Entering the Middle Way – 09 Entering 1991 03 07

45 min · 2,784 words · 7 March 1991

Entering the Middle Way (Khensur Rinpoche)
Entering the Middle Way (Khensur Rinpoche)
Entering the Middle Way - 09 Entering 1991 03 07
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk begins a commentary on Candrakirti’s Entering the Middle Way, opening with the bodhisattva motivation and the role of a text as an example to follow. It then explains the five paths, linked to the mantra of the Heart Sutra, and the first ground (the Very Joyful), including its qualities and the ultimate and conventional awakening mind.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1991-03-07

Duration: 46 min

UUID: 962346ae-e5fe-4700-b9a1-cf5907e8c47d

Words: 2,780

Begin by developing the kind hearted attitude which among the two, ourselves and others, holds others more dear and wishes to lead them to complete happiness and eliminate all of their suffering. In order to lead others to complete happiness, to eliminate their suffering, that if I do not myself if I do not eliminate the faults of myself and bring the consummation of my excellent qualities, then I will not be able to achieve that end. In order to achieve that end of eliminating all my various faults and bringing the consummation of all my excellent qualities, I must carry on a practice. So for the next three minutes, cultivate the kind hearted attitude of the awakening heart, which is that in order to eliminate all my various faults, in order to bring to consummation all my excellent qualities, that I must practice the Dharma. In order to practice the Dharma, I must understand it thoroughly.

And therefore, I’m going to try and seek to understand this present teaching in order that I might be able to benefit all sentient beings. Supplemental middle way, entering into the middle way, and remember, I just recited the verse, which is listed in your translation as four c to five b, where it says, the mind of a child of a conqueror overpowered with compassion to liberate migrators dedicated with Samantabhādra’s aspirations and abiding in joy is called the first. So the text that we’re discussing is the Entering Into the Middle Way, Madhyamakāvatāra, and by the author is Candrakīrti. And why did he compose this text? It was in order for his many disciples to be able to practice the great vehicle well.

So in this the Entering the Middle Way is a book or a text. In Tibetan language, a text is called a. So the the etymology of this word, which is simply translated as text. There’s two there’s two syllables. Means literally means example.

And, generally, we talk about the example and then the meaning of the example. So and the word here means the factor. So the factor of the example. So a is that which is the factor or the element of the example aside from the factor of meaning. Just the the element or the factor of example.

So this the word Tibetan word, pecha, actually, it has a rather significant meaning. Literally, we could say it means the factor of example. And what is being set out is the exemplification of those who have practiced the Dharma. How did they go about their practice? What did they do?

What did they realize? What qualities did they achieve through their practice? So a pecha is an illustration of the mode and the the mode of practice, the types of practices, and what is achieved through practices by practitioners who have actually done this before. So the the the text, which is the setting forth the factor of the example, those we come to understand how those previous practitioners what types of practice they engaged in, how they went through their various practices. We listen to these explanations.

We study them. We come to an understanding so that we ourselves can engage in like types of practices, achieve those same qualities, eliminate those various those similar types of faults. And this is the purpose. So there is example and then the purpose. The example is the illustration of others’ practices and methods of practice.

And then the but the purpose of this study is to achieve those same ends ourselves. So there’s a great deal of meaning in this term, translated as text. So presently, we’re engaged in the process of listening to and reflecting upon the text entering into the Middle Way. And this you know, who was it who was it that practiced Who’s who whose practice is being being illustrated in this text? Those are the very the practitioners who were trainees intent on entering into the middle way.

And their methods of having accomplished this are set forth. Now we begin to what is being taught are the various practices and how to implement those practices. What what how did they achieve their ends? What did they achieve? What did they eliminate in the course of practicing, attaining their levels of understanding?

All of this in order to that we can follow in this in the same we can follow upon making use of their same methods to achieve these same ends. So to give a humorous illustration of this process of following as those who did before, in this and likewise, in in my there’s a story in my home area where I came from. There was a great lama had come, and the various high officials were going to have an audience to go meet with this high lama. Many of the officials, these other high officials, they had never met such a high person, and they didn’t know the protocol. And they’re wondering, you know, how should we go and meet this person?

And the one high official said, just do exactly as I do. Just follow my example. And so they were going to to the place where the high the high lama was sitting, and it was very muddy. And the first high official, he slipped and fell in the mud. And the all the rest of them slipped and fell in the mud.

So we are to follow in the same way, but we are to look toward the bodhisattva and act in the same way as they did. Candrakīrti sets out the method of meditation or cultivation for his those trainees intent on the you know, on entering. And first, he says that they should cultivate compassion. Having cultivated compassion, then they should cultivate the understanding of emptiness. And out of this they will achieve the awakening heart.

But in this case, what is nominal, what is called nominal, or merely name awakening heart. Once they have increased their and achieved an actual experience of the awakening heart, then they become fully qualified it becomes a fully qualified awakening heart, they become bodhisattvas. So we who are seeking to practice the great vehicle should follow in the same manner as the previous bodhisattvas, those who were who practice in accordance with the training entering into the middle way. They first cultivated compassion, then generated the wisdom, understanding, emptiness. Having achieved the nominal awakening heart, intensified their experience, and finally became fully qualified bodhisattvas.

So having the upon initially generating the awakening heart, one enters into the the first of the five paths of the great vehicle, and one becomes a a novice bodhisattva. Then these five paths are set out in the in the heart of wisdom sūtra, within the mantra, Gate Gate Pāragate Pārasamgate Bodhi Svāhā. This sets out the five paths of the great vehicle. So the Gate Gate is the first two paths. Pāragate is the third path.

Pārasamgate is the fourth path, and Bodhi is the fifth path. So in this mantra, which sets out the five paths of the great vehicle, the first it mentions the syllable, Gate Gate, denoting the first of the two paths. And these two paths are the paths of ordinary beings. And by ordinary beings, we mean those who have not had direct realization of emptiness. Once one achieves the direct realization of emptiness, one is no longer an ordinary being but is a superior.

That is to say, one is superior to ordinary beings, having gained direct realization of emptiness and achieved the third of five paths. So during these these so these first two syllables, denote the first of the two of the five paths, and the paths of ordinary beings. And these beings engage in various practices, and the main types of practices in which they are engaging in the course while they abide on these two paths are the cultivation of intensifying their great compassion, deepening their wisdom, realizing emptiness, intensifying their awakening heart. But they combine this with the the various other practices of the six perfections such as generosity, ethics, etcetera. So these first two paths are called the path the first is the path of accumulation.

The second is the path of preparation. Then then the third syllable is that of Pāragate. Pāragate denotes the third of the five paths. And these are these are correct paths, or this path of superior. It is at this point that one achieves direct perception of emptiness, and one becomes a great vehicle superior by the power of that.

And then the fourth syllables, Pārasamgate denotes the increase in the force of one’s wisdom realizing emptiness that one achieves the fourth of the five paths. Then the syllable Bodhi denotes the exalted wisdom of the Buddha, which is the path of the Buddha. So over the course of the third and fourth path, then as denoted by the syllables Pāragate and Pārasamgate, denoting the third and fourth path, there is a presentation of the ten grounds or the ten levels, the ten bhumis, which are spread out over these two paths. So the the third path that denoted by the term Pāragate is only includes the first of the ten ground. Then the fourth path denoted by the term Pārasamgate, it it includes part of the first ground and the remaining remaining grounds up to the tenth ground.

So there are no grounds on the first of the two paths. When the grounds begin on the on the on the third path. And we’ve we have arrived at an explanation of this first ground on the third path. So we’re going to be discussing what are the qualities of having attained the first of the ten grounds. And this is explained in terms of one’s own qualities, in terms qualities in terms of oneself, and there are eight of these, but also in the qualities of of outshining others in terms of one’s qualities relative to others.

So in terms of oneself, there are eight qualities. In terms of how it compares to others, there is the quality of outshining others. So, again, beginning with that verse that we first mentioned where it says, the son of the child of the conqueror, overpowered by their compassion. But additionally, haven’t achieved the direct perception of emptiness. They have now achieved the first ground.

There are two types I’m translating this term in two different ways. bodhicitta. The usual, what we call conventional awakening heart. The awakening heart is what we normally talking about, that for the sake of all sentient beings may attain Buddhahood. This is called the conventional enlightenment mind or mind of enlightenment.

I translate it as the awakening heart. But there’s another type, is the ultimate awakening mind or or the ultimate mind of enlightenment, ultimate bodhicitta, which is the direct perception of emptiness. Emptiness. It is an ultimate mind. It’s it directly perceives emptiness.

So there are there is a direct the ultimate awakening mind and the conventional awakening heart. I translate a little bit different. There the there are various presentations of these ten grounds. There is a presentation as it is set forth in one of them for clear realization, and there is also the the presentation as set forth here in in our present text entering into the middle way. And there’s a difference in these two presentations.

The presentation as set forth in ornament is much more vast. It sets forth many all of the various qualities which are attained at each of the grounds such as the various not only the the emptiness which is being realized, but also the various types of compassion and, you know, and in detail, the various qualities. But here in in entering, when it it only talks about the ten grounds in terms of their direct perception of emptiness. There is the direct perception of emptiness at the first ground, direct perception of emptiness at the second ground. So it it’s a very narrow explanation compared to the ornament.

At the at the path, which is denoted by the the syllable Pāragate, which is the first ground, one achieves the direct perception of emptiness. And this is an ultimate mind. It is the ultimate awakening mind. And just as in the case where one we call someone who has for example, if someone has taken the vows of a monk, we call that person a monk. If they’ve taken the vows of a nun, we take we call that person a nun.

If they’ve taken the vows of female lay vow female lay vows, we call that that person a female lay holder vow holder. A lay lay female vow holder, etcetera. Likewise here, because this person has achieved this bodhisattva has achieved the ultimate mind, we give them a new name. We call them ultimate bodhisattvas. This bodhisattva, upon having achieved the first ground, it is said of this bodhisattva that they had been born into the lineage of those thus gone or born into the lineage of the Tathagatas, that is to say, the Buddhas.

And this is said because they have gone they have moved very far from the lesser vehicle, and they are very close to the actual attainment of Buddhahood. So therefore, they are said to be born in the lineage of the Tathagatas or the Buddhahood. Having been born into the lineage of those thus gone, then as it says in verse number six, he completely forsakes the three links. And these three links are great faults or obstacles to the attainment of Buddhahood, and these are completely abandoned from their very root at this point. And he generates within his mind a great a great joy or a great bliss.

So how is how is this great joy or bliss generated within the bodhisattva’s mind at this point? He he realizes that he has now abandoned these three great faults, these three links, And he he understands that he no longer they no longer exist. That he and in fact, he understanding this, then there are right he he there is no doubt within his mind any longer that he’s quickly going to attain Buddhahood. And there’s a great rejoicing since his sole intention is to attain Buddhahood for the sake of sentient beings. And now he realizes very deeply that he’s actually going to quickly, without doubt, achieve that end.

And it rises in this great sense of joy and bliss from this understanding. So, therefore, this first ground is termed the very joyful. And in Tibetan, means very or great. Means joy. Very joyful, great joy.

At this point, he achieves magnificent qualities. He eliminates far reaching thoughts, and he has tremendous power. And the power to the extent, as it mentions here in in the text itself, at the end of verse six, that he is able to vibrate a hundred world systems. That despite the the tapping of his foot, the the the world’s a hundred world systems will cause the shake. And as the text goes on to say in verse number seven, he at at this point, and advancing from ground to ground, ascends now all paths to bad migration have ceased.

He no longer he he has completely blocked or completely ceased the possibility of taking rebirth in bad migrations. So his his capacity is continually increasing, his power, by means of which he advances through the grounds from the first ground to the second ground to third ground. This is done in terms of of his increasing his capacity and power. And as it says in the on the in the third line of the seventh verse, all the levels of ordinary beings are ended. This this being is having attained the first ground a great vehicle superior, and he he no longer abides on any of the the the paths of ordinary people.

Yeah. So if his qualities were to be extensively explained, they would be explained in terms of twelve sets of hundreds of qualities. Twelve sets of hundreds of qualities. So, I mean, his his qualities at this point, that the bodhisattva having that direct perception of emptiness are unimaginable. And if we were to attain the first ground, then we would have same attain these same qualities.

We would have the same powers. So all of these various qualities, whatever they might be, these excellent qualities, these good qualities are in terms of oneself, one’s one’s own individual. In terms in reference to oneself, one has these qualities.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top