45 min · 2,268 words · 6 October 1990
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher introduces the four close establishments of mindfulness, quoting Je Tsongkhapa on the motivation for listening to the Dharma and Vasubandhu on calm abiding as the basis for this practice. He explains calm abiding, the lesser and greater vehicle distinction as one of motivation, and begins the observed objects, starting with bodies as outer, inner and outer-and-inner forms.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1990-10-06
Duration: 46 min
UUID: b065d68e-e565-4ca9-9193-91007213b955
Words: 2,264
We have attained a precious human life by which we can practice on the path to liberation. We have to develop — quoting from a verse by Je Tsongkhapa, in which he exhorts us to develop the proper motivation for listening to the Dharma. Going on to explain, oh, what is the proper motivation, and that it addresses those who ever wish, who were ever seeking to practice the Dharma? And he goes on to say, Whosoever wish to practice the Dharma must develop a non attachment to the happiness of cyclic existence, that is to say, conditioned existence. And we must see the various faults of cyclic existence and see the excellence of liberation.
That is to say, we must develop renunciation, this determination to be free, in which we strive to be free from cyclic existence and attain liberation. And he goes on to say that don’t allow yourself to waste this human life with all its leisures and fortunes, and that it has great meaning, and don’t allow it to become empty in which there is no benefit whatsoever. Then what are we to do to make our human life meaningful? That simply developing renunciation, that is the wish for only ourselves to be free from cyclic existence, is not sufficient. That it is necessary to develop the attitude which holds others more dear than ourselves.
The aspiration to free sentient beings from suffering and to lead them to complete happiness. That is to say, we should seek to develop a kind heart, the awakening heart. If we generate an awakening heart, then our life of leisure and fortune has become meaningful. So it’s necessary that we develop our practice of renunciation and the awakening heart. But still, this is not sufficient.
Even though we may possess those, it’s necessary that we eliminate all our various faults and to bring to consummation all our excellent qualities. In order to do this, we must cultivate the correct view, that is the understanding of emptiness. It is the correct view which is the path which pleases the victors. That is to say, it is the way of practice which pleases the Buddhas. And these are the three principal aspects of the path: developing the determination to be free, the awakening heart, and the correct view of emptiness.
And continuing in this verse, that we should seek to develop this attitude as a motivation for listening to the teaching. That is to say, that I am listening in order to put into practice what is being explained, and we should not allow our mind to stray outside but to keep it centered, and listening in this way in order to practice, and I will now explain the practice. So today, I’m going to explain the mode, the method of meditating on the four close establishments of mindfulness. So the practice of the four close contemplations is mainly set forth by Vasubandhu, and I’m quoting a verse from Vasubandhu in which he talks about the order of practice. First, that it is necessary to achieve calm abiding.
Having achieved that, one should go on to the four close contemplations. That if we can develop calm abiding well, this is the order of meditation. First, necessary to have a good calm abiding and in dependence upon that, one can develop and receive great benefit from the meditation of the four close establishments of mindfulness. So we have previously explained the way of practice of calm abiding. That meditating on calm abiding is always very beneficial.
The temporal advantage of it is that by development of calm abiding, our mind will not be distracted outside, that we will cease outward distractions and we will be able to abide on an inner object. We will be able to center and remain focused, remain on an inner object. And this gives our meditation a great capacity, a great power. Therefore, the aim of calm abiding is to cease distraction to external objects and to remain fixed on an internal object, to remain single pointedly placed upon whatever object we wish. For example, if I were to set this flower on the table, wherever I place it, it remains there.
It doesn’t move around. It sits right there wherever I set it, and this is the quality of mind which we attain through calm abiding. Whatever object we place our mind upon, it remains there wherever we place it. If we don’t have calm abiding, then our meditation is like a flag flapping in the breeze or a piece of paper blown around, that are continually, our mind is continually distracted in an excited state. There’s no stability to the mind, and our meditation has no power, and therefore it’s extremely excellent to cultivate calm abiding.
No matter what we’re meditating on, if we have calm abiding, then our mind will remain upon the object of observation, and this is extremely beneficial. So in general, the four close contemplations are set forth in the great texts of the discourses of the Buddha. And it is mainly practiced by the practitioners of the lesser vehicle. But the bodhisattva still meditates upon the four close contemplations, the four close establishments. And why is that?
Because in order to bring about the welfare of all sentient beings, the bodhisattva meditates on it in order to gain its realization, whereby to teach it to others, and therefore it is meditated on by both the lesser vehicle and the greater vehicle. The quality of a practice being that of the lesser vehicle or greater vehicle is not in the nature of the practice itself, but is determined by our motivation for that practice. Those who are motivated motivated in order to attain liberation for themself, then their practices are lesser vehicle practice. Those on the other hand who are practicing in order to achieve Buddhahood for the sake of all sentient beings, then that practice is a practice of the greater vehicle. The distinction between lesser and greater vehicle is not made in terms of the entity of the practice itself, in that one is better than the other, one is more efficient, less efficient, but in terms of motivation.
By way of example, there is no distinguishment between the quality of emptiness. There’s no higher and lower emptinesses. That the emptiness is all the same, whether it’s being meditated on by a practitioner of the lesser vehicle, for example, a hearer, or a practitioner of the great vehicle. But the practitioner of the lesser vehicle, the hearer, his or her motivation is to seek liberation from cyclic existence for oneself. Therefore, their meditation on emptiness is a practice of the lesser vehicle.
On the other hand, the great vehicle practitioner is taking that same emptiness and meditating on it, but with a motivation to eliminate the suffering of all sentient beings and to lead them to happiness. And therefore, though it’s the same emptiness, it is a practice of the greater vehicle. So this distinction is not of emptiness, it’s not made in terms of the quality of emptiness itself, but in terms of the motivation for emptiness. One leads to a practice of the lesser vehicle, the other to a greater vehicle, and the same holds true for the meditation on the four close establishments of mindfulness. So beginning the actual explanation of the way of practicing the four close establishments of mindfulness, and begins with a division into eight parts.
There I am, Rinpoche, I just read what is now just translated before you, the first paragraph, which it says there are eight parts to the decisive final analysis of the close establishments of mindfulness, the observed object, the manner of meditation, the necessity for meditation, nature, the divisions, the boundaries, etymological explanation, and establishment of the practice of the close placement of mindfulness in the great vehicle as being superior. Jim, do you have one for Tenzin? So beginning with observed object. The four close establishments of mindfulness. The establishment of mindfulness is a consciousness.
Between the two, mind and mental factors, it is a mental factor. It is one of the five object determining mental factors. It is primarily constituted of wisdom and mindfulness. Wisdom and mindfulness. It is the, in both the lesser vehicle and the great vehicle, the establishments of mindfulness transform their entity into a path, and paths are consciousness.
So this practice transforms the mindfulness and the wisdom into a path. So we have to begin by recognizing what is the object upon which we’re going to meditate on. What is the object that the closest contemplation of mindfulness is observing? What is the observed object? When we observe, for example, we look at the flower, what is looking is eye consciousness, but the eye consciousness has an object, that which it is observing.
That is the flower. The same is true when eye consciousness looks at a book, the observed object is the book. It looks at the hand, the observed object is the hand. So this meditation is observing an object. What is that observed object?
We should try to identify it. For example, when we’re meditating on emptiness, the object that we’re observing is emptiness. The meditator, the agent which is meditating, is the consciousness, and that which it is meditating on, that which it is observing, the observed object, is emptiness. So there are four observed objects of mindfulness, that is the bodies, the feelings, the minds, and phenomena. What do we mean by bodies?
Bodies are necessarily form. For example, our body is form. Amongst the three doors of body, speech, mind, the body is its form. The speech is that which expresses sound. The mind is an awareness.
So by body here we mean all forms. So what do we mean by forms? Forms is constituted of the elements and the evolutes, the elements being earth, water, fire, and wind energy, and those factors which evolve out of these elements, that is to say, which are an aggregate of elements. And these would be the visual forms, odors, flavors, and objects of touch, or we could say tangibles. So that which is an aggregation of these are referred to as forms.
So all these various thing all these various things about us we we which are an aggregation of these four elements. For example, the flower is an aggregation of the four elements. We can refer to these all as bodies. With respect to bodies, there are three different types of bodies. There are outer bodies, inner bodies, and outer and inner bodies.
Beginning with outer forms. Outer forms are those forms which are not contained within the continuum of a being, those forms which are outside the continuum of the being. For example, those objects we see with our eyes. We see visual forms, colors, white, red, etcetera. We hear sounds, pleasant sounds, unpleasant sounds.
If we were to eat some kind of food, like fruit, it would have a flavor. It could be a sweet, delicious flavor, flavors. Objects of touch, tangibles. They could be smooth, rough. So all of the various objects of the eye consciousness, ear consciousness, nose consciousness, tongue consciousness, and body consciousness are outer forms.
Then there is the inner form or inner body. And this is that, those forms which are contained within the continuum of the being. And this would be, for example, the visual form within the being, that a person has a beautiful shape. When we look at her, we see a beautiful form. That form is contained within the continuum of the being.
That they have sounds within them. They have flavors. And they have tangibles, that is, say, objects of touch. They may be smooth, they may be rough. So those objects, those forms which are within the continuum of the being.
So that which is both outer and inner form are the sense basis. And there is the sense faculty such which is like a room. The sense faculty, like the eye sense faculty, which is the fleshy part of the eye, in which there resides a clear form, which is the eye sense base. And it has the quality of being able to reflect like a mirror. Contained within the eye is this clear subtle matter or form, which is the eye sense base.
So the eye sense base is contained within the eye sense faculty. So the reason that the eye sense the sense bases are called both outer and inner forms is because they just as first the sense base has, is dependent, its existence is dependent upon external form, outer form. For example, that is to say, it exists in relationship to an outer form, just as this finger is long compared to this finger. My ring finger is long compared to my to my short finger. Its longness exists in relationship to the shortness of the small finger, the little finger.
The eye sense base is external because its existence is dependent upon its object. But it’s also internal because if it were to be removed, it is intimately connected with the consciousness. If it is harmed in any way, there is an experience of pain. Therefore it is both connected with outer forms and inner forms, and therefore it is said to be both outer and inner form. So just if we were to briefly state what are bodies, they could be condensed into simply to say all forms are bodies.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- object-determining mental factors vishayapratiniyama-chaitta (Skt); sem jung yul nge (Tib)
- One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany all virtuous minds and their function is to ascertain the object. There are five: aspiration, belief, mindfulness, stabilization, and wisdom. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- three doors go sum (Tib)
- Body, speech and mind. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.