The basis. Yes. One two three four. Yes. So so they go in an order.

So the guru is the the greatest. Also, Buddhas and bodhisattvas are very heavy. I think this comes later on anyway, the actual order of heaviness. Your parents are also a heavy object. So, of course, this works both ways.

It also works for good actions. If you give your mom a present, then it’s better than you get more karma from that than giving a present to somebody else. Also, actually, in that sense, the media are also good object because you gain more good karma from particularly sick people. You gain more benefits for giving for from helping sick people than you do from, just helping somebody who isn’t as much in need of it. Heavy because of always being done, in other words, being done repetitively, That’s why idle gossip can become heavy.

And that was the fifth. Sixthly, heavy because no antidote has been applied. So if a person never performs a single virtue, then their non virtues become extra heavy. So if we understand these things, we can try to avoid doing the things that make them heavier. And then, we need to purify so that we don’t have to experience results of our non virtue.

We need No. There were only six. So, the next thing is, now we’ve got all these non virtues, what we do about them. So I’ve been through this before, I’ll just go through it quickly. No, actually I’m not up to the four opponent forces.

I’m just mentioning if we do have to, we we can purify these, and not have to experience the heavy results from these actions if we, purify them with the four opponent forces and, particularly if we purify every day. So, another thing that we have to know about is the results of our non virtue. So, there’s can be said that there are three results or four. It’s actually the same thing. It just depends on how you count it.

So if you say that there are three results, the second one has two subdivisions. So these results are, first of all, the ripened result. Secondly, the results, congruent with the cause. And there are two of these. The first is experiences congruent with the cause, and the second one is actions congruent with the cause.

I’ll I’ll I’ll tell you in a minute. And the third one is environmental results, or you can count those as one, two, three, four if you like. And those same results also come into our good actions. But here, we’re looking at the negative side. So just giving an example, with killing.

For instance, the the the ripened result, refers to a rebirth state. And in the case of killing, the rebirth state could be in the hell states. In actual fact, any of the non virtues can result in any of the any of the lower rebirth states, depending on the heaviness of the particular action. So here’s an example that it could be rebirthing in one of the hell states. And that’s the ripened result.

And the second result, result congruent with the cause, with its two aspects. The first one, the experience, congruent with the cause, could be being having finished with being born in the hell states, then you manage to get rebirth as a human being. But during that life as a human being, you’re going to have to experience results that are related to the action that you committed. And in the case of killing, this would be such things as having a short life and having to experience a lot of sickness. The second point, actions congruent with the cause, is that you have a liking for killing.

That you’re actually born having this liking, that it comes up at an early age and you tend to engage in these actions through that lifetime. And this is a very important point because it shows how these actions become self perpetuating because we engage in negative actions and then we get drawn into them again in future lifetimes and create more karma and it goes on and on. So this is something that we have to cut off and change. And the third one is the environmental result, and that can be such things in the case of killing as finding that your food medicines and so on don’t have much power to sustain life for us. They don’t don’t seem to work for us.

They don’t have a lot of strength for us. In particular, you might find that you get sick and you take medicine, and it might seem to work for a while and then after a short time it loses its effectiveness. Then you go off and try some other medicine and the same thing happens and it goes on and on like that. You just can’t find something that’s going to keep on working for you. This is because of this karma of having killed in the past.

So as well as non virtues, avoiding non virtues and purifying non virtues, we have to accumulate virtue. So we need to know how to work with accumulating virtue. And I haven’t left much time to talk about that. But it doesn’t matter that much really because the the main practice of accumulating virtue is avoiding the ten non virtues that we’ve just been through. And in actual fact, it’s very important to understand that this isn’t just avoiding non virtue and accumulating virtuous karma, but you’re actually practicing virtue and accumulating virtuous karma by observing this practice of avoiding the non virtues.

And because you’re actually consciously avoiding these non virtues, you’re accumulating good karma through that. And you’re doing the practice So that’s the practice of the ten virtuous actions. So this is opposite of the ten non virtuous actions. So it’s actions such as abandoning, killing, and abandoning, stealing, and so on. And this is the so this is the basic practice of the small scope practitioner.

And in addition to that, and in order to make our practice of virtue more effective, we can accumulate more merit by taking vows such as the five lay precepts of avoiding, killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, lying, and intoxicants. So the intoxicants, you’ll notice there’s an extra one in there. Isn’t actually considered to be taking intoxicants isn’t considered to be non virtuous by nature, but it’s something that creates a lot of troubles for us and leads us to other non virtues. When we become intoxicated, then we lose awareness, we lose mindfulness, and we engage in the other non virtues. So there’s a story about a man who was a very virtuous person.

So the some some harmful demons decided to try to lead him into doing some wrong actions. So they they sort of emanated this beautiful lady to who was his to go and sort of tempt him into doing non virtue. And she she met him on the road somewhere when he’s off by himself. And she said, I’m not going to let you go past me. This was sort of a narrow mountain path, so he couldn’t get around her except by going by by her getting out of the way.

And she said, you can’t go past unless you do one of these things. She had a goat with her. She said, you either have to kill this goat or you have to sleep with me or you have to drink this bottle of chang, this bottle of beer. So he thought about it, and he thought, well, the the other two things were obviously very non virtuous, you to commit adultery or to kill the goats. So he thought he’d better drink the chang.

So he drank the bottle of chang and then he did the other two things as well. So the point of that is that we have to remain mindful and aware, and intoxicants interfere with that and interfere with our keeping our other So monks and nuns have a vow not to take intoxicants and also lay people if they take the five vows, take their vow not to take intoxicants. And even if you haven’t actually taken that vow, then moderation is the rule. So then so this is the basic practice practice of the small scope practitioner. And then in order in order to go on and practice the other scopes, we can add the practice of meditation, the practice of concentration, wisdom.

So there are also other virtues that we can engage in, such as the six perfections, which are explained in the great scope. And there are many virtuous actions that we can do such as helping others, giving to others, particularly giving to the needy. We can engage in Dharma activities such as meditating and studying and making offerings to the Three Jewels of refuge. And these practices are very great ways of accumulating merit, and that’s why at a Dharma center you always find that there are many things about the physical setup that helps us to accumulate these virtues, such as having statues of Buddha and pictures of Buddha to make these offerings in front of, which is making it heavy from the side of the was it the basis? Heavy because of the basis.

And we can we have ways of making offerings with water bowls and making mandala offerings. All of these things that we can learn about are actually explained in this book in the preliminaries which are in the early part of the book. Doing practices such as lama chopa which are designed to enable us to carry out all of these basic practices either for the purification of negativities or the accumulation of merit. And I came across a quotation from Geshe Tashi Tsering who was the Geshe at Jamyang Buddhist Centre. Geshe Tashi Tsering said he was obviously quoting the scriptures, but I’m not sure which scripture that he was quoting.

But the best way of offering the best ways of offering are meditating on compassion, love, emptiness, and the six perfections. So with the merit that we’re creating, we want to increase it and to not enjoy not to destroy its power. So one of the things that can make our merit very great is by rejoicing. So we in our in the seven limb practice, we have rejoicing. We have confession of our negativities, and we have rejoicing in our virtues and also in the virtues of others.

So by rejoicing in our own virtues, we increase them immensely. And by rejoicing in the virtues of others, we actually are able to share in the the virtues of others. So these things are skillful ways of of accumulating merit. It’s always said that rejoicing is the is a very good action to do because we can do it without making any without any effort expended or any money. And we can even rejoice lying down if we want to.

So it’s a good practice. And it’s actually true that I mean, it’s it’s very good practice for your mind. If you can really rejoice in the heart, then it just makes for a good heart. So we also have to watch out for anger because anger destroys our merit. So we have to deal with anger, and we need to dedicate our merits every day so that our merits will not be destroyed by anger.

Also, by motivating on bodhichitta at the beginning of the day, this is a very, very skillful way to immensely increase our merits because the thought of bodhichitta is the thought of working for the welfare of all sentient beings, so it becomes huge by means of the base again because the base is very huge. It’s all sentient beings. Then if we’re doing our virtuous actions that we do throughout the day, not just for ourselves but for all sentient beings, then it becomes immensely enormous. By motivating at the beginning of the day, we’re making sure of doing that. And by dedicating at the end of the day, we’re dedicating them so that they don’t become destroyed by anger.

And also, of course, so that they are directed towards enlightenment and not just going to ripen as some sort of temporal good result that comes as enjoyed and gets finished. Instead of that, we want to make sure that our good karma becomes merits supporting our path to enlightenment. And so we need to do these practices of, motivating and dedication. And so we also have the, the same ripened results for our good karma, as I talked about before, for our bad karma. Just to go through it quickly because it’s time, the ripened result is the, the rebirth, in the upper realms.

Generally, the best ripened result is in the god realms, and then the second best is in the demigod realms, and the third best is in the human realms but what we want to have is precious human rebirth where we can keep on practicing Dharma. Secondly, the result congruent with cause can be experiences such as wealth, long life, harmonious family relationships, and so on. And it’s also possible to experience actions congruent with cause. This can be seen in people who have natural renunciation and compassion right from the time of their birth. For instance, Lama Yeshe, when he was very small, showed a lot of compassion towards people with suffering and so on.

These are the results of having practiced in previous lifetimes. And then also the environmental result can be good environment and getting nourishment from your food and drink and good results from your medicine and so on. And there’s a number of different things that make our good karma more powerful And, these include, because of the field and that, in in descending order, is first of all go going upward. Sorry. First of all, ordinary people so ascending order.

First of all, ordinary people, then your parents, then practitioners of virtue, lay or ordained bodhisattvas, Buddhas, and one’s gurus respectively. Then, having taken vows. So, in the case of a person who’s taken vows, their their virtues and non virtues apparently become much stronger because they’re holding vows. Thirdly, the thing being done. So for instance, in the action of giving, the the giving of dharma is, much better than giving material things.

Fourthly, the intention. So Bodhicitta, I already mentioned, makes the action the virtuous action very powerful. And fifthly, the sorry. No. There’s only four.

So those are the four things. And then if you want to know what sorts of results you get from your virtuous actions. There are eight ripened qualities. And these are, there are eight of these. Long life, a handsome body, good family, high family, great wealth, trustworthy speech.

In other words, people, find your speech convincing, persuasive, great power and fame, being a male, and being strong in mind and body. So being ladies, we always have a problem with this being male one, but the explanation for that is being male is that that you can go it’s safer for you to go alone into isolated places or also to go into public places. I think this is referring to the times when perhaps going for a woman to go alone into the city wouldn’t have been a particularly safe or easy thing to do. So it means that males are free from some of these obstacles. It’s not any reflection on the capabilities of the body, but simply the situation of being female exposes you to makes you vulnerable to certain difficulties and dangers that males don’t experience.

And so I think in this day and age, the lamas say that that women’s karma is changing now and that being a a woman nowadays can be as good as being a man. And

Key terms in this teaching

four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
possessed result
One of four ways we can experience the result of an action, also called environmental result; possessed result is the environment we find ourselves in when we take rebirth. LYWA
seven-limb practice
The seven limbs are: prostrating, making offerings, confession, rejoicing, requesting to turn the Dharma wheel, requesting the teachers to remain in the world and dedicating. LYWA
ten virtuous actions gewa chu (Tib)
Actions of body, speech and mind which are the opposite of the ten nonvirtuous actions, therefore, one refrains from killing, speaks the truth and so forth. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
three poisons dug sum (Tib)
Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
upper realms
The three higher realms in samsara of human, asura and sura. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top