Emptiness — 2012-04-06

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Emptiness (TBI)
Emptiness (TBI)
Emptiness — 2012-04-06
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2012-04-06 – KR.mp3

UUID: b882a836-bfdb-4ea0-b2e2-76f0cb1390d4

Teacher: —

Collection: Emptiness

Date: 2012-04-06

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 31m

Words: 9,576

Such as the details of what Geshela spoke about this afternoon. You know? Do you have any questions you would like to ask then? Yes, Natalie. Well, fundamental questions, for instance, the reasonings refuting the existence of God, I think are fundamental for Westerners.

The reason for which we try well, I’m giving you what the fundamental questions are. Right? But the reason for which ignorance is the first of the 12 links. What is ignorance? I mean, are many forms of ignorance.

Right? What ignorance are we talking about, etcetera. You know? Was that your only question? Please.

There’s no there’s no answer to your question. There’s no answer. The question of beginnings is is one which is left open in the Buddhist teachings. Members of the other religious traditions have the same problem. If you ask them what comes before God, are stumped, right?

There’s no answer. The Buddhist position fundamentally was that he discouraged metaphysical questions as metaphysical questions. Metaphysical questions were encouraged only if they had a direct practical application. Then the beginning or beginninglessness of ignorance seemed unrelated to practice. But in Buddhist terms, basically, what we’re dealing with is the actual state of affairs we’re in, which is an infinite cycle of transmigrations with no beginning and if we don’t do anything about it, no end.

As Geshela explained this morning, this infinite cycle of transmigrations occurs within a cosmic cycle which is separate. Which is a cycle of appearance of universes which corresponds rather closely to the Big Bang actually. Expansion of the universe, eventual contraction, destruction of the universes, and the so called empty eons, which are spoken about in the Abhidharma and of which Geshela spoke this morning. But consciousness traverses these cycles uninterruptedly. During the empty eons, when there is no coarse matter, the sentient beings transmigrate into the concentration realms, The first, second, third and fourth dhyana.

Then they manifest out of these concentration realms into the physical universe when the physical universe reappears. Are there other questions? Yes. Yes. It does.

The form and the formless realms, precisely. Precisely. To be born in the form and the formless realms, you need you cannot be born there by normal virtuous karma. It does, but normal virtuous karma does not. You need a specific type of karma called immutable karma.

This is karma which is generated in meditation. So to be reborn in the form of the formless realms, the cause is actually one of the dhyanas, one of the meditative states in this life. So none of us in this room probably can be born in the form and formless realms unless you are meditating hours at home and have at least reached the first dhyana. Rebirth in the form and the formless realms is the foremost goal of many, perhaps all of the Hindu traditions. The Hindu traditions.

So the Hindu traditions, for instance, Raja Yoga, Patanjali’s Raja Yoga, aims for liberation through single pointed concentration. And they believe that through single pointed concentration, they gain moksha liberation. The Buddhists do not accept that what they gain is liberation. They say, yes, indeed, they gain something. What they gain is rebirth in one of the form or the formless realms.

It is not liberation because once the immutable karma which causes them to be reborn there is exhausted, then they are reborn somewhere in cyclic existence. In the formless in the formless realm, there are four aggregates, the four mental aggregates, but there isn’t a physical aggregate. There’s no body. These are realms of pure mind. Perhaps what we call god in the West might be seen in Buddhist terms as a being of the formless realms.

Perhaps. Are there other questions about what we covered today? Everyone in this room has a So the cycle, this is one of the So it takes a long time. But to be frank with you, I have friends who are involved in the ecumenical dialogue in Switzerland and the dialogue with scientists. This is where the contact really occurs.

I mean, we talk talk to the physicists and we say that in Abhidharma it is taught that the universe goes through through four cycles of 20 eons. 20 eons of emptiness, 20 eons of growth, 20 eons of abiding, and 20 eons of destruction. And that the process of destruction leads to another empty eon and we have cycles of expansion and contraction, the physicists, cosmologists, find this straight up their alley. Are there other questions? Yes, Lily.

How much does this explanation of 12 links of dependent arising apply to being Well, some miraculous births. You have four types of birth. Birth in Buddhist Abhidharma. Birth from moisture, which seems to correspond with the birth of unicellular organisms. A birth from an egg, which is the birth of invertebrates, a birth from a womb, is what we call mammalian birth, and a form of birth which is not recognised nowadays, miraculous birth, which is the birth of gods, but for that matter it can also be the birth of certain hell beings.

So the hell beings are born directly in the hells. Then the 12 links apply to miraculous birth, but not in the fullest sense of the term. Specifically, some limbs such as the limb of name and form don’t fully apply. I will see if Geshela goes into that or not. Yeah.

Well, in the form and formless realms, beings have four aggregates, right? Only the mental ones. Someone who is born through miraculous birth can have all five aggregates. It’s just the birth process lacks certain of the limbs which are present in these three other forms of birth. It’s a slightly different presentation.

Maybe Geshela will go into that. Are there other questions? I’m glad you asked that question. That’s really what I would like to do with you today. Not so much I will dissect it.

But not so much do that, but I saw some very dear friends outside standing in an absolute daze. And then I promised that they told me their head was spinning. I told them I would make their head spin in the opposite direction. What I’d like to do, leading up to Richard’s question, is talk a little bit about the Buddhist view. I think it will be really helpful for all of us.

So if you’ve taken the class in tenets, which was given here two years ago, then you can resurrect those foundations. Carol has told me she will print out, if you inscribe yourself, the translation of Jitsunepa’s text on tenets and the commentary given here. I’d recommend it. It’s very good, very simple, very clear. Alternatively, we have this book in the library which is another text of tenets giving the four Buddhist schools of philosophy and their position on the view.

You can also purchase this and read it. So you have to understand the, let’s say, the Indian specificity. All of the monotheistic traditions consider that the world exists in the way it appears. They are realists in the modern sense of the term. What we see is what is.

None of the Indian schools of tenets with the possible exception of the materialists, consider that things exist in the way they appear. Nobody does. Neither the Buddhists, nor the Sankhyas, nor the Jain, nor the Vedantas, nor the Mimasayas. It’s a common position. They all agree that things exist differently from the way they appear to an ordinary being like ourselves.

They all agree that our present existence is suffering. This is a common agreement in the Indian philosophical traditions and all basically agree there is a liberation from the suffering. And they all agree that the suffering has been going on for beginningless lives and will continue for beginningless lives until we unless we try to reach this liberation. So this is what I have called in some conferences the Gangetic view, the view of the Ganges. You have a beginningless cycle of lives, which are of the nature of suffering, which are controlled by karma and causality.

Things do not exist in the way they appear And through seeing the way things actually exist, we gain liberation. This is the inner core of all the Indian traditions. Whether you’re speaking of the Buddhist, the non Buddhist traditions, they all agree on this matter. Where they disagree is on the actual mode of existence of phenomena. It’s not minor for them.

It’s critical because through seeing things as they are, you gain liberation. Moksha in the non Buddhist traditions, Nirvana, and later on full enlightenment into Buddhist traditions. How do you ascertain how things exist? You see already there’s a fundamental suspicion with respect to appearance, which is absent in the West. We are dyed in the wool realists, all of us in this room.

The Indian mindset is one of idealism in one form or the other. How do we identify the way things exist? For the Hindu traditions, it’s mainly through revelation. Through the Vedas, through the Upanishads, for those traditions which accept the Upanishads, the yoga schools through the great treatises of the yoga schools such as Patanjali’s Yoga Sutra and so forth. For the Buddhists, it is through reasoning.

Reality is therefore accessible to reasoning. Then for this reason, the Buddhist schools disagree with each other on what reality is. But they agree on a certain foundation. What is the position of the Indian schools? Non Buddhist Indian schools assert that although phenomena on the outside appear to be real and solid, in reality, the only truth is the Atman, which is the inner self and the realization that this inner self, the Atman, is one with the universal self, the Brahman, is in and of itself sufficient to lead one to Moksha.

This is the position of all of the Upanishads, which are received in most of the great Indian schools. So realizing the self as permanent, one and unitary, and as one with the Brahman, which is God, the creator, is sufficient to become a Jivanmukti, one who is liberated alive. The Buddhist position is exactly the opposite of this. Whereas in the Indian schools of thought, is broadly asserted that there is a creator god understanding that one soul is identical with the creator leads to liberation. The Buddhists say there is no god, there is no creator god, and liberation cannot therefore be attained to identifying oneself with his creator God.

It is identified through understanding the true nature of the person, which is that it does not exist as permanent, one and independent. So the Hindus asserted exists as permanent, one, and independent. The Buddhist asserted it exists as impermanent, multiple, and dependent. These are radically contradictory assertions. Now, the Hindus, and when I say Hindus, it’s a very generic term, the Indian schools of philosophy consider that this assertion of the self as permanent, one and independent is in keeping with our intuitive sense of who we are.

When we move in daily life, when I move in daily life, I think ilea goes downtown. I see a permanent globular ilea inside me somehow who is doing things, who is unchanging. And the Indian schools of thought say, it is obvious for all that the soul, the atman, is permanent one independent. The Buddhists, because of their reliance on reasoning, say that even though it seems obvious, it is false. Because when we analyze, there is no such soul or self to be identified.

So when we speak of self in a Buddhist context, we are really speaking of the soul, the Atman. Right? Then how do the Buddhist understand how this soul can be refuted? They analyze. And this is why, from a Buddhist standpoint, persons are divided into five aggregates.

To try to break down the constituents and see if there is this permanent one and independent self or not. The aggregates are the body and then four aspects of the mind. One could have chosen another subdivision. Feeling discrimination, compositional factors, sometimes called volition and consciousness. If you can’t find the aggregates within those five, if you can’t find the soul within those five, it does not exist.

So this core position that persons are not permanent, that they are not one and that they are not independent is shared by all of the schools of Buddhist philosophy without exception. From the so called Vaibhashika school up to the Madhyamika schools. On that basis, they disagree. After that, they posit greater or lesser degrees of selflessness. They disagree because the Buddhist tradition is rooted in reasoning.

And disagreement is not only legitimate, it is actually almost necessary. The goal is not some revealed truth about one’s practice. The goal is through reasoning to find the actual mode of existence of the person and the phenomena and then meditating on that to eliminate what ties one to psychic existence. Now why does a misapprehension of persons and of objects tie us to psychic existence? Because if we see things as permanent, one and independent, our attachment or anger towards them become much greater.

They are a far more powerful support for those emotions. You see this if you fall in love with someone. If you fall in love with someone, you see this process of exhortation of the other person, which ends up with the other person being frozen in time and space. The emotions such a person can generate are tremendous. Likewise, a much more Yugoslav specialty is falling in hatred with someone.

We do not love very well, but we hate very well. My grandfather was married to my grandmother to put an end to a blood feud which lasted one century. Nobody really knew why it had started. Falling into hatred is the same process of, but not exhortation, but denigration of the enemy until the enemy becomes this one independent autonomous entity which is the ultimate support for loathing. The moment you have deconstructed that, these emotions don’t have a ground to arise upon.

But do you have any questions about this? Because this is this is the foundation of the Buddhist view. Yes. Well, there are many answers to your question. I think generally speaking if all of the trainees had the same capacities, yes.

But these various schools were formulated for people of different capacities. Not everyone benefits from the same medicine. For instance, it’s a reason His Holiness discourages conversion of Westerners to Buddhism. Most Westerners don’t benefit from Buddhism. As a proof of the fact, our statistics for the Buddhist centers, we have, I think it’s one student out of 1,000 who stays after ten years.

It’s clear proof they don’t benefit, you know. So they benefit perhaps from something else. His Holiness has really intimated Westerners benefit from Christianity. Just part of the Western heritage. Why?

Even though from a Buddhist standpoint, right, in terms of pure analysis, the concept of God is at odds with reasoning. For someone whose mind is not very sharp, who’s not going to engage in that analysis, who’s not going to study, The concept of God is a very powerful foundation on which to build ethics and the idea of brotherhood of all created by the same father in Christianity, but even in Judaism is a very powerful foundation on which to create love or build love and empathy. Viewpoint is actually in terms of viewpoints force, but extremely beneficial. Now within the Buddhist presentations, there are many presentations which if they are analyzed ultimately are insufficient or inadequate, but they are of benefit for a certain category of disciples. Does that help to answer your question?

Are there other questions? I’m sorry. These are very they’re very foundational issues, but I think it helps to cover these. Yes. Yes.

The Tibetan tradition is to work through all of the schools of tenet. And my strong suggestion to Westerners who want to convert to Buddhism is to first study the religions which are part of the Western tradition to be able to close the door on them. It is important to have studied Christianity, to have an understanding of what Christianity is of its heritage in our society and to be able to shut the door and lock it. Otherwise, it is impossible to practice pure dharma if one becomes a Buddhist. And then before becoming a Buddhist, after having studied the Western tradition, which means really the monotheistic religions.

Judaism, Christianity, and Islam is a Western religion. There are Western countries which are Muslim. Turkey’s a European country. Then the next step is to study Indian religions in their generality. In other words, what we call the Gangetic traditions, what are the features of Indian religions, a belief in reincarnation, generally speaking, a belief in karma and causality, a belief that life is bad, to put it really bluntly.

Whereas all of the monotheisms assert life is good. I mean, if the world is created by God, then the foundation of the world is good. The world may be fallen as asserted by many great Christian thinkers like Augustine, but its foundation is good. The Hindu and the Buddhist vision of the world is that the world is evil. It’s not a minor difference.

And then on this basis, one must gain liberation from this pit of fire. So this is the Indian viewpoint. One must first be sympathetic to the Indian viewpoint before being able to become a Buddhist. And then once one is sympathetic to the Indian viewpoint, then one has to ask oneself, what of the two great paths in Indian thought will I follow? The atma vada, the path of the soul, or the nairatma vada, the path of non soul.

The atma vada is that of Vedanta, of Sankhya, of Yoga, of Mimamsa. The Niratma vada, the path of no soul is the exclusive Buddhist path. So my personal conviction is that if one does not do this, one cannot become a sincere Buddhist. Are there other questions? Yes.

So there are many schools, Buddhist schools which assert this. It is the main position of the Chitamatra school, which considers that all so called thoroughly established phenomena within the three natures, the imputed other part and thoroughly established phenomena, all thoroughly established phenomena, according to mind only, are inherently established. This is not the position of the Madhyamica school. The reasoning is very simple. The reason for which it’s refuted in Madiameka is very simple because the emptiness of a phenomenon is dependent on the phenomenon itself.

The emptiness of a phenomenon cannot exist without the phenomenon. Likewise, the phenomenon could not exist without its emptiness. Therefore, this book and if we take the Prasangika viewpoint, the emptiness of inherent existence of this book are two sides of the same coin which cannot exist without each other. Therefore, this book is empty of inherent existence, but the emptiness of this book is also empty of inherent existence because it is imputed on the basis of the book. Then there were many many problems with this in Tibet.

Some schools such as the famous Jonangpa School tried to resurrect a fusion of the mind only and the Madhyamika schools. This school is considered as out of the pool of the orthodox traditional Tibetan schools, precisely because its presentation of emptiness is nonstandard. Well, they would. Don’t study the Jonang purview. Then if it does, what are you doing here?

If it makes sense, you shouldn’t be here. I mean, the Geluk tradition teaches a Prasangika view. All of the Tibetan schools teach the Prasangika view, sometimes mitigated by Svatantrika. Then the Jonang purview, I mean, actually was forbidden in Tibet. I mean, the printing of the books was banned, you know.

So use reason. Well, Dalai Lama’s function now is to assemble. That’s but from a pragmatic standpoint, from the standpoint of reasoning, the viewpoint’s very problematical. It is, my private opinion, it is a view which is rooted in Hinduism. Because the founder of the Jonangpa view, not the founder, but the resurrector, should I say, Dhrupo Pasherab Singhe, came from the Dhrupo Valley in Nepal, which was actually strongly influenced by Hinduism.

If you look at the Jonangpa view as view, it’s basically a Vedantic view. It is it is Vedanta. Then Durboba Sheikh Abseinh tried to reformulate it as what he called greater Madhyamika, which is greater than ordinary Madhyamika. But the system, as I said, is is not accepted. If you accept that emptiness is inherently existent, then from the prasanika viewpoint, you are not even able to gain liberation because you will generate attachment to emptiness.

Once you accept a phenomenon as inherently existent, then that phenomenon serves as the foundation for the arising of desire and hatred. So this is, for instance, the great and powerful Buddhist critique of all the monotheisms. All the monotheisms, the revealed Abrahamic monotheisms, and the Indian monotheisms assert the existence of a creator who is inherently established. Then from the standpoint of the monotheisms, creation is non inherently established, clearly. It is established independence on the creator.

But the creator, as permanent one and independent, is inherently established and acts as the sole inherently established phenomenon as an extraordinarily powerful basis for the generation of desire and hatred. You can interpret the totality of the jihad in these terms. Once you have posited a god who is one, unique and independent, who creates a universe and you view the universe as existing independent on this god and he has revealed himself through history by holy writ, then clearly this entity acts as an extraordinarily powerful basis on which to generate desire for those who act in keeping with his will, and hatred for those who act in opposition to his will. The same critique can be addressed with the Jonangpa tradition. That inherently existing emptiness becomes the foundation on which desire and hatred arise.

Are there other questions? I didn’t understand what you were saying. My apologies. So my statement is a general statement. It does not apply to every single case.

It’s a general statement for all, for Westerners, which is explicitly rooted in the teachings His Holiness has been giving for the last ten years because of broadly speaking, some fundamental failures in the transmission of Buddhism to the West, which now are statistically established, there is no doubt, which have led His Holiness to, encourage Westerners as a community to reflect carefully before converting and to first examine the religions as his holiness puts it of their ancestors. Now individually, some people may have a strong karmic connections with Buddhism through the past, then there’s no reason for them to go through this again. But what is important is that what one practice be pure dharma. To practice pure dharma, which is dharma which is not mixed, one must be able to shut doors. Because pure dharma is a complete system of mind training which is a real benefit for the mind.

Once one starts mixing dharma with other religious traditions or the scientific traditions in some case, then one puts oneself in a delicate situation where the components may or may not be compatible. For instance, someone who practices generating love and compassion and at the same time in the background has a strong Christian understanding of love and compassion. We have a much more emotional type of love and compassion arise than is actually the goal of the sevenfold cause and effect generation of love, compassion in bodhicitta. And we do see this in westerners. We do see this.

Likewise, we do see over and again misunderstandings, core misunderstandings regarding reincarnation. I read somewhere that some 70% of American Buddhists do not believe in reincarnation. Then there was an an ongoing debate in Tricycle, which is one of the leading Buddhist magazines, between Stefan Bachelor and Robert Thurman regarding reincarnation, in which Bachelor he has never come out and say he doesn’t believe in reincarnation. He systematically says he’s agnostic, but one can read between the lines, you know. Bachelor does make a living as a professional Buddhist teacher.

So this means that from the standpoint of his students, is possible to be a Buddhist and not to accept reincarnation. Alright? So this means that there are core problems. And that’s why I think for Westerners, it’s a slow but it’s a safe procedure. One should start by becoming familiar with the Western religious background.

From one’s own side, be comfortable with closing the door on that. Then study the Indian religious background, feel that one is at ease in the Indian mental universe, and then within that enter into a study of the Buddhist teachings. Because if one does not accept past and future lives, one cannot be a Buddhist. That one can come to the temple as much as one wants. One’s meditation will have no power, no force.

The time spent coming to the temple as far as realizations in this life are concerned is wasted. The time would be better spent perhaps practicing something else. Of who? Of Paul Williams. There are two stories I’ll relate.

Paul Williams in another case. The first one, this is why His Holiness now systematically discourages conversion and encourages Westerners to first study Christianity. When His Holiness came to India in 1959, one of his earliest students was a Polish lady who was rooted in theosophy. She converted to Buddhism. I think she even received some level of ordination, received countless initiations and teachings, and practiced for decades.

However, on her deathbed, she abandoned the totality of the teachings, asked for a Roman Catholic priest to come, re enter the church, received confession and extreme unction. Then His Holiness said, this is basically a wasted life. Had she remained Roman Catholic from day one, she could have practiced within the setting of the Catholic church, teachings which are of great benefit. One can generate very powerful ethics, one can generate love, a limited form of it, compassion, you know. Who can say the Christian teachings are not of benefit?

Instead, she what she practiced was of no benefit and what she didn’t practice was what she appealed to. In the case of Paul Williams is even more extreme. Paul Williams is a leading Buddhist scholar who converted to Anglicanism as a teenager, then as an Anglican converted to Buddhism. And he practiced within the Gelug tradition. He became a professor of Buddhist philosophy, think, University of Edinburgh, if memory serves me well, or Manchester, one of the two.

It’s in England some place. And for some twenty years, he was, as Geoffrey Hopkins, my late man or mentor, a practicing Buddhist who taught Buddhist philosophy. Then doubt started to increase more and more after twenty years, specifically regarding what we talked about, the suffering and evil nature of existence. He simply could not see life as suffering and evil. The more he tried, the greater resistance there was and eventually he started studying Roman Catholic dogma, abandoned Buddhism, converted to Roman Catholicism, and at present is a lay Dominican friar, while still being a professor of Buddhist philosophy.

Then those twenty years are wasted. These cases are not rare. These cases are common. We have people who were attending the center who have converted to evangelical Christianity. I know Buddhist men who have converted to fundamentalist Islam.

Then sign of great confusion. And if the person has taken refuge, lay vows, initiations, Bodhisattva and Tantric vows, and they abandon everything, then from our standpoint, there are heavy consequences. Very heavy consequences. For this reason, it seems important to slow down the process of conversion of Westerners to Buddhism. So then on an individual basis, that people go through the steps because it’s a one way street, you see.

Once you’re in, if you want to go out from the the standpoint of one’s own future, it is not void of consequences. We do not have an obligation to proselytize unlike some other religious traditions. We actually have an obligation not to teach if the conditions are not appropriate. It is the meaning of the three vessels which are again and again taught in the lamrim. So for that reason, I think the goal is not to rush into something, but to build solidly.

We should go through this slow process of studying a bit the history of religions, which is of great benefit to us. It is very possible when we do this that some of us will realize they simply do not have the religious fiber. I think a large proportion of the students we have don’t. His Holiness has become very aware of this. For this reason, His Holiness now is publishing in English books which address a massively secular audience.

Such as, what is it called already? Ethics, no, after religion? For Ethics for the New New Millennium was the first and beyond religion. Beyond religion. So these are books in which His Holiness presents a non religious secular ethics rooted in interdependence for a Western audience which no longer is able to function in a religious setting.

These are not books for Buddhists. Own has been very clear. His own has said he said before 2000 that there were three categories of beings at present in the West. Those who practice the traditional or in the world, excuse me, those who practice their father’s religions, those who practice Buddhism, and those who were in between. He said the first do not concern us.

Those who practice the religion of their ancestors, Islam, Judaism, Christianity, Taoism, Confucianism, are rooted in a spiritual tradition, and the great world traditions are broadly speaking of benefit. And the Buddhists are already taken care of. The problem is the vast majority of westerners and many people in the world who don’t know and who are no longer really able to connect to a religious tradition. Such people will not benefit if they become religious. But they may benefit through a secular presentation.

That is okay. That’s why I do feel and it’s what we’ve tried to do here at TBI. We try to build in a very, very gradual way. Geshela is doing this beautifully. I try to do it in my talks to basically present the situation of Western society, then present our own traditional religious background because it’s not something we can take for granted anymore.

Most people do not know anything about Christianity even though Christianity is very much part of who we are. It’s in the background of so much. For instance, when we relate to a Buddhist monk like Geshela, we relate to a fantasized image within our mind of a Christian monk. We see this a lot. Buddhist monks are not Christian monks.

Very, different world view. And then once that is set to present the Indian viewpoint, within that the Buddhist specificity and to move upwards like this. I’m sorry. I’ve talked talked a lot about these talk topics. It’s an introduction.

Do you have any questions before we break? I’ll be happy to give it. So you will need your two handouts. Your first handout on the definitions on page three, and your second handout on If page two. In other words, you will need definitions on page three, Abhidhamma Samuchaya on page two.

So, this is the technical question. The definition of ignorance within the 12 limbs of dependent arising. This is a definition of the first limb of the 12 limbs. Not all ignorance is ignorance within the 12 limbs of dependent arising. There are many forms of ignorance such as ignoring karma and causality, which is not ignorance within the 12 limbs.

Then if we look at the definition, it is a mental factor. Ignorant regarding suchness which has become the motivation of impelling comma, which is subsumed within one series of dependent arising within it with itself. Ignorance is a mental factor. So you have a two fold division of mind into main minds and mental factors. Main minds are, the various visual, auditory, olfactory, gestative, bodily and mental consciousnesses.

For instance, my eye consciousness perceiving the color blue of this cup is a main mind. A main mind is focused on the totality of its object. Main minds are accompanied by mental factors, which are the surrounding components of a main mind. They are not different in nature from the mind they surround. And they have five features which point this out.

They are similar, let’s see if I can give them to you. They are similar in terms of object, in terms of aspect, in terms of nature, in terms of time, and in terms of object. These object, so referent object, referent object, aspect, time, nature, object. What this means is that a mental factor, for instance, desire is a mental factor, ignorance is a mental factor, which accompanies a main mind, is observing exactly the same thing as main mind at the same time. You dissociate, you differentiate them mentally.

But you cannot have a mental factor existing without the main mind it accompanies or a main mind without the mental factor. Ignorance is a mental factor therefore ignorance always exists accompanying a main mind whose mental factor it is. That’s point one. Ignorant regarding suchness, ignorant here in Tibetan is which actually means clouded. But we’re running short of English terms here.

It is clouded regarding suchness. It is confused regarding suchness. The suchness referred to here is from within the selflessness of persons and of phenomena, the selflessness of persons, not the selflessness of phenomena. When it is said that ignorance is confused with regards to the selflessness of persons, what this means is that ignorance does not engage its object. So in this respect, ignorance is not a wisdom.

A wisdom engages its object, albeit at times wrongly. Ignorance does not engage the object, which is here the selflessness of persons, which has become the motivation of impelling karma. So this mental factor of ignorance is what lies beneath impelling karma, which is the karma which impels one to take another rebirth. This ignorance gives rise to that karma which is subsumed within one series of dependent arisings with itself. That means that this ignorance and the impelling karma it generates are actually two of one cycle of 12 links.

Now this one cycle of 12 links does not mature over one life. It matures either over two or over three lives. But they are not necessarily subsequent. It is almost exceptional for them to be subsequent. You might have a first group of one series of 12 links accumulated during life one, then lives two to 57 in between and at life 58, the remaining of the 12 links of that first series are accumulated.

This is one series. The lives in between lives two to 57 do not concern us. They are parts of other series of 12 links. If it is accumulated over three lives, you might have one portion of the 12 links accumulated during life one, the second perhaps three or four links accumulated during life 19, and the third during life 124. Life one nineteen and one twenty four are one series of 12 links.

So you can see that the various 12 links which constitute our continuum. When we speak of the 12 links, we are speaking of the continuum of the aggregates. The five aggregates, right, for beings in the desire realm are intertwined in the same way as the warp and the woof. Or like thread within a rug. You have one cycle of 12 links, another cycle of 12 links, a third cycle of 12 links, a fourth cycle of 12 links, a fifth cycle of 12 links.

There is nothing else from a Buddhist standpoint but this sum total of cycles of 12 links. There is no self behind them. Yes? Well, it’s connected, but basically, the 16 lives is a prophecy of Guru Vajradhara. However, if you take the bodhisattva vows or any virtuous deed, just make it simpler, you practice one virtuous deed purely, then in our case, we are ordinary beings.

So the virtuous deeds we practice, we practice under the power of ignorance. Which ignorance? The ignorance which sees the person as, in this case, self existent. But we can still practice virtue like that. On that basis, we can practice virtue, non virtue or immutable karma.

If we practice virtue and that virtue is not destroyed, in other words, we dedicate it, that cycle of 12 links, that series will mature. When it matures, we do not know. It can be destroyed by anger. So does that answer your question, Richard? If you are interested, excuse me, if you are interested in, these topics, I would suggest those of you who have it to read through a good English book on Lorig, the mind and mental factors section.

Elizabeth Knapper’s translation of mind in Tibetan Buddhism, I think we have copies in the library. There is like, it’s only five pages on mind and mental factors. The presentation of mind and mental factors comes from the same great Indian Shastra, from which the 12 links come, Asanda’s Abhidhamma Samuchaya, and Geshela will be drawing on it all the time. If you can understand the difference between a main mind and a mental factor, this will be of great help for this material. Then if there are yes, Richard?

No. It’s not an example. It’s not an example. The 12 limbs of one given series can never mature in less than two lives and they can never mature in more than three lives. But these lives do not have to be subsequent.

Yes. Exactly. No. You could not have a situation where 12 links of one series mature over lives one, nineteen, 64, and 400. It is not possible.

They mature over lives To give an example, one in nineteen or one in nineteen in sixty four. Does that answer your question? No, no, one action. One cycle of 12 links covers the process of generation, motivation, performing and maturation of one action performed either under the power of a delusion, this is the thoroughly afflicted 12 links, or under the power of a virtuous, albeit contaminated state of mind, this is the totally purified 12 links. So if let’s say, with anger as a motivation, we start ignorance.

With ignorance in the background and anger as a motivation, you stomp on an ant. You initiate a cycle of 12 links which will necessarily mature over two or over three lives, which may be almost infinitely separated in time. If motivated by, let us say generosity, you donate as one of our students the to the temple, then you will give rise to a cycle of 12 links, which will mature over two or over three lives. Those are the two possibilities. Arya beings, in other words beings who have had the direct experience of emptiness, no longer generate cycles of 12 links because they are no longer or the ignorance which is within the 12 limbs of dependent origination is no longer present within their continuum.

They have had the direct experience of emptiness. So an arya being, in other words, has control over his rebirth. That’s what we are saying. Were you did you want to ask a question? Yes.

We can We can try. Yes. I don’t know about that. My apologies. But do you believe do you believe in the four continents?

So where are they? I don’t know. I mean, are many, many such statements. I’m not sure whether they’re applicable or not. I mean, we’re gonna if we’re gonna talk about this, then we have to believe in Mount Meru.

Then where is Mount Meru? Right? Mount Meru is a physical object. As a physical object, it has to be perceived by the sense consciousnesses. The witnesses to Mount Meru are few and far between.

His Holiness has been searching. He hasn’t found many. And the four continents, don’t know. If there’s no Mount Meru, I don’t know. See, you know, I think for us it is of benefit to address the Buddhist teachings frontally and with the mind of critical examination.

Then there are aspects of the Buddhist teachings which have not aged well. I think Buddhist, certainly, the cosmology of the four continents, the eight subcontinents in Mount Meru has not aged well. Put it mildly. His Holiness does not subscribe to it. I personally do not.

I don’t see why I should, you know. But, on the other hand, there are aspects of the Buddhist teachings which have weathered time surprisingly well. I mean, the 12 links in Buddhist cosmology are two different things. I mean, the world is round. There’s no big debate about this one.

Then I had as a teacher, the greatest living teacher of Abhidharma. He’s no longer with us, unfortunately. He was an extraordinary great Mongolian Geshe, Kinsugnawa, from Drepung. He’s a terrifying character, but somehow we got along very well. And he was teaching us Abidhama, met some twenty five, thirty years ago.

And he came to Mount Meru and there was this big pause and he said, well, if we go in space far enough on a rocket, perhaps. But what struck me, you see, was his was an empirical mindset. He had been raised in a world where Mount Mary was taken for granted, but he Mount Meru is something which is checkable. Alright? If it exists, we should be able to see it.

Then if there are no more questions for today. Yes. I think Geshela will talk about it probably on the last day because there are certain links which are necessarily grouped together, and they cannot be split over lives. So I think Geshela will talk about it. For instance, if you take the last two links, it’s obvious.

The link of birth and aging and death cannot be split. It is self evident. You cannot be born in one life and age and die in another life. Then there are other links which are grouped as groups. So you have either two groupings or three groupings.

Either less, no more. It does. I mean, it is said that meditating on the 12 links is yet to do it to pride because nobody understands it. Right? It is so difficult to understand.

But it is the you will see I if you have time, I translated, and I really suggest if you want to read it tonight, if you’re not exhausted, Asanga’s 11 meanings of the 12 links. It is extremely profound. It is on page pages five and six. How should dependent arising be seen in terms of its meanings? The first meaning is the absence of a creator.

This is a very powerful statement. If dependent arising exists, it excludes the existence of a creator. And the second is the meaning of arising within a cause that is self evident. The third is the meaning of the non existence of sentient beings. Dependent arising means bluntly that sentient beings lack inherent existence.

Asanga puts it very, very bluntly. Sentient beings don’t exist. There is no sentient being apart from the flow of the 12 links. This infinite flow of intertwined 12 links. It has a meaning of being under another’s power.

In other words, we have no autonomy and independence. We are under the power of previous series of 12 links. Then two meanings are evident, the meaning of impermanence and momentariness. In other words, we are in a constant state of flow and transition. The meaning of the continuum of causality being uninterrupted.

This is the beginninglessness of the flow of the 12 links. We are none other than the river in which, or we are none other than the river of the 12 links, to use a metaphor. Then concordance between cause and effect, Deshita talked about today. Difference of cause and effect, because cause and effect are not of one nature in the Buddhist tradition, as it say in some Indian schools like Sankhya. If you assert that cause is the same effect nature as effect, you are ultimately asserting the unity of all phenomena.

And from the Sankhya standpoint, you are asserting that the goal of the individual must be to return to the source of all, which is God. So the Buddhist assert a difference in nature of cause and effect and meaning 7.11. If you have the time to look through them, it is very, very thought provoking. Of what? Immutability.

So immutability here refers to the fact that the 12 links are immutable, according to, Justin Chuki Gierczyn’s commentary and that therefore there is no creator. The flow is immutable. They are immutably present. Then my apologies, we have doubled the time. Thank you very much.

We’ll just begin straight away just, adopting meditation posture. Just clearing our minds from all of the discussion and the obviously, there’ll be a lot of stuff flowing around in the mind at the moment. So just quietly just doing some mindfulness of breathing just for a few moments. So we’ll just go through the four characteristics of the first of the four noble truths. I’ll just read them out and then we’ll I’ll take each one separately.

So the four characteristics of the first of the four noble truths which is the truth of suffering. One, phenomena such as the physical and mental aggregates, because of their characteristic of undergoing continuous momentary production and disintegration, are impermanent. Two, as that process of change is impelled by karma and delusions, the aggregates have the nature of suffering. And then three, because there is no independent self which exists separately from the aggregates, they are empty. And four, as they lack the existence of any type of self supporting person, they are selfless.

And I will contemplate and just meditate on the first one which is impermanence. We will have some idea of impermanence and But the main reason that we seek an understanding of impermanence is to understand that attachment to the five aggregates is suffering. And in order to understand pervasive suffering, we have to understand how these different levels of impermanence work. Geshela said some while ago that even a child can understand that things change and don’t last forever. Things arise as the result of causes and conditions, remain until their lifespan is finished and then they are extinguished.

This is not difficult to understand. But this is a very coarse level of understanding of impermanence. Beyond that however, we need to now just consider the next level which is there is a more subtle level of which we must become aware and this level is called changing moment by moment, referring to the fact that things do not stay the same for even one moment. Things are in a constant state of change. The suffering of change.

However, the aspect of impermanence that poses the greatest challenge is that when phenomena come into being due to causes and conditions, those same causes and conditions that produce them at the same moment contain the seeds of their own destruction. So if we look at impermanence at the three levels, things arise, abide and then pass away. This we know. The next is that they are changing moment by moment. And the more subtle level we need to just pause and think about that for a moment, is that the same causes and conditions that produce them at the same moment contain the seeds of their own destruction.

This way we can see that there is nothing to grasp at or to cling to. And this very impermanence then is what impels and also causes us to be under the control of forces that induce very subtle levels of suffering and these are the controlled forces of karma, the kleshas and the aggregates themselves. And our present unenlightened state of ignorance and delusion. These are the forces that are uncontrolled. We cannot control them while we remain under the delusion of suffering.

This is why we can say that we need to understand our present unenlightened state is dukkha. And then the second characteristic of the first truth, which is suffering. Our present existence came into being due to ignorance and afflictive emotions, and we need to understand this very clearly. Just having the five aggregates is suffering because they are produced by the fundamental confusion of ignorance and afflictive emotions. Therefore, there is no basis for pure happiness.

However, we are looking to be free from samsara. This is the uncontrolled cycle of lives. We need to understand that we can liberate ourselves from this. Then the third aspect of the first noble truth is the characteristic of emptiness. This refers to the emptiness of a self that is permanent, unitary and indivisible.

However, this characteristic of emptiness that there is no I from the aggregates is a very gross level of selflessness. We need to almost go to the Heart Sutra to get an understanding of this. The aggregates are and are not. We are always identifying with the I and we always associate the I with one of the five aggregates. It is this attachment that should be understood to be suffering and abandoned.

In order to understand that, we have to understand that this thing we called I is only the combination of ever changing physical and mental phenomena and events. Just think about that for a moment. What is there to cling to? What is there to grasp at? Geshela gave an example this morning with the Dalai Lama.

I’d like to illustrate that just a little further. During the course of the studies that I’ve been doing and listening, I listen to the, news broadcasts and so on. Sometimes some very disparaging comments are made about the Dalai Lama. And it would be very easy to become upset by these disparaging comments. If we have truly understood the nature of emptiness of the I, who is it that they are actually talking about?

And therefore is there any necessity to become upset? This doesn’t imply that we would passively stand by while somebody that we have great respect for and whose teachings we listen to so carefully should not be spoken of well by us. And let one man just gently say to someone that that might be their opinion but it’s not necessarily the only opinion. And then we apply the same set of criteria to ourselves. It’s also brought out in the eight verses, mind training, that when somebody disparages us, that we shouldn’t take that on board.

That is an imputation in the mind of someone else. So if we begin to understand this particular aspect of the emptiness of self. We can just decrease the amount of suffering we have. Just think that through for a moment. We identify with the I and we associate the I with the five aggregates and it is this attachment that should be understood to be suffering and abandoned.

And then there is the fourth characteristic of the first noble truth, which is selflessness. This goes to a slightly subtler level, even an emptiness. This refers to the lack of existence of any self supporting independent substantially existing person. This is not how we see things. In contrast, we instinctively feel that we are more than just a combination of mental and physical aggregates.

We are certain there is something there that is self supporting, a self that is self sufficient and a substantial reality. Characteristic of selflessness refutes the wrong notion of a self that can be found within the five aggregates. Usually we say things like me and my five aggregates as if we are a controller of something. And yet here I sit, I can be seen, I’m functioning, I’m doing stuff. So here we have to see the notion of the ultimate and conventional reality.

Ultimate and conventional self. The arya beings see no distinction between the two. They see both simultaneously. This is what we struggle with. We both are and are not.

We’ll just do the dedication prayers. We’ll do on page 10 in English nine, ten, eleven and twelve. In making this dedication, Carol came and told me Tyra died an hour ago. To those of you who’ve known her, it’s okay. So we’ll do the long life prayer for his holiness.

O holy and venerable Lama, from the clouds of compassion, you are the source of all happiness and bliss, all powerful Chenrezig, Tenzin Gyatso. Please remain till the end of existence. Should the situation arise where the supreme precious teachings no longer pervade, or though pervading should they degenerate, then through the mind, being moved by great compassion, may the treasure of benefit and happiness be revealed. May the jewel of Supreme bodhichitta, which has not arisen, arise and may it never diminish, but increase more and more. May all father and mother sentient beings be happy and successful.

May all the abodes of evil migration always be empty. May the prayers of all bodhisattvas, whoever they are and wherever they reside, be quickly accomplished. Now I’d like to just ask for your indulgence and I think what we need to do right now is recite the Heart Sutra. It’s on page 13. 13 Thus I have heard, once the blessed one was dwelling on Rajagriha on Vulture’s Peak, together with a great assembly of monks and Bodhisattvas.

At that time, the blessed one was totally absorbed in the concentration that examines all phenomena called profound illumination. And at the same time, the Noble Avalokitesvara, the Bodhisattva Mahasattva, was engaged in the profound practice of the wisdom gone beyond, analysing the five aggregates by nature empty. Then, through the inspiration of Buddha, the Venerable Sariputra spoke to the Noble Avalokitesvara, the Bodhisattva Mahasatva, saying: How should those of a good family learn who wish to follow the profound practice of the wisdom gone beyond? Thus he spoke and the Noble Avalokitesvara, the Bodhisattva Mahasattva replied to the Venerable Sariputra saying: O Sariputra, whatever son or daughter of good family wishes to follow the profound practice of the wisdom gone beyond, should look at it like this, analysing the five aggregates by nature empty. Form is empty, emptiness is form, emptiness is no other than form, form is no other than emptiness.

In the same way, feeling, recognition, karmic formations and consciousness are all empty. Therefore, Shariputra, all phenomena are empty without characteristics. They are unborn and unceasing. They are neither impure nor free from impurity. They neither decrease nor increase.

Therefore, Shariputra, in emptiness there is no form, no feeling, no recognition, no karmic formations, no consciousness. There is no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind. There are no spheres of the eyes up to no spheres of the mind. There are none of these all the way up to the sphere of mental consciousness. There is no ignorance nor is there destruction of ignorance.

There are none of these all the way up to there is no old age and death, nor is there destruction of old age and death. Thus, there is no suffering, no cause suffering, no cessation of suffering and no path. There is no wisdom, no attainment and no non attainment. Therefore, Shariputra, because there is no attainment, all Bodhisattvas hold the wisdom gone beyond. And because there is no obscurity of mind, they have no fear.

Passing utterly beyond falsity, they reach beyond the bounds of sorrow. All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times by relying on the wisdom gone beyond, fully and clearly awakened to unsurpassed, most perfect and complete enlightenment. Therefore, the mantra of the wisdom gone beyond, the mantra of great insight, the unequalled and unsurpassed mantra, the mantra that calms all suffering should be known as the truth. For there is no deception. The mantra of the wisdom from beyond is proclaimed.

Wisdom gone beyond. Then the Blessed One arose from their concentration and appraised the Noble Avalokitesvara, the Bodhisattva Mahasatva, saying: Very good, very good, O son of good family. It is exactly like that. The profound wisdom gone beyond should be practiced exactly as you have said, and then the Tathagatas will rejoice. When the blessed one had said this, the venerable Shariputra, the noble Avalokiteshvara, that whole gathering in the world with its guarded men, anti gods and spirits, their hearts full of joy, praise the words of the blessed one.

So ends the noble discourse on the essence of the wisdom gone beyond. Thank you all everybody. We’ve had quite a day. See you all bright and early in the morning. Oh no, no, no.

There was a good flow of we couldn’t stop that. The questions come. You know these things happen. It’s okay. I don’t know.

I’m not suffering.

Key terms in this teaching

atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
dhyana samten (Tib)
An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
four continents
In Buddhist cosmology, the four continents around Mount Meru, one at each cardinal point; ours is the southern continent, Jambudvipa (Rose-apple Land). LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
Mount Meru
The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top