2 h 7 min · 4,803 words · 2010 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 127-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche unravels the cycle of saṃsāra through the 12 links of dependent origination to show why understanding emptiness is essential for liberation. A central point: emptiness is not voidness or nihilism, but the very ground that makes karma, causality, and rebirth function. Rinpoche traces how ignorance of phenomena’s true nature cascades into desire and grasping, perpetuating the endless six realms. Using the mirror analogy—a reflection appears without the face entering the glass—he explains how rebirth occurs through causal chains without a permanent self transmigrating. Realization, he stresses, requires all three trainings (ethics, concentration, wisdom) sustained through meditation, not intellectual understanding alone. Pitched at serious Buddhist practitioners.
File metadata (for organising)
File: BV12May2010 – KR.mp3
UUID: 32fa982f-341b-4961-9944-cf21ce30233a
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Emptiness
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~4,785
Okay. Okay. Probably you guessed that Rinpoche is wearing his hearing aid, And he he said it’s very loud here. Very, very good. So we will meditate for one or two minutes on generating the motivation to listen to these teachings.
And the motivation should be both for the teacher himself and for those who listen to the teachings, a motivation exclusively to work to benefit others. To benefit others not in the contingent or limited sense of the term, but in the ultimate sense of the term, because thereby we will accumulate through listening to these teachings, well nigh infinite merit and virtue. What motivation is a motivation we should generate? It is a motivation which reflects that every single sentient being has been our mother in a past life and has been as kind to us as our father and mother in this very life. Therefore, the kindness of sentient beings to us is infinite.
And to repay this kindness, we, from our side, must pledge ourselves to place them in the state of full enlightenment, a state of unalloyed happiness. And with this as a motivation, let us listen to the Bodhicitta Vivarana of Nāgārjuna, which are the very essence of the Buddha’s teachings. Page five. Verse six. As Nāgārjuna says, one who does not understand the meaning of emptiness, such a one will never be able to escape from the wheel of lives.
What is referred to here by emptiness is the ultimate mode of being of phenomena. And for one who does not understand emptiness, there is no hope to escape from samsaric existence. Such a being cannot attain liberation and such a being therefore is not qualified to be a basis for liberation. In as much as this being is led from life to life within the six realms of cyclic existence, the three higher and the three lower realms, through the power of the ignorance which apprehends the true existence of phenomena. And in dependence on this deep rooted ignorance compelled by it, this being wanders over and over again through the hell grounds.
As Lama Tsongkhapa was an emanation of the wisdom aspect of the Buddha, Buddha Mañjuśrī said in his Three Principal Aspects of the Path, hence put effort in understanding interdependence since for one who has realized bodhicitta and renunciation without interdependence, there is no liberation. The reason of this quote is to teach clearly that in dependence on bodhicitta and renunciation alone, it is not possible to attain liberation since it is impossible through bodhicitta and renunciation alone to eliminate the ignorance, which is the motor of cyclic existence. That ignorance can only be eliminated by eliminating the ignorance which apprehends the existence of a true self, of phenomena through generating the view of emptiness. And this view of emptiness can only be generated through a realization of dependent arising or interdependence. As Buddha Śākyamūni, our teacher said, in his sūtra, he who sees dependent arising sees phenomena and he see, he who sees phenomena sees the Buddha.
The reason or the meaning of this quote is as follows, he who sees dependent arising is able in turn to realize emptiness and he who realizes emptiness is then able in turn to attain the state of full enlightenment. And generally speaking, there are three broad categories of interdependence, so pratityasamutpada. The first is the coarse, the second is subtle, and the third is even more subtle. Coarse interdependence refers to phenomena’s arising in dependence on causes and conditions. And within the term interdependence in Tibetan ten drel, the first ten, which corresponds to pratitya in Sanskrit, refers to the cause, and the second drel, which means to connect, to relate, samutpada, corresponds to the effect.
So the effect arises in dependence on the cause. And at present, we will be addressing inner interdependence, which is the 12 links. And the following section in Ngawang Darpa’s commentary on page 43 of the English translation is a refutation of the Vijnaptimatravada view, the view of the school which asserts existence of mind alone. Rinpoche will not enter into this in detail. Generally speaking, all of the Buddhist schools of philosophy accept the four seals, which are that all composite phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are of the nature of suffering, all phenomena lack the selves of persons, and finally that there is a nirvana which is of the nature of peace and bliss.
Within the four schools of Buddhist tenets, the mind only school, the Vijnaptimatravada or Cittamātra school, asserts that composite phenomena, the first phenomena within the Four Seals are truly established. And, the commentary criticizes this view as a profoundly erroneous view since should phenomena be truly established, it would be impossible for them to be transitory and impermanent, since the very transitoriness and impermanence is radically incompatible with the true establishment of phenomena. And we will now pass directly to teaching interdependence, the third outline at the bottom of page 45 of your English text, in which Ngawang Darpa quotes the root text of Nāgārjuna, the Bodhicitta Vivarana, the workings of dependent co-production arising in 12 links that start with ignorance and end with aging and death. All these I say resemble dreams and magical displays. Here, dependent co production refers to interdependent origination.
In other words, all phenomena which arise in dependence on causes and condition. And they arise as 12 links. The 12 links here comprise six links which are causal links and six links which are results of those causes. The 12 links altogether constitute the totality of cyclic existence. Moving on to page 46, all these which refer to the 12 links, I say resemble dreams and magical displays.
They resemble dreams and magical displays because arising in dependence on causes and conditions, They lack inherent establishment, and the same way as the imputation of horses and elephants upon twigs and pebbles through the power of a magician’s spells. They do not exist in the way they appear. And on page 46, moving on to verse 60 of Nāgārjuna’s root text, the bodhicitta Vivarana. Apart from such a 12 linked wheel, this refers to cyclic existence, the wheel understood in the light of the 12 links, starting with ignorance and moving on through composite phenomena and consciousness, and the endless cycle of ignorance, composite phenomena and consciousness giving rise to groups of 12 links after groups of 12 links, which constitute cyclic existence that rolls along the path of life. I do not think that there are beings reaping the results of what they do.
In other words, what is being asserted here is that there is no sentient being, there are no beings apart from this endless causal succession of the 12 links. And then moving onwards with the root text on page 46, verse six one, in dependence on a mirror, the face’s mandala appears, the face is not transferred into the mirror, and yet without the mirror, there is no image of the face. Just so, the wise should always be convinced that it is through the interlinking of the aggregates that rebirth and other lives occurs, but not that something transmigrates. Empty phenomena in short derive from phenomena that are likewise empty. The agent and the action and the one who reaps its fruits.
All this, the Buddha said, is relative, the all conceding truth, the conventional truth. So this is the bodhicitta Vivarana, the root text, and Nawang Drapa’s commentary follows. Aryanagarjuna asserts that all the activities which occur in dependence on the collection of causes and condition from the first impure link. The first impure link is the first of the 12 links, the link of ignorance, all the way up to the final 12 links of aging are similar to a dream and a mirage, because even though they appear, they are not inherently existent. They are similar to a dream and a mirage because in the same way as a dream and a mirage lack true existence.
Likewise, even though they appear from their own side, they also lack true existence. Therefore, all that exists is the endless succession of the former causes giving rise to the latter results. From non truly existing causes, an endless cycle of non truly existing results arises. Moving onwards at the bottom, the last paragraph of Page 46. Then should one inquire, this is in other words a question or a doubt, whether there is a cause for the cycling, for the circling and cyclic existence of beings apart from that.
In other words, the doubt which is being raised here is whether there is another cause for cyclic existence apart from the 12 links of the interdependent origination. Returning to the commentary, sentient beings roll on the path of life, everything in block letters is in your root text, or cyclic existence in dependence upon this wheel of the 12 links of dependent arising. There is no being whatsoever, no principal, general and permanent self apart from the 12 different agents. And which he says, should there be a principal, general or permanent self, it would be a permanent phenomenon. As a permanent phenomenon, it would be unable to transmigrate.
We’re returning to the commentary, the various links of birth, death and so forth, which is an agent asserted as reaping the causes and the results of causes of what they do, in dependence on motion and so forth within the mind of Īśvara or the creator. So here, apart from the 12 links of interdependent origination, which include six links which are causal and six links which are connected to the result, there is no other motor for cyclic existence, neither a permanent self nor for that matter a permanent creator. And therefore, there is no cause of cyclic existence apart from these 12 links and no cause such as Īśvara. And moving onwards in our comment on page 47, an example of the conventional death and transmigration of beings would be, so here, beings are never asserted as ultimate beings or ultimately existing beings, are merely conventional or nominal beings, would be for instance that even when relying on a highly reflective mirror, in other words, a mirror in which everything would appear clearly, For the oval of a being’s face appears within the mirror, the face has not moved onto the onto the mirror. So it is quite clear here, Rinpoche says, that there is a distinction to be made between the person’s face and the reflection of the face in the mirror.
What appears in the surface of the mirror is a reflection of the person’s face. It is not the face. And this is given as an example to illustrate the mode of existence of the 12 links. LePage says that this example probably has to be understood as follows. The 12 links appear as truly existing in the same way as the reflection of a face appears within the mirror, but the 12 links from their own side are not in the slightest truly existing phenomena.
And therefore, it is in dependence on previous causes or previous habituation that the illusion of true existence appears. However, causes from their own side are not truly existent in the slightest, and their results are not truly existent either. And in keeping with this, it is said that this is an assertion which is made by the Mādhyamika scholars. And moving onwards on Page 47. However, in the same way as should the mirror no longer exist, the reflection likewise would cease to be produced.
Mādhyamika scholars have always certified that there is ultimately no birth into another life and no transmigration into another world, apart from the mere convention of the entry of the aggregate of consciousness into the egg at the time of conception. Then, then here indicates a doubt, should one inquire whether a false cause gives rise to a false effect, most definitely. In brief, is a case since from causes with thoughts or phenomena which are empty of inherent existence, Phenomena, which are their effects and which are empty of inherent existence are produced. Moreover, the conqueror taught agents and so forth, as well as the reapers of the results of deeds to be conventional. Here from causes which are not truly established, which are actually empty of true establishment.
Effects which are empty of true establishment are generated. And it’s in dependence on this formulation of effects which are empty of true establishment that it is possible for karma and causality and for the state of full enlightenment to exist. Otherwise, it would be impossible for them to exist. A truly existing cause could in no way give rise to a truly existing effect or to anything else for that matter. Furthermore, it is said in a sūtra, understand phenomena, trees and so forth, in the self same way as the arising of natureless reflections in a highly reflective mirror.
This passage in sūtra clearly teaches the emptiness of true existence of all phenomena. Moving onwards in the commentary, and as is said in the root verses on Madhyamaka, Nāgārjuna’s great text, if the effect were not empty, how could a cause produce the effect? Clearly, Rinpoche says, it is only a cause which is empty of true existence which can give rise to an effect. Otherwise, no effect could arise. And we have finished a presentation of the third outline teaching interdependence in the light of the 12 links.
And for this, it is important to understand clearly what the 12 links are. They’re listed in footnote 243 on page 45 of your English translation. The first of the 12 links is the link of ignorance, which is that link which ignores the actual mode of abiding, the ultimate mode of abiding of phenomena, which is emptiness. Generally speaking, all phenomena can be divided into two categories, conventional phenomena and ultimate phenomena. Ultimate phenomena refer to the ultimate mode of abiding of phenomena.
Conventional phenomena are all those phenomena whose mode of appearance and whose mode of existence are discordant or incompatible. In other words, they appear in a way in which they do not exist. They are called conventional phenomena in English. In Tibetan, the term is kun dzob denpa. Zob is derived from dzunpa, which means to lie.
These are lying phenomena because in the self same way as a liar never acts in keeping with what he says and can often be a very pleasing and appealing person, but we learn to distrust him. In the self same way, conventional phenomena do not exist in the way in which they appear to exist. They appear to be established truly, to be inherently established, and yet they lack even the slightest atom of establishment, inherent establishment from their own side. Ultimate phenomena on the other hand, which refer to the ultimate mode of existence of phenomena such as emptiness, are phenomena whose mode of appearance and whose mode of existence are concordant or are similar. These phenomena do not appear as inherently existing and likewise do not exist from their own side as inherently existing.
And which he says, it is exactly the same thing as for instance, if ignorance were present, ignorance about the status of this house were present, then we would not know what was in the house and would not be able to identify what is in the house. In the same way, when there is ignorance regarding the mode of existence of phenomena, we are unable to ascertain what it is. Or for instance, if we were to take Australia as our subject of investigation, when neither the sun nor electricity, the light due to electricity are present, then we cannot understand in any way our object of investigation. And therefore, the first link, ignorance, has to be eliminated. Ignorance has its own mode of apprehension of phenomena since it is through the power of ignorance that conventional phenomena are apprehended.
They appear to the mind afflicted with ignorance as not merely imputed by the mind, as not existing merely as nominal imputations, but as existing from their own side. Yarbache gave the example of his cup or the book on his table, which to our sense consciousnesses appear naturally as existing from their own side independently of mental imputation. Likewise, for persons such as Prince Uttashi, who appear to us to exist from their own side as Prince Ottashi before the name is assigned to them. They appear to exist from their own side. Now, these phenomena which appear wrongly to exist inherently, there are two subdivisions of phenomena, agreeable and disagreeable phenomena.
Agreeable phenomena give rise to desire, and disagreeable phenomena give rise to anger or hatred through the power of desire in turn. Desire for the flesh of beings, desire for their offspring, desire for their hides, desire for the body of another, which leads to sexual misconduct. Beings in turn engage in heinous non virtue, and through the power of hatred as well, beings engage in terrifying deeds such as slaughtering each other and so forth. In every single case, through the power of desire and hatred, which derive from the ignorance of the true nature of phenomena, karma is accumulated. Principle here is ignorance, which is the root of karma.
And what is understood by karma, karma is a deed which is performed by a subject under the power of a motivation. A subject here can refer to a human being, but can refer also to any other sentient being, any other being with consciousness, since all beings accumulate karma. The motivation, in the case of a non virtuous motivation, might be the motivation to kill another. And in dependence on this motivation, one would engage in deeds such as inflicting harm on another and causing their death. That deed and the results which accrue from it are what are known as karma.
And therefore, returning to the first link on the footnote two forty three of page 45, which is ignorance. If we were to take the case of a virtuous deed performed to the power of ignorance, should a subject, for instance, with a virtuous motivation make, let us say, offerings to the triple gem and so forth, Then through the power of ignorance, he would nonetheless have accumulated a virtuous deed. And this virtuous karma in turn is the second of the 12 links, the link of compositional factors, which itself is divided into virtuous and non virtuous compositional factors, virtuous and non virtuous karma. Virtuous karma is karma which is accumulated through a virtuous motivation. Non virtuous karma is karma which is accumulated through a non virtuous motivation.
Karma itself is a transitory phenomenon, an impermanent phenomenon. So it disappears, but it places karmic imprints within the mind. This is the third of the 12 link, the link of consciousness. And these karmic imprints which are placed within the mind, then eventually mature under the power of the eighth, ninth, and tenth link. The eighth link is the link of craving, which refers to desire.
So under the power of the ever increasing craving, as craving arises once, twice, three times, the potency of the karmic imprint imprint which is implanted becomes ever more powerful until it gives rise to the following link, the ninth link, the link of grasping, and at its most powerful, the ninth link leads into existence. So this is a presentation of six of the 12 links, the first, second, and third, and the eighth, ninth, and tenth, which are the causal links. Then there are six links at the level of the effect, since the effect which is induced is a birth with its concomitant aging and death. And then moving onwards to the six links of the effect. The first link of the effect is the eleventh link, which is the link of birth.
The second is the link of name and form. This refers to both the form aggregate, which is not present at the very beginning at the level of the mind of the clear light of death, And the four mental aggregates, which are the aggregates of feeling of recognition, of volition and of consciousness, are called globally name. So form and the four aggregates which are mental are called name and form. These are followed by the six sources, the fifth of the 12 links. The six sources here refer to the six collections of the eye consciousness, eye organ, and the form which will be perceived in the child to be, as well as the same collection of the three for all of the other sense consciousnesses.
The ear consciousness, the nose consciousness, the tongue consciousness, the bodily consciousness, and the mental consciousness. The following link at the level of the effect is the link of contact. So all at the level of the six sources, even though, for instance, the eye consciousness, the eye organ, and form itself were potentially present, there was actually no experience of seeing. At the level of the sixth limb, there is the experience of seeing a form, which is differentiated into a pleasant or an unpleasant form. The same thing happens with all of the other sense consciousnesses.
And it is at the level of the seventh link, the link of feeling that sensation arises in dependence on the discrimination between pleasant and unpleasant forms. Pleasant forms give rise to happiness and unpleasant forms or unpleasant perceived phenomena give rise to suffering. So this completes the presentation of the six links at the level of the result, which are birth, aging and death, name and form, the six sources, contact and feeling. Now, the six links which are connected to the cause of the six causal links are created within one life and generally speaking, the six remaining links are experienced within a future life. So a minimum of two lives is necessary for all 12 links to be accomplished.
And the link of feeling, the seventh link is subdivided more specifically into happy, unhappy, and neutral feelings or neutral sensations. Happy feelings or happy sensations give rise to desire. Unhappy feelings or unhappy sensations give rise to anger or rejection. And neutral feelings or sensation give rise to ignorance. Hence, in dependence on those three subdivisions of feeling, all three poisons, desire, hatred, and ignorance are generated, and the cycle of life cycles again, and a new set of 12 links is created.
So we will stop here for today. And if you have any questions, now is the time to ask them. There are two ways to meditate on the 12 links of interdependent origination. The first is to meditate on the sequence of generation, and the second is to meditate on the sequence of cessation. The sequence of generation is meditated upon through meditating on the fact that ignorance gives rise to compositional factors, in other words karma, which in turn gives rise to the various other components, at the level of the causal link.
And in turn, the sequence of cessation is meditated upon through meditating on the fact that if we put an end to ignorance, which is the cause, then we put an end to its effect, which is compositional factors. If we put an end to composition of factors, we in turn put an end to its effect, and we work in this way through all 12 links. And then analyzing clearly what is understood by ignorance, we can see that ignorance refers to that conception of an inherently existing self, and this must be countered through its antidote, which is the view realizing emptiness. Therefore, we meditate on the view realizing emptiness. And for this as a preliminary, we need training in concentration and ethics.
Therefore, we would train in all three trainings as well. And first and foremost, we would need for these meditations to generate renunciation or the thought of definite emergence. And then through realizing, or through generating renunciation, we realize the importance of meditating on emptiness, meditate on emptiness. To meditate on emptiness, we must have generated concentration. So we engage in the training of concentration.
And to generate the training of concentration, we must have the training of ethics. So we train in the training of ethics. And also, it’s quite it’s it’s not adjust yet. So the question is, to summarize, in the context of last week’s comment that the Buddha did not meditate, did not explain meditating on a mere elimination of existence or mental activity as meditating on emptiness. His mental activity or conceptual mind is synonymous.
So here, Rinpoche says, meditation on emptiness is only possible if one engages in the threefold activities of hearing, thinking, meditating. And hearing specifically refers to hearing over and again teachings on emptiness from highly qualified teachers. And then reflecting on it oneself and reading carefully texts on the topic. To realize emptiness, it is indispensable to rely both on reasoning and on scriptural sources. The teachings of the Buddha which indicate clearly what emptiness is, the various similes for emptiness which are given, and stainless reasoning.
And then in dependence on this one generates a sense, ah, perhaps this is what emptiness is like. At this point, one engages in meditation on emptiness. And in the same way as if we want to see clearly a drawing which is being held in our hand, we cannot have a hand or anything else fluttering in front of the drawing because we cannot see the drawing clearly. Likewise, to meditate clearly on emptiness, we need a very clear mind. And this very clear mind which we need is the mind of Samādhi or single pointed concentration.
Then there is hope to gain some sort of realization of emptiness. As Mañjuśrī said to Jetsün Tsongkhapa, to gain realization of emptiness, one needs four things. One needs first to accumulate the collections of merit and wisdom. Secondly, one needs to purify all of one’s sins, all of one’s faults. Thirdly, one must make powerful prayers to the tutelary deity seen as totally inseparable from one’s spiritual teacher.
And fourthly, one must study and meditate again and again on texts explaining emptiness. Without the accumulation of merit, without the purification of sins, without prayers to the tutelary deity inseparable from the guru, and without profound and careful study, remember, it is very difficult to gain any realization of emptiness. If it was easy to meditate on emptiness, Rinpoche says, all beings would effortlessly be meditating on emptiness right now, wouldn’t they? Okay, thank you. Verse nine.
I’ve got a few announcement. And the twenty second of this, is this weekend. We have, calm abiding meditation. You know that how what Rinpoche said tonight. In order to, you know, have a good focused meditation on emptiness, you have to have calm abiding meditation.
So there is a chance you got. So Anila is going to lead on this, and, please bring a vegetarian lunch to share. And next week, Wednesday, is the last teaching for the, Bodhicitta Vivarana and, also last teaching for Rinpoche because the following week, there’s no teaching, but, Rinpoche is going to leave on a Friday on twenty eighth. And, also, in calendar, there is no mention about Guru Puja on a Thursday, but Thursday is a very big day. It’s a Saga Dawa day.
We check in a Tibetan lunar calendar. So there is precepts in the morning and sorry. Not actually as such taking, but you can take precepts. But there will be three will be fully ordained. Not sorry.
Not fully ordained. They are ordained. And in the evening on that night, which is the twenty seventh, and there’s a big Guru Puja at 07:00 and, come come along and joined. And, the next day, Rinpoche is leaving, and, we can all ask Rinpoche to come back quickly. And, so that, next week is the last Wednesday and, of course, the Thursday teaching.
But, following week, which is ’27 and ’28, there’s no teaching. It’s a Guru Puja. And yeah. And Is there anything? And, of course, after, Rinpoche’s leave on the twenty eighth, there’ll be no teaching on the daytime, during the week.
But, of course, Geshe-la will teach on Sunday morning, 10:30. And, you know, is is teaching a Lamrim — medium Lamrim so that you all welcome and try to push your time in there. I think that’s all. There’s a hot tea there. Not chilly hot.
Very nice and warm. It’s very warm. And, biscuits. Please, enjoy your chai.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four seals
- The four basic tenets that define Buddhism. They are: all compositional phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are by nature suffering, all phenomena are empty of self-existence and nirvana is true peace. LYWA
- Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
- A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
- six realms
- The general way that Buddhism divides the whole of cyclic existence; there are three lower realms (hell, hungry ghost and animal) and three upper realms (human, demigod and god). LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.