46 min · 3,159 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 46-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche uses a single flower to explore a fundamental paradox: phenomena appear to us as solid and truly existing, yet are empty of inherent existence. He outlines three levels of dependent arising—dependence on causes and conditions, on parts and attributes, and on imputation by thought—that explain why this paradox is real. Rather than abstract argument, he employs vivid thought experiments: How does a grub perceive the flower? Where does color exist? Why does a pen’s size change with distance? These experiments show how mind and sensory experience participate in what we call reality. He then applies this analysis to the self: the “I” is empty of inherent existence, yet ignorance of this drives all suffering. For practitioners already familiar with bodhicitta and Lamrim training.
—
**Issues flagged:** None
File metadata (for organising)
File: Line in 0213 – KR.mp3
UUID: 9ac4326d-c563-4c88-8d2f-5a109313cd80
Teacher: —
Collection: Emptiness
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,156
Today we do the meditation on emptiness and dependent arising. And this is the wisdom aspect of the path, which is the second great wing that balances the wing of method by which we can fly to Buddhahood as the analogy is set out. And the main, the most important component of the method part is the aspiration that we developed yesterday which is bodhicitta and now we complement that by developing the wisdom side of the path. And this today will be based on verses 106 to 108 the Lama Chöpa request prayer, which goes, We seek your blessings to complete the perfection of wisdom through the space like yoga of single-minded placement upon ultimate truth, conjoined with the ecstasy and great bliss induced by the discriminating wisdom analysing suchness. We seek your blessings to connect subsequent attainment on illusion by realising how all external phenomena like true existence yet still appear like a mirage, a dream or the image of the moon on a still lake.
saṃsāra, nirvana lack even an atom of true existence. All cause and effect interdependent arising are unfailing. We seek your blessings to discern the import of Nāgārjuna’s thought which is that these two are complementary and not contradictory. So before we enter into the meditation on that, let’s do the preliminaries. First calming our mind, bringing our focus to the breath as we’ve been doing.
Now developing positive motivation in the three stages, as we’ve been doing before. Now having developed this positive motivation of bodhicitta visualize the refuge field and with a sense of fear and faith, we recite the verses as we’ve been doing from the sheet, starting with I go for refuge to the Lama, I go for refuge to the Lama, I go for refuge to the Buddha, I go for refuge to the Buddha, I go for refuge to the Buddha, I go for refuge to the Dharma, I go for refuge to the Dharma, I go for refuge to the Sangha, I go for refuge to the Sangha, I go for refuge to the Sangha, I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha by the merit of meditating on Lamrim and so on. May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, by the merit of meditating on Lamrim and so on, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am enlightened, to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, by the merit of meditating on Lamrim and so on, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings.
Four immeasurables, may all sentient beings have happiness and its causes, may all sentient beings be free from suffering and its causes, May all sentient beings never be separated from happiness and be free of suffering. May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment and anger, holding some close and others distant. I prostrate with body, speech and mind in faith, each and every offering I make, including those really performed and those mentally transformed. I declare all non virtuous actions accumulated from time without beginning. I rejoice in all ordinary and noble beings actions.
Please Buddha by living as our guide and till saṃsāra ends reveal the teachings to all sentient beings. I dedicate the virtues of myself and others to the great enlightenment. By the virtue of offering to you assembly of Buddhas visualized before me, this mandala built on a base resplendent with flowers, saffron water and incense, adorned with Mount Meru and the four continents as well as the sun and the moon, may all sentient beings share in its good effects. O holy and venerable Lama, with the clouds of compassion that form in the skies of your dharmakaya wisdom, please release a rain of vast and profound dharma precisely in accordance with the needs of those to be trained. And verse 84.
Recalling Rinpoche’s commentary on this verse today. Through the power of having made offerings and respectful requests to you, O holy and venerable Gurus, supreme field of merit, we seek your blessings, O protectors and root of well-being and bliss, that we may come under your joyful care. So in thinking about emptiness and dependent arising, we need to think of the two truths. The two truths are the conventional truth and the ultimate truth. And these two truths are characteristics of each and every phenomena.
So for example, if we take the flower which is sitting here at the front and we’ll talk about the flower a lot during the session today, so have a look at the flower if you’ve got your eyes shut. Get a view of the flower sitting here if you can all see it. This flower these flowers just we look at any one of these flowers, it has two sorts of characteristics. One of the characteristics is that it is a conventional truth and one of its characteristics is that it has the characteristic of ultimate truth associated with it in the one same entity. Two characteristics in the same entity of the flower.
And so the way the flower there’s different levels of way this appears to different levels of being and their realisation. When we ordinary beings look at this flower, then what appears to us is the flower mixed with the flower appearing to really be there outside from its own side by itself, inherently existent. It profoundly seems that way to us, it appears that way. But it isn’t that way That’s a mistaken projection on our part, that appearance. And the fact that it doesn’t have the fact that that appearance is not true, that it’s mistaken, the fact that the flower lacks that that is the emptiness characteristic of the flower.
And the reason the flower lacks that inherent existence even though it appears to have it is because it’s a dependent arising phenomenon like all phenomena are. We see, whenever we look at the flower or any other phenomena, it appears always mixed with seeming to be inherently existent, existing from its own side, truly existent, really there by itself in its own right. But when one attains the path of seeing and has one’s first direct realization of emptiness, then at that moment, one will only have appearing to one the emptiness of true existence, the lack of inherent existence. Only that will appear, no other phenomena will appear to one, one’s consciousness at that time. And then, when one comes out of that wisdom of meditative equipoise and emptiness and goes into the wisdom of subsequent attainment, one will then see the phenomena again, the flower will again appear to you and it will appear to you the inherent existence of the flower will still appear at that stage, but now one clearly knows that that is not true.
One sees through it, so you realise that this is not the way it seems like. This still appears, but I know that an incorrect appearance. I know that with great clarity now. And then at the stage of Buddhahood, in the Buddha’s omniscient mind, always the one awareness will see the flower and the emptiness of the flower, two simultaneously, whereas previously the one mind of the bodhisattva up to that point can only see either one or the other, not both together in one consciousness. So this is a super brief outline of the path of practice up through the paths to the state of Buddhahood that is the work of meditating on emptiness, is to be able to move through those states from where we are now to the state of Buddhahood.
Emptiness the flower is empty because it’s a dependent arising and it’s being a dependent arising can be understood at three levels. The first level is that it’s a dependent arising because of causes and conditions, the second because it is dependent on its parts, and the third is that it’s a dependent arising of the most subtle of the three because it’s merely imputed by thought. So let’s go through these one by one and meditate a little on each of these. We think of the causes and conditions that this flower depends on. When we see the flower, really, it seems to be there just an object isolated and cut off from everything else, quite separate, but this is not the way.
The flower comes about by a whole set of causes and conditions and this level is very easy to understand and yet quite powerful if one thinks about it a lot. We think of all of the conditions the sun, the sunlight, the water, the seed, the earth all of these came together in this flower. It also depends on all the laws of physics and chemistry and biology. All these laws and processes come together constituting the flower, allowing it to exist. So we can begin to see that the whole universe comes together, similar to the idea we used with special kindness.
There’s this vast interconnected network of causes and conditions that spreads out and includes the whole universe, all of which come together supporting, constituting and making a reality this flower. So develop this strong sense of there can be no flower existing independent of that vast network of causes and conditions Then moving on to the second of the two levels, considering that the flowers are dependent arising on the basis of its parts and its attributes. We think if you take away it’s made up, it’s got all these things that come together petals and stem and stamen and it’s got particular shape and color and there are all sorts of characteristics come together. And the flower can only exist in association with this coming together of all these parts. If you take those parts away, there can’t be any flower.
And now the third and most profound and difficult to understand of these three types of dependent arising. This is that the flower exists merely by the imputation of thought. And perhaps this one is so difficult to get some grasp of because it goes so deeply against our most profound conviction about the way the world is. But the idea here is that if there’s no consciousness to which the flower appears, it can’t exist. Its existence depends on its being posited by, imputed by, or appearing to consciousness.
And rather than going through some arguments, I want to give you a number of thought experiments to try and help stimulate to get a sense of what this might mean. First thought experiment is in regard to how different beings might relate to this object. So for us, there’s a flower sitting here. We all agree on that, it appears to us and we agree on that, but if I look closely and I see there’s a little grub inside the flower gnawing away at one of the petals, try and put yourself in the place of that grub. What is it that exists in this area of the flower for the grub?
Certainly perhaps a tasty meal, maybe not the flower in the way that we know it. Second thought experiment, let’s think about the color of the flower. One of these important things that is so important to us about what constitutes flowers, its beautiful color. Let’s try and get a sense of what the color actually is, where is this color? This lovely orange color of this flower.
Where is it? Is it out there in the flower? Is it in my mind? If I don’t have any experience of that orange color, where does it exist? If I have a blind friend and I’m trying to tell him about what orange is like as a phenomenal object, what am I going to say?
That color arises dependently on the consciousness that observes it. And you hear accounts of people having these blind people who regain sight, see a colour for the first time. A new object enters their experience for the first time ever, which didn’t exist before for them. Another part of this thought experiment, our eyes have a trichromatic vision system, we have three color receptors. Some animals have only two, bees have four, tetrachromatic.
Bees can see in the ultraviolet spectrum. Just try and imagine a phenomenon that we have never experienced, we can’t even imagine, but bees have it. We don’t. Because of the special eye faculty of a bee and various other creatures they have a consciousness that perceives a phenomena that we don’t and can’t even imagine. Begin to think that the objects which seem so hard and out there from their own side are beginning to feel a little bit shaky.
Next experiment. Here, open your eyes and pick up a pen or a pencil. Hold it in front of you. Look at the pen in front of you. Quite close to your eyes, as close as you can focus.
We’re looking at the size. We’re asking if this is an inherently existent object that somehow exists completely independent of us and our experience, then its size is invariable, one would expect. But just move it back as far as your hand can go, full length, and it smaller. It’s quite big when it’s up close to your eyes, you put it back there, it’s smaller. How bizarre.
Of course, we understand the physics of this, but nevertheless, this experience of an object getting smaller is a bit strange. So his size does this throw some question on? The object being there from its own side? The next experiment, again with the pen in your hand, but with your eyes shut this time. Hardness.
One would expect that hardness and shape as felt would be pretty inherently existent. I mean, the stuff in the world is just there and we feel it. Hold the pen. Put your concentration on the skin near the pen, the sensations that come from the skin near the pen. What you are experiencing is a set of sensations arising in the skin.
And out of that we construct the experience of hardness, heaviness and that there’s a pen there. So I put the pen down now. We think about the flower again. The flower is there, all its parts are there, we experience it, we agree on that, it conventionally exists. And yet, it doesn’t exist the way it seems.
It’s merely imputed on the basis of that collection of parts. If we look amongst the parts we can’t find it, if you take a petal that’s not a flower, If you take a stem, that’s not a flower. And you might say, well, you put them all together and it’s a flower. But is it? Is the collection of all those bits and pieces, is that a flower?
Take them and blend them all up into a puree, you’ve still got all the parts of the flower, is that a flower? Something emerges here on the basis the parts, Something’s projected here. Maybe this process is similar to what you’ve experienced when you look maybe you’ve had one or other of these experiences that may help shed some light on what’s happening here. When you look with those three-dimensional glasses at two pictures, then suddenly out of the two pictures that are flat you get this spectacular emergence of a three-dimensional image that you have just constructed. Or even more dramatic, those pictures where you have two pictures side by side made up of meaningless dots and if you align your eyes correctly, suddenly a picture emerges out of them.
There’s a basis, but what the object that emerges there is merely imputed. So now bring your focus to in oneself, oneself of myself. Here I am, I have a sense of being me. This is correct, we exist, but this sense of myself is always tangled with this superimposition about I’m really inherently existent, just like the flower, the same lines of thought apply to this self as to the flower. This sense of self becomes very, very strong when we get angry or some other strong emotion.
You just recall, sometimes when you became very upset or angry and this strong sense of me arises. It’s so inherently existent. But this appearance is mistaken just like it is with respect to the flower. I don’t exist inherently. This Self is an imputation by thought.
I am empty of inherent existence. I am empty of inherent existence. I am a dependent arising. And because I’m a dependent arising, I really am here sitting on this mat, perhaps feeling a pain in the knee and I have suffering and all the other sentient beings are just like me and they have suffering and they don’t want to suffer and they want to be happy. They’re all empty of inherent existence but they don’t know.
They’re all suffering with this terrible ignorance about what they really are. And how wonderful it would be if they could all understand what the situation really is. And not be driven by this profound ignorance to do all the terrible things that they do Even though they want to be happy, they always do the things that make them unhappy. So if this is going to come about, I must develop, I must become a Buddha so as to help them learn. So the dedication prayers, one hundred and sixteen and one hundred and seventeen.
All this wonderful merit that we’ve generated today, the merit of all the beings and all the Buddhas and bodhisattvas, our precious teacher, all this merit, let’s offer it for the full enlightenment of all sentient beings through these prayers, recalling the emptiness that we’ve been meditating on. So verse a 116, Whatever white virtues we thus created, we dedicate as causes, enabling us to uphold the holy Dharma of scriptures and insights, and to fulfill without exception the prayers and deeds of all the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas of the three times. By the force of this merit in all our lives, may we never be parted from Mahāyāna’s four spheres and may we reach the end of our journey along the path of renunciation bodhicitta, the pure view on the two stages. And now from the sheet verses eleven and twelve. May the jewel of supreme bodhicitta, which has not arisen, arise and may it never diminish but increase more and more.
May all father and mother sentient beings be happy and successful. May all the abodes of evil migration always be empty. May the prayers of all bodhisattvas, whoever they are and wherever they reside, be quickly accomplished.
Key terms in this teaching
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- four continents
- In Buddhist cosmology, the four continents around Mount Meru, one at each cardinal point; ours is the southern continent, Jambudvipa (Rose-apple Land). LYWA
- four immeasurables caturapramana (Skt); tsä mä zhi (Tib)
- Also known as the four immeasurable thoughts or the four sublime attitudes, these are four states of mind or aspirations: loving kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy and equanimity. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Mount Meru
- The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.