2 h 2 min · 13,107 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 122-minute teaching, Jampa Ignyen offers a comprehensive introduction to the small scope practice of the Lam Rim, focusing on death and impermanence as foundational topics for Buddhist practitioners. Drawing on Pabongka’s classical text, he explains how reflecting on death transforms emotional habits and attachment that dominate daily life, showing how anxiety, resentment, and craving stem from forgetting our mortality. The bulk of the session walks through Pabongka’s arguments for why remembering death is essential: it prevents procrastination and superficial practice, anchors spiritual work in long-term rebirth rather than temporary worldly gain, and creates the inner conditions to work skillfully with the negative emotions. Jampa emphasises practical methods—monitoring one’s mind each day, recognising resentment and pride, loosening attachment to possessions and reputation through understanding their impermanent nature, and gradually replacing emotional reactivity with virtue. He stresses that the small scope is not beneath serious practitioners but a necessary foundation, and offers concrete guidance on balancing effort with relaxation and developing humility about one’s actual progress. Aimed at practitioners new to the Lam Rim path and those seeking to ground their study in daily emotional transformation.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Jampa Ignyen Death1.mp3
UUID: d1c8acac-26c8-4693-8233-cd5c4e6b8367
Teacher: Ven Jampa Ignyen
Collection: Death and Rebirth
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~13,104
Oh, So as, Jampa Ignyen is being wired up for sound, it is my great pleasure to welcome you on behalf of Tibetan Buddhist Institute. My name is Chris Ridley, and just a couple of housekeeping matters. For those who don’t know, the the toilets are available through the kitchen, and we’ll be having A break for lunch at 12:15. Question and answers with Jampa Ignyen at quarter to two to half past two. Afternoon tea, half past two to three.
And then the final session, three to half past four. So it’s a wonderful opportunity that we have to have Jampa Ignyen, Dr. Ian Coghlan, who is an adjunct research fellow at the School of Philosophical, Historical, and International Studies, Monash University in Melbourne, currently works as a translator for the Institute of Tibetan Classics Montreal, Canada. Holds a PhD in Asian studies and his specific interests include Buddhist metaphysics, phenomenology, hermeneutics, and psychology. He became a monk at Dharamsala, shared digs with Tenzin in Sera Je monastery, And he was a monk for twenty years. Is that right, Jampa?
Yes. Yep. And at Sera Je Monastic University in 1995. His current projects include the translation of the first book of the Compendium of Buddhist Science and Philosophy which has just been published and a forthcoming translation of Buddhapālita’s commentary on Nāgārjuna’s Fundamental Wisdom. And currently, he’s teaching at the Vajrayāna Institute in Sydney.
So we’re very fortunate to have Jampa, a senior student of our beloved Khensur Rinpoche. And so without any further ado, I will hand over to Jampa. But actually, one further ado, the the session is being recorded. And so when we have the opportunity for questions, the mic will be passed around. So if you can just hold your fire until you get the microphone, you need to have it straight, you know, up against your mouth so that then the questions and answers will be recorded.
So thank you so much. Jampa. Thanks, Chris. Might help if I turn it on. So page one verse one b, refuge and bodhicitta for teachings.
Verse two, three, and four, seven-limb prayer. And then on page five, the short mandala offering, and we do verses one and three. So we’ll be reciting the Tibetan phonetics and the Englishes on the other side of the page. So I wish to welcome everyone here for the course. So we’re dealing with these topics, death and impermanence.
So death and impermanence are an everyday reality for us. And certainly, we’re impermanent. And gradually, breath by breath, we’re approaching death. So these facts are things that we need to bring into the path itself. They’re just a fact of our existence.
We need skillful methods of reflecting on these facts. And by doing that, then these can help us. These can develop our wisdom and affect our emotional state and the way that we respond to the external world, emotionally. So this particular section falls within the small scope practice, section of the Lam Rim. And we have these three scopes, the small scope, medium scope, and the great scope.
In Tibetan, the terms are and really literally meaning a small being, a medium being, and a great being. These are all important. There’s nothing that we can leave out of these three schemes. We might be attracted to the great being practices and think that we can simply overlook the small and the medium and go straight to the really extensive, challenging, impressive practices that occur in the great scope. But really, the small scope for us is extremely important just to get an idea of what is incorporated in the small scope, what a small being’s motivation is like.
So these three scopes are really talking about our motivation, and they’re talking about how we interpret our experience, our emotional experience of the world. So when we talk about the small scope, it’s really the basic level of spiritual practice that we can engage in. Now a spiritual practice is something that, in a way, we have an idea about. And occasionally, it becomes clear to us what a spiritual practice is. But at the same time, we’re confronted by various emotional issues on a day to day basis, and often our mind is anything but spiritual.
It’s a bit unworkable. It’s a bit, swept up by other issues. And this tends to be our common experience no matter where we go, no matter who we meet on a day to day basis, everyone’s sort of dealing with their emotions. So small scope is the first step really in dealing with the emotions. Now the emotions themselves are incredibly deeply, ingrained within us.
We have all of these emotional habits and triggers and buttons. And often, in the course of our daily experience, we’re reacting to our own emotions. Something happens, we dislike something, we get a little bit annoyed, We push it to one side, but it keeps on coming back during the day. Every time it comes up, it’s a bit of a problem. It’s a little bit heavy, a little bit prickly.
On a day to day basis, that’s what we’re dealing with. Now what the small scope is aimed at doing or the purpose of it is is the beginning of the practice of being able to effectively, skillfully deal with our emotions. So how do we do that? So what are we talking about in the small scope and what comes up in the beginning of the Lam Rim in the small scope is this reflection on death and impermanence, reflecting really on our own death primarily. As the Kadampas would say, that if we don’t think about death in the morning, the morning is wasted.
If we don’t think about death at midday, the afternoon is wasted. If we don’t think about our death, our pending death, our approaching death in the evening, the whole evening is wasted. Our tendency is not we know about death intellectually, but emotionally, it’s something that we’re still confronting. We need to be able to bring the ideas that are presented in Lam Rim down to an emotional level for ourselves. So as this is often said, in this regard, the head has got to educate the heart.
We know intellectually that death is approaching. This is extremely useful for us. But if we don’t bring it down to a deeper level, if it doesn’t affect us, then it’s not so much use. Intellectual knowledge without much traction, without much use, without much benefit. It’s like when we hear of people who have a near death experience.
You know, they’re they thought they died. They passed away and were utterly convinced of the fact, really getting the idea of death onto an emotional level. And they survived somehow, they’re you know, they wake up and they’re still alive, then every day they take as precious. You read of these accounts of people. And that’s due to being able to bring the idea of death into an everyday emotional level.
So the purpose of these initial spiritual practices, that is the practices of the small scope, is so that we, bring them to a point where they affect our daily emotions. Now we just have to, you know, reflect, step back and reflect a little about what our daily emotions are. Every one of us, you know, has a complete dossier, you know, like on what our emotions are like and where what our buttons are, who pushes our buttons, who to avoid so our button buttons are not pushed, and so on. Everyone is in the same boat. Often, the way we deal with the emotions is unskillful because we often deny them, avoid them, try to distract ourselves from them.
For instance, we like to like shopping therapy is a good way of avoiding the emotions. We feel bad, so we go out and buy something. Had a terrible conversation on the phone. Okay. That’s it.
I’ll go and buy that new shirt I wanted to buy. That’s it. I’ll who cares about the credit card? I’ll buy the new car. That’ll often, the motivation for doing it is that we’re not dealing with something emotionally.
So for us, our ongoing, the work that we have day to day is just developing more skillful strategies with dealing with the old problem. So our measure of progress in the dharma is that we’re starting to deal with the emotions more effectively. But when I get annoyed, for instance, and we get annoyed and we remain annoyed for days and weeks, And we often don’t skillfully deal with this. Intellectually, we realize I shouldn’t be annoyed, but at the same almost in the same breath, we’re thinking about why we should be annoyed. And then we wonder, why do I feel so heavy?
Why, you know, am I bent over? Why am I so tensed? You know, that I might I need to go and get a massage. Why do I need a hot bath? It’s really because the emotions themselves have a physical effect.
If they didn’t, we’d be fine. If the emotions didn’t weigh us down, we’d be in a pretty good state. We’d probably be happy most of the time.
Carefree, contented. What stops us being contented, is those unskillful emotions, our indulgence in them, our regret for indulging in them, our awareness that they’re nonvirtuous, our awareness that our nonvirtue is accumulating. That also weighs heavily upon us. So all of these things, all of the negative emotions, the physical stress, and then also the that stress that builds up day by day causes us physical ailments. We’re susceptible to getting coming down with the flu.
Who knows what other, you know, more serious ailments arise. If we trace their causal sources back to their roots, we come up with the three poisons. So much of our the coalface for us, where the work lies for us, is the emotional states. Now, of the emotional states that we experience, the positive ones are not a problem. Love, compassion, patience, effort, taking joy and virtue, and so on.
All of these, they’re emotions. They move the mind. They mix with the mind, but they’re light. They’re not really you know, we don’t have a problem if we’re walking down the street and suddenly we’re overcome with love for the all these strangers we see. That’s not a problem for us.
It doesn’t weigh us down. In fact, if it happens, sometimes it may happen, actually, it’s a very light feeling, and we know immediately that it’s good for us. It doesn’t tense us up. What tenses us up is the the other emotions. So there, in a way, in the beginning of this entire project of looking at, for instance, Lam Rim is working out what the problem is, what the you know, just every day, what’s the small problems that I can start to deal with?
So the small scope practice is good for us because this is like the small lead in where we can actually engage in ourselves. Little bit by little bit. Little victory by little victory. We’d all love to be the great, you know, practitioners, full of compassion at all times. And we probably have this aspiration, and we need this aspiration.
But on the ground, the reality on the ground is that we’ve got a fair way to go yet. We’ve got lots of small issues that we’re not resolving very well in the present. But on the other hand, there are various things that we’re also doing reasonably well. So we need a bit of a, we need the capacity to encourage ourselves in our practice, be content with our practice, and then know when to put effort in so that we do develop as individuals. By developing as an individual, then we can gradually put ourselves into a position where we can be more of more benefit in the society in which we live amongst the people we meet.
I mean, we see this all the time. If someone you know, like, if we happen to be in a walking down the street and there’s an argument occurring And we think, oh, we can see where this argument is going. You know, they’re getting they’re revving each other up. They’re, you know, pushing each other’s buttons. And then if someone just takes the alternate tack, oh, this is stupid.
Yeah. Why are we arguing? There’s no reason, no ground here. Let’s stop it. Stupid.
You know, something like that helps us, helps everyone around. If an alternate alternative to following the negative emotions exists, then we have to look at it seriously, all the time. So this skillful way of dealing with the emotions is really the field of mind training, lojong. In Tibetan, lojong. Jong there means to train or to purify purify the mind.
So we don’t have any lack of opportunity to purify the mind or train the mind. Even if we look at our mind in a present state and ask ourselves what state are we in at present? Is it virtuous? Is it neutral or is it non virtuous? And we should ask this question a lot.
Then that’s good for us. We can just check. And if there’s an issue there, I’m annoyed about something, then we should deal with that immediately. Why am I annoyed with that person? Why am I annoyed with this?
Or why am I impatient about that? Or if there’s a residue of resentment in my mind stream at present. We go, oh, what is it? Oh, so I have this thing with this person, my relative, my partner, my children, and so on. There’s a slight ongoing resentment there.
And we often bump our noses against this, see what’s there. Then, as Śāntideva says, we’ll treat the mind like a stick of wood. Don’t do anything. Don’t act with that resentment in place. Either we just don’t act on it or, if possible, we apply the antidotes.
Remembering to apply the antidotes is also one of our ongoing tasks. We need to push ourselves to apply antidotes so that we overcome these emotional issues that have arise from time to time. Basically, what we want is our mind to be flexible, comfortable, clear, not heavy, light, pliable. Enjoy the bliss of pliancy. The mind in its present in the present should be quite blissful.
Very light, easy to generate virtue, easy to generate compassion. We think about other beings. Compassion should be there almost automatically. Our mind should be in an optimum state. It’s very good for us.
And if it’s good for us, then it helps other people around us. We come across people that are in a good space. It helps us. We sort of once his holiness was in France, and he visited this Christian monastery. And he walked around the monastery, and there were some prayers done and so forth.
And and he mentioned that he came across this one monk, and when this he was near to this monk, he felt himself leaning towards him for some reason. And later, he had the opportunity to ask, you know, what is your practice? And this monk says, oh, my main main practice is love. I contemplate love. I’ve been doing so for many years.
So an excellent practice. So instead of us entertaining all these other emotional problems and quandaries and sort of heavier thoughts, If we were to practice contemplating love after breakfast, okay, today I’ll just concentrate on that. I’ll just focus on thinking about love for all sentient beings. And I’ve got to hold to that thought, and I’ll start practicing it. Any other thoughts that come up, oh, well, I’ll put them off.
Like, I’ll think about them later. So just contemplating in this way is very good for us. And being good for us, it’s good for those around us. Right. So we’ll start with something of the Lam Rim text itself.
Now, what I’m doing here is just looking at the small scope practice of Lam Rim, and I’m using Pabongka’s text. This text was actually given in 1921 in Lhasa, and it was given to a group of mainly monks and nuns at 3,000. And he was going to give this large initiation. And so a lot of the early part of the text is to do with guru devotion, and which is a necessary element of the mantric vehicle. So but then he moves on to the three scopes.
So we’re looking at the first scope again. Small scope. So we shouldn’t think small scope means a small practice. Something that we’ve probably gone beyond now. We’re not at that level any longer.
We’re at least intermediate, if not the great level. But actually, this small is actually, we’re really there at that small scope level. So small scope level, in brief, is the idea of practicing in the present to attain a human rebirth in our next life. So engaging in the practice of the 10 virtues in order to attain a human rebirth. So putting to put it in a very brief now this we need because at present, we’re not too sure of our future rebirth.
There’s no guarantee. We don’t have a signed document anywhere. We don’t have a warranty. We don’t have anything that is going to guarantee where we’re gonna be reborn in future. We may even have doubt about some deep seated doubts about rebirth itself.
Rebirth itself is based on the entire the field of inner causation. We’re convinced of external causation. We can see that apple tree grows from an apple seed, that, you know, cooked food comes from putting it on a stove in a pot. You know, we age, our physical body ages, and we can see this is a causal process and so on. But the internal, now here meaning the mind itself, also is completely governed by the laws of causation.
The mind itself, how it exists in the present moment is completely due to causes and conditions that we’ve put in place. Present moment and the previous moment and so forth, going back for many days, weeks, months, years. Not only years, but decades. Not only decades, but even into our previous life. And in fact, the proof one of the proofs for rebirth is the fact that the mind always has a substantial cause and always has a substantial result.
It has a con continuum. Just as the present mind automatically just leads to the next mind, to the next, to the next. We don’t have to put any effort into this process. Our mind continues. And for that reason, it’s said that the mind is beginningless and the mind is endless.
So therefore, rebirth. So the idea of the small scope here is that rebirth does occur due to the laws of causation that completely determine the state of our mind in the present moment. Everything is there due to a cause. Nothing more nor less than the causes that we’ve put in place ourselves. We are the creator of the mind we have in the present moment.
Now it’s said in Lam Rim that look at our present mind. You know, everything all the virtue that’s there is due to the kindness of others. All the non virtue there is due to our own hard work. All the problems we’ve actually managed to, create ourselves. But all anything that’s beneficial is coming from other beings.
And if we think about that, we can often get a little bit, well, wait a minute. Surely, there’s something good coming from me. That thought will arise for us. But as it’s said in the perfection of wisdom sutras, as it’s said in Abhisamayālamkāra in the commentaries to the eighth chapter of the, what, ornament of realization. The enlightened activities of a Buddha give rise to the virtue in one’s own mind stream.
The virtue that we have comes from the inspiration of other beings. It comes from the the compassion that arises in the mindstreams of others. So, for that reason, others are extremely kind to us. So then we look at our our mind stream in the small scope practices, and what comes up is this idea of death, that death is approaching. And really, death is one of the four major sufferings of a human being, and that our death is really something that’s caused by ourselves.
The Buddha initially sought the deathless state when he left the palace and renounced the palace, renounced the kingdom, and so forth. And his goal was to find, if possible, a state beyond death in which death did not have a toehold. It lay beyond this great, issue that we face. So it really reflects the purity of his aspiration at that time, that he could really see the problem so clearly. We can’t see the problem of death very clearly.
At times, we think, oh, death is gonna be a relief for us. It’ll get beyond our emotional issues. Many people in our society have this thought that, oh, death, may it come sooner? I can put the load to one side. I can the emotional emotional issues that I experience, I’ll be able to put down.
But death itself is not necessarily the resolution of our our situation. What did Hamlet say? To dream, to sleep per chance to dream. It’s really that. We have this opportunity at present to start to deal with the bigger issues.
Will death solve them for us? It’s something we need to think about. So in the small scope, one is thinking about death a lot. Not in a negative sense, but in the sense of, let me use that to start to deal with my emotions in the present moment. So this is an extremely skillful way to practice, recalling death all the time.
I must die at some point. Let me use this time well. Let me use it for the practice of virtue. If I’m not employing my mind in the practice of virtue at the present moment, I’m wasting my time. If I’m collecting nonvirtue in the present moment, who is gonna have to pay for this?
Where is it gonna manifest? Where’s the result of that nonvirtue going to blossom? So by thinking of death, we’re thinking of the precious time we have and to use that in the best possible way. By doing that, it help helps us to approach death with less regret because the regret comes from wasting our time. Often you hear of this, people that get to the end of their life and, you know, and what regrets they have.
And
Often the regrets are, you know, not spending the time they have more productively, not just making money, but using it, to help train the mind, to purify the mind. Of what? Of the negative emotions. So thinking of death can just make us step back from saying that thing that is gonna make us regret saying it. We got a lot of stuff to purify.
We got a lot of regrets sort of floating around in our mind stream. The things that we should have done that we didn’t do, either because we were too shy or weren’t brave enough or, you know, we’re in a bad mood at the time. We have, you know, a dozen excuses, a 100 reasons why we allow ourselves to do things that we really shouldn’t do or think in in a way that we shouldn’t think. So death is something that is going to help us. Whenever we think of death, we can think, what is my state of mind in the present?
Death is approaching. My mind should be virtuous. Death is coming. I have to meet death with virtue. I have to go through the death process with a virtuous state of mind.
I might die in one minute. What’s my mind like at the present? Am I gonna have regret if I his current mind is what’s manifest at the time of death? So thinking of death is a bit like the stick approach. As the Buddha once said, a good horse runs at even the shadow of a whip.
So the shadow of a whip is a bit like the thought of death. We know we’re going to die. I am going to die. We get so distracted, though, we put it off. It’s all on the back burner.
But in the small scope practice, no more back burner. We have to start practicing. So practice means current moment. What is my mind? What state is my mind in?
Okay. So we’ll just look a little bit at Pabongka’s text. Okay. So in the beginning, he says, what I’m stating here is not false. It’s not invented Dharma, not some invented method that one can use, because it is the pith of the authentic oral teaching.
So he’s talking about the Lam Rim itself. This is not foolish talk. It’s not something that we can discard easily because it comes from the classical texts. It comes from an authentic source that is that constitute the words of great, courageous beings who’ve taken on this practice. It is not a shimmering mirage because saintly scholars and adepts have experienced it.
This is not a perilous cliff because it is the highway to the highest enlightenment. And then he goes on to say that between our meditations, we should mainly read books that teach about the optimum human rebirth, that our current rebirth, that we’ve actually discovered this opportunity. So we have to rejoice in this opportunity. If after thinking about the difficulty of obtaining this most beneficial human rebirth, you develop a wish to extract some benefit from it, you should train your mind. Through the three scopes of the Lam Rim.
So this is the practice. This is the three scopes. The extent to which you train your mind on these three scopes determines how much of the small, medium, and great scope essence you will eventually extract. So what benefit we extract depends on, the level that we’re training the mind. If we want to achieve buddhahood, we must first develop realization into the earlier sections of the path.
If not, we will not develop realization into the latter parts. So we have to start from the beginning with patience and do it small step by small step, incrementally small step by small step. Because every the small authentic step that we do manage to take, we will really rejoice in that. Because we’ll see that, ah, yes, I have did achieve something there. That really bad habit I had, you know, I’ve now it doesn’t arise very often.
When it does, I manage to. So getting that sort of having that experience is important. So then Pabongka talks about, for example, Khampa pilgrims coming to see the Śākyamūni Buddha statue in Lhasa Cathedral leave first their homes and then arriving finally at the statue after months and months of work. The road leads there bit by bit. They actually have to walk out their front door to start.
It is impossible for them to skip any part of the way. So we can’t step out the door and just then arrive at Lhasa from the Far Eastern region of Kham. So nor can you develop realization into such higher paths of the path as compassion, higher parts of the path such as compassion and so on. So really developing fully established bodhicitta and so forth until you achieve the lower parts. So it needs this incremental bit by bit, small step by small step approach.
As it said in Bodhicaryāvatāra, if you have not even dreamed of benefiting yourself before dreaming of this for sentient beings, how could you be of benefit to others? So if we cannot even taste a small level of benefit for ourselves, how are we able to then wish that for others? We have to engage in this practice, in this Dharma practice ourselves and start to gain a taste of the experience. So getting a taste of the experience in a way is like seeing that our mind is being affected. It and that effect is weaning us away from the negative emotions, our addiction to the negative emotions.
So he goes on then to say, here we speak of small and medium scope practices. We mean training in the training the mind in the stages of the path shared with the small and the medium scopes. So when we’re looking at this, here, the small scope and the reflection on death and impermanence, we’re doing it by having this aspiration of great compassion, the aspiration that we eventually generate great compassion in our mind streams. So then he goes on to say, the small and the medium sections of the Lam Rim, you must focus on achieving Buddhahood for the sake of sentient beings. Developing bodhicitta is the actual practice, of the small and the medium scope parts of the path.
The small scope is a preliminary to developing bodhicitta. So even though the small scope one is not directly focusing on bodhicitta, bodhicitta is part of the motivation for practicing the small scope. In way, we are practicing it. So as he goes on to say, there are people who cannot train their minds in the small in the great scope initially, so they need to practice in stages for people with good mediocre or inferior minds. So we as practitioners, we all have our own capacity.
And it’s good that we recognize what our capacity is. Some of those around us have great capacity for practice. Some of us have less capacity, and some have small capacity due to various things, our family commitments, our work, and so on. And so it’s not easy for us to sit down and have the leisure to read a text or do a little meditation and so on. But that’s fine.
We need to keep in mind, just where we are, what time we have available, develop the aspiration to eventually be able to do a retreat, and spend some months on these practices, years, in fact. But that will come later, just like a ripe fruit falling from a tree. First, the fruit has got to ripen. Prior to the fruit ripening, the fruit itself goes through various stages. You know, when a first flower emerges, then the little fruit is there, and then it gets bigger and bigger, we have this little green fruit there.
Now at present, our practice is probably at that stage. It’s just like a a green fruit. It’s still got to mature. How it matures is through practice. The mind stream matures through aspiring to generate wisdom and compassion.
Having that aspiration there matures the mind. Now present, our mind is not so mature. Why? Because we’re immersed in the moisture, immersed in the water of attachment, ignorance, hatred, anger, so forth. There’s one stage the Buddha talks about, there being like green wood and how you actually can start a fire with wood.
And he talks about you know, he’s talking to the monks and he talks about if there was a green branch from a sapling that had been cut up and it was resting in water, it was lying in the water, would anyone try and use that bit of wood in order to start a fire? You know, in the old method, of course, you know, you’ve got a know, you maybe got a bow with some string and you’ve got a bit of If you cut that green sapling out of the stream and tried to start fire with that, you wouldn’t be able to do it. First, you have to take the sapling, that green bit of wood, and you have to put it on dry land, and you leave it there and let it dry out. But just letting it dry out from being in the water is gonna take some time. Then once the water itself has dried off, then the branch itself has got to mature.
The inside has got to not just the outside has got to dry out. The inside has got to dry out. Right? Then once the once that wood is really dry, then you can use it to light fire. True?
Now that’s a bit like us. Present, our mind is like a green fruit immersed in water. The water is the objects of the senses, the objects of our attachment around us. Our mind naturally goes to objects of attachment and engages them and, almost without resistance. Gets caught up with objects of attachment.
Our mind is immersed in attachment, and it engages objects of attachment quite freely. Is this true? So our mind is a bit like that. So we have to actually get the fruit or the bit of green sapling and take it out of the water. We’ve got to remove our mind from the objects of the senses.
Right? So the mind starts to mature a little bit. So it’s not we’re not completely captivated every time we see an ad on TV or, you know, objects of sense like food or we start to lessen our attachment. It’s a strong attachment we have for objects. Then when that happens, when one is able to start to develop detachment from objects and start to develop a sort of beginning of renunciation, then also, then the mind, the internal mind starts to minimize the three poisons.
Attachment itself starts to subside. That helps the subsidence of ignorance and attach and hatred, anger, the three main poisons. So when that comes about, it’s possible to ignite the fire of liberation. Now present, it’s difficult for us to generate renunciation because we’re so immersed in the objects of the senses around us day in, day out. And it doesn’t help that if we watch TV, there’s ads, you know, like, in our face all the time telling us, buy this.
We need this to be happy. We can’t really be contented unless we have this object or that object. So all of that we need to just watch, watch ourselves, and watch our attachment. So we need to mature the mind in the present so that the the mind is gradually able to let go of these deep seated emotional states that we and everyone around us has. So this process is, again, called mind mind training.
So Pabongka says, without some familiarity with the earlier parts of the path, with how to begin to train the mind, you will have no renunciation. We it’s hard for us to develop renunciation at all in our mind stream. So we need to defeat in the beginning any pride we may have about being a Mahāyānist, follower of the great deep practices of the great vehicle. We have to become simpler as beings. We need to maintain the aspiration to be a great practitioner, but at present, we’ve got a long way to go.
We’re still at the small scope level of practice that, we need to start to implement. Basically, for us, in order to practice, we have to more and more clearly understand exactly where we are in our practice. And what are the faults? What are the main faults that we have as individuals that we’ve got to start applying the antidotes to? But for us, general, we can say attachment is an issue we have to deal with.
And then the others as well. Ignorance is the deepest. It’s going to be the problem that we really need a long term strategy for. In the meantime, we can start to address the antidotes to attachment and aversion. So we have plenty of material to work with in our own mind stream.
In fact, we don’t even need any new experiences. We could go and live in a cave at present, and we’re just all the memories of our experiences would be enough. But we’re not at that stage yet because we need training in order to get to that stage. So Pabongka is here talking about this. So he mentions to develop bodhicitta, which is the actual practice, you need to develop such compassion that you simply cannot bear others being tormented by suffering.
But in order to develop this compassion, you must know exactly how you yourself are plagued by suffering. And you must understand that the whole of saṃsāra is by nature’s suffering. But first, you must fear the lower realms to even so this is the standard advice in Lam Rim. For without this, you will have no repudiation, no renunciation of celestial or human happiness. You must therefore train your mind in the small, medium, and great scope, paths by first understanding the small and the medium scopes.
So this this training is like the foundation that supports a house. Now for us at present, we’re attached to so many things that even talking about attachment can be painful. That it’s you know, we can talk about it a little bit. If we talk too much, we get sick of it, then it starts to the ears start to hurt, I think, Because there’s so many things we’re attached to. And if if we don’t have those object
So if we don’t have the possibility of gaining them, then we’re not really happy. So we have to, therefore, work at the level that we’re at at present. I think gradually, then improvement will will come about. The great antidote to our attachment is to skillfully observe the faults in the objects of attachment. Anything we’re attached to will at least have a a fault there.
So we need to think of these. That will help us lessen our attachment. That shiny new car actually has many faults. We probably think, oh, no, it doesn’t have any faults. Anyway, it’s got a seven year guarantee, a seven year warranty, so I don’t care what faults it has.
Actually, the faults are more deep seated. It’s a contaminated object. It’s it’s completely contaminated because its causes are born from the three poisons. Now we might think, oh, that’s a bit esoteric. You know?
I’m just buying a car, you know? But the fact is that at our level, there’s nothing all the objects around us, there’s nothing pure. There’s nothing really pure there, nothing worth being attached to. Even our own physical body, which we know pretty well, as we’ve had it for a long time. We’re quite attached to it, but it’s so full of faults, and we often disguise the faults that it has.
It’s impure. It’s just, you know, like, keeps on leaking these substances, sweat, so forth. We gotta keep washing it. We gotta keep dressing it up. Otherwise, people will avoid us.
Our own physical body is not not really a suitable object of attachment. But a lot of our attachment is really strongly influenced by ignorance because we don’t examine carefully, the object itself. And we still may think that, wait a minute, that shiny new car doesn’t have any faults, so what’s wrong with being attached to it? The trouble is that it’s susceptible to decay. Already, probably, the rust is starting to enter these on a minute level.
You know? They didn’t paint it, you know, really properly everywhere. So it’s already starting to rust out here and there. And it’s probably got a little fault in the engine somewhere that they didn’t detect. And the gearbox maybe has only got 10,000 k in it.
When we start to look at it, the more and more we start to see faults. Same with the house. The house is actually cracks in it. There’s all sorts of minor faults with. You know, the house that we’re living in or that we just bought.
So the more we think of the reality of these objects, the less our attachment it harms our attachment to them. We’re not endeavoring to minimize our attachment in order to stop us having fun or enjoying things around us. We need to have a level of worldly enjoyment. But we also need to be aware of the facts of the world around us and the danger of attachment, being overly attached. Because lessening our attachment will help us with our practice, and it will give us more and more contentment.
In a sense, that’s why monks and nuns have few objects, possessions. Because the more possessions we have, the more the heavier the burden becomes. It only becomes heavy because of attachment. It’s the attachment that weighs weighs on us. So in the small scope, we’re looking at these issues.
We’re looking at death for ourselves. It helps us to have less attachment for our own physical body. And, also, impermanence helps us. We understand things around us are impermanent, changing moment by moment, decaying moment by moment, disintegrating moment by moment, that we’re not so swept away by attachment for these things. So in the beginning of our practice, in the small scope, we’re looking at this.
We’re looking at our death and the impermanent nature of the objects around us and the fact that they are being destroyed moment by moment. They don’t endure. They’re not fixed. This is not to stop us from having finding pleasure in the world. This is not the purpose of this type of reflection.
The purpose of this reflection is to start to oppose attachment because the attachment is the great engine of saṃsāra. And we return to saṃsāra all the time through our attachment to existing. But as much as possible, we need to reflect on these issues with the objects around us. So then Pabongka also talks about being farsighted from the beginning. So in our practice, we need, from the very beginning, to really look not just to, you know, tomorrow or one month, one year, ten years in front, not just our life ending, but then our next life.
Keep our mind on that. We must be farsighted from the beginning. You must feel I am prepared to use my entire human life to pursue just one meditation topic of the Lam Rim. So even if we spent one our entire time thinking about overcoming attachment, for instance, that would be very useful. Instead, we tend to be farsighted in human, worldly things, which is the wrong way around.
We lack persistence in worldly things. We should lack persistence in worldly things, not in the dharma. Now currently, we have a great deal of persistence in worldly things and not much effort put towards the Dharma itself, we should reverse that. We put most of our effort into the Dharma and less effort into worldly things. If we feel it’s impossible not to achieve anything in the Dharma and practice with courage, you will not have to spend a month or a year on a single meditation topic.
Now here, of course, he’s talking to an audience of monks and nuns who more leisure in their practice than we as laypeople have. But if we have the aspiration that, okay, I can achieve insight into the nature of Dharma, and it’s possible for me to gain this level of insight, and we practice with courage by applying our time successfully, with effort, with a sense of great courage, then our practice will proceed more quickly. As one Geshe Kamapa said, we say our contemplations achieve nothing. Why do you think this? Don’t lie.
You are distracted in the daytime and fall asleep at night. So for us also, our practice tends to be distracted. So if possible, we should minimize our distractions because often when we’re distracted, we don’t enjoy being distracted. We just get distracted. And when we practice, we should try and apply ourselves with enthusiasm and keeping our mind on the topic.
You know, often we sit down and do our practices, and we start we read through the first verse, and then we’re off thinking about something for five minutes. And, oh, where did I stop? Wait a minute. I’m back here. And I do the second verse, and the same thing happens.
And, you know, we could do our prayers in ten minutes, but it might take us twenty twenty minutes or twenty five minutes because we’re thinking about all this other stuff, the shopping list. Oh, that’s right. I gotta do this. I gotta do that. So important for us when we’re practicing to really focus, as well as we can, keep our mind on topic, check on our motivation and so on.
Have a good, strong, virtuous motivation to begin with. And then put our feet up and just do a little meditation. Just relax at that stage. So we need a good blend of, effort but being relaxed. So this issue is not just something that we face.
Everyone faces it. Even the great practitioners face just this problem, being a bit distracted and caught up in emotional issues and the mind not really being very focused. But at the same time, with that in mind, we need to be able to do as well as we can and rejoice in the practice we do. As Pabongka then goes on to say, We don’t make a determined practice our starting point, yet we roll our eyes at the top of the head and pretend to meditate when we do just one recitation of, for example, Tsongkhapa’s Basis of All Good Qualities. If we act in this way, our wish to develop insights and realizations into the Lam Rim is an extremely greedy one.
This is where the fault lies. So if our practice is really associated with attachment, you know, we have we can all already see the shingle great meditator being placed on our door or something like that, then it’s not good for us. We need a lot of humility in our practice, in other words. Because our practice is not that, you know, not that good. I mean, it may have highlights.
You know, we might have selection of the five best meditations of the year. We might even put it on our web page, you know, with photos and sitting there, you know, looking very virtuous and concentrated. But at the same time, have to develop humility. This ability to just be aware of what our practice actually is, not adding anything to it. And, of course, all of that then deals with our pride.
And as human beings, pride is one of the big ongoing, things that we we confront. Of course, is one of the five poisons. Pride and jealousy make up the other three. The root poisons, which are ignorance we’ve got. Huge amount of ignorance we have.
And then on on the base of that ignorance, have attachment, greed. And then we have hatred, anger. And then we have pride, and then we have jealousy. Pride itself, which is an inflated sense of our own ability, our level of practice, is no good for us, of course. So we need to take away the rose colored glasses that we have and just see the bare fact of our own meditation practice, See the bare facts of just how virtuous is my mind?
How am I doing on a day to day basis? Does my mind become virtuous? And if so, when? And, of course, the story of that one Geshe who used to have those pebbles on his table. He had a whole series.
We should probably do the same thing. It’s an excellent piece of advice. One set of white pebbles, one set of black. And every time when we’re seated there, a negative thought comes up, we take out the black pebble and we put it, you know, into, like, today’s activity pile. And then at the end of the day, we see what’s in the today’s activity pile.
And for him, that practice was very useful because at the end of the day, he could see just, okay, where are the majority of my thoughts? So by then realizing the danger of having so many negative thoughts on a daily basis, because death is approaching, then this helps us to actually stop thinking in a negative way about others, stop resenting others. This resentment is sort of and if we stop and look, we often find resentment there to this, to that. I resent the situation. I mean, I resent work.
I resent play. I resent you know, we have this. All of that is bad for us, utterly useless, just harms us. As I said, it’s like us drinking poison and then thinking I’m gonna harm someone else or resenting someone else but drinking poison. Because when we resent, the poison is manifesting in our mind stream.
It’s right there in the center of our heart. And that that the resentment then affects the mind itself, and then it creates creates the tendency to then get annoyed. From that resentment, annoyance can arise. We start listing all the faults of that person. We already listed these that person’s fault, you know, quite we’re so well rehearsed in the faults of that person.
We think of one, and we’ve got a dozen others that come up. And then beyond that, there’s another 50. And then all the incidents where we can recall they did this, they did that, they did that again. We’re like masters at the art of developing resentment. But all of it’s bad for us.
It’s always down on the mind. It makes the mind unclear, makes the mind unworkable. The mind then becomes heavy, And we wonder why is the mind so heavy. Not only that it physically affects us, we tense up. We think about the person.
We tense up, and the tension goes into our shoulders and then into our neck. And we wonder, my neck at the end of the day, I can hardly move it. Why? We because of the ignorance we have, we don’t even realize why. Instead, we tend to think, oh, that other person.
Yeah. They’re the cause. I’m feeling so bad because of them. And we blame them even more. So and so we have this strong tendency to affirm our habitual patterns concerning the emotions.
So this is something that we need to remind ourselves to be mindful of. Just be mindful. When when these emotions arise, just look at the emotion without acting on it, if we can. We just stop it and look at it. It’s almost like a feeling, a negative feeling towards a person.
It’s sort of with a little bit of an edge to it. Like, it’s gonna harm it wants to harm. So therefore, it’s nonvirtuous. Any harm, any thought to harm is always nonvirtuous. So if we detect that, even though it might be quite subtle, oh, next time I meet them, I’m gonna turn the other way.
I won’t even talk to them. So it’s like harming them by not talking to them. So on. Right. So
In these small scope practices in the beginning, we’re starting to deal with the ethical issue of not engaging in the 10 non virtues. Why are we not engaging in the 10 non virtues? Because they produce rebirth, not as a human re human being. All of that resentment is not gonna help me become a human being in future. None of it.
Not one moment of it. And all the hours I’ve invested in maintaining it all goes against me. And it doesn’t even harm that person. It’s sort of an odd situation to be in. Would I put up with this?
In a way, we put up with it perhaps because we think it will harm that other person. That’s terrible. That’s appalling. Actually, our standards have declined. Our standard of behavior is not as good as it should be.
In fact, if our thoughts were revealed to other beings, you know, completely, we’d be appalled. We’d be although all the Buddhas, the three times and 10 directions, see all of our thoughts. And if they see any even a slight measure of improvement is probably brings a glow to them. They see that in us. Just like a mother, if they see a slight improvement in their child through the mother giving instruction, again and again, don’t do that.
Then finally, the child, oh, okay. You’re right. I shouldn’t do that. And the mother is overjoyed. Wonderful.
So do the Buddhas in the if they see that we’re finally dealing with some deep seated emotional issue that we have and we’re starting to take the bull by the horn, so to speak, and okay. I’m not gonna do that anymore. Then It’s said that the Buddhas rejoice in that sort of progress from our side. So this is what we’re doing at present. We’re trying to practice the 10 virtuous actions and not practice the 10 non virtuous actions.
So in the 10 non virtuous actions, we have the three poisons. And then by implication, all the negative emotions that are born of those three poisons. Right. So also, Pabongka goes on to say that, a Kadampa master, said, look far ahead. Be farsighted.
Be in tune. So be farsighted. Our practice has to be farsighted. So we’re looking beyond death. We’re looking at death.
We’re looking even beyond our death. So looking beyond our current death is being farsighted. Just looking at what am I gonna be in my next life and realizing that I have to put in place the causes for that now. This is being farsighted. Be in tune.
Being in tune with a goal of being human in future. But that’s not to say that even if we don’t know anything of Lam Rim, that a person may not be reborn as a human in their next life because of having a basic sense of ethics. That’s wonderful. And many people have this basic level of ethics that prevents them from doing many non virtuous actions. They feel uncomfortable about doing this or doing that.
That’s a sign of inborn wisdom. So as wisdom developed in the past that remains in one’s mind stream, that helps to direct one’s activity one’s activities in this life. So we just have a feeling, oh, I shouldn’t do this. That’s we don’t necessarily know why we shouldn’t. So that’s wonderful.
We need to tap into that all the time. But on top of that, we also see that we’ve got issues with the emotions that we’re not dealing very well with. So this is where dealing with starting to overcome these emotions is going to require us being farsighted. We can’t now just think only of this life. If we only think of this life, we’re not gonna be able to get rid of those negative emotions.
We have to start thinking about our next life all the time. So it’s a small scope practice. Where am I going to be in a hundred years? What state am I going to be in? What state do I want to be in?
So then Pabongka goes on to say, these three things are vital. That is looking far ahead, being farsighted, being in tune. The meaning is that you must look far ahead to the goal of omniscience. Be farsighted about the small and the medium scopes. And meditate to reach the right pitch or tension.
Being skilled in one’s practice so one knows how far one can push oneself. One’s capacity, how much can one bear? And when one’s got to relax and put one’s feet up and put something on TV and just veg out and watch it, but do so mindfully. We have to do what we like doing as well. Because if we like playing cricket, well, we stick with cricket.
If we like bowling, 10 pin bowling, It’s okay. At times, we need to do things we like to do so we can relax. We have to be easy on ourselves. We have to know what we enjoy doing and do them, but mindfully. Do them without letting us be, you know, unskillful.
We do them while practicing while practicing the opponents to the nonvirtuous negative states of the afflictions. So then he says, your practice, too, should be at the right pitch. When you receive Dharma orally from your guru and then practice frantically for a few days with superficial renunciation, this is a sure sign that you will make no progress. So here, we’re a bit more like the tortoise than the hare. Although we might want to be the hare, it’s actually the tortoise that that won the race.
There’s a great lesson in that for us, just a little bit every day. You know, just five minutes good meditation where we really focus on, you know, getting a pure motivation together. Very good. Then we can have an hour off, half a day off. We have to be able to relax And, we need that physically, actually, because we often we tense up so much due to the negative emotions that we have.
We have to exercise ourselves. We have to stretch and do yoga. We have to do running. And this helps the body to disperse that tension. So we have to be very skilled in this way.
So then Pabongka moves on to the heading of how we extract the essence from our optimum human rebirth. So training our mind in the small scope. So then training the mind in the small scope, develop a yearning for good rebirth, teaching the means for happiness. So good rebirth, thinking about a good rebirth requires remembering that our present rebirth will not last long and that we will die. Thinking about what sorts of happiness or suffering you will have in your next rebirth in either this or the other types of rebirth that are possible.
So the drawbacks of not remembering death and so on. So the drawbacks of not remembering death. So thinking of death and impermanence. First, death. So death is the gross level of impermanence, and it manifests because of the subtle impermanence.
So what constitutes our mind body is all impermanent on a very subtle level, meaning it doesn’t endure for a moment. It says that it takes seven years for the cells to be, what, regenerated. But, actually, none of those cells even remains for a moment. They’re continuously their arrival is their destruction. We tend to think the body is fixed.
It hasn’t hasn’t changed from the morning. It’s still pretty much as it was in the in the morning. We have a very strong sense that the body is not changing moment to moment. The table is not changing moment to moment. Still the same table or this tablecloth is still the same tablecloth that was here this morning or that was here half an hour ago.
Completely different. Completely changed. It’s still a tablecloth, but it’s not the one that was put there before. True? If we look at it from an atomic point of view, it’s composed of atoms, the cells of the cotton or whatever themselves composed of atoms and molecules, molecules composed of atoms, the atoms.
Each of those has a nucleus and electrons and so forth. All of those particles are in a state of constant motion. So this is really what subtle impermanence is about. We can’t see it. We look at it with our eyes.
It all looks as if it’s not changing. But, really, everything is changing on a subtle level. Because of that, things change on a coarse level. Because we our physical body and the mind itself change all the time, then they can also change on a coarse level. And so death.
Death is really our physical body no longer can support our consciousness for one reason or another. So this is something, that we face. As Pabongka says, if we don’t recollect death, you would only think about this life. So that’s just how it is. We don’t think about death or only thinking of this life.
We get caught up in its many demands, food, clothes, and so on. And thus, we don’t practice Dharma. If you recollect death well, you will work hard to prepare for your next lives. Just as a kadampa about to go in on a journey would work only at preparing and packing. So if we had to go on a long journey, we’d have our bags packed because we might be on call.
You know? They say we’re gonna be there. We’re not exactly sure when. So we’d have our bags packed, ready to go. So our bags being packed, meaning we’ve prepared lots of virtue.
We’ve stored in our suitcases vast amount of root virtue so that we can take with us. On the other hand, if we have a vast amount of non virtue that we’re taking with us, no use to us at all. But if we’re gonna go on a long journey, we pack our bags, and we take what we what we have available to take, which is our karma. But then Pabongka goes on to say, your enormous craving for food, fashion, reputation, and so on can be blamed on your not remembering impermanence. So we have this craving for food, nice food.
We have our own favorite foods, and we’re willing then to go on to new foods. And we have this attachment to the food, attachment to the taste, to the texture, to the smell, to the setting, so on, all of these attachments we have. And fashion. We’re attached to fashion. We never wear anything quite out because it goes out of fashion before we wear it out.
And so then we have to recycle it, maybe sell it on eBay if we can get anything for it, or otherwise, give it to Vinnies. We have craving for our reputation. So we do have a craving for reputation to be well known. Maybe a celebrity, be on TV, people ringing me wanting to know my opinions about this and that. You know, name appearing in the papers, and we can collect all the newspaper clippings.
Or we have a Facebook page with 200,000 followers. 500,000 followers. And we tweet and, you know, our tweet messages go out throughout the world. People even read them. But we have this attachment to these things, food, fashion, reputation.
All of this attachment comes about because we forget about impermanence. Every day that passes without recalling impermanence is a day of our life that’s wasted. We’ve wasted a day if we don’t remember impermanence. These ideas go against our strong attachment. Good.
That’s the whole intention is that we start to lessen our attachment, whatever the attachment is. And why? Because we’re gonna die. That if we didn’t have to face death, things would be different for us. So remembering death.
So by remembering death, then we start to apply these opponents to the eight worldly dharmas, such as reputation, gain and loss, praise and blame, reputation, ill repute, or taking joy in having all of those negative things, like taking joy in having a property here or property there, having taking joyful about being in fashion, you know, being able to walk down the street and, oh, I’m wearing the latesteacher. I’m wearing the latest shoes. And, you know, looking at ourselves in the street, you know, in in the windows, you know, they don’t look too bad, you know, so forth. And we’re attached. It’s just a sign of, like, complete attachment to the object And thinking that that’s a free that’s quite fault free if we do that.
But, actually, underlying it is this attachment to stuff. And we know that very thing that we’re rejoicing in is gonna go to Vinny’s in a couple of years or worse. So it’s good for us to think think along these lines, recall impermanence so that we’re settling the mind a little bit. Because with all of these all of these so called negative emotions, there is a cost to them. The mind becoming heavier, more uncomfortable.
The mind becoming more inflexible and vulnerable and vulnerable to the attachment. So another drawback is that we of not thinking about death is that even though you remember Dharma, and this is often the case we’re in, we don’t practice it. Even when, you know, we’re there, we might be
Reading something on Dharma, and we accept what’s said there. At the same time, we have this insight. We’re annoyed with someone. And we go from one object to the other. We read something, and then we think, ah, yeah.
You know, inside, we’re annoyed. So being annoyed is not dharma. Even though we’re reading, you know, words maybe don’t be annoyed with other beings, but in internally, we’re annoyed. We’re impatient, or, we have resentment. Right?
So this is our you know why everyone is in the same boat on this issue, and even great practitioners have to deal with this. So it’s not as if we’re, you know, the worst of the worst. But we do need to open our eyes to this and be aware of the fault, our fault in this. We’re not faultless here. We’ve got lots of faults.
And the only way we can overcome them is by listening to other beings, especially those who criticize us. Whenever anyone criticizes us, we have to zero in exactly on what they’re saying and listen to it. They’re right. I have this fault. Not be impatient with them.
Not get annoyed with them. But here, even if we remember the Dharma but don’t practice it, again, this is a fault of not remembering death. The Dharma is there. We read texts all the time, and we agree with it. Intellectually, it’s yes.
Yes. But the heart is going in another direction. Our heart is, oh, my enemy. They’re definitely my enemy. Oh, I resent them, and I’m justified in doing so.
So here we need to remember death. Death will wake us up. So as Tsongkhapa says, everyone thinks death will eventually come, yet they keep the evil thought, but I will not die today. I will not die today right until they’re on the point of dying. So we tend to be like that.
I’m not gonna die today. And tomorrow comes, I’m not gonna die today. Next day, I’m not gonna die today. And on and on and on we go. But one day, it’s gonna come, and we’re gonna die that day, and we’re still unprepared.
Because even though we studied a lot, we’re not applying it because we’re distracted. We’re not thinking of death. So as Pabongka says, you grasp onto the idea that you are not going to die and think, oh, I could practice Dharma next year or the year after. You are forever procrastinating. You think about Dharma, but do not practice it.
You remain engrossed in thoughts such as, I want this valuable object. Meanwhile, what you are preparing while you are not practicing Dharma, your human life is running out. So good for us to think about death and impermanence. It’s a bit like bucket of cold water over our heads. Wake up.
Death. Death is at hand. I’m staring at death. Some say that it’s good to go and meditate on a cliff face because if we’re standing next to a cliff, we’re seated there meditating, that will help us remember death. Death is in in front of us.
By whatever method, it’s we can bring it into our daily conversation with ourselves. It should be there. Maybe we should think first thing in the morning, today, I’m going to die. Because we may. And whatever helps us to practice virtue in the present moment will be useful.
We have to wave a stick in front of our face or by whatever method, change the present state of my mind to something more virtuous. And then the third point here, the drawback that you will practise but not practise properly. So if we don’t remember death, we will get some level of practise. At the moment, we are Dharma practitioners, but because we do not ignore this life’s trivia, our practice is not at all pure. We study and contemplate, yet unintentionally want to be scholars or famous.
We meditate, do recitations, and so forth, thinking this will remove life’s unfavorable circumstances. Like, get rid of the bank manager’s objections to me taking out a loan or something like that. Even great meditating hermits are not free from involuntarily wanting to be famous and so forth. As the great Atisha said, ask me what the results of thinking only about this life are, and I will tell you, they are merely the results of this life. Ask me what will happen in your next life, and I will tell you.
You will be reborn in hell as a hungry ghost or as an animal. So this is what Atisha himself mentioned. If we think only about this life, we’re in danger. In other words, you will achieve a few resultant benefits in this life, and your next lives will result in your going to the lower realms. Right.
So this is confrontational for us. So we need to think a little bit about this. Does it apply to me? But within that, also, we’re not going to immediately come to a clear understanding on these issues. We need to keep an open mind and keep testing.
Pabongka then goes on to say, if you act like this, you are no different from a layperson. He’s talking about laypeople just being swept away by the issues of this life and not thinking about their next life. And if the monks and nuns present at that teaching are only thinking about this life, then they’re no different from laypeople. So we as laypeople or we as ordained should not act like laypeople who are attached only to things in this life. A dharma practitioner must first ignore this life.
I’m not saying you should become a pauper, even paupers or a beggar, in their wanderings, do not ignore this life. The things you should ignore are the eight worldly concerns. Anything mixed with these concerns is not Dharma. So Dharma only begins beyond the eight worldly dharmas. Anything even mixed with them is not really Dharma.
So the yogi Cha Chub Chog asked Atisha, what should I meditate? Or should I meditate? Should I teach? Or sometimes teach and sometimes meditate? Atisha said to each, this will not help.
So he said three times in terms of should he meditate, should he teach, or should he do both? He said, this will not help. This will not help. This will not help. Cha Chub Chog then asked, what should he do?
And he said, give up worldly things. So the advice applies to us. What should we do? Give up worldly things. Give up the eight worldly dharmas.
So the eight worldly dharmas, gain and loss, praise and blame, fame and ill repute, or taking joy in those worldly things, or taking worldly taking joy when those appear and being unhappy if worldly things don’t appear, such as praise and so on. So at present, we’re, like, quite influenced by the eight worldly dharmas. We have to check on this. How much of my daily activities are caught up with personal gain and loss? How much do these affect me or praise and blame?
How much does praise blame me affect me on a daily basis? How much does blame affect me on a daily basis? How much time do I give to these things? And good reputation. How much time do I put in having a good reputation?
But just for this life alone. And how much am I taking joy in having a good reputation and being unhappy if I don’t have a good reputation and so on. So this was a great practitioner, and in a later life, he was. Lama and as, he really practiced giving up the eight worldly dharmas. So maybe part of that was due to this teaching of Atisha when he just said that won’t help.
Worldly activities just doesn’t help. Lama Gampopa said, You fools! You haven’t succeeded in a single type of practice, yet you are proud of being Dharma practitioners. See whether you are first of all Dharma in your mind streams, ignoring this life. So he’s addressing us, talking to us, we fools.
We haven’t succeeded yet in a single practice. But we regard ourselves as Dharma practitioners, and a certain amount of pride comes up. So he said, then first, look in our mind streams to see where there’s Dharma. Now Dharma, another meaning of dharma is virtue. See, this is what virtue there is in our mind streams and virtue that ignores this life.
So, really, this is not easy for us because the world as it is at present is so focused on just this world, the success in this world. Everywhere we find it, you know, it’s in the media. It’s just success in this life alone is. But actually, all of that is not dharma. We need to take it with a grain of salt.
We need to realize that actually, in the end, engaging, you know, in this sort of activity is not going to produce what we actually want, what we aspire to, which is pure happiness. So as then Geshe Tolungpa also said, it is good, my lord, if you practice generosity, but better to practice Dharma itself. So this is very it’s really quite subtle. I mean, we do engage in generosity, but often our practice of generosity is mixed with all sorts of I hope someone’s watching when I’m practicing generosity so that they see I’m making a nice generous offering, so there’s a bit of pride, ignorance, attachment, and so forth. Our motivation is not necessarily very pure.
We want, through that generosity, we want our reputation to be enhanced, which is a worldly Dharma. So on. We have all of these rather worldly motivations that affect our practice of generosity. Far better we practice generosity in a place where there’s no one else so it becomes somewhat purer. We never tell anyone about it.
That way, we’re starting to withdraw the practice from the eight worldly dharmas. So therefore, instead of practicing generosity, practice Dharma is the advice, meaning just practice virtue, virtue that’s completely free of pride, ignorance, attachment, resentment towards others, jealousy, etcetera. Geshe Potowa said that we cannot sew with a two pronged needle. Another good example. No use having a needle with two sharp ends.
If it has two sharp ends, there’s no way to put the thread, so we can’t do much with it. If you do not think about if you do not think about death, you will not ignore this life. We need to be able to begin to ignore all the issues of this life. Otherwise, we will not have a Dharma practice. If you did not ignore this life, you will be controlled by the eight worldly concerns.
So it’s one or the other. At present, we’re pretty much in the camp of the eight worldly concerns, And we do some Dharma practice, but it’s quite superficial. As Pabongka then goes on, we’ll only be controlled by the eight worldly concerns, where we’re happy if we acquire stuff and unhappy if we don’t. We’re happy if comfortable and unhappy if we’re not comfortable. Happy if famous and unhappy if we’re the opposite.
Happy if praised and unhappy if criticized. So all of these things are signs of the eight worldly dharmas. Nāgārjuna also said, the eight worldly concerns, we mean the worldly thoughts of acquiring, possessing stuff or not possessing stuff, comfort or discomfort, fame or notoriety, praise or criticism. Keep a level head. These are not subjects for your thoughts.
The dharmas, one should not even allow them allow thoughts of them to arise internally. They’re all rubbish. So Nāgārjuna mentioned this. So he he said it for a reason. He he said it so that we’d take notice of his words.
And also mentioned, in saṃsāra, the city of preconceptions, wander the zombies of the eight worldly concerns. So saṃsāra itself is like a, yeah, a city of preconceptions. Within that, the eight worldly concerns wander around like a band of zombies. You are in a terrifying charnel ground. Have your guru perform an exorcism.
So Lingrepa made this statement. So in other words, within saṃsāra now what is saṃsāra? saṃsāra is our mind body continuum in the present moment. This is saṃsāra. So within our mind body continuum, within our mind stream itself is the city of preconceptions.
We have all these ideas about all manner of things. Oh, yeah. Sorry. We’ll just finish. We’ll just finish this one one verse.
Sorry about that. So we have these zombies of the eight worldly concerns. So those those preconceptions are just these thoughts about this life alone, really. So therefore, we’re in this dangerous situation, a terrifying charnel ground, really. We should make prayers to our guru to protect us from these worldly concerns.
So, again, a wonderful statement dealing with the danger of the eight worldly concerns that we currently experience. So, okay, we’ll just leave it there. We’ll have a well earned break and come back later for question and answer session. Great. Thank you.
Oh, should we do the dedication? Nope. That’s fine. So we returned at quarter two, two. Two.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
- The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
- guru devotion
- After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
- Vajrayana dor je theg pa (Tib)
- The adamantine vehicle; the second of the two Mahayana paths. It is also called Tantrayana or Mantrayana. This is the quickest vehicle of Buddhism as it allows certain practitioners to attain enlightenment within a single lifetime. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.