45 min · 2,232 words · 16 May 1991
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the Prasangika Madhyamaka method of refuting naturally existent production, using the example of a blazing fire not producing thick darkness and the seed and sprout. It presents the consequence form of reasoning and shows how tenets differ in their assertions of emptiness and natural existence. A student discussion follows about whether seed and sprout are simultaneous and how the potency of a seed transforms into a sprout.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1991-05-16
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 24482c9f-181b-4e48-8022-601d65841f88
Words: 2,228
Thick darkness. That arise? So we cannot say that from a blazing fire, which is very luminous, arises thick darkness. It does not arise because you assert that from a naturally existent cause which is other, a naturally existent result which is other is produced. But in return, they say, Well, we do assert that from a naturally existent cause, which is other, a naturally existent result, which is other, does arise.
That doesn’t mean that from a blazing fire, the darkness should arise. The adversary goes on to say this: There’s no reason why we can say that because there’s a blazing fire that there should arise thick darkness, just because there’s no relationship between a blazing fire and thick darkness. One does not imply the other. There is no relationship between one another. Therefore, because there is a blazing fire, it is not necessary that thick darkness arise.
So then the proponent answers back, Well, if you say that, then there’s no reason why a naturally existent sprout should arise from a naturally existent seed. There’s no reason why a naturally existent sprout should arise from a naturally existent seed. Why? Because there is no reason why a naturally existent sprout should arise from a naturally existent seed Because there is no relationship between a naturally existent sprout and a naturally existent seed. They do not imply or benefit one another.
It’s just like the non existent relationship between darkness and fire. So, is this refuting reasoning, is this a parallel example? So, is the reasoning parallel between if from a naturally existent seed a naturally existent sprout is produced, then it follows that from a blazing fire, thick darkness must be produced. Is that similar reasoning? Are they concordant analogy?
Are they parallel? So if you present that as the case of making these parallel, then if the seed were nonexistent, then the sprout would arise. Even though there was no seed, the sprout would arise. Because by the nonexistence of the fire, the darkness arises. Through the nonexistence of the seed, the sprout should arise.
So, the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school is not arguing that sprouts do not arise from seeds. This is conventionally held by everyone. These are conventional realities, and these are not being refuted. What is being sought to be refuted is that naturally existent sprouts arise from naturally existent seeds. And they are saying that this is the way of refuting, that if naturally existent sprouts arose from naturally existent seeds, then thick darkness would arise from blazing fires.
So, then the adversary answers, you know, is no fault. Just because I hold that a naturally existent sprout arises from a naturally existent seed doesn’t mean that thick darkness arises from blazing fires. I do assert that natural existent sprouts arise from naturally existent seeds, Even though I assert that, I don’t have the fault. It does not hold that darkness arises from fire. You have the fault that if from a non naturally existent seed, the production of non naturally existent sprouts would mean that darkness arises from blazing fires.
What the consequence of middle way school is saying is that there exists no relationship between a naturally existent seed and a naturally existent sprout, just as there is no relationship between the fire and the darkness. Why? Because if the seed is naturally existent, it does not depend upon anything else. It exists independently. And if the sprout is naturally existent, it too exists independently without relying upon anything other.
If the sprout is naturally existent, it doesn’t rely upon anything other than itself. It does not depend upon the seed. It is established without depending upon the seed. And if the sprout exists without depending upon the seed, then there’s no relationship between the sprout and the seed. And if effects arise without depending upon causes, then there exists no relationship between them, thick darkness can just as well arise from blazing fires.
So it’s difficult then for them to reply in the face of this type of reasoning. So, it’s necessary to reflect well upon this reasoning that we’ve just presented, that if something is naturally existent, it does not depend on anything other. That is to say, if the seed is naturally existent, the seed does not depend upon anything other than itself. If the sprout is naturally existent, it does not rely upon, does not depend upon anything other than itself. Therefore, the seed and sprout are both naturally existent, then there is mutually no relationship between the seed and the sprout.
So, we are presenting a consequence, and the consequence is as follows: thick darkness arises from a blazing fire because a naturally existent effect arises from a naturally existent cause. The reason this is called a consequence is, in a consequence the assertion of the opponent is used as a reason. Using this as a reason, then the proponent is forced to accept an assertion which they do not wish to accept. By using their assertion as a reason, they are then forced, as a consequence of having to accept their own assertion, they are forced to accept a consequence which they do not wish to accept. So, the assertion which is being used as the reason is that a naturally existent sprout is produced from a naturally existent cause.
They have to accept this because this is their own assertion and this is being presented as the reason. If they accept that, then they must accept the consequence, which they do not wish to, and that is that this being the case, then thick smoke must arise, thick darkness must arise from a blazing fire as a consequence of accepting their own assertion. They must accept an undesirable premise. This is the most skillful method of refuting wrong conceptions. As a consequence, as a result of being presented such a consequence, the proponent, upon reflecting upon the significance of the consequence being presented, realizes that they can no longer maintain their original assertion, that if they were to maintain their original assertion that many faults would accrue, and therefore their wrong conception is reversed.
So, this is the first reasoning that we’re going to make use of. It would be good if you had some doubts about this, if you have questions. Why is that? If they have natural existing sprouts and natural existing natural existing causes and natural existing results, how how can there be any emptiness that contradicts anything? So they do have their own assertion.
Each tenet has their own unique assertion as to their meaning of emptiness. So they do have an assertion. They do make a presentation of emptiness. For example, the emptiness as set forth by the Sūtra School is that the self is empty of being a self sufficient, self sufficient self. That’s their presentation of emptiness.
According to the Mind Only School, they assert an emptiness, which is the emptiness of the form and the valid cognition apprehending that form as being substantially different. According to the Autonomy Middle Way School, emptiness, as they assert it, is that the object exists objectively by way of its own mode of subsistence without being posited by the force of appearing to a non-defective awareness. That’s their form of assertion of emptiness. Within all of those assertions, they assert that all phenomena are naturally existent. So according to the lower tenets, if something exists, it’s naturally existent.
Amongst the existence, there are both impermanent phenomena and permanent phenomena. So according to the lower tenets, just because something is naturally existent doesn’t mean it’s permanent. For example, sprouts are natural existent seeds are natural existent and they’re functional phenomena. Yeah. For the consequence of middle way school, they’re the same because they both don’t exist.
Natural existent objects and inherently existent objects do not exist, so there’s no difference. For the Autonomy Middle Way School, these two are mutually inclusive. Whatever is naturally existent is also inherently existent. So these are synonyms. According to the mind only school, there’s some difference between those two.
According to the mind only school asserts three natures. There is dependent nature, thoroughly established nature, and imaginary nature. Dependent nature are various functional phenomena. Thoroughly established nature is emptiness and imaginary natures are permanent phenomena. Amongst these permanent phenomena or imaginary natures, they do not Imagined natures do not naturally exist, but they inherently exist.
Thoroughly established natures, emptiness. And probably for the great exposition school and the sūtra school, natural existence, inherent existence are the same. Was talking about the seed and sprout thing different, like, produced from other, like, different entities. Uh-huh. Then there’s one argument against that, that you can’t pinpoint the moment in which the seed stops being a seed and becomes a sprout.
One argument against what? The seed and the sprout can’t be two separate entities because you can’t pick the exact moment when the seed ceases being a seed and becomes a sprout. So if I take your first assertion, you’re saying that the seed and sprout are the same entity or they’re not different entities? Well, let him follow. Let I don’t know.
I just perhaps you could just say how I think I’ll get in trouble if I’m if you could just say that is it possible to pinpoint the moment in which the seed stops being a seed and becomes a sprout, the exact moment? So the moment of the production of the sprout is the moment of the cessation of the seed. It’s simultaneous. So there is one instant, like one sixty fifth of the finger, isn’t it, or whatever, where that actually occurs, that can be pinpointed? So the production of the sprout and cessation of the seed are simultaneous, and there’s a moment where this occurs.
So, but the seed and the sprout do not exist simultaneously. If the sprout exists, then the seed doesn’t exist. So, when the essence or the potency of the seed transforms into the entity of the sprout, then that is the moment of the cessation of the seed and the production of the sprout. So, the seed has the potential to produce a sprout. So, it has this potency, the potential to produce a sprout.
When this potency is combined with, for example, water and earth, then this aggregation of conditions activates the potency and then this potency is exhausted. Once that potency is activated, then the potency is no longer present. It’s been activated. It’s exhausted. And this is the production of the sprout.
When the potential to produce the sprout has been exhausted, then there’s the production of the sprout. There’s no longer the potency, and the potency is seed. So, what we mean by the seed is potency or the potential to produce a product that is the sprout. And if we take an example of an onion, an onion has many layers of skin. But within this, in the center, there is an essence, which is its potency.
This is the actual seed. When this is planted in the ground and it comes in contact with water, a sprout arises in conjunction with that water and the potency transforms into the actual entity of the sprout. The skin remains. The skin is not the sprout. The skin is not the seed.
It is its potency which is the seed. And when its potential to produce a sprout has produced a sprout, then the seed no longer exists. It no longer remains. Some people might think because the skin still are there, that the seed is still there. So, that’s right.
If you plant like barley, barley has a husk. You put it in the ground, a sprout will arise and the husk will remain. The skin remains, but the husk is not the seed. This is if you sprout seeds, and then you have a sprouting, and you can see that the sprout arises in the skin or the shell remains. Extension of the potency.
Of the potency. Can you give me another word besides extension? At the time of the sprout, the potency for a sprout remains. That’s right. And the sprout possesses a potential to produce a subsequent sprout.
The first moment of the sprout has the potential to produce the second moment of sprout. The second moment has the potential to produce the third moment of the sprout. So it has the potential to maintain its continuum, its continuity, but not to produce another sprout. So in the way that a seed produces a fruit and a grain and a grain produces another sprout, then the sprout produces has the potential to produce a subsequent sprout. Like a chicken is born from an egg, and eggs are born from chicken.
Chicken and egg are just revolving cause and effect, just like sprouts and seeds. Without sprouts there’s no seeds? Sprouts there’s no seeds? The so what’s your question? So, at the time of the production of the sprout, the seed, the potential to produce the sprout becomes nonexistent because the potential has been transformed into the sprout.
And both the seed and the potential to produce sprout both become non existent at the time of the production of the sprout. Did you get your money back? So,
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
- The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is there a single moment when the seed ceases and the sprout is produced, and can that moment be pinpointed?
Yes, the production of the sprout and the cessation of the seed are simultaneous, and there is a moment where this occurs. The seed and sprout do not exist at the same time. The seed is its potency, the potential to produce a sprout. When water and earth activate this potency, it is exhausted, and that is the production of the sprout. Once the potency is gone, the seed no longer exists. The skin of an onion or the husk of barley remains, but it is not the seed; the seed is the potency in the center. So the remaining skin does not mean the seed is still there.