44 min · 1,850 words · 9 May 1991
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk refutes the extreme of production from self, the view that a sprout arises from itself, using reasoning from Candrakirti and Nagarjuna. It argues that cause and effect do not exist simultaneously, and that the cause ceases when the effect is established. It also covers Dharmakirti’s reductio arguments and briefly cites the Heart Sutra on the identity of the two truths.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1991-05-09
Duration: 44 min
UUID: 7de0acc7-9889-40b2-83c0-9f74ebabae5d
Words: 1,846
If you assert that the seed and sprout are of one nature, the seed being the producer and the sprout being the produced, then the producer and the produced would be of the same nature. They would be one. And if the producer and the produced were one, then all three, the producer, the produced, and the action of production would be inseparably one. So if you say that if you say the producer, the produce, and the production are one and not different, then you would have to accept the fire, the wood and the burning are one. The eater, the eaten, and the eating are one.
The goer, place of going and the going would also necessarily be one. And these are they would these would entail absurd absurdities. So these are extremely poignant reasoning which Candrakīrti is setting forth. These are the the Candrakīrti was an emanation of Mañjuśrī. It is necessary to set out that at the time of the seed, the sprout is non-existent.
But additionally if we were to assert that the sprout exists at the time of the seed then Dharmakīrti also has many additional reasons which can refute this. The seed and the sprout are cause and effect, aren’t they? So what the enumerators are asserting is that because seed and the sprout are cause and effect that it’s necessary that the effect exist at the time of the cause. Thus at the time of the seed, the sprout must exist. But our own tradition asserts that the effect does not exist at the time of the cause.
That upon the aggregation of causes and conditions an effect is newly created. That that which has not existed previously comes to be newly existent upon the cessation of the cause. Which one of those assertion is better? Candrakīrti points out the various faults if we assert that the effect exists at the time of cause. If we were to say, well how does dharmakriti go about refuting that?
So the seed and the sprout are cause and effect. But if we were to say that the sprout exists at the time of the seed, if we were to say that? The opponent is asserting that the effect exists at the time of the cause. And Dharmakīrti is debating.
He says, take for example there’s a stalk, a single stalk of grass. When you say stalk, say stem of grass, blade of grass, blade, a blade of grass. And upon this blade of grass is an insect and this insect has the karma to be reborn in the future one hundred times as a cow. Therefore, following your assertion, then it certainly follows that upon a single blade of grass there are standing one hundred cows. Why?
Because there is the karma which is the cause of those one hundred cows present and therefore if the cause and the effect are of the same nature, if the effect exists at the time of the cause, at the time of that cause, that karma, there must also be on that blade of grass one hundred cows which is the effect. Another absurdity would follow that the result of food is feces. Therefore, at the time of your eating food, you’re eating feces because they’re the same nature. So then another assertion which you could put forth would be that in Champa’s stomach there are the six varieties of migrators, the six types of migrators. Why?
Because there is the karma which is present in my stomach which would propel one into those six migrations. Therefore there’s the cause and if the cause and effect are simultaneous then there must be the six migrators in my stomach. Within my mind there must be the hellbeings, snakes, tigers. There’s a woman in my stomach. So this is the reasoning which we can make use of it to refute that at the time of the causes the effect exists.
We cannot say that within my mind there exists animals, human beings, because there is the throwing karma within my mind which would bring these effects about. Though there is the cause, the effect does not exist at the time of that cause. This type of reasoning applies equally to the case of the seed and the sprout. That the seed and the sprout have a relationship of cause and effect and at the time of the seed the sprout does not exist. At the time of the establishment of the sprout, the cause ceases at the time of the establishment of the sprout the seed ceases to exist.
That is to say, at the time of the establishment of an effect the cause ceases to exist. It becomes non existent. When the result is established, the cause becomes non existent. At the time of the cause, the effect does not exist. At the time of the effect, the cause does not exist because the potency is exhausted in the production of the result.
The potency of the cause is exhausted in order to produce the effect and therefore the cause is destroyed in the process of producing an effect. So if in asserting the cause and effect to be of the same nature then they must exist at the same time, at the same nature, and this is what is meant from production from self that since it already exists it is being produced again from itself. But from the point of view of our own tradition we hold that cause and effect are not of the same nature. The cause does not exist at the time of the effect and the effect does not exist at the time of the cause. Therefore there is no production from self.
So by use of these various reasons of Candrakīrti and Nāgārjuna, the assertions of the enumerators of production from self are refuted. That is they say that the sprout is produced from itself. So, we have simply used as a basis of illustration of sprout in refuting production from self, but this equally holds true for all products. So that completes the refutation of production, the extreme of production from self. If you have any questions?
Yes? Until germination, and then it becomes a cause. So the seed is both a cause and an effect. It’s an effect of previous crops and it’s also a cause because it has the potency to produce an effect. And this potency exists at the potency to grow a sprout, this potency exists at the same time as the seed itself.
The potency and the seed exist at the same time. But in general, the seed is both a cause and effect simultaneously. In general we can say that cause and effect exist simultaneously, but when we apply it to in terms of a particular basis, for example the seed, that is the cause and its result is the sprout. That seed and that sprout in the relationship of cause and effect do not exist simultaneously. But in general we can say that cause and effect exist simultaneously.
But in terms of a particular basis, then they do not exist simultaneously. The sprout and the seed do not exist simultaneously. More developed seed. A more developed — I think that’s what the enumerators are saying. More developed When the sprout is developed the seed has been transformed into the sprout.
The sprout arises through the transformation of a potency which the seed possesses and when that potency is completely exhausted in the process of being transformed into a sprout and the seed cannot exist at the time of the sprout. Has been completely exhausted. There’s another type of production for example of a mother giving birth to a child. At the time of the child, the mother who gave birth to the child is non existent. But there is a similarity, there is a continuity of similarity of type of the mother.
Her potency has not been exhausted. That we can say that the mother continues to exist but not the mother at the time of the child because she has a continuity of similarity of type. But the mother which is the giver of birth to that child no longer exists at the time of the child. The mother which actually was present at the moment of birth of the child no longer exists. There’s a difference between these two ways of production.
In the case of the seed, there’s no continuity of similarity of type. Its potency is completely exhausted in being transformed into substantially into the sprout whereas the mother’s potency for her further continuance has not been exhausted even though she has given birth to a result in the child. Yeah. That’s Yeah. What can we say for genetically?
How do you say? I don’t know how to say that. So the the the the for example, a a a child and and its continuum into becoming an adult, that the child of say five years old is the cause of the child of six years old and that child is the cause of the child of seven until they cannot be of the same nature because they are of the nature of cause and effect. In order for two things to be of the same nature they must exist simultaneously And the child of five and six do not exist simultaneously therefore they cannot be of the same nature. They’re cause and effect but the similarity of type keeps arising but they’re not the same nature.
I know. So this occurs over every moment of the continuum, that the previous moment gives rise to the subsequent moment, moment by moment. They’re not the same nature because they cause an effect. Same nature. The.
As a relationship of cause and effect. A relation yeah. Without the previous having existed then the subsequent cannot exist. Without the seed having existed then the sprout cannot exist. So there’s that relationship.
Another translation is the same entity. Same nature, same entity. Here in discussion of the enumerators that they are saying that the sprout and the seed are inseparably one. When they assert that the two things are the same nature, it is in the same way that a flower and a metok are the same nature in the sense that they are inseparably one. I ask — the same as if I hear “by same nature” it could also mean same entity.
And in this case of the enumerators it would mean very much the same, same nature and same entity. But in general there is a distinction. For example, the two truths, conventional truth and ultimate truth are the same In Heart of Wisdom Sūtra it says, form is emptiness, emptiness is form. Other than form there is no emptiness, other than emptiness there is no form. And this teaches that the two truths are of the same entity, that the conventional truth and ultimate truth are the same entity and this applies to all phenomena.
Key terms in this teaching
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
- Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.