Death and Rebirth – 2013-03-10 – KR

48 min · 6,330 words · 10 March 2013

Death and Rebirth (Ilia Durovic)
Death and Rebirth (Ilia Durovic)
Death and Rebirth - 2013-03-10 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. A question-and-answer session with the teacher covering the bardo state after death, including the timing of rebirth, the role of mental training and memory, and the effect of prayers and rituals on the dying and the deceased. Also discussed are reincarnation research, the power of vows and curses at death, the ethics of euthanasia for animals, and the rarity of precious human rebirth.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 48 min

UUID: 9e364643-19ea-4ef5-afdb-7fc1845a6d71

Date: 2013-03-10

Words: 6,326

Then I will be delighted to take your questions. Some of you wanted to ask me questions during the break. My apologies, I wasn’t able to answer. I had compulsory commitments, but I’m glad to take them now. I was thinking, you know, as regards illness in the Western population, you recall ever seeing a, for example, a Lama, a Tibetan Lama with dementia?

It’s an excellent question. I don’t know in thirty years experience of one single case, not one. And I think it is because of the level of mental training. In the Tibetan Buddhist system of education, a great emphasis is placed in all four traditions on memorization. A geshe typically would have memorized between 2,003 pages of text and a great emphasis is placed on debate.

As a result, some of my teachers who were well in their nineties would apologize when they couldn’t recite a 120 page text entirely by heart. It was that level of memory. I should point out my father was a very famous scientist, very powerful mind. And until the time he died, I saw no difference in his mental capacity whatsoever. So I think it is a matter of mental training.

I personally believe it’s memorization. The doctor who was my mother has an excellent memory for her age. She still memorizes. In her age group, lot of women memorized, a lot of people memorized verses of the bible every day, then this seems to have a very good effect on the mind. That we’ve created a society in which we don’t rely on our minds anymore.

We don’t memorize, you know, and it’s in my generation that this de emphasis on memorization happened. And I think we’re reaping the fruits. Are there other questions? In the Bardo, it in the Bardo in the Bardo, is it only do all sentient beings go through the Bardo or just human beings? So it depends not on the sentient being but on the rebirth they’re going to have.

If sentient beings are going to be reborn in realm, in the hell realms actually, or if they are going to be reborn in the formless realms of the gods, they have no bodily transition. For instance, being who is to be reborn in the hell realms just manifests in the hell realms. Likewise, someone who has engaged in the third or the fourth dhyāna and who is to be reborn in the formless realms just passes there immediately. Then as Geshe explained yesterday, there are two types of pretas. Those who have a rebirth from the womb and those who have miraculous rebirth.

If you have miraculous rebirth, you don’t have a bodily rebirth. Apart from that, the pretas who are born from the womb have a bodily rebirth or pass through the bodily before being reborn. So do all animals, so do all human beings. Going from a hell realm to say human realm, for example, that hell realm person goes through? So normally you would go through a bardo passage because you’re being reborn as a human being.

But I don’t know of any discussion about this. Normally, would. What is it about the cycle of seven and especially 49 that Geshela said the Bardo being cannot remain after that time. What is it? What’s happening in that sense?

I don’t know. I mean, I actually have never read this anywhere. This is my own private understanding. So you have to accept it as my own private interpretation. I personally believe it’s connected to the moon cycle.

The moon cycle is of twenty eight days. Therefore, every seven days, the moon is in an aspect of 90 degrees to its position at the beginning. Now we know the moon has a big influence on water, on a lot of elements on earth. But I don’t know this for a fact. Should point out that it is not just in Buddhism, in the more traditional Christian traditions, mourning is engaging for forty nine days after death.

In the Eastern Orthodox Church for instance, one mourns someone who has passed on for forty nine days. So it is historians trace this back to Babylon and to the planetary meaning of the week of seven days. But I think there’s something much more fundamental going on. Yes. Good morning.

There was a question from yesterday, Ilya. Geshela talked about consciousness staying at the heart for three days, but sometimes even up to a month. During that period, can that person communicate? I mean, not verbally, obviously, but communicate with people close to him who are still alive? What sort of communication are you talking about?

I suppose it’s obviously nonverbal, like a sort of telepathy or spiritual communication. During those three days, I don’t know. I would assume not because once the mind is at the heart, it is in the state of what is known as the mind of clear light which is non conceptual. However, the bodily being can definitely communicate using telepathy. And as I mentioned before, it’s one of the reasons for which we perform pujas.

And all the religious traditions have rituals of mourning by the dead body because the departed spirit, we would say in English, the Bardo being, becomes aware of this and then stays in the area of the dead body and there could be a limited influence on the rebirth of the Bardo being. It’s very limited. Normally, is said that at the time of death and if one wants to be really precise within the process of death, it is at the time of the disappearance of all coarse conceptuality one’s future rebirth is determined. But it seems that this can be modulated in the bodily state. And it can be modulated.

By modulated I mean that you could not for instance transform a rebirth, a future rebirth as an animal into a rebirth as a human being. But you could definitely modulate it and for instance transform a rebirth as an let’s say an animal working in the fields to a rebirth as a pet. That it seems can be done. These pujas are most effective when they are performed by those who have a strong karmic connection with the person. This means parents, close relatives or the teacher.

But they are not nearly as effective as we would like them to be. Could I just follow on one other quick Yesterday, you seem to be using mind and consciousness when we were talking about the body and the bardo state interchangeably. Are they interchangeable in this context? Yes. Yes.

Yes. Yes. Yes. Ilya, my question is about regarding reincarnation. I read the book Irreducible Mind. Oh, congratulations..

That was fine.. And I also read 20 Cases of Reincarnation by Stevenson. And I myself don’t really recall a time in my life where I ever did not consider reincarnation a fact and karma a fact. So that’s always been quite well established in my mind. Last night, I decided to start reading Wambach, Helen and I found some of the stories there quite challenging mainly because they don’t seem to accord with the Buddhist teaching on reincarnation.

And these the the particular thing is that there’s about an average of fifty years between one human life and the next. So I understand that in other realms in the Buddhist scriptures, it’s explained that, you know, one human day equals certain amount of their years or something like that. And that’s the only explanation that I can come up with for why there would be this very short interval between human lives. Now what is your what are your personal views on on this? Why there is intervals of fifty years between human rebirths On average.

On average. Yeah. In in her research, which seems to be quite credible. Well, there’s a couple of things to keep in mind. From a Buddhist standpoint, if Wambach’s cases are authenticated, and I think they are, but she’s done a statistical study of it.

Once you have obtained a human rebirth, your odds of getting in the future a human rebirth are much higher than if you haven’t obtained a human rebirth. Because having obtained a human rebirth once, you actually have the possibility to create the karma for another human rebirth. So you might after that human rebirth be reborn as an animal. You might be reborn in a hell realm, but you will have, especially for those who were born during religious ages, some type of virtuous karmic imprints. It’s just a matter of these maturing.

So I think that probably goes a long way to explaining that interval. The sample in other words, which you are talking about is not a standard sample, right? You’re talking of people who are primed to have human rebirths because of previous human rebirths. Once one settles in the lower realms, then, frankly, it is very difficult to see how a being can get out. But her research would her research would necessitate that not one single one of her subjects who record more than one life, most of them she regressed to three, was ever born in any other realm other than human or animal and that seems statistically impossible to me.

So that’s something I talked about I think during the last symposium at some of the previous conferences I gave here. Why is it that in cases of hypnotic regression non human rebirths are so rare? And why is it that in cases of spontaneous recollection of past lives non human rebirths are so rare? There are several factors. The first I think is that the data is there.

Certainly in Stevenson it is there. There are clear cases of memories of animal rebirths and of hell rebirths. Clear without any ambiguity. What is striking in every case where there are these clear memories is that the memory is almost contentless. It’s one experience.

There’s an experience of eating grass. There’s an experience for someone who remembered being reborn as a rabbit. There’s an experience of being stung. And the person actually doesn’t know who he was but you can extrapolate from the memories that it was probably a horse or an oxen because the memory is of being big and of having blinkers. And in the case of a hell rebirth memory, case of Vijayaratna which I mentioned in the previous conference I gave here, Vijayaratna murdered his wife, was executed, in Sri Lanka in 1928 and was reborn as a human being some twenty years later.

That entire interval is basically occupied by one memory of fire which seems to correspond to a hell rebirth but there is nothing in that hell rebirth apart from an experience of fire. But rebirths in hells, I mean, I don’t know about the precise figures, but rebirths in hells are meant to last an extraordinarily long period of time. So unless you’ve got time, you know, I think as it does in Tushita or somewhere time passing much more quickly in hell as compared to on Earth, then it doesn’t make any sense. But I am prepared to accept that time passes in a different No, no. That’s not what is happening.

What is happening is in the case of Vijay Ratna almost certainly he after committing actually it’s clear in the analysis of the case, after committing the murder of his wife repented very strongly and there was clear repentance after committing the deed. Then he confessed in the Theravada Buddhist tradition to monks who came to the prison before his execution and I think as a result of this repentance, his stay in the hell realms was short, his death was premature. So what is referred to in the length of the deaths in the hell realm is the maximum lifespan. If there is no repentance of any type which cuts that lifespan short. Looking to the cases in Stevenson, they are challenging because there is almost no content in those memories.

It’s just a memory of suffering And the French cases, which I mentioned, where there are clear memories of a cold hell. Geshela mentioned, I think was quoting about not being able to find another rebirth. And is that a poetical way or a, you know, of saying this extraordinarily difficult because the monotheistic religions say, you know, you have one human life and that’s it. But so I’m assuming that that’s just a way of saying that to obtain the precious human rebirth is incredibly rare and not just to lay back on our laurels and say, well, I’ll get another one. But he did definitely say that because we won’t ever find it again.

I think frankly getting a human rebirth is difficult and getting a precious human rebirth is incredibly hard. I mean there is only 7,000,000,000 human beings on earth. If you count all the insects, the fish, the animals, the birds, we are looking at trillions of creatures. I don’t know how many insects you would have in Adelaide. Then the moment you start considering insects as conscious beings, as opposed I think to the dominant new age understanding of reincarnation which is it happens between human beings and to a degree with group souls of animals.

But the moment you consider insects as individual sentient beings, you realize that once you’re reborn as an insect, it’s pretty much over. Now not all human rebirths in addition are precious human rebirths. Of 7,000,000,000 human rebirths, a true precious human rebirth with the 10 endowments in the eight freedoms is something only a practicing Buddhist has and it is an incomplete rebirth, since we were not born at the time of the Buddha. Then non practicing Buddhists who are the, in my opinion, the practitioners of the world’s great faith have a similarity of a precious human rebirth, because the great faith Christianity, Judaism, a moderate reading of Islam all teach ethics. Then ethics is a foundation for the high rebirth, so such a rebirth is close to a precious human rebirth.

And then the very rare people who are able to have ethics without any type of religious belief whatsoever, also probably qualify. But that’s a small minority of the population. Everybody else is basically at the complete mercy of their karmic imprints, their past karmic imprints. If they had good past karmic imprints, they will naturally have a tendency not to steal, not to engage in sexual misconduct and so forth. That’s rare.

That’s rare. So if you take Adelaide for instance, it’s a city of one in some million. How many sincere practicing Christians are there? How many sincere practicing Jews, sincere practicing Muslims, sincere practicing Buddhists, sincere practicing Hindus, all of whom follow a path of ethics? There’s what 50,000 people.

If one’s optimistic, probably a lot less than that. The Christian churches are empty. The synagogues are empty. They’re just social clubs. Right?

The Buddhist centers on a major weekend like this, we have 30 people. Then that means that you have a very, very small proportion of the population who understands the difference between what the Buddhists know as the white and the black path. The path of virtue and the path of evil, the path of non virtue. So human rebirths are rare and precious human rebirths are extremely rare. Rare.

Yes, Jill. Just following on, quick question, which relates to Judy’s question as well, the pretas having a miraculous and a womb rebirth. Does that mean that pretas are taking human and animal form in our realm? Well, I use the term mammalian rebirth for rebirth from the womb. Maybe I shouldn’t have, because obviously they’re not having human rebirth or animal rebirth.

They are reborn from a mother’s womb. A womb. Pretas? Then I have no direct experience of this, so, I have no way of commenting on it. But this is what is taught. Yes, please.

Yeah. I wonder if you could just comment on you talked about giving medication to help people and when they’re dying to have as much consciousness as possible. And and what about animals who want to alleviate their suffering? I know it’s all about the motivation, but if you want to euthanize them for because you can’t bear their suffering. I just like your comments.

Are you talking of reducing their suffering or euthanasia? Putting them to sleep. It’s very different. For animals, the issue with morphine doesn’t arise because an animal’s mind is more or less by definition dull and an animal would have no capacity or no control enabling it to generate a virtuous state of mind before death. Assuaging the sufferings of an animal as much as possible is perfectly possible.

There’s no need to worry about the impact on mental clarity. Then active euthanasia is killing And it must be avoided as much as is possible. If a pet is extremely ill, then one should try to let nature take its course. If it is absolutely impossible to do that, one has to be very aware that if one puts the animal to sleep with the motivation of compassion, it’s a karmically mixed deed. So it’s a deed of killing.

Clearly, the Lojong motivation, the indirect motivation as we say is compassion. But the short term motivation is the will to kill. The deed is probably complete. The animal will die as a result of this, then one’s own lifespan will be impacted. Now because pets can be very close to oneself, it can be a karmically heavy deed.

So one’s lifespan certainly will be impacted in future lives, that’s a given. In this life it might be. Therefore it’s better to not do this at all And if it really has to be done, then one has to engage in purification after. Does that answer your question? To give an idea of the problems, imagine what your reaction would be if someone in the room said, my child really is suffering a lot.

It is crippled. Can I put it to sleep? Everyone would be horrified. Now from a Buddhist standpoint, there is no major difference between an animal and a child. Both are persons.

In the case of animals because we own them as slaves because that’s what it amounts to, we consider we have the right to castrate them, to clip their ears in keeping with fashions, to cut their tails, to neuter them in the case of females, to sell them, to buy them. We would never do this to a human being. And if it is inconvenient for us to put them to sleep or if we think their suffering is too great to put them to sleep. The moment we think of the animal as a person like us, we can see how wrong this is. So I think before putting to sleep an animal one should ask oneself under what circumstances would I engage in active euthanasia on my own child.

Then indeed there are circumstances where it may have to be done, but they’re few and far between. It is heartbreaking. But you see, it is more heartbreaking for you than for them because you suffer through empathy. But frankly, from a Buddhist standpoint, if the animal can experience this, there’s a lot of karma which is not going to mature in the future for that animal. Then obviously if it’s insupportable, it’s insupportable.

Then you have to find the dissolutions. But there is no way it will not be a deed of killing. Then once one really believes in karma, one is very careful with these deeds. It comes back in one’s own face. Yes?

And to come back to the bardo state, if after forty nine days there is no karmically suitable rebirth, can that happen? Like what happened after forty nine days if there’s no rebirth? Then it’s not considered. Normally, it always happens. It can happen, however, that the bardo being is reborn as a spirit.

In other words, when we speak of ghosts, for instance, is what we’re speaking about. The being enters the bodily state, then it’s a preta rebirth really. Typically through attachment to a house or to a piece of land or forest or a river, the being is reborn and it’s a miraculous rebirth as a preta, in other words, rebirth when one is not reborn from the womb as a preter who is the guardian of that house, of that river, of that stream. This is how the protectors of the land are reborn. Elliot, yesterday, spoke about, the need to obtain a virtuous mind through habituation at the time of death.

And I was reading in Cases of Reincarnation Talk about the Tlingit Indians of Alaska, the Indians of Alaska, and how they were through pure volition and not through any virtuous deeds through their life were able to redirect their rebirth. It’s perfectly possible. I mean if the will is strong enough, why not? But there has to be some sort of karmic imprint which is brought to maturation whether the person is conscious or not of it. There may have been some virtuous deed in their life, but will is a power which directs definitely the mind.

I mean there’s a case in reincarnation in biology of an Alaskan fisherman, these are Inuits who believe in reincarnation, who was so tired of working as a slave basically on the fishing boats that he said I will be reborn without a right arm in my future life. And he said this on a regular basis. Then after his death, the child which was reborn and which remembered the life of the person who turned out to have been his grandfather was reborn without an arm. That’s a clear case of a vow. It’s what we call a vow which was led to fruition within one lifespan.

I have a case in my own family. My father before he died basically took a vow to return to protect us It was put in writing in his will. Then he became after his death basically a protector of our family for almost seven years appearing in dreams, giving instructions in dreams and so forth. It is the power of a vow and especially the vow of a dying person is particularly powerful. It’s a vow which is taken as a person is descending into death to a state of non conceptuality.

Such a vow will come to fruition. It can be a curse. There’s a famous case in French history but it takes us very far away from our topic. The last of the knight tempers, Jacques de Molay, was burnt at the stake by Philippe le Bel in France in the thirteen hundreds and it was on trumped up charges. Philippe Lebel wished to destroy the Order of the Knights Templar which was hugely rich and influential.

And Jean of Malay, after being severely tortured, was burned at the stake in public in front of the entire French court and he cursed the king and he cursed the dynasty of the king. In his curse, he said, you Philippe le Bel will die before the year the year runs out and so will the pope and I forget his name is Clement V, I think, and your lineage, the Capetian dynasty will disappear within, I think it is three Was it seven years? Seven years or seven It was very short and the actual life of the King was interrupted. The Pope did die as was foretold by Jean de Molay, Jacques de Molay, and the dynasty was interrupted. Then it’s a striking case because it’s accepted by French historians that this did happen and it’s very awkward, right, because the efficacy of death curses is not really recognized in history.

So vows and curses at the time of death are of great power. It’s a manifestation of the will of the person. But there has to be an underlying virtue for rebirth? For rebirth? Yes.

Yes. Yes. In the context of the channels, the winds and the drops. Well, I think it’s the nervous energy myself. The channels seem to correspond broadly speaking to the nervous system, the drops might correspond to the neurotransmitters and the winds might correspond to the nervous influx.

Then this has to be examined clearly. It is probably not the coarse nervous influx we’re talking about, very subtle forms of the nervous influx. Yes, please. I wonder when the the Bardo beings’ originations, when there is a point where the mental states arise, do they really have any experience in those states before the body? Bardo beings are conscious like us.

Bardo beings have actually a much higher level of consciousness than we do. They have the precognitions. They have very clear minds. They basically travel instantaneously to whatever destination they think of. Just the spirits.

Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. For example sorry.

For example, people grieving, and the Bardo body feels physically or within itself, many times pain than it would if you and I were crying now. Aren’t their senses heightened? Yes, I mean they have many mental senses. Then they are sometimes called smell eaters. I think largely perhaps for historic reasons because there were cultures in which one would make sacrifices to these beings and they tend to be burnt offerings.

You find this in Christianity, in Judaism or in Judean certainly. They don’t have sense organs like us. It’s clear that they have very heightened sense capacities nonetheless, mainly of a mental order. Then precisely because they come instantaneously when one thinks of them and especially when one utters their name, there are particular strictures in the mourning rituals in Tibet. You find these in all of the great world traditions.

It’s only in the West which has become a spiritual wasteland that people don’t have a clue how to handle these things. In the Tibetan Buddhist tradition and I think in all Buddhist traditions really, one of the key elements in the death process is that there is no mourning. There is no mourning basically because mourning can create sadness in the dying person affecting their rebirth and it can create very powerful attachment in the battle being creating what amounts to a ghost, which is what one wants to avoid. Then, in Tibet, certainly, after the death of, the patient, the patient’s name was never uttered, So that the patient not be brought back, the name was never uttered. And anything which reminded one of the patient was given away or the dead person was given away or the person’s possessions had been given away before that person’s death, you know.

The goal being to enable the Bardo being to pass very smoothly into the next life. Then the tradition of strong mourning from a Buddhist standpoint is a very problematical one. It’s problematical before the death of the person because it creates great mental suffering for the dying person. It’s problematical after the death because it can prevent the bardo being from transmigrating. Clearly.

And therefore after the death of the person, one performs rituals whose goal is basically to because the bardo being is there like a person in the room to uplift them. One performs pujas, if they have teachers as a representation of the teacher, one never speaks of the person by name. Typically, among the Tibetans, I think it’s one year. So this is something I think Westerners are completely oblivious to. But it is very important.

Naturally, naturally. A name has the power to attract. Yes. I think Christina oh, Natalie. I just wanted to clarify, Ilya, are life force and consciousness the subtle mind?

Life force and consciousness are the subtle mind, was that your question? Yes. Not really. The life force is something I think much more in keeping with modern medicine, right? It’s the vitality of the person.

Then in consciousness, we have coarse consciousness and subtle consciousness. When we speak of the death process, death can be said to occur when not only the life force has abated, in other words the heart does not beat, there is no EEG anymore, but in addition the subtle consciousness which is at the heart has departed. That cannot be measured. It is only a trained practitioner who can ascertain whether the subtle consciousness is still at the heart or not. If it is, there is from a Buddhist standpoint the body is still alive.

So that subtle consciousness when we talk about mind, is that what we mean? Depends of the context. Generally speaking, when we talk about mind, we talk about all the minds, including the subtle consciousness, but also conceptual minds, sense consciousnesses and so forth. Then when we talk of the subtle consciousness, if we want to be precise, we refer to the fundamental mind or the mind of clear light. And that is what transmigrates.

It’s a non conceptual mind, the most subtle mind of all. It bears the karmic imprints. So that subtle clear light mind that transmigrates, is that a valid cogniser? Is that what valid cogniser is? No.

It could be a valid cogniser, but it is not necessarily a valid cogniser. Valid cognizers are valid in their way they apprehend an object. Then let’s say if that subtle mind or apprehending emptiness, it would be a valid cognizer. The first instance of that subtle mind apprehending emptiness would be a valid cognizer. Otherwise, in ordinary beings, that subtle mind probably has no definite object.

You can’t say it’s a valid cognizer. I think there was Chris in the back who had made a sign. Just going back to the death process or just straight after death. So the sewer practice would be a ritual. That the sewer practice?

Which sewer practice? Yes, yes. So that is a ritual. That’s supposed to help the person pass on? Yes, I mean whatever basically it’s not mechanical, You understand that?

Whatever the person has profoundly believed in in this life, It’s not automatic. There’s no automaticity in these matters. If the person is a sincere, let’s say Sakya practitioner or Nyingma practitioner or Kagyu tradition, any practice within the tradition the person profoundly believes in will be of benefit before and probably after death. Much more before death than after death. Before death is real capacity to affect future rebirths.

Someone may have, you know, led a death squad all their life in South America. If at the time of death a skillful Roman Catholic priest induces repentance, that person would have a happy rebirth, as long as there’s some type of virtuous karmic imprint in their life. And another person might have led an extremely virtuous life all their life long, and if at the time of death great physical suffering arises, and as a result of this anger arises within their mind, they will be reborn in some type of lower rebirth. So before death, one has tremendous capacity if one is skillful in the management of the death process to control the next rebirth. After death, it’s extremely limited.

So our efforts are wrong efforts. We put much more effort in rituals after death, which are not terribly effective and very little effort in helping the dying person to die happily and calmly in a religious frame of mind, which is of great benefit. Then whatever ritual the person is connected to in this life will be of benefit. Let’s say if someone is a sincere Buddhist and after death one would for instance recite the Guhya Samaja tantra, typically perform Lama Chöpa in their room, whatever sadhana, whatever deity they were connected with. But if they are hostile to Buddhism, this actually may not be helpful at all.

And if they were, for instance, a very pious Jew, they want to recite the Kaddish. If they were a pious Christian, let’s say in the Eastern tradition, one would expose the body. Whatever the person is connected to. Because in this matter there’s no ultimate truth, right? It’s the mind of the person in their reaction which counts.

Does that answer your question? Regarding the cessation of suffering, despite any analysis of that topic, we’re unable to check whether this is concordant with reality as we have no experience to relate this to. So is this a case then where where we’d have to rely on faith in the triple gem that there is complete cessation? Establishing the existence of a truth of cessation is not easy, but it can be done. I think if one understands that the afflictions are impermanent and is convinced that they are all impermanent and one understands the relationship between an affliction and an antidote, which is that of being directly contradictory with each other.

Whatever increases causes a decrease of the other component of the pair, then one can see how it will be possible to lead an affliction to disappearance. Then the big question is whether this disappearance would be permanent or not. If it is permanent, one speaks of an abandonment. Then an abandonment is a cessation. Because let’s say the cessation of the affliction of desire means desire could never appear again.

That is a difficult topic one has to study for oneself. It is difficult. Ilya, I know this has been raised before, but I’m still struggling with it. If the state of mind at the moment of death is so important, what about people who are killed instantly in an explosion or a head on? And there’s no certainty.

It’s what they were thinking of, let’s say for instance, if you take the case of soldiers in Afghanistan for instance, it’s what they were thinking of at that moment which is determining. So the first thing as a Buddhist practitioner, I think to be honest, this is the case in Christianity, certainly in Roman Catholicism and the Eastern Orthodox Church, is that one prays for a good death. And one tries to put all the conditions on one side for a good death, which means a death with limited pain as much as possible and a death with as much mental clarity as possible. Then generally speaking, from a Buddhist standpoint, if the person has the mental strength, it is better to die alone. Much better than to die with people around one.

It is much easier to control one’s own emotions than to control that of one’s family or friends who often are completely untrained. They can be a very limited benefit in these situations and what one wants is to be in a situation where one has and this is a matter of one’s religion. If one is a Christian, a picture of Jesus, might be a Roman Catholic, a picture of the Pope. If one is a Jewish, it might be the Torah. For a sincere Tibetan Buddhist, it might be a picture of their teacher of Je Tsongkhapa.

If they are in the Nyingma tradition, it might be a picture of Guru Padmasambhava. But it must be a teacher or a representation in whom the person has faith. Now who we have faith in is up to oneself. You are coming to a Gelug center, that doesn’t mean that all of you are connected to the Gelug tradition. But it is up to you before you die to make a strong connection, or not to do so.

Then if you don’t, you will have passed by a very, very big opportunity to control your next rebirth. And for those who die instantaneously, the issue doesn’t arise. I mean typically, it is said that they experience the solutions, but in a highly shortened state. I’m not quite sure what that means personally. Clearly with Stevenson’s research, it’s also very clear that they are the ones who tend to remember previous lives.

I mean seventy percent of the cases of spontaneous past life recollection in Stevenson’s work come from people who had violent deaths in the previous life, probably because it collapses the dissolution process. Then there are conceptual states of mind from the previous life which pass into the next state of life, which is not supposed to be really. And it’s generally not a good thing. I mean, there is very few of Stevenson’s cases of children who remember past lives who is particularly happy to have remembered their past lives. Does that go towards answering your question?

Yes. Does. Is there time for one more quick one? A very quick one. Yes.

I don’t mean this cynically, but I just wondered, given that human rebirth is hard to find, attain, how does Buddhism account for the fact that the world population is increasing? That’s a common question. Yes, it is. It’s not a very difficult one. Basically, this world is not the only world there is.

It’s only human beings who think that this planet is the only planet which is inhabited in the universe. We have billions of planets. It would be surprising if life existed only on this planet and nowhere else. So we have passages of sentient beings from other planets to this planet. I’m sure you met in school people who were extraterrestrials or seemed like them.

I did, you know. Then we have people from this world who pass, we have a teacher here, he has first hand experience, I’m sure. Then we have people from this planet who transmigrate to other planets. We have gods who transmigrate to rebirth as human beings. It’s a constant process.

And I think it’s 12 to 16. We do have to stop now. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
dhyana samten (Tib)
An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
Kagyü
The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Marpa, Milarepa, Gampopa, and their followers. One of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Cf. Nyingma, Sakya and Gelug. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
preta
Hungry ghost, or spirit. The preta realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
Tushita Ganden (Tib)
The Joyous Land. There are two Tushita realms. One is the pure land of the thousand buddhas of this eon, where the future buddha, Maitreya, and Lama Tsongkhapa reside. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Do all sentient beings go through the bardo, or only human beings?

It depends not on the type of sentient being but on the rebirth they are going to have. Beings about to be reborn in the hell realms, or in the formless realms of the gods, have no intermediate transition. A being to be reborn in the hell realms simply manifests there. Likewise, someone who has engaged in the third or fourth dhyāna and is to be reborn in the formless realms passes there immediately. There are two types of pretas: those born from the womb and those with miraculous rebirth. Those with miraculous rebirth do not pass through the bardo. Pretas born from the womb do pass through it before rebirth, as do all animals and all human beings.

What happens in the bardo if no karmically suitable rebirth is found after forty-nine days?

Normally a suitable rebirth does always happen within that time. It can happen, however, that the bardo being is reborn as a spirit, which is what we mean when we speak of ghosts. This is really a preta rebirth. Typically, through attachment to a house, a piece of land, a forest or a river, the being takes a miraculous rebirth as a preta, meaning a rebirth not from the womb. Such a being becomes the guardian of that house, river or stream. This is how the protectors of the land are reborn.

Are life force and consciousness the same as the subtle mind?

Not really. Life force is closer to the notion in modern medicine: it is the vitality of the person. Consciousness is divided into coarse consciousness and subtle consciousness. In the death process, death can be said to occur when the life force has abated, meaning the heart no longer beats and there is no EEG, and in addition the subtle consciousness at the heart has departed. This cannot be measured. Only a trained practitioner can ascertain whether the subtle consciousness is still at the heart. If it is, then from a Buddhist standpoint the body is still alive.

Is the subtle clear-light mind that transmigrates a valid cogniser, and is that what a valid cogniser is?

No. The subtle mind could be a valid cogniser, but it is not necessarily one. A cogniser is valid in the way it apprehends its object. If the subtle mind is apprehending emptiness, it would be a valid cogniser, and the first instance of that subtle mind apprehending emptiness would be a valid cogniser. Otherwise, in ordinary beings, the subtle mind probably has no definite object. So it cannot simply be called a valid cogniser.

Do we have to rely on faith in the Triple Gem to accept that complete cessation of afflictions exists?

Establishing the existence of a truth of cessation is not easy, but it can be done through reasoning. One needs to understand that the afflictions are impermanent, and be convinced of this. One also needs to understand that an affliction and its antidote are directly contradictory. Whatever increases one causes the other to decrease, so it is possible to lead an affliction to disappear. The big question is whether the disappearance is permanent. If it is permanent, it is called an abandonment, and an abandonment is a cessation. For example, the cessation of the affliction of desire means desire could never appear again. This is a difficult topic that one has to study for oneself.

If a human rebirth is so hard to attain, how does Buddhism account for the world's population increasing?

This is a common question and not a very difficult one. This world is not the only world there is. Only human beings think this planet is the only inhabited one in the universe. There are billions of planets, and it would be surprising if life existed only on this one and nowhere else. So sentient beings pass to this planet from other planets. Beings from this planet also transmigrate to other planets, and gods transmigrate to rebirth as human beings. It is a constant process, so the number of humans here can rise because beings keep moving between planets and realms.

Scroll to Top