44 min · 2,404 words · 27 June 1991
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This talk continues a commentary on Candrakirti’s Entering the Middle Way, opening with love, compassion and the motivation to listen. It explains emptiness as the absence of the object of negation, the truly existent, illustrated with fire and wood, a cup and a purse. It distinguishes the truly existent flower, refuted by reasoning, from the ignorance that conceives it, which is refuted by the path.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1991-06-27
Duration: 44 min
UUID: 5322398b-7084-4ad7-8346-0e30b62b82c0
Words: 2,400
Begin by reflecting upon the two qualities of love and compassion. Compassion, wishing that may all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering. In love, may all sentient beings have happiness and the causes of happiness. And increasing the forcefulness of our love and compassion in developing exceptional resolve, in reflecting upon that I myself will free them from their suffering, and I myself will bring them happiness. But, though having developed this exceptional resolve, seeking to take responsibility, when one examines as to whether one presently possesses the ability to bring this about in fact, one sees that in fact one simply has developed a kind heart but does not have the ability to bring it about.
When can I achieve such an ability? By means of cultivating through meditation, wisdom and method, that is the realizing emptiness and developing the awakening heart, that one can eliminate all of one’s various faults and bring to consummation all of one’s excellent qualities. And then it is in this way that we can achieve that ability. So for the next three minutes, seek to cultivate the motivation that in order to develop such a potential, such an ability, that I am going to listen to the teachings on the profound Dharma of the great vehicle in order to meditate upon them and to bring them to final consummation through my practice, and thereby be empowered to be able to benefit all sentient beings. The Buddha is said to have a greater love for all sentient beings than a mother does for her child.
This extends to all sentient beings regardless of any distinction, whether they’re high or low, good or bad, without any distinguishment, without making any distinguishment among sentient beings, extending this great love toward all of them. And the compassion which is being referred to is embodied in the wish that may sentient beings be free of their suffering and the causes of their suffering. And as the means to eliminate the suffering of sentient beings along with the cause of their suffering, all of the various causes which bring about their suffering, such as the cause of ignorance, which is the root of all our suffering, To eliminate these, as a means to eliminate these, the Buddha taught vast and varied methods of the Dharma. And the root of our suffering is ignorance. In order to eliminate ignorance, the Buddha taught emptiness.
The Buddha said that if we do not understand emptiness, we will continue to wander in cyclic existence. And therefore, as a means to understand emptiness, the Buddha presented hundreds of various reasonings to bring about this understanding. So, how are we to understand emptiness? We can understand emptiness if we examine by way of illustration the three factors of the wood, which is the cause of fire, the fire, and the result of the fire, smoke, looking at these three factors. So in terms of these three factors of the wood, which is the creative cause, the fire, which is the entity which is the main entity and then the result, and the smoke, which is the smoke.
We can begin to understand what we mean by emptiness. In the fact that if the entity of fire was truly existent, then its cause would have to be truly existent, and its result would have to be truly existent. So we’re going to try to understand emptiness. And the emptiness was initially set forth, the teachings by the Buddha himself, on his teachings on transcendental wisdom. Then these were commentated on by Nāgārjuna, and for example, in his text, The Fundamental Wisdom.
Then this was again commentated on by our present text, Entering into the Middle Way, Candrakīrti. And then this was again commentated on by masters such as Tsongkhapa. So, previously, we have talked about the qualities of the student to whom emptiness may be taught. And then we discussed the benefits of the teachings on emptiness, that through the understanding of emptiness, through the teachings of emptiness, one then goes on to observe one’s ethics, one goes on to develop compassion, respect for the Buddhas, and finally dedication. Then the necessity to listen well.
And this is in talking about the benefits which were just outlined of listening to the teachings, then the student is admonished to listen with a single pointedness to the teachings in order to arrive at these various benefits which were just outlined. And this will bring about, finally, the consummation of all of one’s excellent qualities. So, in his text entering, Candrakīrti sets out, admonishes to listen well. Through listening well to the teachings on entering into the middle way, one will become proficient in the view of the profound and the vast. Out of that, we’ll gain mastery with respect to that.
One will attain the ten grounds and will ultimately bring about be able to bring about the welfare of both oneself and others. Therefore, listen well. Entering the Middle Way is a commentary written to Nāgārjuna’s Fundamental Wisdom. And in Fundamental Wisdom, the initial verse set forth, though the text itself is extremely detailed and vast, the very first verse condenses all the meaning which is going to be set forth. And this verse said, There is no production from self, other, from both, or from no cause.
All things are not produced in a truly existent fashion, I think. So, as a basis and if we explain this, if we take it as the basis of illustration of flower, a flower is not born from itself. A flower is not born from other. It is not born from both self and other. And it is not born from no cause.
There is nothing which is born in any in any of these ways. That’s what the verse says. So, there are many ways in which we can categorize emptinesses. There is divisions into eighteen, sixteen, four, and two. And in general, we will look at the division of emptiness into two.
So, are these two ways of categorizing emptiness? There is the selflessness of phenomena and the selflessness of persons. And by persons I mean sentient beings. So, the order of presentation in the text Fundamental Wisdom is that first the selflessness of phenomena is taught and subsequent to that phenomena of person selflessness of persons. In general, the order of realization of these two types of emptiness are: First, that we will gain a prime cognition with respect to the selflessness of a person.
Subsequent to that a realization of selflessness of phenomena. But the order of explanation as put forth by Buddha and then Nāgārjuna is that first the teachings on selflessness of phenomena are presented, Subsequently, the teachings on selflessness of persons. So, these four methods of production are each individually refuted. These four represent various types of assertions by various opponents. For example, with respect to there are non Buddhists who assert the production from self.
And in order to refute this, it was taught that it was necessary to teach production, that there is no production from self. Then amongst the Buddhists, from the Autonomy Middle School down, there is the assertion of production from others. And this was refuted by a teaching from the non production from others. Then there was the assertion as to both the phenomena that products are produced from both self and others, and this has gone on to be refuted. And then it is refuted that products cannot rise from no cause, and then this is refuted.
So, in the explanation of emptiness, we must come to an understanding of what is being negated, what is the object of negation, in order to understand what we mean by emptiness. There is object of negation which is being refuted. Now, when we say emptiness, the word empty, what does empty mean? Empty of what? Empty of the object of negation.
By emptiness we don’t mean nothingness. We don’t mean vacuity. By emptiness we mean that things, phenomena, are empty of the object of negation. If we illustrate this by an empty cup, when we say the cup is empty, we say that there is a factor which is absent within the cup. There is something which is not there.
There is a factor which is nonexistent. For example, there is no tea or water or drinkable. There is no food within the cup. There is a lack, an absence of a particular factor. That’s what we mean when we say the cup is empty, an absence of a particular factor.
So, when we say the purse is empty, we’re not saying that the purse doesn’t exist. What we mean is that there’s a particular something which is not in the purse, and this something is money. There’s a factor of a particular phenomenon. There’s an absence of a particular phenomenon within the purse. It is empty of that factor, money.
So, there is the non existence in the theory of emptiness. The non existent factor is the object of negation. The factor which does not exist is the object of negation. And what is the object of negation? The nonexistence of the factor of the object of negation is emptiness.
That’s what emptiness is. It is the nonexistence of the object of refutation. And what is the object of refutation? The object of refutation is true existence or within the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school, inherent existence by way of its own character. In talking about emptiness, we’re talking about a nonexistent.
A nonexistent, there is something which does not exist. That which does not exist is the object of negation. Without understanding the object of negation, then we cannot understand what doesn’t exist. Therefore, we cannot understand emptiness. Initially, we must understand what is the object of negation.
For example, today within our teaching room, if I were to ask, Is Robin here? Is Robin here? Robin is not here. But we weren’t able to recognize who Robin was, then we couldn’t say whether Robin no matter how much we looked around the room, we wouldn’t be able to say whether Robin was here or not. We have to recognize who Robin is to say whether she’s here or not.
So, in order to understand that something doesn’t exist, we have to understand what it is. If we don’t understand what it is we’re looking for, then we can’t say that it doesn’t exist. And this is why we have to understand the object of negation. Śāntideva says, Without contacting the imagined, its nonexistence is not ascertained. Without recognizing the object of negation, we cannot ascertain that it doesn’t exist, just as in the case if we do not recognize who Robin is, if we aren’t able to identify her, then we can’t say whether she exists or not.
So, in general, we can talk about two types of objects of negation, those are negated by the path and those which are negated by reasoning. For example, a truly existent flower does not exist. And the way in which the existence of the truly existent flower is able to be refuted by reasoning. So, the truly existent flower is refuted by means of reasoning. It is the object of negation by means of reasoning.
So, through a process of examination as to whether the truly existent flower exists or not, we’re able to refute by means of reasoning the existence of the truly existent flower. So, though reasoning is able to refute the existence of a truly existent flower, it is not able to negate the wrong conception, that is, the ignorance which conceives of a truly existent flower. So there is the ignorance which conceives of a truly existent flower. This ignorance or this distorted awareness is not negated by the reasoning which negates the existence of the truly existent flower. The main object which is being sought to be negated is the ignorance which conceives of the self of the flower.
That is, the ignorance, the distorted awareness which conceives of a truly existing flower. This ignorance is what is being sought to be negated in that because of it, various afflictive emotions arise. In order to bring about a cessation or the negation of the conception conceiving of a truly existent flower, it’s necessary to generate the wisdom which realizes the non-true existence of the flower. This wisdom consciousness has the ability to eliminate or to negate this conception, conceiving the truly existing flower.
So, as the wisdom realizing the non true existence of the flower increases in its potency, there comes about a direct realization of the non true existence of the flower. That is, one develops a wisdom directly realizing the non true existence of the flower. And this becomes a path or the ground, that is to say, the mode of actually traveling to Buddhahood by means of the paths and grounds. So, we said there were two types of objects in negation. The object in negation, which is the existence of the truly existent flower is negated by reasoning, and the ignorance conceiving of the truly existent flower is negated by the path, that is to say, a wisdom directly realizing the non true existence of the flower.
So, there are two objects of negation. The first is the truly existing flower, and this is negated by means of reasoning which establishes the nonexistence of the truly existent flower. The second object of negation is the ignorance conceiving of a truly existent flower. This is negated by means of the wisdom realizing the non-true existence of the flower. So, I’ve used as a basis of illustration a flower, but we can extend this to all phenomena whatsoever a table, book, room, water, etcetera that all phenomena whatsoever can be the objects of these two types of objects of negation. For example, we ourselves, in terms of our aggregate, that of the body, that the truly existent body is refuted by means of reasoning, and the awareness conceiving of a truly existent body is refuted by means of the path.
Again, with respect to the truly existing I, the truly existing I is refuted by means of reasoning, and the conception, that is, the view of the transitory collection, is refuted by means of the path.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.