45 min · 2,192 words · 6 October 1990
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the four establishments of mindfulness: body, feelings, mind and phenomena. It describes three kinds of feeling (pleasurable, displeasurable and neutral). It presents mind as primary consciousness together with mental factors that perceive and distinguish the details of an object. Phenomena are explained through the Four Noble Truths, separating those to be abandoned (true suffering and its origins) from those to be practised (cessation and the path). The transcript is fragmentary.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1990-10-06
Duration: 46 min
UUID: f87117b6-4cf0-4bb8-b751-13a97aaedf02
Words: 265
[00:00:06] [non-English speech, 4 s, detected zh 0.82]
[00:00:44] The second of the topic is feelings, and we understand what feelings are. From time to time we experience happiness, and at other times we experience suffering. At other times we experience neither happiness nor suffering. We have a neutral feeling. So it is the experience of these various feelings.
[00:01:07] That which is the entity which experiences pleasure is pleasurable feelings. And the entity which experiences displeasure is displeasurable feelings. And that which experiences neither pleasurable nor displeasurable feelings is the feeling of indifference.
[00:02:00] So there are five types of feelings. There are physical, the feelings of physical pleasure and displeasure, the feelings of mental
[00:02:12] [unclear, 4 s]
[00:02:52] [non-English speech, 5 s, detected it 0.34]
[00:03:48] Examples of bodily or physical pleasurable feeling when we see something very appealing to the eye.
[00:03:59] Then we have a pleasurable feeling of the eye. When we hear some sudden sound, we have a pleasurable feeling of the ear. We smell a pleasurable odor, a pleasurable feeling of the nose. When we taste something, we feel a pleasurable feeling of the time. When we feel something, that’s something which is very smooth.
[00:04:32] We have a pressure force in the body. These are all physical pressure force in the body.
[00:05:27] And then the absolute ability of being partly a pleasurable feeling, partly just pleasurable feeling, showing how much, when we see our enemies,
[00:05:40] a feeling of displeasure. Displeasure is a feeling of the eye. And when we hear some bad sounds, we think a displeasurable feeling of the ear. When we smell something terrible, then we experience a displeasurable feeling of the nose. When we taste something very bad, we want to spit it out, and we experience a displeasurable feeling of the tongue.
[00:06:12] The thing with the touch, I think we don’t have to touch. We make the special feeling of the body leader or the special feeling of the body leader.
[00:06:59] And then with respect to mental sexual feelings, someone would speak nicely to us if our practice is going well, that we have some kind of obvious
[00:07:16] are activating, we achieve it. Then we would develop happiness, a liking, a joy. And this joy would be a mental, special feeling.
[00:07:58] On the other hand, if we were trying to do some kind of activity and things weren’t going well, we didn’t achieve our desired results,
[00:08:20] and we might become worried about it. We would be unhappy, and if unhappiness in this case would be a mental displeasure, unpleasurement.
[00:08:52] [non-English speech, 8 s, detected es 0.58]
[00:09:45] The various bodily feelings which arise, both pleasurable and displeasurable, on the whole, arise
[00:09:59] from the skillful and unskillful actions. On the other hand, the pleasurable and displeasurable mental feelings that we experience arise out of the quality of our thinking process, our thought conception. That is, depending upon whether these are the quality of the way in which we are thinking, speaking in a healthy manner,
[00:10:31] or unhealthy man to become the pleasurable and displeasurable human of the mind.
[00:11:24] For those who have active thought process, interlock, they will experience many types of pleasurable and displeasurable mental feelings. On the other hand, those who have a very calm mind, not many thoughts arising, they abide in a very relaxed manner without a good fear of…
[00:12:01] [non-English speech, 20 s, detected ja 0.84]
[00:12:31] That’s the reason we can make use of the observing breath in the inhalation and exhalation as a means to calm the active thought process that in observing in the breath that thoughts will be generated in the mind to come through that.
[00:13:05] [unclear, 31 s]
[00:13:59] We need this thought process in order to practice the dharma. We have to make use of this thought process in order to achieve happiness. But at those times when it’s
[00:14:23] when we don’t need it, if we are still generating this thought process that’s still active, then we’re going to experience many pleasurable and unpleasurable feelings rather than simply having our mind abiding the last man.
[00:14:58] So there are five types of thoughts. There are two physical, bonded, pleasurable and displeasurable feelings, two mental, displeasurable and unpleasurable feelings, and then those feelings which are neither of these, none of these are looking at the feelings of displeasurable.
[00:15:30] But if we were to condense these five, we could condense these three, they could be feeling the pleasure, the pleasure and the difference.
[00:16:03] [non-English speech, 37 s, detected pt 0.30]
[00:16:40] and minds are that which holds objects. In general, there are two types of minds. There are minds and mental factors. Obviously, minds are primaries. That is to say they are like a king, whereas mental factors are like the retinue of the king. They are very conservative kings.
[00:17:20] If there is to divide mind up, we can, we can, this means stick. And here, the use of mind is in the technical sense.
[00:17:59] So there are six minds of primary consciousness. Those minds are the eye, ear, nose, tongue, body. And then there’s the mental primary consciousness, that is that consciousness which is not dependent upon sense faculty, which is the mental consciousness.
[00:19:21] So these six types of minds conduce them into outer and inner minds. The outer minds are the minds of the eye, ear and nose.
[00:19:30] where the mental mind is called the inner mind and the outer mind are not stable where the inner mind is.
[00:20:32] Why are the outer mind considered not stable? When we go to the street, the sense consciousness, or the outer mind,
[00:20:50] withdraw, and they are not operative during sleep, whereas the inner mind, the mental sense consciousness continues to operate. Again, when the Bodhisattva is in meditative approach on emptiness, the sense consciousnesses are not operative, where it’s just in the same way as occurs in the sleep.
[00:21:21] [non-English speech, 41 s, detected ja 0.58]
[00:22:03] [unclear, 27 s]
[00:22:36] a lot of more roughness, more of the roughness. By way of an example, when the eye primary consciousness sees the flower, it sees really the rough, the rough entity of the flower.
[00:23:37] The eye’s primary consciousness sees the flower, and if it’s a crisp flower, then there is the surrounding mental factor of feeling,
[00:23:55] experiences which is the experiences of pleasure surrounding the primary consciousness is the mental factor of feeling and this experience is pleasure.
[00:24:32] They would be able to understand that it’s red, that it’s the mental factor of perception, of discrimination.
[00:25:35] would examine as the number of petals to understand its shape, whether it’s a good cloud or not. So there are these retinue or surrounding factors which examine in detail the nature of the architecture.
[00:26:15] So again, this holds true for the other primary consciousnesses, for example, the ear primary consciousnesses, upon hearing a sound. Hearing the eruptions of the sound, then there was immediate surrounding mental factors which would examine the nature of that sound, whether it was pleasurable, unpleasurable, et cetera.
[00:27:02] So, in general, we told true to all phenomena that the primary consciousness
[00:27:12] understands the rough entities, the rough aspects of an object, and this is surrounded with mental factors which distinguish the details of an object. So by means of this aggregation of these primary and primary mental factors, primary consciousnesses, primary mind and mental factors, this aggregation, this combination of these, then all phenomena can be understood in all these years.
[00:27:57] So the mind is mainly is that which holds the entity of the object. In other words, the entity is in the nature. Where is the nature, holds the nature of the object?
[00:28:44] We look at body, human, mind. Now we’re going to look at the fourth thing.
[00:28:58] The word in Tibetan is chu, and in Sanskrit it’s dhamma, and the meaning of the word dhamma, literally, in Sanskrit, the word dhamma is a Sanskrit word which means to hold.
[00:29:46] So the effect of this word dharma means to recognize, to identify. For example, I can recognize that this is a flower, this is a table, these are glasses, this is a book, that is a dream, this is a class.
[00:30:04] [non-English speech, 7 s, detected zh 0.98]
[00:31:00] The word dharma can have at least these two different senses. There’s the dharma, which is practical, which is spiritual. But the general means of the word dharma are all objects of knowledge are dharmas. This is that dharmas can be translated as phenomena. In general, they can be said to be
[00:31:25] The three types are skillful phenomena, non-skillful phenomena and non-satisfying phenomena The way we usually talk about Dharma
[00:32:01] is in terms of that which through body, speech and mind, in terms of oneself or others, is unskillful karma. That which brings about what harms oneself or others is an unskillful karma.
[00:32:34] [non-English speech, 40 s, detected ja 0.93]
[00:33:49] So there are these two types of gamma here, skillful diamonds, unskillful diamonds, and unspecified diamonds. And as we have mentioned, those which are, those skillful diamonds, I think we can look at these phenomena. Skillful phenomena are those which bring about the resulting happiness. Unskillful phenomena, diamonds, are those activities of bodies, which bring about, are those objects, are those phenomena which bring about
[00:34:22] result in suffering. And these were specified by the Buddha. The Buddha said, this is a skillful dharma. This is an unskillful dharma or phenomena. And others, he did not specify. That’s why they termed unspecified dharma, unspecified phenomena. For example, a table. It does not bring about a result in happiness or a result in…
[00:34:51] suffering the earth water fire and wind energy are unspecified genres they do not think about either they do not have the quality of the goodness or badness
[00:35:27] I think it says in one of the three realizations that all objects, all phenomena are the objects of observation and these can be, all objects are condensed condensation of the three types of phenomena, that is to say skillful, unskillful, and that’s the problem.
[00:36:00] [non-English speech, 22 s, detected ja 0.81]
[00:37:36] In the object of this, the four-way division of a built object, that is the body, clean, mind,
[00:37:46] phenomena, what is meant by phenomena here, or what is meant by dharma here. There are, as we mentioned, there are six consciousnesses, six primary consciousnesses. Those objects which are taken by the sense consciousnesses are bodies, so that’s not what is being referred to here. But those objects which are taken, those phenomena which are taken as objects are the mental consciousness.
[00:38:15] but this phenomena which is taken as objects as a mental consciousness, are what is referred to here as phenomena. That is to say, those things, those phenomena which cannot be understood by sense consciousness, but can only be understood by mental consciousness, is what is referred to here as phenomena.
[00:38:45] [non-English speech, 20 s, detected ja 0.47]
[00:39:48] What would be the phenomena which are only taken as objects by the mental consciousness? That would be, for example, in terms of the Four Noble Truths, that the first two of these Four Noble Truths
[00:40:06] are true sufferings and true origins of suffering. And these are the type of abandonment. So those are the phenomena which are the category of abandonment. On the other hand, there are phenomena which are to be put into practice. And these would be, that is to say,
[00:40:37] which lead to liberation, which is the cessation of suffering the third noble truth, true cessation. And those paths which lead to the cessation of suffering the fourth noble truth. And these are purifying agents. So the object phenomena here refers to those objects which are to be rejected and those objects which are to be adopted and cultivated. So the five sense consciousnesses cannot
[00:41:10] understand the Four Noble Truth.
[no transcribed speech 00:41:12-00:42:25]
[00:42:25] Why do you say it comes under the category of phenomena? Because you gave it as one of the examples of an unspecified, that is neither skillful or unskillful, but an unspecified phenomena.
[00:42:52] As were earth and fire. And they’re also objects. They’re also bodies. Is it included in the category of phenomena? Is what has been included in the category of phenomena the concepts of the table rather than the touch?
[00:43:29] [non-English speech, 35 s, detected ja 0.62]
[00:44:36] Yeah, so when we spoke about phenomena and we exemplified it in terms
[00:44:47] This is a way of condensing it. If we were to expand it, then we could include the table because that is the true suffering.
[00:45:29] So something to be a true suffering doesn’t have to be unstickable. For example, our body, because the true suffering doesn’t have to be unstickable.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.