Entering the Middle Way – 21 Entering 1991 05 23

45 min · 2,575 words · 23 May 1991

Entering the Middle Way (Khensur Rinpoche)
Entering the Middle Way (Khensur Rinpoche)
Entering the Middle Way - 21 Entering 1991 05 23
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching explains why ethics must be practised together with generosity, using the image of planting a field so that resources continue to arise. It describes the dangers of unskillful actions and the protection that ethics gives, citing verses 22 to 25 of Entering the Middle Way. A brief question and answer session follows on how wisdom (realization of emptiness) relates to the motivation of seeking happiness and resources, and the talk notes that realization alone does not remove desire.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1991-05-23

Duration: 45 min

UUID: fe7883c0-be43-4e89-b9e3-8b7eccd502bb

Words: 2,571

An analogy would be a farmer who plants seeds in his field in order to bring forth a crop. Out of that planting arises a bountiful harvest. He’s able to supply himself with all his various needs through having this harvest, but he simply doesn’t stop there. Replants part of that harvest in order to ensure that he again will be able to reap another harvest the next season. And he does this each season, in this way ensuring that he will always have a harvest without end.

But on the other hand, there’s another farmer who plants a field and there rises a poor crop. And he foolishly makes use of the entire harvest of that year into supplying his needs. He doesn’t replant the field. So eventually, the proceeds from that harvest will be exhausted. Since he has not planted a new field, in the future he’s going to experience great difficulty because there’s no new crop forthcoming.

We can all easily understand that. So, applying the analogy to the context, someone who both observes ethics and practices generosity will have resources within the context of a happy migration. Within a happy migration, they will understand the benefit of further practice of generosity. By practicing further generosity, then they are going to ensure that in the future they again will have resources. Again, observing ethics that will be in the context of a happy migration.

Again, they will be able to understand the benefits of generosity since they have been living in a happy migration, and they will again practice generosity in this way, their resources, that is the objects of enjoyment, will never end. And to extend that analogy, those who do not observe their ethics, though practicing generosity and being born in a bad migration, though enjoying the harvest of their past generosity, not plant new fields of generosity. They are just like the farmer, who, having planted a field once, simply unintelligently makes use of his entire crop without replanting the field, and it will have no future crop. So this is the reason that it’s necessary to observe ethics in conjunction with generosity. But even with the observance of ethics in itself, if we do not observe ethics, then we will be reborn in a bad migration.

Why does that happen? That through the non-observance of ethics one takes bad migrations? This is spoken of in the twenty second verse, where it says, If, when acting freely and living agreeably, he does not act to hold himself back from falling down, He will fall into an abyss and lose control. How will he raise himself from there in the future? Presently, we have freedom over our actions, that we can direct ourselves to create skillful actions or unskillful actions, positive or negative, that we have the control over the quality of our future rebirths, that we can, through our actions, which can be freely entered into, we can determine whether we have a good or a bad future rebirth.

What befalls us, whether good or bad, is within our control. It is in that our fate is within our hand, our own hands. While we have this opportunity of control, we should reflect well upon this fact. If we want the future to be of good, then we must practice the causes which create that good. That such a type of future will not come about haphazardly.

We must create its causes. Then, too, while we have the freedom to create the causes, if we do not create those causes, to exercise our control to create those causes, then since we are habituated from beginningless time to the creation of negative causes, there’s a great danger not directing oneself to controlling, taking the opportunity where one has control. If one does not take advantage of that, there’s a great danger that one will simply create the causes for only a bad future. What are these positive causes to a happy state in the future. This is ethics.

If we observe our ethics well, without doubt, we will achieve a happy state in the future. The observance or non observance of ethics is within our hand, within our control. If we create the cause, the result will arise. That’s definite. This is conclusive.

There’s no problem with this. If we do not exercise our freedom in implementing the practices to create these positive causes for future types of desirable states, then because we have from the beginningless time been habituated to the creation of unskillful actions, then it’s almost definite that we will fall to a bad migration, those of a hell being hungry ghost or animal. So, what’s the problem with falling there? So, there’s a great problem involved in such a state. Not just the fact of the great suffering which one experiences in such a state, the quality of the deprivations of the body, the misery of the places, the cold, the heat, etcetera.

But the very fact of being in such a place, that one is offered no protection. Who can protect you in such a situation? Who can lead you out of such a situation? In those types of realms, there’s no one who can show you the way to liberation. There’s no Buddha.

There’s no Dharma. There’s no spiritual community to draw you out and protect you in such a miserable place. Why is there less protection from the Buddhadharma and the spiritual community in these types of realms? The way in which the Buddha and the Dharma and the spiritual community are able to protect us is by means of our practicing. If we don’t practice, then they can offer us no protection.

In such a situation, we cannot practice. We cannot practice, for example, ethics, the ethics of the ten skillful actions, the abandonment of the ten unskillful actions. We all can see this quite readily. If we look at a dog, a dog can’t practice. It’s completely involved in negativity.

The beings in these realms are continually creating the negativities, for example, the physical unskillful actions of killing, sexual impropriety, the verbal of lying, etcetera. In this way, they not only have no protection but they continually are creating further unskillful actions. Out of these unskillful actions, again, this perpetuates the cycle of taking rebirth in bad migrations, of taking rebirth in hell, of hungry ghosts, of animals continually creating negative actions again, taking rebirth again and again in this perpetual cycle of negative, bad migrations. So it’s really very difficult if one does not observe ethics. The Buddha out of his great compassion for us and wishing us happiness initially taught generosity because knowing we want happiness then what are the ways in which happiness can be brought to sentient beings through such material means as food, clothing, shelter, medicine, companions?

And these are all brought about through the practice of generosity. So first, the Buddha taught generosity. So, by means of generosity, we are able to achieve this temporal type of happiness. But so that we are never apart from this happiness, that this happiness is able to come to us continually, that it’s not temporary, but it’s an eternal type of happiness, He taught ethics to ensure that we always have continual resources, objects of enjoyment. What are the benefits of observing ethics?

And this is mentioned in the latter two lines of verse twenty three. When virtues are nurtured on the field of ethics, the enjoyment of effects is unceasing. Ethics is being likened to a field, an expanse of land, upon which grows flowers and trees, which can be planted and can bring forth all the various types of crops and places to live, shelter, quarters where one lives, are all supported by this field, this area, this land. Likewise, that ethics is seen as the foundation of all of the excellent qualities, both of the great vehicle and lesser vehicle. So, you know, we place buildings are built on land that the place that we live in, the places our homes are supported on the land.

If there wasn’t the land, then it’d just fall through. So, likewise, ethics is the the the foundation of all excellent qualities. Without the foundation of ethics, one cannot achieve ultimate qualities. So, for ordinary people like ourselves who have not realized emptiness, then in order to achieve a human life by means of which we can achieve qualities depends upon ethics. So, as it says in the twenty fourth verse, For common beings, those born from the word, those set toward solitary enlightenment and conquerors children, goals of definite goodness and high status is none other than proper ethics.

For common beings, ordinary people, for hearers, solitary realizers, bodhisattvas, to attain their embodiment, it is necessary that they rely upon ethics. And, dependence upon their particular embodiments, they can achieve all the excellent qualities that they can gain realizations of the various paths and grounds. And this has its foundation the observance of So, ethics is extremely beneficial. It’s a very powerful and necessary practice. So, here it is taught the benefits of practice of ethics.

In the twenty-fifth verse: Just as an ocean is incompatible with a corpse, and just as prosperity is incompatible with calamity, so a great being subdued by ethics does not wish to live with faulty ethics. A corpse that the ocean throws up upon the shore. It does not mix with the ocean. Cannot stay within the ocean. It is thrown up out of the ocean.

Likewise, prosperity and calamity are mutually incompatible. Likewise, just as these, that those who practice ethics are incompatible with those who do not practice ethics. With respect to ethics, there are two types. There is mundane ethics and super mundane ethics. This was previously explained in terms of generosity.

That supra mundane ethics is the ethics of those who have direct realization of emptiness. When they realize the non-natural existence of the agent, the action, and the object towards which the action is committed, this is referred to as supra-mundane ethics. For those ordinary beings who do not have direct realization of emptiness, then their ethics is termed mundane ethics. So, you know, we’ve emphasized the importance of ethics, but what would be the main point of the practice of ethics? And this is whether one is a lay person or living in the vows of renunciate, then it is the abandonment of the ten unskillful actions.

Those three physical, four verbal, and three mental unskillful actions. But in the case of those living vows of renunciation, they have many special types of vows. So, you know, we’ve emphasized the importance of ethics and its practice. That, you know, there is no reason we cannot practice ethics, that we can all do this. And therefore, you know, if we think about it, it’s for sure that we can do it.

And however much we can, we should try to practice ethics and thereby ensure a happy migration in the future. And this will be extremely beneficial. Simply from not committing unskillful actions is not the practice of ethics. There must be a refraining from the commission of unskillful actions. That is to say, one must intentionally commit oneself to refrain from various types of unskillful actions.

Simply not committing a negative action is not the practice of ethics. One must commit oneself to refrain from that negative action, and then it becomes a practice of ethics. So there is the committing oneself to the abandonment of the ten unskillful actions and the practice of the ten skillful actions. That one commits oneself to refrain from the negativities, understanding the negativities involved in unskillful actions. And as much as one is able to act in accordance with one’s commitment.

So the Dharma is something which is practiced within one’s mind. And in this practice of ethics, if we think of intelligently, then we can see that involves there’s no great expense to us to practice ethics. It’s not really that difficult. We’ll stop there, but we’ll take five minutes for questions. You only get what you deserve.

So the Buddha said that from a cause that will arise, a result will be similar in type. Therefore, in order to ensure that you are able to meet with the Dharma in the future, then you must create a cause which is similar in type. And this would be that you must practice the Dharma in this life. If you practice the Dharma in this life and couple that with prayers that you’ll be able to meet the Dharma in the future, then you will have results similar to that in the future. Doesn’t make sense to me, possibly makes sense to everybody else.

Question of combining method and wisdom makes makes a lot of sense. But wisdom, as far as I’ve apprehended it so far, means something like direct realization of emptiness, which would seem to contradict things like the motivation of method being looking towards objects of enjoyment or eternal happiness. The motivation of the last two sentences. The motivation of the method or the motivation of cultivating ethics which are towards objects of enjoyment or eternal happiness. So, saying that’s kind of a wisdom?

No, I’m saying that they seem not to marry. Mean the understanding of emptiness and wishing for happiness in the future? Wishing for resources in the future seem to be contradictory. I see. Though one had realization of emptiness, but did not observe ethics nor practice generosity, then though one had an understanding of emptiness, one would still take rebirth in a bad migration.

That understanding of emptiness cannot in itself protect you from a bad migration. That, again, just the realization of emptiness by itself will not bring about liberation. That if though one has an understanding of emptiness, if one did not practice ethics and generosity, one did not practice generosity, in the future one was reborn without resources, that is, as a beggar, then would that have the supportive conditions whereby to carry on a practice? And one’s realization, understanding of emptiness would degenerate. And therefore, it would have been of no benefit to you.

But it’s not the question that that ethics or that generosity ought not to be practiced. It’s the motivation for the practice that doesn’t strike me as being as going with the realization. Why? Merely the understanding of emptiness does not eliminate desire or attachment. One has to the realization has to be cultivated over the five paths.

Path of accumulation upward. And then it’s only at the finish of the five paths that desire is eliminated. So, it says in the Entering the Middle Way that the bodhisattva, upon realizing emptiness, makes even greater effort in his practices of generosity and ethics. He makes even more effort in cultivating the awakened heart and compassion because he does not want to allow these to degenerate. This will be explained later on.

So, we cannot The realization of emptiness does not abandon desire. That even having direct realization is not enough. That one must cultivate it until it becomes extremely powerful, and then one is able to abandon from the very root desire. The the the there are five paths of the hearer. As it’s as it’s explained in the mantra

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top