44 min · 2,201 words · 7 October 1990
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This talk continues a teaching on the four close establishments of mindfulness. It explains that meditating on impermanence and suffering supports each other, and that practising in stages builds future understanding. It describes how wisdom examines the body while mindfulness holds the understanding, and how contemplating the body’s defects generates renunciation and cuts attachment to cyclic existence.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1990-10-07
Duration: 45 min
UUID: c3655767-6bca-45f4-a1fe-e34308291758
Words: 2,197
That could be incurred in this way of meditating. And then it’s probably best if you were to proceed to meditate on the first to whatever you were able and then move on without trying to realize it completely to the second. And then you would at least be planting latencies with respect to meditating on all of these. And then in the future due to the power of those latencies one could come to an understanding of these very quickly. So, you know, it’s difficult for us to gain realizations, but we can implant the latencies.
You know, even if we don’t realize these qualities in this life, by planting the seeds of their realization through covering the various objects of meditation, we will be able to understand them in the future. But additionally, in intermediate, one’s contemplation of impermanence will benefit one’s understanding of suffering. And one’s understanding of suffering will benefit one’s understanding of impermanence. So it would be to in this case of impermanence and dissatisfaction to to meditate both of them. For example, in Meditating the Graduated Path to Awakening, if one were to stay on the initial topic without ever until one realized it without ever passing to subsequent topics, then if you could spend this life, would be one would not have implanted any latencies with respect to the understanding of the later topics.
And in this way one could waste one’s life not having implanted these latencies. So those who are expert in the ways of practice are continually seeking to meditate on the complete path of awakening. Therefore at least they are implanting the latencies for future understandings of the complete path. And not only that, but meditating on the latter topics benefits one’s understanding of former topics, just as the former topics will benefit one’s understanding of the latter topics. The the I checked.
So what the meaning of that phrase here is, where it says phenomena being unapprehensible, is that which is unapprehended is the true existence of phenomena. The true existence of phenomena is not apprehended. So this is what the phenomena being non truly existent is apprehended. Its true existence is not apprehended. True existence is unapprehendable.
The hearers do not meditate on emptiness. So this explanation is given in terms of the Autonomy Middle Way school and not the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school. This explanation is given in terms of the Autonomy Middle Way school and not the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school. The the So, I was asking, we use these three activities of listening, reflecting, and meditating. And what is the difference between reflecting and analytic meditation?
Which I said they’re the same. Here what is meant by meditation in this threefold activity is having developed meditative concentration. And then this would be stabilized meditation. So in there and and listening to the explanation on the on the four close establishments of mindfulness. These are the four close establishments of mindfulness.
That are the characteristics which have to be meditated in relationship to them. When you hear this, then there arises a wisdom arising from hearing and listening. So then when you when you sit there and you’re you’re thinking about what you heard, this is this the way that this is this, and you make this using your intellect, various reasonings, trying to understand the explanation. This this is what you’re doing is contemplation. This of these threefold activities are are reflection, and out of this comes the wisdom rising from reflection.
And then if you’ve accomplished calm abiding and through this process of reflecting, you come to reflecting through this examining the object using various reasonings, you come to a conclusion. Then you, you cause the mind to abide single pointedly upon that conclusion, and this would be meditation. And out of this rises wisdom arising from meditation. So we have to proceed through these three activities, the order of these three activities of listening, reflecting, and meditating. So the the the your experience of the pain in your knee is a product of previous karma that you’ve created, but it’s not definite as to how you created that particular karma.
It could have come out of attachment to your body. It could have come out of becoming angry at someone. It could have arisen out of ignorance. So it’s not definite what was the motivating force for the creation of that karma. If I were a Buddha and you asked me that question, I could tell you exactly what you did to create the karma, to create the experience, and what you’re experiencing now.
If you were to ask a Buddha, he could tell you. To the pain. So there’s one meditation you can make use of. You just think to yourself how terrible the pain is. I can’t stand this pain, and I should go to the doctor and get some medicine for it.
Another way you could look at your pain would be that understanding that the pain you’re now experiencing is a result of negative karma that you created in the past. And by experiencing that pain now, you are purifying the karmic latencies, which could have caused you to be reborn in hell. So it’s wonderful that all you have to do is go through this slight suffering instead of going to hell, and this will make you happier. So the great Kadampa master Atisha, he said that suffering is like a broom. It sweeps away all of the dirt and it purifies us.
And that is to say we’ve been purified of all of our negativities through going through the process of suffering. So just as a room as a broom cleans a room, likewise our suffering cleans out all our negative karma. I must, for the sake of all sentient beings, in order to free them from suffering and to lead them to happiness, to eliminate all my various faults and bring the consummation to all my excellent qualities, I must attain Buddhahood. Develop the kind hearted motivation for that in order to achieve that end, I must listen well to the great vehicle teachings on the four close establishments of mindfulness in order that I might be able to meditate on them and practice them. We’ll spend the next five minutes developing an awakening heart to develop such a motivation.
As it states in his text, the Differentiation of the Middle and the Extremes. Because the body is the appropriate, because the feelings are the cause of craving, because the mind is the ground, and because the path is the source of non observation, non obscuration, one is led to the four truths. Therefore, meditate upon the four close establishments of mindfulness. So we have finished the discussion of the observed object and the common manner and the exclusive manner of meditating on the four close establishments of mindfulness. So here we’re now going to discuss the reasons for the meditation or necessity, that is what are the benefits to be derived from meditating in this way?
And this is citing the quotation by Ārya Maitreya. Initially we said that according to Vasubandhu that the four close establishments of mindfulness are wisdom and are classified as wisdom and mindfulness. And in terms of applying these characteristics, the two characteristics of specific and general characteristics to the body, it is the wisdom which examines the body in terms of the specific characteristics and then examines it in terms of the general characteristics. So the function of wisdom is to examine and know the nature of its object. And it is the function of mindfulness to not forget what has been identified by the mind, identified by wisdom.
The wisdom performs a function of investigating and identifying the nature of the object, and then mindfulness does not allow the the understanding or the identification to be lost. It it it holds this understanding in the mind. It it it’s a factor of remembering. It is able to re it recalls, back to mind again and again the understanding which has been brought about by wisdom, and this is the sense of the meaning of the four close establishments of mindfulness. If mindfulness does not hold what has been understood, then it will be forgotten.
And therefore, what has been understood is of no benefit. For example, if one were to, by applying wisdom, understand emptiness without the familiarizing process, that is with that understanding through the force of one’s mindfulness of what has already been understood, then one will simply forget what one has understood and one has gone through a lot of difficulty for nothing. So by by means of so the four close establishments of mindfulness initially employs a wisdom which functions to examine the object. For example, in terms of the body, examining it as to its impermanence, its dissatisfactoriness, its empty, and selflessness. When it has ascertained characteristics of the body, then the function of mindfulness is to hold this ascertainment in the mind to remember it.
And then the process of meditation is a familiarization. Mindfulness functioning to hold what has been understood, and there is a familiarizing oneself with the realization. And in this way the level of consciousness is raised in its capacity, its power, and one’s practice goes well in this fashion. So applying the four close establishments of mindfulness to the body, one initially examines with wisdom the body in terms of its impermanence, understanding that it is momentarily being produced and disintegrating, understanding this nature of the body. Additionally, one would look at the body in terms of being dissatisfactory, examining for that quality, understanding that it is by its very nature it is of the nature of suffering or dissatisfactoriness.
And going on to look at it in terms of being empty and selfless, these four general characteristics. Arising out of that, one will look upon the body as a prison and as being in the nature of suffering and develop the intention to be liberated from such a type of body. Out of out of applying these four general characteristics to the body, examining the body in terms of them, one will see that the body is a dissatisfactory, a thing which is dissatisfactory. And one will develop an intention to be free from it. That is the I one will develop the attitude, the orientation to turn away from again taking such a type of body because it is a dissatisfactory thing.
What we mean by it is a thing which is dissatisfactory, that we will begin to understand that the body is a source of creation of suffering, that is the basis for the generation of suffering. But not only that, but it is by dissatisfactory it means it has a defect. I was trying to think of words for this, a defective disorder such that it is inserviceable in the practice of Dharma. It serves as an obstruction to our practice of Dharma. It obstructs the liking for inter engaging in the practice of Dharma.
It is inserviceable in the pursuit of Dharma. And therefore, seeing this, one develops intention to be liberated from it or to abandon it. So, you know, to if we’re talking about the the nature of the body previously in ancient time there were a great number of meditators who meditated on the close establishments of mindfulness, and this large congregation of monks. And they had really deprived, decrepit bodies. And many of them, out of this, there arose an intention to commit suicide.
On the other hand, we like our bodies a lot. And I think if we were to talk about all its drawbacks, you wouldn’t like it. If yeah. Anyway, By the way, example, if you were you were you were you were up to up to your chin if you were up to your chin in a pile of shit, you wouldn’t be able to bear that. You would think, well, I’d rather kill myself than go to stay here.
It’s definite that if you know what to say of months and years, if you to contemplate being in that situation for even a day, you’d think about killing yourself. I don’t wanna say anything. So, eat food, having eaten the food, and before it’s defecated, has turned into excrement within ourselves. And that excrement is within ourselves. If if we were to think well on actual nature of the body, we would we might we would come to the conclusion that it’s even dirtier than what that situation that we described previously.
But I won’t talk about it because you don’t like it. Many of the great masters such as Śāntideva and Nāgārjuna and his precious Garland talk about the quality of the body. And also it’s mentioned in the various sutras on the close establishments of mindfulness and out of this previously many practitioners would commit suicide. So some of the monks. So the reason that the Buddha taught this was in order to help us to cut our attachment out of which we create karma and perpetuate cyclic existence.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What is the difference between reflecting and analytic meditation in the threefold activity of listening, reflecting and meditating?
Meditation in this threefold activity means having developed meditative concentration, so it is stabilized meditation. Listening to an explanation, such as that on the four close establishments of mindfulness, gives rise to wisdom arising from hearing. Reflection is sitting and thinking about what was heard, using the intellect and various reasonings to understand the explanation. From this comes wisdom arising from reflection. If calm abiding has been accomplished, then after examining the object with various reasonings and reaching a conclusion, the mind is made to abide single-pointedly on that conclusion. This is meditation, and from it comes wisdom arising from meditation.