Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 06 D A 2000 05 16.MP3
UUID: 7feca35c-c864-4593-a724-486cfbeaf820
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: Dependant Arising 2000 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2000-05-16
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 49 min
Words: 4,561
There’s no question it’s like I’m experiencing it. But when we purify our mind and investigate things, we start to see it’s not quite like that at all. This phenomena here cannot exist without our mind and the whole history of our mind, how it interprets things. The fact that we may find these flowers attractive now is not even because of experience in this lifetime. We have a whole karmic history that forces us to conceive certain things as beautiful, bad, this tastes nice, this I don’t like this taste.
There’s no logic to it, It’s just karma. Countless experiences from the past coloring our mind, which we take to be the factual truth. Check for yourself how many times you have made a comment about something, someone or something, and found that the person you were commenting on didn’t agree with you at all and you’re so surprised because it’s so obvious that what you see is true. How could people disagree? That’s why there are wars because both sides utterly convinced they’re right.
That’s why people fight with each other and scream and yell at each other because one holds to one’s own view because it seems so unquestionably true. How could the other one possibly see anything different? They’re out of their mind. They’re deliberately torturing me. But it’s not that way.
The other person is actually seeing something different because there isn’t anything factually there to see. This is the interesting thing. There is a pot of flowers here, but there’s no objective pot of flowers that you can say this is what this pot of flowers is like. But we believe there is a definable pot of flowers here that has very specific things from its own side. We are convinced from its own side.
It’s all it’s all there. That’s the point. It’s all there, here. The Buddha says there’s hardly anything here. Most of it is in here.
This is the most subtle level of dependent arising, which is not easy to understand. But it is important to try to be aware, to develop some awareness, to check-in one’s daily life one’s perceptions, to do this exercise, to try to have some awareness that what I’m experiencing is basically coming from my mind. It’s not coming from the outer world. It’s coming from my mind. Everything good, bad, ugly, and beautiful is coming principally from my mind.
This awareness can save the entire world. It can bring immediate happiness into our own life or less confusion as soon as we have that awareness, whenever we get into some problem or conflict, to have that awareness, that space to remember this is arising in my mind. It is not fixed like that. It’s not this solid concrete reality that I believe it to be. And because it’s arising in one’s mind, because it is something that is arising depending on many factors.
The wonderful thing is it can change. If this world truly existed, we are in big trouble. We are in very serious trouble because it means things can’t change. If our mind truly existed, we are in big trouble because we can never achieve liberation and enlightenment. If our mind was an independent phenomena, we are in big trouble.
Fortunately, our mind is not an independent phenomena, it is a dependent phenomena, therefore we can change it. So if we just look at the text now a bit would be good to look at the text a bit, because the course is on the text. I would just rush through the first few verses because I tried to give some very brief points on them before. So I prostrate to the Guru, Manjugosha, Ignorance is the very root of all troubles in this transitory world. Transitory because it’s impermanent.
It’s changing all the time. And it’s also a transitory world because we are transiting through it. We’re not going to stay here. We can’t stay here. We’re going to move on from this to other places.
We may come back to this world, but we’re certainly going to leave it. So all these troubles are averted by understanding the dependent arising which you, meaning the Buddha, have taught. How then could the intelligent not understand that the path of dependently related arising is the essence of your teaching? So you may have heard of the Heart Sūtra, which is about the teaching of wisdom and dependent arising. So it’s called the Heart Sūtra because the teachings of wisdom are the very heart, the very essence of the Buddha’s teaching.
As I said last week, how do we stop suffering, which is what we all want to do, so that we can experience genuine happiness, lasting happiness. We have to oh, where’s my phone? We have to destroy ignorance by developing wisdom. Loving kindness and compassion doesn’t stop suffering. This is not the way to stop suffering.
It helps, and of course it’s incredibly important, but loving kindness and compassion itself does not stop the suffering of our own suffering, the suffering of the world. What is the actual direct antidote to suffering and particularly the causes of suffering is this wisdom, this consciousness that we develop that destroys, that is the very opposite to ignorance and destroys ignorance. So therefore the teachings of wisdom are at the very heart of the Buddha’s teachings. In the Hīnayāna teachings they are the final goal, If one wants to achieve liberation from suffering for one’s own sake and achieve the state of nirvana, being an Arahat, in a state of lasting bliss, then one has to develop wisdom. When one has developed that wisdom completely, job, the goal of liberation is completed.
But if one develops the Mahāyāna mind and sees that others are suffering as much as oneself even more, and they’ve been so kind in countless lives, they’ve been my mother in countless lives, life after life, sentient beings have been my mother, father, brother, sister, everything, Then one generates the Bodhicitta thought to free every sentient being from suffering. So how do you do that? Firstly you have to free yourself from suffering by developing wisdom, and then what a bodhisattva does to guide others out of suffering is to teach them wisdom, to guide them into developing wisdom. A bodhisattva will also encourage people to be kind, patient, compassionate, and all these things, but this is secondary to developing wisdom. And of course when one has perfect wisdom, one has perfect compassion.
Because when we think that suffering truly exists from its own side, it’s really real, one feels compassion. But when you understand that suffering doesn’t truly exist, it has no valid reasons for coming about. People are suffering totally unnecessarily in this hallucination believing it’s all real. This is an even greater reason for feeling compassion. So this wisdom is the heart of the Buddha’s teaching, and dependent arising is therefore the essence of this.
The easiest way to realize wisdom is to realize dependent arising, because if things dependently arise, they can’t be independent. If things aren’t independent, they don’t truly exist from their own side, the way we believe. This is not an independent cyclamen. Right? It’s not independently beautiful.
It can’t be. If it was, everyone would know that this is everyone in the entire universe would know as soon as they looked at, oh, Cyclamen. Little baby, you could show it to a little baby, they would say, oh, cyclamen. If things truly existed, I could show you the Chinese well, a Chinese book, and you’d be able to read it because all the characters in it truly exist, you would know what they meant because they would be independently they would independently exist. If they sorry.
If they independently existed, you would know the meaning because it wouldn’t depend on anything else. But when you look at a Chinese character, it depends for you to understand what it means. It depends on something. But if things didn’t depend on things, one would understand them instantly. Pick up one of Einstein’s books, and you would understand it instantly.
You just read it and understand it because it didn’t depend on anything. It would be independently obvious what it meant. That’s why dependent arising is the easiest way to have an access to the true nature of phenomena, the experience of which liberates us. Am I making some sense at all? Yes.
Okay. This being so, O Saviour, who could find anything more wonderful to praise you for than your teaching of dependent arising? So in traditional commentaries, which I’m never going to get to, but you can read this book which has one of them, it explains that there are many ways one can praise Śākyamūni Buddha as a great teacher because of his great wisdom, his great compassion particularly and so on. Various ways to praise the Buddha for his skillful means and so on. But what Lama Tsongkhapa is saying, really the very best way to praise Śākyamūni Buddha is because of teaching wisdom and particularly teaching dependent arising.
If one really understands this, one understands how profound Śākyamūni Buddha is, what the perfect teacher he is. He discovered this most subtle ultimate truth, the empty nature of all phenomena, he experienced that directly for himself, that he had the incredible wisdom to be able to explain that to others through this very simple method of dependent arising. So then it goes on to say in a simple way what dependent arising is, Whatever depends on conditions is empty of inherent existence. What excellent instruction could there be more amazing than these words? So these are just a few words, but that is the very heart of the whole teaching on wisdom.
Whatever depends on conditions is empty of inherent existence. Inherent existence is a technical term describing what we are experiencing now. When we look at things now, I don’t mean just look, but know things, experience things, everything we experience is experienced as being inherently existing. That is, we believe that this ourselves, our own body, all phenomena are really existing in a fixed way with their own characteristics, powered, substantially existing from their own side under their own power. Inherently, they are inherently there, unquestionably inherently existing.
But nothing exists like that at all, because if we start to look, we can discover that things do depend on conditions. And if things depend on conditions they aren’t inherently existing, they aren’t truly existing. They are existing but they don’t truly exist. Truly exist in the sense of what I try to say factually, objectively, really there from their own side with their own inherent characteristics. Things do exist, but they don’t truly exist.
They do exist as a dependent arising, but they don’t exist as being as truly existing, as independently existing. Nothing exists that way. Nothing can exist that way. Even the Buddha doesn’t truly exist. Buddha exists, but Buddha doesn’t truly exist.
Buddha exists as a dependent arising. Through wrongly holding dependent arising, the childish strengthened bondage to extreme views, but for the wise, the same thing is the means to cut free from the net of elaborations. So I wanted to go into this verse tonight, there’s not really much time, but I can start. Lama Tsongkhapa is saying here in this verse six is that one can study, believe one understands dependent arising, but come to a completely wrong conclusion about what it means. So the childish here is referring to people who don’t have any belief in Buddha, the Dharma, the Buddha’s view of the nature of phenomena, and therefore have extreme views.
So for example, just very roughly for the time being, in the terms of the three aspects of dependent arising, the obvious, easiest part to understand is how things depend on causes and conditions. And we can all say, Oh yes, I understand that things depend on causes and conditions, therefore I understand things that depend on their arisings, therefore I understand emptiness. But the point is, in reality, when we hear that in the Buddhist teachings and if we’re Buddhist then we try to believe it, right? Or if something depends on causes and conditions, therefore it’s a dependent arising, therefore it must be empty of true existence. Oh, this is very logical, I believe that.
Yes, yes. Right? But in reality, what most many great scholars of the past, non Buddhists argued, and this is what we tend to do, is that for example, if you make a cake, someone here regularly make a cake or you make cook, you know, make dinner, make a sandwich, everyone’s made a sandwich, right? Maybe not everyone. If you make a sandwich or you make a table or what?
What else can you make? Anything. You make something, make a sandwich. Of course, as one is making a sandwich, one understands that to make a sandwich depends on causes and conditions. You need bread, this and that, butter, some things to put inside, time and energy to do it, table to make it on, plate, knife, sauce, something, mustard, something like this.
So it depends on causes and conditions. But when it’s made, you think, I’ve made this because I made it, it’s really there. There’s a real sandwich there. I know there’s a real sandwich there because I made it. One doesn’t believe, oh, here’s an empty sandwich here, a non-truly existing sandwich here.
We believe there is a truly existing, definite, totally existing from its own side sandwich because I created it. Here’s this table created by cause and conditions. It’s really here from its own side because someone made it. Of course, tables don’t exist if you don’t make them, but if you make them, they’re really here. Wrong.
Not really here. The Buddha argued because it depends on cause and conditions, it’s here, but it’s not really here. It’s here, but it’s not truly here. It’s existing. There is a table here, but there’s not a truly existing table here at all.
Something to think about. So when it refers to extreme views, maybe just briefly explain this. In Buddhist tradition, they talk about there are two extreme views that one can fall into, two wrong extreme there are many kinds of wrong views, and there are the extreme wrong views and there are two kinds of extreme wrong views. So one extreme set of extreme wrong views about the nature of reality is that things really exist independently, separately. They’re really, really permanently there.
These extreme wrong views lead to suffering, by the way. This is what is called also in Western philosophy, naive realism, which is what we’re all suffering from now. It’s called naive realism, which is this naive belief that things are really out there like they appear. Like a very gross form, maybe a distorted gross form of this is when children, but unfortunately it’s not children but even adults do this, is that when a child watches a movie they believe it’s real, that the actor is really the hero there like Rambo. People children think that character on the screen really exists going around, you know, destroying towns and and doing all those strange things that Rambo does.
Yeah. Even some adults believe that. The characters on television I once saw on television a character, an actress from Coronation Street, so she was one of the naughty characters in Coronation, if you’ve ever heard of this program. And she said how people often would come up to her in the street and insult her because she’d done something naughty and because they really believe she is that person. How could you have said that to him last week?
So this is kind of distorted naive realism, but this is what we’re doing now, really believing that things are unquestionably as they appear to my mind. So this is one extreme wrong view, which is also mixed with a view of permanence, things that really not only are things like this, but it’s permanent. When a child is licking an ice cream, or even when we’re eating an ice cream, at one level we know it’s not going to last, but in the moment it seems very permanent. Yeah. And especially the more attachment we have to the experience.
Check for yourself. Intellectually, can say this is not going to last. It’s not going to last, but one really wants it to last and is slightly believing it is lasting. You lick it slowly so it lasts longer to make sure it is permanent. So then the other extreme view is that nothing exists at all, everything’s an illusion, it doesn’t really exist.
There philosophical schools that argue this, but this is quite a more rare type of extreme view, but sometimes our mind can tend to go in that direction, but usually our mind goes in the other direction. Most of the time it’s stuck in this extreme wrong view that things are really permanently like that. So we have these two extreme views. Then there is the view of the Buddha, and this view is called the middle way. In Sanskrit it’s called the Mādhyamika, but in Tibetan it’s called Uma, which is where Uma Thurman, the actress, gets her name from by the way because her father is Professor Robert Thurman who is a great expert on emptiness and he named her Uma.
Anyway, small aside. So the middle way of the Buddha, the Mādhyamika, doesn’t mean that it’s halfway between it’s a mixture of this extreme view and like you have this and you’ve got the edges of the extreme wrong view here and then they meet here and so the middle way is a bit of this extreme view and a bit of that one. It doesn’t mean that at all. The middle way means it’s right in the middle and it’s completely separate from that extreme view, and completely separate from that extreme view. It’s something quite different.
It’s this middle view, this middle way where things are existing, which is opposite to the view that they don’t exist, but they don’t truly exist, which is the opposite to this view that things really, really exist unquestionably, independently. So this is the middle way view, which is a very subtle view to actually understand and experience. But the childish who don’t understand things, when they think about dependent arising, they think, oh, this has arisen depending on things by causes and conditions, therefore it really exists. So that just strengthens this extreme view. It doesn’t help to gain the middle way view.
But for the wise who really understand dependent arising as the Buddha taught it, and as for example Nāgārjuna, the great disciple of the Buddha taught it, this very same thing means to cut free from the net of elaborations. So the net of elaborations is referring to the fact that with our mind ignorance elaborates, things are existing in a particular way, then ignorance elaborates on that. It creates this whole other story, this whole other fantasy, this whole other illusion about how things are, that things are non truly existing, they are existing as dependent arisings, but our ignorance elaborates on that, that this is really existing, truly existing, inherently existing from its own side, and it’s really beautiful, it’s really ugly, it’s really desirable, it’s really this, that, that, that, that, you know, millions of things from this fundamental elaboration of true existence that we put on everything, countless other concepts, misconcepts come. A whole net of elaborations come with that. In the train of ignorance comes attachment.
Because it’s really beautiful, we desire it, because it appears to be completely separate from me, and it’s really out there separate from me, so beautiful. So I want it. I must have it. And then I get it, and then I’m stuck with it, and I can’t separate from it. Because if I separate from it, I won’t be happy anymore.
Because once I’ve got it, I’m happy. Yeah. I’m really happy now. I’ve got it. I’m really happy.
And if I let go so I can’t let go, have to hold on, hold on, more suffering, fear, confusion comes, a whole net of elaborations, jealousy, oh, because someone’s got an even better one, oh my god. Doubts, do I have the best one? Fear of losing the best one? Countless elaborations come. I am so wonderful because I’ve got the best one.
You are so pitiful because you don’t have the best one. Just from ignorance, countless this net of elaborations of suffering arises. So since this teaching is not found elsewhere, you alone are the teacher. That is, only the Buddha deserves the title of someone who can teach us to be free of suffering. Because only the Buddha understands the true nature of phenomena and can teach it.
For a Tīrthika this name would be flattery, like calling a fox a lion. So the Tīrthikas are generally you could say this refers to most other non-Buddhist philosophers. So Lama Tsongkhapa is saying that these other non-Buddhist philosophers, to call them teachers is just being polite because they’re not real teachers at all. They can’t really teach us to be free of suffering. They’re only teaching something that is partial.
It doesn’t really solve the problem totally. So it’s like calling a fox a lion. The real lion is the Buddha, Śākyamūni, and in the sutras the Buddha is often referred to as the lion’s roar of the truth, because a lion in the jungle, when he roars, everyone else goes quiet, totally shuts up. In the jungle it’s all noisy, all the monkeys are screaming, the birds are chattering away, all the other animals are making their noises, but when the lion roars, they all shut up, totally silent. So when the Buddha proclaims the truth, all the other phony philosophers just keep quiet, or they should.
This is what Lama Tsongkhapa is saying, something like that. It’s getting pretty late. We haven’t got very far, but we had better stop. Last week, I asked you to think about and we — I meant to check with you this week, I’ll ask you to think about it again this week some more. It’s really important to understand how ignorance is the cause of suffering.
Do you understand this? Have you thought about this and made the connection? Which is basically saying, do you see how ignorance gives rise to desire, anger, jealousy, pride, and all these things? And do you see that these are in their nature suffering and are the cause of karma? Okay.
Hold it. So so do you understand that, though? Oh, okay. Good. Right.
Yes. Okay. Okay. But to put it down in a very basic way, for example, like we’re saying that misconceiving the way things are is the root of every possible suffering. So for example, you look at a tree and the Buddha is saying, The way we see a tree is not the way the tree exists, and that is the root of all suffering.
Do you understand that? Is not seeing a tree in the right way the root of all suffering? Think about it, think about it. Is it because we don’t see trees in the right way that we are suffering? I’m quite clear what you’re saying, but Well, saying the tree exists and it looks different to many different people.
Right. Is that does it look different because it is like a sensation, we sense it and from that sensation, we get a perception of it then a mental formation of that tree. Is that what’s sort of happening? I think the words you’re using are a bit vague, sorry. You don’t get a sensation of the tree, you do get your mind perceives it.
Right. Yeah. It’s not a sensation. You you have especially with your eye consciousness, you directly you directly see the tree, then with your mental consciousness you conceive something about that tree. Oh, this is something maybe to make clear, that with all that we have the six senses, right?
The five physical senses of eye consciousness, ear consciousness and so on, and then there is the mental consciousness. So all of the six consciousnesses perceive true existence, this false existence, this inherent existence which is false. But it’s only the mental consciousness that grasps at that as being true. And we are trying to remove ignorance from the mental consciousness, right? Because it’s the ignorance in the mental consciousness which is the very source of suffering, the root of suffering.
I didn’t mean to do these questions now because I think it’s getting late for most people. I think we better especially because we have to request Kyabje Rinpoche to do the Tārā prayers now. I’m I’m sorry. I I would like to leave more time for questions, but I tend to ramble on. I’m really sorry about this.
But I’ll try next week to say less and we discuss more and cover more verses somehow. Excuse me. But somehow there seems to be many things to say about this topic. Anyway, but again, just try and think about this point more and more. Basically, what I’m asking, do you see the relationship or how ignorance gives rise to the delusions, the afflicted thoughts?
Yeah. Because these are suffering. And the other thing is also just to do some meditation where one just kind of reminds oneself that you can sit for a few minutes each day, it would be nice to do this, then like in the evening or sometime, and then just go over your day’s events and try to be aware that what one experienced with one’s eyes, one’s nose, taste, tongue, body, the mind, although it appeared so real, so real from its own side, really out there, really existing with all its characteristics out there, independent of me, actually it’s all coming from my mind. And can you try and catch yourself having some awareness in daily life of that, that this beauty I see is not really there at all. It’s something I am conceiving, I am putting, which is not bad.
The problem is saying something unbeautiful negative is not bad in itself because conventionally, relatively, certain things are beautiful, certain things are ugly, conventionally. And we have to respond accordingly. But the problem is we believe that it’s totally from its own side and therefore we respond inappropriately. If we could understand that this is beautiful, that this beauty isn’t coming from the object, it’s being created by my mind, one could enjoy the object but without attachment to it. That is possible.
But because we see the object, the beauty out there, we get attached to it. And attachment is important to discover is suffering. It’s not pleasure, it’s suffering in its very nature. But it’s so helpful to try to maintain this awareness that everything I’m experiencing is dependent arising, depending on causes and conditions, parts, my mind. Therefore, reason for anger
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- tirthika mu teg pa (Tib)
- An outer being, a proponent of a non-Buddhist system of beliefs with tenets that assert either eternalism or nihilism, views which bind them to samsara. Also known as an outsider, one who adheres to an outsider doctrine. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.