Entering the Middle Way – 04 Entering 1991 02 14

44 min · 2,277 words · 14 February 1991

Entering the Middle Way (Khensur Rinpoche)
Entering the Middle Way (Khensur Rinpoche)
Entering the Middle Way - 04 Entering 1991 02 14
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. A commentary on the three types of compassion, drawn from the Entering the Middle Way verse on compassion for migrators likened to a moon reflected in rippling water. Compassion observing merely sentient beings is the base, and compassion observing impermanence and then emptiness grows stronger through the realizations that accompany it, though the wish for beings to be free of suffering stays the same. The talk closes by contrasting renunciation, which concerns one’s own suffering, with compassion for others, and by discussing the mental unhappiness that compassion can bring.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1991-02-14

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 798d510c-dbec-4a44-ba52-8c5335c3ba23

Words: 2,273

So, this is the first method in the development of compassion, that we are to direct these four levels of immeasurables toward all sentient beings, that is to say, with equal regard, without any bias, without any feelings of difference, whether it’s enemy, whether it’s a friend, whether it’s animal, whatever it is, to direct these levels of immeasurables. First, wouldn’t it be wonderful if all sentient beings were free of suffering and the causes of suffering? May they be free of suffering and the causes of suffering. I myself will free them from suffering and the causes of suffering. Please empower me that I might be able to free them from suffering and the causes of suffering.

And this aspiration should not be something that we recite from the mouth, just words coming from our mouth, but we should try to actually generate these states of mind. And out of this will come a very powerful compassion. It is extremely beneficial to cultivate compassion in this way. So this the compassion which arises in this way is the first of the three compassions. It is called compassion observing merely sentient beings, merely sentient beings.

The second type of compassion is called compassion observing phenomena. Then so with respect to the second and third types of compassion, this line from the text where it says, homage to that compassion for migrators seen as evanescent and empty of inherent existence like a moon in rippling water, this directly teaches the third type of compassion, which is compassion observing the unapprehendable, and indirectly teaches the second type of compassion, which is the compassion observing phenomena. And where it says evanescent, this is to be taken as meaning impermanent in a sense of momentary disintegration. So, it is presenting the compassions in terms of analogy.

And first it refers to migrators, or that is to say sentient beings. And of course by this we mean all sentient beings. And it refers — it says that they are evanescent. No, it says that it refers to the water which is rippling. Now, there you have a small body of water which is clear and still.

And then there is a moon which appears reflected on the surface of the water and then a very light breeze, a wind comes along and ripples the surface of the water. And therefore the reflection of the moon appears to be changing. That is it. The moon does not remain the same from moment to moment. It is momentarily — it cannot. It momentarily is not able to remain as it was the previous moment. It’s undergoing momentary disintegration. Likewise, all sentient beings who, due to the force of afflictive emotions and karma, are not able to remain static, that they are constantly undergoing change, undergoing momentary disintegration. So, you know, it’s sure it’s for sure that we’ve all seen this similar type of situation explained in this analogy.

And there’s a small clear surface of water and the moon appears and its reflection is reflected on the surface of water. A light breeze comes along and the surface of the water ripples and that moon is not static even for a moment. Is the reflection static even for a moment? No. So the wind ripples the water.

So what is the migrators? We are similar to these migrators being referred to here. It refers to all sentient beings. And by that is meant beings which take rebirth under the influence of afflictive emotions and karma.

That such types of beings are not able to remain static even for a moment. That they are constantly undergoing a process of disintegration. That from the very moment of birth, initiation of the process of disintegration begins, that we simply do not remain static, unchanging, even for one moment. This is what is meant by impermanence, that is to say momentary disintegration from moment to moment. Are we undergoing momentary production and disintegration?

It’s just like a clock. The hand never remains in one position. It’s continually, momentarily moving. It never is not moving. Likewise, our life is continually under the process of disintegration.

So, a phenomenon were not undergoing this momentary disintegration, that is to say, if a phenomenon abided in a state of non-disintegration, then that is what we mean by a permanent phenomenon. By impermanent phenomena, we mean those types of phenomena which are undergoing this process of momentary disintegration. So there are permanent phenomena which do not undergo momentary disintegration. They are unchanging. They are not born.

They are not produced out of causes. And they also give no results. But we ourselves are impermanent. We have causes, we produce results, that from time to time we have suffering, from time to time we have happiness, this changeability. So it is those sentient beings which are qualified in this manner of momentary disintegration just as the reflection of the moon rippling in the water is evanescent.

Never static. Likewise, sentient beings who are forced to take embodiment under the force of afflictive emotions and karma are in the same way evanescent. They are undergoing momentary disintegration. So we develop the second type of compassion with observing sentient beings qualified by this impermanence. So observing these types of sentient beings qualified by momentary disintegration, we develop wouldn’t it be wonderful if sentient beings were free from suffering the causes of suffering?

May they be free from suffering the causes of suffering. I myself will free them from suffering the causes of suffering. Please empower me to be able to free them from suffering the causes of their suffering. So what we mean by compassion observing phenomena: it is the compassion which is affected by the wisdom having realized impermanence, observing sentient beings, qualified by impermanence. So it is a compassion which is being affected by a wisdom which has previously realized impermanence, being directly affected by a wisdom which has previously realized impermanence, and this compassion observing sentient beings qualified by impermanence.

This is what we mean by compassion observing phenomena. So, then the third type of compassion. This is set out directly in this verse, in that it says now in terms of the emptiness of inherent existence, not only the momentary disintegration but also the emptiness of inherent existence. So taking this analogy of the appearance of the moon in the water, though it appears to be a real moon, in fact it is not. And though phenomena appear to truly exist, in fact they do not.

So this third type of compassion, which is the compassion observing the unapprehendable. The unapprehendable is the true existence. So this third compassion refers to a compassion which is directly affected by a wisdom having realized emptiness of true existence. This compassion which is affected in this way is now observing sentient beings qualified by the emptiness of true existence. So this individual has directly realized emptiness of true existence.

And this wisdom which has directly realized — so this compassion is the unification of the wisdom having directly realized emptiness and compassion, observing sentient beings who are qualified by their emptiness. And this is what is meant by the compassion observing the unapprehendable, this unification of this wisdom and compassion. You know, when we do Guru Puja, Lama Chopa. And we say the line — it means unapprehendable, means mercy or translated as compassion. So this is referring to the compassion observing the unapprehendable.

So amongst these three types of compassion, it is this third, the compassion observing the unapprehendable, which is supreme. And then that which is placed beneath that is the compassion which is affected by realization of impermanence which observes sentient beings. And there is the third of these types of compassions, and that is the compassion observing merely sentient beings. And that is to say, it is a compassion, but it is not in any way affected by a realization of impermanence nor is it affected by a realization of emptiness. It is simply observing the suffering of sentient beings and there arises the various levels of compassion, how wonderful it would be, may they be — requesting observe that they be free of their suffering and the causes of their suffering.

Simply observing suffering sentient beings, the mere suffering of sentient beings unaffected by either the realizations of impermanence or emptiness. So the order of cultivation of these three levels of compassion would begin with the first, developing the compassion which observes merely sentient beings, that is to say, which merely observes their suffering and develops the aspiration, the wish that they be free from suffering and the cause of their suffering. And then one would go on to gain the wisdom realizing impermanence. And then this would affect one’s compassion, observing those sentient beings. And this would be the second type.

And then one would go on to cultivate a realization of emptiness, and then this would affect one’s compassion observing those sentient beings, and this would be the third type of compassion. So, the reason that there is an increase in the power of these three levels of compassion: the first, that which merely observes sentient beings, that which observes mere sentient beings, has no assistant. The second has the assistance of the wisdom realizing impermanence. It’s assisted by that. And the third is assisted by the wisdom realizing non-true existence.

And so this is the reason it is the most forceful of these. So we’ll stop there, but we’ll take five minutes for questions. That’s right. The nature of, or the aspect is compassion. The aspect of all three of these is compassion.

And the nature of that compassion remains unchanged. But the second is more powerful than the first, the third more powerful than the second due to the force of the accompanying realizations. In the case of the second, that realization of impermanence; the third, realization of non-true existence. It’s due to this that there is an increase in power, increase in the quality and the excellent quality of the meditator who possesses these. But the aspect is compassion in its nature.

Doesn’t change. So that’s right. So because one has realized impermanence and realizing impermanence, seeing sentient beings grasping at what is impermanent as permanent. So the forcefulness of one’s compassion is increased. Because it’s being assisted by one’s own realization of impermanence, when we observe sentient beings and realizing, understanding that they are grasping at the impermanent as permanent, one’s compassion is increased.

Though the nature of the compassion is the same, it is more forceful. So the object of observation of all of these three compassions is sentient beings. Same. The aspect, the subjective aspect, is may this being be free of suffering and the causes of suffering. So that aspect, that is the aspect, the subjective aspect, is exactly the same throughout all three of these compassions.

Okay. Why is that? So does compassion have a nature of suffering? Does compassion have a component of suffering? Yeah.

So, we don’t experience suffering because suffering only arises out of unskillful actions, and we haven’t created the unskillful action for it to arise. Therefore, we don’t experience suffering when we generate compassion observing someone else suffering. But we can experience an unhappiness of our mind, an unhappiness of mind. They don’t call it suffering. They call it unhappiness of mind.

And this arises out of preconceptions. And the Buddhas don’t have preconceptions. So though they have compassion, they don’t experience this unhappiness of mind. But you can experience unhappiness in mind by generating compassion. We don’t call that suffering though.

Suffering arises out of unskillful actions. So there is due to the thinking process or thoughts, we experience some kind of mental unhappiness. So at such a time then we should practice giving and taking. Sometimes when people practice giving and taking and they generate compassion they experience some kind of mental unhappiness and then they should think about the benefits of the development of compassion, all of its advantages and this will help to lighten their mind and the mental unhappiness will go away. So renunciation and great compassion are opposites.

Renunciation is generated in terms of one’s own experience of suffering, observing the various types of suffering that one is undergoing, that I can’t stand to undergo this in the future. If I don’t do something, then I’m going to continually undergo this same suffering again and again and again. Therefore I have to make use of this opportunity to practice the Dharma and to rid myself of suffering once and for all. And there arises the aspiration to be free of suffering, which is the mind of renunciation in terms of one’s own suffering. But on the other hand, compassion is observing other sentient beings’ suffering, developing the thought, may they be free of suffering and the cause of the suffering, and out of this comes compassion.

So one is observing one’s own suffering, suffering in terms of oneself when it comes to renunciation, and suffering in terms of others when they develop compassion. So that’s right. But so in terms of oneself, renunciation and compassion are the same. In terms of others, we can speak of compassion, but we can’t talk about renunciation in terms of others. Okay.

So, do we want to suffer or do we not want to suffer? And we naturally answer, well, I don’t want to suffer. And therefore, we have to abandon our suffering if we don’t want to suffer. And in order to abandon our suffering, we have to

Key terms in this teaching

Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Does compassion have a nature of suffering, or does it include a component of suffering?

Compassion does not involve suffering, because suffering arises only from unskillful actions, and generating compassion for someone else's suffering does not create such an action. However, one can experience unhappiness of mind, which is not called suffering. This unhappiness arises from preconceptions. Buddhas have no preconceptions, so although they have compassion, they do not experience it. If mental unhappiness arises when generating compassion, one should practice giving and taking. One can also think about the benefits and advantages of developing compassion. This lightens the mind, and the unhappiness goes away.

Scroll to Top