3 h 8 min · 17,952 words · 1 June 2012 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. On the opening day of a three-day teaching at a Tibetan children’s school in India, the Dalai Lama addresses young Tibetan students and college-age attendees, many returning from previous years. He frames the talk around why Buddhism has endured and deepened over two millennia, moving beyond blind faith into rigorous philosophical inquiry. He traces Buddhism’s rise alongside other Indian religious systems, showing how Buddhist scholars—from Nāgārjuna through Dharmakīrti to Tibetan logicians—refined their positions by engaging with non-Buddhist critics rather than retreating. He then introduces the text he will teach, Nāgārjuna’s Drops of Nourishment for People, beginning a verse-by-verse exploration of ethics, wisdom, and right conduct. Throughout, he emphasizes that modern Tibetans and Buddhists worldwide must study their tradition actively, understand it through reasoning, and apply its insights to practical life—not treat it as mere custom or superstition. This opening session establishes intellectual rigor and responsibility as the foundation for the deeper teaching to follow.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Teachings on Buddhism for Young Tibetans at TCV; June 1, 2012 (Day 1 of 3) Vi….mp3
UUID: fbb7bd89-1024-4ba3-a430-8a635b4028c5
Teacher: HH Dalai Lama
Collection: Dalai Lama Talks
Date: 2012 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~17,986
How many years has it been for you since you started learning this debate? It’s been three years, and it’s quite good. Ninety three point five. English, ninety three point five. So how many hours do you study in in a week?
The way you debate it. So when you actually start knowing how to debate quite well, then you Yeah. Find more interest in debating. You become more hot when you debate. Yeah.
Do. I love everyone’s in the breach. Yeah. So as the schools are on holiday and the colleges and on holidays. Therefore, we have started this discourse on dharma since six years.
This is the sixth one for the Tibetan students. So you are a new generation youth. Wherever whichever part of the world we are in, everywhere, people wherever people are more educated, it’s quite clear that there is more advancement, material advancements. So regarding us, Tibetans, when we came into exile, the refugees, we started taking initiative as in starting schools for Tibetan children And to educate our children. So, of course, it’s difficult to fulfill all the goals that we have set in the beginning, but we have been rather quite successful.
This is quite clear. So you are the gen new generation. So the school children. So there has been this idea of having this introduction to Buddhism and teaching for the school children since this is the best time as you are on holiday, and we have no much other time. So amongst the students here today, how many of you have not been here before?
Please raise your hands. Those of you who are new, it’s first time for you to come here. Please raise your hands. So the most of the students are have been here before in in this kind of discourse. So how many college students are here, and how many students also?
So as I said earlier, the materially advanced countries have been able to make those progress in order to for this advancement and progress to happen. Of course, individuals have to take initiative and put effort. I mean, the individuals themselves have to have some direction and and know how to fulfill their goals. And with these, determination and your goal set goal that you have in mind, then, of course, you are able to make progress in your countries. So I’ve told before also, perhaps if you look at the history of human beings, Since about three thousand years or so, there has been the religious faith and belief amongst people.
So when people put some hope have some hope, then they have started putting their faith in some kind of a deity or a spirit or something. And so even today, we can see people who are doing some kind of spirit worship and also sacrificing animals and so forth in order when people are sick, in order to cure the the patients. So there has been such a practice. But then as few human beings’ intelligence grew, then people have started finding reason and look at things through reasoning. And therefore, the religious philosopher religious traditions with some philosophical background, It seems that about four thousand years ago, Egyptian in Egypt, this kind of religious belief system developed.
I don’t know exactly, but but in India, we can tell for sure that say for sure that before Buddha came into this into India, there have been there have been these different religious traditions and philosophical systems in India. So people have started finding reason to prove what they believed in, the existence of those gods and so forth. So I usually make the difference between religious beliefs which have some philosophical background and, those without any philosophical background. So, those with the philosophical background, the religious traditions, seems to have started in India. So before Buddhism spread in India, before Buddhism came in India, there has been the Sankhya School, and then from there, some subschools developed.
So it’s been since now, two thousand six hundred years, the Buddha Śākyamūni came to India. And then contemporary to him, maybe there was a difference for about Mahavir. Mahavir. Mahavir. So the Jain founder of Jainism also lived around the time of the Buddha.
There may have been some twenty years or thirty years difference between them, but so Buddhism and Jainism developed in India around the same period ago. And within the Sankhya school, there were the theistic and nontheistic sub schools. So I’m not sure when the nontheistic Sankhya school developed. If it it may be that they developed around the time of the Buddha. So these three, the Buddhism, Jainism, and the non theistic theistic Sankhya school do not believe in a creator god.
Other than this, the other religious traditions do believe in a creator god. And within them, the second group, there are some who do believe in past and future lives and also causality. So non-Buddhist Hindu schools. So some say that they the universe was created by Brahma, but then there is also the working of karma created by beings. So they believe in the law of causality on the one hand, but then the the main thrust of the philosophical background or understanding is that’s the the universe is created by Brahma.
But then the nontheistic Sankhya school say that the things come through causes and conditions, and they don’t believe in a creator god. So this shows the there’s some development further development in by using reasoning because they find some logical inconsistencies if you were to believe in a creator god. And because of this, they started positing that there’s no there are logical fallacies. As it is mentioned in Dharmakīrti’s Pramāna Vartika. So an eternal creator gods, you were to believe in such a thing, then there are a lot of logical fallacies that are mentioned in the Pramāna Vartika.
So, of course, you people can pick up put faith in a creator god. But then when you use reasoning and logic, then you find some fallacies and such a belief. And therefore, in Buddhism, there is no belief in a creator god. But the the Buddha, when he began giving his teachings to people, he started with the four noble truths, so which are based on the the understanding that we have happiness and suffering and which come from cost conditions. And therefore, the Buddha’s teaching is the essence of Buddha’s teaching is that of dependent origination.
So dependent origination in terms of causality is one thing. And so this is what the Buddha has taught. And if you also use reasoning, there is no beginning to the past and future lives, beginning and ends to life. And then also the fact that mind has a nature such that it’s our disturbing emotions can be overcome. So since time beginning this, this has been the case that the delusions that are in our minds can be overcome and, there can be overcome through, by applying the antidotes to the delusions.
And therefore, the Buddha was somebody who was able to teach dependent origination from his own experience and insight and, without relying on other, depending on other, teachers, to teach the dependent origination and had the pinnacle of experience of dependent originations. So since the Buddha gave his first sermon, the first sermon of noble truths for noble truths until today, has been over two thousand five hundred and fifty years. So from amongst all the religious traditions with philosophical background, the teaching of the Buddha since he’s still as a Buddhist, I can say I’m not saying that Buddhism is the best religious tradition, but if you were to check without bias, you can tell that the Buddhism teaching of the Buddha is the has the the deepest philosophical understanding, philosophical system. When the Buddha began giving teachings, he opened the minds of the, disciples and, be open to the truth and, not restrict them to and ask the disciples to check his teachings by using their intelligence. So this is really great.
If the Buddha had said that whatever I teach you, you must believe in them, Perhaps there won’t have been so many great masters. Buddha said Buddha has told his disciples that monks and scholars should examine his teachings. And just as gold is tested by rubbing, cutting, and burning. So he said that you should not believe in whatever I teach you. You shouldn’t believe right away, but you have to use reasoning, experiment it, and you use reasoning.
And then, when you find them, to be, standing to the test of reasoning and all this, experiment and all this, then you should believe in my teaching. And so this is something not perhaps not perhaps in some non-Buddhist schools, they they do have such a way of approaching the teachings. So there are, of course, in the scriptures, when there is a challenge from somebody, then you have to confront it. And then when you don’t have a challenge front, when you’re not challenged by anybody, then you cannot make progress also just as it is in the case of our health. When you meet with different obstacles to your health, then you show some you use some antidote or you’re trying to overcome those obstacles by applying different means, remedies.
So people who are born in high lands, like plateau, Tibet, and so we have certain genes and also have the physiological structures accordingly, being able to have no difficulty in breathing in high lands in high altitudes. So this physical change physical nature has developed over years. And so it is similar to the trees. So when when where there is hot climates, then you have different and the the tropical weather regions. You have some kind of trees that grow there.
But then in colder regions, the trees are different. When I was in Israel, I saw some kind of a tree. So I was introduced to some tree which was said to have to retain its water in the roots where there is not much rain in. That roots keep the water. So when you have some challenge from somebody, you’ll be able to face them, confront them.
You have to confront them. And for example, in the case of logic and epistemological texts of Buddhist Buddhism and non-Buddhist traditions, Hinduism and so forth, sometimes the non-Buddhist philosophers challenged the Buddhist logic and epistemology, and then they the Buddhist had to defend them. And they’re in this way. So this has been the case since the time of the time of master Nāgārjuna. And then later on, Asaṇga and Vasubandhu developed it.
And then finally, the Dignāgā also wrote text on logical epistemology. So after his writings of the compendium of valid cognition and so forth, then some non-Buddhist have actually made objections to the Dignāgā’s system of logic. And to those challenges criticisms, then the Buddhist scholars have like, Dharmakīrti and so forth, have actually answered the criticisms, argued against the non-Buddhist scholars. And then those were again challenged by non-Buddhist scholars later on who came after Dharmakīrti and so forth. And then you can find later on that in during the time of Shāntarakshita, he also answered the non-Buddhist scholars.
And so when there are new challenges, you find new logic and reasons to defend your own.
So it seems that we should be actually grateful to the non-Buddhist traditions as well in for making the Buddhist logic and epistemology to to develop further and more become more refined. So with regard to the logic and epistemology, Tibetan scholars have paid a lot of attention to it. In Chinese translation, the door of reasoning is said to be to have in in Chinese translation. But the seven text on logic and epistemology by Dharmakīrti have not been it seems they they were not translated in Chinese before. But later, it seems the people have translated it.
So in the past, it’s not there. So amongst the Chinese scholars, there may not have been many scholars, many people who have written text on logic and epistemology. In Tibet, for example, Sakya Pandita Kunga Gyaltsen has written that Tshema Rigter, the treasury of reasoning. And then after him, there have been Sakya masters who followed his tradition before the Gelug system evolved in Tibet. The Sakya scholars have written commentaries on epistemology and logical texts.
So I don’t remember the names, but there was a great master who started what is known as the collected topics tradition. So so most of the Tibetan writings have these three points. They first set up the position of the opponents and then reject them, and then establish their own system and try to do away with any arguments or criticisms to one’s own position. So this show how to actually confront the and the challenges that one faces. So this kind of way of approaching the debate, like, if you face this challenge, you have to answer this way.
If you face that challenge, you have to face that challenge. You have to use this reasoning to challenge it and so forth. Clearly mentioned in the Tibetan texts. So the Tibetan scholars paid great attention to logic and epistemology. And even in one’s own writings, the Tibetan scholars have actually used logical epistemology, logic and reasoning to establish one’s own position.
So when there is when there’s a challenge, then you actually are peaked to pay attention to your own position. What do you say? So we are in the next era now. In the fifties and sixties, the communist China Chinese have said that the Tibetans are rather ignorant. In Austria, recently during my last visit in Austria, there were a few Chinese, men and women who have come to the street on the street to raise slogans against me.
But then when they were asked, one of them has actually said to Tibetan that Tibetans don’t know anything. They they know Buddhism, a religion, but then they don’t know anything. They follow Buddhism rather blind through blind faith. In the fifties and sixties, the Chinese authorities also have said this. So Tibetans have only blind faith in Buddhism.
So during those days, they are they say that when as the science and technology advances, this blind faith will go away, and so Tibetan Buddhism will actually die out. But then it’s been now since the forties and fifties, about sixty years now. So now if you look at Tibetan Buddhism today, of course, it’s not so, nice if I say this, but then even scientists, the top scholars and scientists, when they do some research, they take points from Buddhism and also mainly with regards to related with the things that are related with the mind and emotions. So I have many Christian friends, of course, many many other friends. I had a discussion with some of them.
What are the expressions of the god? How did god actually sorry, create the universe. So when I asked this, how god created this universe and so forth, So the person told me that, oh, we are not actually we we don’t do such analysis and investigation. So they only keep faith in god, and they don’t use reason. I think I said to you, I have a I maybe I told you last time.
I have a friend, Indian friend, who is a doctor. So he has set up hospitals, clinics for people. And he came to see me with the doctor who performed surgery on my gold stone and took out the gold stone. And this Indian, he told me, he came with this doctor, the surgeon. He said that the universe was created by God, but then there are so many bad people in this world.
And he asked me, why did God create such so many bad people? So I jokingly told me, first of all, God created hell and heaven. So since hell is created by God, there must be people who should go there, I told him. So this is there’s nothing more I could say. Of course, God is infinite love, wisdom, and power.
So, of course, God cannot have evil feelings or ill feelings towards certain beings. So when you believe in a creator god, of course, things are very complicated. Become very complicated when it these kind of questions are raised. So there are more and more new found some interest in Buddhism everywhere in the world. So recently, when I was in Australia, just before my breakfast, I went out of my room and to the roof.
And I just happened to shout that this place is so beautiful. The birds, the singing, and the scenery scenes around and so forth. As I, said this, got rather loud. Someone downstairs was, one lady one lady came out of her room with a cup of tea in her hands, and she told me that in the West, you have brought this kind of pure Buddhist tradition, to the West. This is really, we are really fortunate for, having a pure Buddhist tradition.
He she didn’t look like in a hippie type, but, some are really educated. So she didn’t she was a really gorgeous looking lady and didn’t look like a hippie. So usually, when I give lectures in the West, I say that the westerns westerners have their own their own religious traditions, traditional religions. So this is what I mean, actually. I mean it.
I met somebody in France or somewhere some years ago. Wealthy person told me that he wanted to build a meditation center. So he was a very wealthy person. I told him sincerely, you have in your own country, you have your own, traditional religion. It is better to, follow one’s own traditional religion and it’s not good to convert yourself to, if you wish to build, meditation center, it would be better to, do so in a Buddhist country.
So this France is not traditionally Buddhist country, and I don’t think it’s a good idea. And I said that, like, if you if, someone were to, come to the Tibetan settlement and build a Christian monastery, what would Tibetans think? So it’s a similar thing with building a monastery or a meditation center, a huge one in traditionally Christian country. So I didn’t find it quite I found it rather uncomfortable. And so later on, the person has stopped built a meditation center in Thailand or somewhere.
So I never try to propagate Buddhism in the West. So I always tell the people that this is not in my intention and that people should follow their own traditional religion and then people are taking more interest in Buddhism. And some people don’t say that they don’t find it convenient to there are people who say that they don’t find it convenient to go to Buddhist centers, but then they’ve it’s easier, convenient for them to stay in their house and read Buddhist books books. Perhaps amongst Tibetans, we may have people who read Koran or bible and so forth when they own their own home, although they may not do so in the public. In the Chinese communist documents, So in the past, the Chinese, they say they have said that the Buddhism is blind faith.
Tibetans have blind faith, and it’s like a backwards sort of tradition and so forth. This has been challenged And today, I have I have a friend, Christian, and then we discussed about when we had discussion, he’s they said that So people are taking they said that the people are taking lots of interest lots of people are taking interest in Buddhism, Tibetan Buddhism, and what is the cause for that. And so there has been some discussions among the Christians themselves to find the cause for people to taking interest and paying attention to Buddhism so that they could also use the same kind of technique to recruit people to their own religions. So the Chinese, without knowing the depth in-depth Buddhism in in-depth So amongst that 6,000,000 Tibetans, how many of us really sincerely practice Buddhism through understanding it? Of course, most of the elderly people may be following Buddhism out of blind faith.
It’s not the faith itself, the tradition itself, but the people who follow it. So there’s a story in one region of Tibet. There there was an oracle deity. And to at one time, the oracle deity said that if you don’t behave well, then people they I will actually I will cast spell on you. And the Oracle had said that you when you wear your boots, don’t you itch where you tie your lace.
And that is my I have no spell on you. That’s quite silly, isn’t it? And one Oracle saw when when the Oracle meeting went into trance and he saw a horse down there. And he said, I have some I will help you. And the the oracle said that your horse will have a baby, a pony.
And and then the house master, the father of a house said that it’s it’s actually a male horse. And then the oracle actually said, even if it’s a male horse, it’ll give birth to a baby. So how silly. So in Tibetan society, we have lots of, talk like when somebody becomes sick or, some, llamas and so forth say, oh, this is because of such and such negative influence and so forth. And then they they recommend this and that kind of prayers.
So they don’t talk about doing prayers can lead you to liberation, enlightenment, and so forth. But it’ll help to overcome your sickness and to obstacles and negative influence and so forth. This is this shows the lack of understanding of the Dharma. I teach I tell the Chinese, Koreans, Vietnamese, And so in other words, all the other Buddhist people, we have to be today, we have to become a twenty first century Buddhist. What that means is what have we have to understand what Buddhism actually teaches and then followed the teaching.
We should not say that we are Buddhist because our forefathers are forebears and such as our grandfathers and mothers are Buddhists and parents are Buddhists and so forth. So it’s very important to always emphasize to study Buddhism and understand it. In the beginning when we started the Tibetan schools in India in exile, we have we had teachers who told these students very, with strong dedication in their work. And later on, there has been some setback in the teaching style of the teachers in Tibetan schools. So Tibetan Buddhism is not about when you talk about teaching Buddhism, it’s not about how to pray only, but it has to do with changing, transforming people’s minds.
So merely doing prayers, if merely prayers can make transformations, then Buddhism would be same as other religious traditions which are only So in the the religious traditions which believe in creator gods and some of them, they don’t teach about the workings of mind, the function of mind that much. But when it comes to the Brahma vihara, then there is the the tradition of Vipassana and Shamatha, the insight and calm tranquil abiding meditations. So when you only base your religion on faith alone, you don’t have to talk much about the system of minds, the workings of the mind. So Buddhism is about changing the mind, transforming our mind. So it cannot be done through surgery or by giving injection and or doing exercises.
But then you have to use your own mind to overcome the distorted notions and develop the right views, the right understanding. So, the transformation has to come through, the mind by using our mind. When we talk about liberation and omniscience, this has to do with our mind. Liberation and enlightenment has to have to come through based on the mind. And so the mind has to be used to transform the mind.
So this is what Buddhism teaches. I never say that Buddhism is the best religion. Never. So it is like saying, you know, one medicine is this is the best medicine. Because when you have to talk about some medicine being the best,
Or not, you have to talk about whether medicine actually works best most effectively for the patients. So without relating to a patient or sickness, you can’t you can’t say that this medicine is the best. And so accordingly, according to the predispositions, mental dispositions of the different followers of different religions, then you have to say this religion is best for the that this kind of person and that religion is the best for this that kind of person. So you can’t talk about the best religion and without relating this to the followers of people. So I am not actually saying that Buddhism is I’m not it’s not the case that I’m not saying that Buddhism is best religion.
So all the religious traditions have the practice of love, compassion, tolerance, self discipline, nonviolence, and so forth. But with regards to the philosophical system, perhaps Buddhism has the widest philosophical system of his of a thought. So I never say Buddhism is the best religion. For some people, Christianity would be the best. What’s most relevant?
I have a I had an American Christian friend. He was intro he took interest in Buddhism and in meditation. So he learned meditation. I told him these are very common practices, but then he asked me one day about emptiness. And I jokingly told him, this is not your business.
Emptiness teaching on emptiness is not your business. This is about the business of, our business, the Buddhist. So regarding him, he has total faith in his creator god and then practice love, compassion, and so forth. So he does these practices. He did these first practices based on his single pointed faith in a creator god.
But then if he were to learn about emptiness, then what emptiness actually talks about is that everything is interrelated, interdependent, and this might actually harm his belief in single pointed belief in the creator god. So it’s difficult to say, one religion is best. But for Tibetans, for example, there are few, very few Tibetans who follow Christianity and the Bern tradition has been there in Tibet before Buddhism came to Tibet. And then after Buddhism spread in Tibet, many Bon scholars have studied Buddhism and then made perhaps changes in Buddhism. So in, today, if you look at Bon tradition, you’ll find lots of, ideas and concepts that are taught in Buddhism as it is taught said by Thuken Chökyi Nyima in his crystal mirror on philosophical systems.
So 99% more than 99% of Tibetans are followers of Buddhism. So Buddhism is our culture. In the West, they they have the Judeo Christian culture. So the the West in the West, their their culture is very strongly related to con connected with Judeo Christian tradition And with regard to Tibet, our culture is much related to connected with Buddhism. So, of course, there are people who criticize Buddhism today.
But what Buddhism teaches, what Buddhism is about should be first studied, understood by studying them. As it was done in India in the ancient times, the Buddhist and non-Buddhist traditions when they challenged each other, they first learned the other’s tradition. And then but after understanding the position of the other, then they started criticizing them, arguing against them. So if you want to argue against somebody, you have to know what the other tradition teach. So you cannot criticize Buddhism just because some people, like, the old people, finds that they have been, rather, they have suffered under the religious hands.
So usually when I talk I usually talk about secular ethics. So when I use the term secular, secularism, I also clarify the point, make some clarification here. For Christians and some other Muslims, some say say that, secularism has a negative connotation, which means anti religion. But this when I use I I tell them that when I use the term secularism, I don’t mean anti religion, but we respect all religions. So when we, explain things, we don’t touch religion as such.
But then, touch on the points about, the human, principles, the the moral principles that are, that, don’t need to be touched, for which we don’t need to touch, religion as such. So during the Bolshevik revolution, perhaps, they they were anti religion. But if you think carefully, closely, you will find that the Bolshevik revolution was actually against the anti the religious institutions which were supporting the kings. So they they have strong connection with the rulers, and the rulers were supported by the religious leaders. And then the the rulers, the kings and queens, actually used them to hold authority over people.
And so if you look carefully, it’s the Bolshevik revolution. It’s not against against the it’s against was against the religious institutions where there was so much abuse of religion. So if you were to overthrow such authorities such authorities and kings and so forth, then, the the religious institutions which supported them also should be criticized and overthrown. So the Bolshevik revolution was about helping the poor people, the poor and needy ones who were oppressed by the real leaders. So it shows there’s the the practice of compassion and love in there.
So who will actually criticize or be against the practice of love and compassion? So in the the French Revolution and Bolshevik Revolution, the this I mean, they happened they were not against religion anti religion as such, but they were against anti against the religious institutions which supported the kings in those times to hold power. So this is just something that I was saying on the side. So in the last three hundred years or so, science and technology developed. And because of the the development and progress in science and technology, many of the problems, I mean, that humanities have faced were overcome.
So many of the things that cannot be, achieved right away through prayers and religion, religious faith, Then and because science and technology, we have been able to give the the results right away. People have rather turned their attention towards science and technology more and more. So recently, I met a professor in the West. He was, from a a Christian background. He said, today, people naturally have this question of what’s there is the nature of god and what is god.
They have question. So many people in the West today, don’t find it comfortable. They are they can’t actually believe in a creator god. So he was himself, of course, a religious person. So people’s attention will turn towards material development.
But then since the towards the end of the twentieth century, then we can we have we can see that people there there are people who are really, really wealthy. Of course, in our, religion, we talk about the Vaishravana being really, wealthy and deity. So in the West, there are people who are really, really wealthy, but then they have no peace of mind. And then although they have all the the material amenities, but then they because of their lack lack of peace of mind, they take drugs, like sleeping pills. And in the worst case scenario, people commit suicide.
Just this morning, I heard on the BBC, I heard about, some people killing others and then, chopping up their head and hands and sending them as personal parcels. So there are lots of case of murder which showed the the lack of practice of love and compassion. Of course, this may be related with political issues. And in Syria, for example, look at the situation today, how serious it is, how sad. In the past, when I was in Tibet, when we hear when we heard that, oh, somebody has been killed, it was it was considered as something unbelievable.
But then today, it’s like, you know, even if thousands and 10 thousands of people were killed, we don’t feel so shocked. So the human life is not it seems that people don’t have a value human life. So the lack of compassion. So the rich people these days from their own experience say that, peace of mind cannot be achieved through money. So this is one problem they are aware of.
And then from amongst the, scientists, especially people who are, working on, like, studying brain science, neurology, health science. They also find it quite intriguing about the two broader problems in society. So they say that you have to find peace of mind and happiness through by using the mind. So if you have a peace of mind, if you are happy, then physically also you are healthier, as the scientists say. So if you have lots of fear and so forth, negative emotions a lot, then that also harms our physical health.
So the people today are turning towards paying more attention to the inner values and and not satisfied with the material development alone, which has been the trend for the last three hundred years since science and technology developed. So in the last five or six years, people have been so talking about the lack of the paying attention to the inner values in our education systems. So it’s happening now in America, Canada, and Europe, and also in India. And people are paying attention to this. So there have been some meetings in Delhi to pay more attention to as to how to develop the inner values through secular ethics.
So I I told Indians that India is the country where it’s should be India should take the lead in teaching about secular ethics. So if we could establish some system in India for studying about secular ethics using secular ethics in educational systems, then it could be make some difference. And when in modern education you can make some difference through secular ethics, People have said that this should be included in what an education system. And so when they think about making a curriculum for this, then they are talking about, as far as I know, there are no Indians who say that they they can actually take these lessons from the the Indian religions, but they talk about taking lessons from the Tibetan Buddhism. So this is something that we so today these days, I say that Buddhism.
So when you use the term Buddhism or the philosophical you usually get the idea of some kind of a belief system, like blind faith. But then I usually use the term Tibetan Buddhist philosophical system and also about mind and emotions. And there’s no other traditions and thought systems which have so much broad and deep, I mean, presentations of these topics. So I, try to I also see that we have to make an academic study of mind, science, and philosophy philosophical thoughts as an academic subject and not as a religious subject So we can use the the thoughts that are found in our scriptures, literature for other the We can also use logic where we can talk about we talk about the alternatives between different things, the relationship, like a three part relationship or four part relationship and so forth in other subjects like science, medicine, and so forth. In Amdo, there has been some system of teaching in schools using Tibetan Buddhist logic.
And after the students from that school in Amdo went to I mean, graduated from the school and went to China proper to study to do higher studies. And then the universities, the professors there in China have noticed something different in the Tibetan students who came from that school in Amdo. And the professors have actually have come to that that the school in Amdo and asked how the teachers actually gave taught the students. So they have said that the students who come from your school are rather different from other students. The way this they are able to study different subjects and so forth.
And so the Chinese professors have done some research in the Tibetan school. And I also met in a discussion with scientists. I met a very, famous scientist and
During the question and answer sessions, these scientists asked me. You the Tibetan students. You when you when the Tibetan students using logic and the epistemology, reasoning in their studies is something which is unique, he he said. Can this not be extended to other subjects? The the this way you study the subjects in the monasteries, can it not be extended to other subjects?
And I said, this is possible, of course. So the presentation of when we do make presentation of, the different subjects that are taught that we find in our literature, without, touching, talking about religion, we may be able to use logic. On the one hand, we can use the science, and then we can also use logic and reasoning. So if we can combine these two, the Tibetan, students can, learn the different subjects better. So it can become a new way of educating.
So we, I have, actually expressed this opinion, during a, Tibetan, meeting of the, Department the of Education of the Central Tibetan Administration. So we have an opportunity, now, it seems. So people are actually looking at us with some hope. So this treasure that we have and with us Tibetans, we don’t have to rely on other countries, other religi languages, but we can study them in our own language. So in Vienna, I had some meeting with some scientists, And one of the scientists explained about the the non-Buddhist traditions like Sankhya school and so forth.
And then another scholar talked about explained or may have gave his presentation on the Mūlamadhyamakakārikā by Nāgārjuna. And then they asked me what I have to say. And then during my turn, I said of course, I actually The subject is I said this is a very complicated subject that we are talking about. And the language with regard to language, we have lots of complications. And what is said in the in Sanskrit cannot be expressed precisely in English.
Many scholars say this. So scholars say that the Tibetan language has that ability to actually express this what is said in Sanskrit. Exactly. And one scholar told me that the Chinese is slightly different from Sanskrit, but Tibetan language has been on par with Sanskrit. This scholar told me that that in the case of China, China even has actually made a lot of progress before Buddhism spread to China.
And therefore and therefore, because of the developments that have happened in China itself, the and Tibet has rather been backwards compared to China. And therefore, when Buddhism was translated tends to when Tibetan started translating Buddhism, we had to actually make a lot of coin a lot of Buddhist vocabulary. And then perhaps, therefore, we are able to express the what is said in Sanskrit exactly. So I’m saying this to the students, new students to, so that you may find some inspiration to pay more attention in learning all your own language data. So this is what I hope you could do.
Otherwise, you might find, oh, Tibetan religion, Buddhism, all these philosophy are very complicated and so forth. So if you find some that Tibetan is something an amazing language, then you will also be proud of your own language. Of course, we make the difference distinction between the spoken and written languages. Of course, in Africa, there are many different dialects and tribes speaking different languages. In America also, in San Diego, recently I met tribes, the Indians, and so forth.
And there are many different dialects among the Santiago and people living in within Santiago. So we have our own unique language and our own script written language and which is really great. And therefore, you should feel proud of in order to become proud of our own people. If you pay attention to Tibetan language, yes, know the uniqueness of our own language, it will be that will make a difference. So this is an introduction to the Tibetan kits, about our own people and language.
So when we talk about, Dharma, religion when do we have to finish it? This program. So Tibetan Buddhism? Of course, Buddhism there’s Buddhism in the Pāli tradition. So maybe I already talked about it before.
Then Buddhism in Sanskrit tradition, which is spread from China to India India to China and from there to from China to Korea, Japan, and Vietnam. So in Vietnam, they also say that there are certain traditions which spread directly from India. So Buddhism, and Tibet did not spread from China as such. The Tibetan Dharma emperors were people, it seems, who actually, try to find facts from the truth. So they were rather unbiased and always very critical in what they want.
So, of course, Songtsen Gampo married Chinese princess. And with her, Tibetan the Chinese empress and the Jowo Śākyamūni. And then also, he married Songtsen Gampo married a Nepalese princess. So Songtsen Gampo found it best to actually take Buddhism from India itself. So, of course, the Tibetan kings and the Chinese kings had already established some kinship and relationship.
Of course, there was the Tibetans already had their own indigenous religion, but Songtsen Gampo was not satisfied with it, but researched where he could take Buddhism or some other religion. And then he found that it would be, best to take Buddhism from India itself, and therefore, he also, looked for the authentic tradition. And those days, Nālānda University was the main institution where Buddhism was kept alive. So Songtsen Gampo didn’t invite. Just any kind of Indian who claims to be Buddhist.
But, the Tibetan emperor, Trisong Detsen, in fact, invited one of the top Nālānda scholars, Shāntarakshita, who was the founder of the subschool of subschool of Svatāntrika Madhyamaka tradition, which in the Sakya tradition, they call it the the upper or the higher Savatantrika Madhyamaka school. So the term using the term higher or here has to do with the distinction that we make between the Cittamātra tradition and the Svatāntrika, Buddhist philosophical thought, where Cittamātra is considered higher philosophical school. So Shāntarakshita followed the Madhyamaka’s thought, and also, he combined it with the Cittamātra tradition. So then he found the Yogachara Svatāntrika Madhyamaka school by himself. So which he was such a school, such a great scholar.
So, of course, in those days, I wonder how Trisong Detsen actually found about found out about the the Shāntarakshita inviting him because there were no telephones and televisions and other transportation. Thanks. And another Tibetan Indian master, Kamalaśīla, was also invited by Trisong Detsen. He says in his the first book of the stages of meditation that he wrote it in at the behest of the Tibetan emperor, Trisong Detsen. So I’ll not go into the Tibetan history Uh-huh.
When Tibet was rather fragmented. The the one of the Tibetan chieftains in in those times was called Yeshe Ö. He requested Atisha. He was the one who invited to to Atisha to Tibet, and he requested Atisha to write a text, and Atisha wrote the Lamp for the Path to Enlightenment. And then later on, the at the request of Trisong Detsen, Kamalaśīla also wrote his Stages of Meditation.
So Tibetan kings didn’t actually, were not contented with any kind of tradition of Buddhism, but actually they were they wanted the authentic tradition of Buddhism. And therefore, they took Buddhism from India. And Shāntarakshita came to in Tibet when he was quite old, and and then he passed away in Tibet itself. And one historian told me that Shāntarakshita, although he had reached such a high age old age, he actually also started learning Tibetan after coming to Tibet. And he advised the Tibetans to study Buddhism, to actually, study Buddhism through our own language, Tibetan.
And he advised Tibetans to translate the the scriptures from Sanskrit into Tibetan. So now when we have studied Buddhism, we can study it through in in our own language. The the scripture comprise comprising the Kangyur and Tengyur can be studied in our own language. And then at some point, after those emperors, Tibetan Tibet became rather fragmented. And the each region has their own leaders and lots of conflicts happen.
There used to be a Tibetans oh, used to say that his region was rather independent. And we have today, we are rather Tibetans have now become one. This is thanks to the Chinese occupation and occupation of Tibet. So Buddhism Tibetan Buddhism. When you see the value of Tibetan Buddhism, then we can see how great our religion and the culture which is related to it.
And then also the language that the Tibetan empress have, actually devised. So we don’t have to, of course, look down upon other races, other people. But when people try to take advantage of us, then we have to show our own, greatness. Amongst the Chinese, there are many many of them who actually are very sincere about, to Tibetans, very dedicated to the Tibetan cause and so forth. So but then when you find people, Chinese, for example, who say that Tibetans don’t know anything, they are totally ignorant and all this, then we have to be able to answer them.
So Yes. About by knowing about the greatness of our own culture and language and religion, of course. So keep this in mind. Okay? I have been I have had lots of interaction with many different people.
And since my childhood, I memorized many classical texts, Indian, writings of the Indian masters. And I studied, did my studies under the fear of, whip that my senior tutor used to keep on this on his table. And so I pursued my studies under this kind of fear. But then, when I was about 14 or 15, then I started actually taking serious interest in my studies and giving thought and reflection reflecting on the teachings. And then meeting with people.
When I meet with other people, because of the training that I had of using, the logic and reasoning, And it seemed also to have a very strong memory. Maybe I have received some blessing of Mañjuśrī. I seem to have some kind of a retentive and forget forgetful memory. When there’s something that I hear and it’s that’s not really important thing, then I don’t really mind keep them in mind. But when it’s really important thing, then I can actually keep them in mind.
So I am now in my mid seventies. So this is an advice that I’m as an old man, I’m giving to you younger generation. Two thirds of my life has gone, but one third of it still. So I’m giving you this advice. So be courageous.
Secular ethics is not contradictory to Buddhism. Buddhism is for everybody. And we will have problem if we only talk about one religion and one truth, one god. But in Buddhism, we have it’s a universal teaching which
Touches on the human principles and the the religion of the vehicles of the gods and humans because of Brahma and so forth. And there is also the saying that so long as human mind is there, there and concepts can never end. So you have to also Buddha Buddha himself respected other religions, other people, And he never imposed his religion on his followers and other people. So he respected others. So I’m not saying because of my attachments to Buddhism as such.
But after having met with many different people from many different fields and religious traditions, I find it to be the most profound tradition that we have. And then this religion that and this culture that we have can serve humanity. And, with our with this, tradition and, teachings on mind and emotions, we can actually give contributes to the world, to humanity. So who can do this is you, the younger generation. So the for the teaching that we’re going to have, the discourse here, one text that I’m going to use is Nāgārjuna’s Drops of Nourishment for People.
So this text talks about the moral ethics, principles of that we can practice as humans. And then the second text is by, was written by Lama Tsongkhapa. So as usually I say that’s the the uniqueness of Buddhism can be expressed through the teaching of dependent origination, that was given by the Buddha. So today, we’ll go through Nāgārjuna’s text. There is no oral to the explanatory tradition of transmission.
When I read this text, I want I actually suspected if it was really written by Nāgārjuna. So towards the end, he was actually complaining a lot. Because the time at the end when Nāgārjuna lived was a time when Buddhism was actually spreading and So perhaps this is because we were when we think about Nālānda, we were thinking about the whole of India being kind of influenced by Nālānda. And when we think about Buddhist Buddhism, we get some idea about the whole of Nālānda. The Nālānda actually pervading the whole of India.
That’s not the case, of course. So of course, master Nāgārjuna may have been in Nālānda, but then there were others, places in India where Buddhism also spread in those days. And because of that, there may have been some decline in other parts of India in Buddhism. And that’s why Buddhist Nāgārjuna was complain. I find Nāgārjuna really a great scholar and a logician.
So when I find in this text some complaints, I was quite surprised. I will not read through the text. There is no oral reading reading transmission of the text, so I’ll not read through line by line. In the beginning of the text, in our Kanjur, Tanjur, maybe there are about 10 different scriptures of volumes which were translated by, from China. One of the text in the Tengyur is, a commentary on the, sūtra unraveling the thought.
And I read this commentary by Woncheuk who was a Korean scholar. So except for those 10 volumes, all the other the the rest of the Kangyur and Tengyur texts were translated from Indian language. And therefore, in the beginning of all the scriptures, we have this mention of in the language of India, And then the translation of that title I mean, with regard to the title in the language of India and the the title is given in Sanskrit and then in the language of Tibet. Tibet. So this text is a text on the worldly wisdom.
We which shows that it’s just actually gives us instructions on how to live life based on moral principles. And in the text, there are references to different stories and fables. In the later part of the text, it’s talking about the how to live a life which will help you in the next lives. So in Tibet Tibetan tradition, we have the 10 practice of the 10 virtues which are said to be the the 10 virtuous actions, divine actions. And then there’s there are 16 moral principles for human to live a good human life, good life as humans.
So in the first verse, Nāgārjuna is saying that I’m not a great poet as such. So first the first verse is salutation to Mañjuśrī, and then the second verse is about writing the text, composing the text. Although he he says that he is not a great poet. But then in order to help beings, he will write this. There is a commentary to this text which is said to be ascribed to the one of the disciples of Lama Tsongkhapa, Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen.
He has made some, divided the text into four different, four major outlines. So the first one is about in human society. Yeah. This is what I usually also say. Whatever good or bad aim we have, whether it can be fulfilled or not.
Whatever the aim, whether bad or good, if you were able to achieve it, we have to have in order to materialize that goal, we have to have the the the approach or the means by which we want to should be realistic. If we use unrealistic means, then we cannot achieve the goal or the objective. So we have to have a realistic approach to fulfill our goals. So we all don’t want suffering but want happiness. But then if you look at, as I said before, materially developed countries, if you look at them, the people there also don’t want suffering but wants happiness.
But then what they tried was that they thought that, they they they followed an unrealistic approach to finding happiness. They focused more on the material development rather than inner values. So of course, we have the five objects of the senses that doesn’t give real stable happiness, but we have lots of, thoughts and concepts, hopes and fears. So with regards to the pleasure of senses, the even the animals can enjoy them. So because of of this human intelligence, we can create lots of ups and downs in our life.
And so the animals cannot do that much. People in the West are very rich, some of them. Even we can say that their wealth can even compare with Vaishravana, the deity, who seems to be very wealthy. So our happiness should not be confined to physical, happiness alone, pleasure alone, but we have to also find happiness in mind. So therefore, we cannot rely only on material development and progress, And therefore, we have we can find a realistic approach to find happiness by using our mind.
And therefore, today people are talking about paying attention to the inner values to find happiness. So if we were to if we are to find some realistic approach, if everyone loves oneself, you are dear to yourself. If you can use if you can actually cherish yourself by using and being realistic and logical, but not using all kinds of bad means such as murdering others and stealing others people’s possessions and so forth. So we have to use reasoning, the power of reasoning, in order to find a realistic approach. So what Nāgārjuna is saying is that the one outline is about finding what we want through by by experiment and reasoning.
So when I was a child in my childhood, one of the one of the doctor physicians used to tell me the story of the the prince in the cuckoo’s body. So who used to say that all whatever you do has to be done through research and experiments. And without doing any experiment, you should not do things. So was number three says, do not talk about the faults of others for whatever faults you see in others. You too have them equally.
So many of the faults that you find in others that you point and others are within yourself. So if you don’t have any faults, then if you point out the faults of others, and if you think that it will help them, then you should actually criticize their faults and try to correct the people. But if it doesn’t help, you should not. So then it uses the parable of the fox and the women. And then this, do not praise yourself.
Whoever praises himself is weak minded and poor in intellect like the Kalandaka. So you should not praise yourself saying that you are somebody great or somebody something like that. Because you are actually causing harming yourself by doing that. Showing your silliness. In other words, in in relation in connection with the bodhisattva vows, this is you should avoid praising yourself because of your attachment to some gain of wealth or offerings and so forth.
So this is teaching us not to do that. Do not rely on bad companions for whoever befriends. Bad companions will bring ruin on himself just like the jackal did by befriending the wolves. You should have reliable friends. But reliable not in the sense that you, someone who takes drugs and alcohol and all this.
So because you’ll be ruined if you’ll be friend with such friends whom you may consider to be reliable. But you should be friend with people who are reliable in the sense that they can actually lead you upwards from goodness to goodness and build up all kinds of good qualities within one’s end. So friendship is dependent on trust. So you have to be friend be friends with others who are conducive to, who can actually help you to grow yourself in a a good way. Do not share confidential matters with bad people.
Here, bad people refers to evil people who actually shows moods and change to you, have all kinds of moods towards you, or moody when you talk something good about towards them. And they may be considered as childish. So evil natured ill natured people should not be befriended. And you should not be close to them. But if if you find people who can listen to what you say and, take heed of your advice, then you should be close to them.
So just as when you befriend with people who are good, principled, then you will also, actually, become good like them. And therefore, and on the contrary, if you’re different with bad people, then you will also become bad. Therefore, it shows that you have to be careful. Be cautious in your behavior. Give up your recklessness at all times.
You should never act like a mad elephant. So whatever you do, you should think about the benefits it has for you and what is the advantage and the disadvantages of doing that. If you have a long term if you have some short term benefit, but then in the long term, if it’s really harms you, for example, in terms of becoming a thief and so forth. So you should be cautious all the time in your behavior. You should think that I’m a human being.
I’m a Tibetan. If I do something bad, people will say, oh, Tibetans are bad. They will not say this person is bad and such. And then secondly, I am a follower of Buddhism. And then you should show conscience.
Yes. So just as Śāntideva says that, when you have an injury, you should you will you’ll be really careful about not getting hurt. So likewise, you should be conscientious here, wishing to express yourself in words. Here, when you talk when you talk with people, you should also always check whether you are saying something which are not that the wordings are not correctly done and all that. One Tibetan woman came to see me in the past from the Western part of Tibet.
She said to me, all of us were imprisoned. And when she said that, she was in front of me. So you can find the fault there in the expression because the the old woman was right in front of me when she said all of us were imprisoned. She was there, not imprisoned not in prison. So you always have to check how you use words.
In nineteen fifty four, fifty five, the relationship between China and Tibet was not so bad. I met one day, Fermin, and we were just conversing. And I asked him, what human being what is human being? And he had no answer. And in Tibetan, we see a human being is someone who can speak a language and who can actually understand others.
But that, of course, definition doesn’t, actually, cover only human beings.
There are other beings who can do that. And then we talked about past and future lives. He said there’s no, he told me there’s no past and future lives. I asked him, how do you know this? And he’s I said and he said, because we can’t see it.
Past and future lives. And I I then I challenged him by saying, if there is something, is it necessary that we have to see that? And he said, no. So we can find the logical fallacy in what people say when they use language. So it’s it’s really it’s really helpful to learn logic and reasoning.
I have a friend who lives in Bhutan. And he teaches other people, and he also teaches logic and reasoning. And one of the students one of his students actually took more interest in logical reasoning. And then this Bhutanese students became was a lawyer actually in Bhutan. So he’s that lawyer said that the logical reason that he learned from the teacher when he taught Buddhism was really helpful in his finding this law suit, the cases, the legal cases.
I mean, he was finding he found the logic that he learned helpful in his legal cases. So even if there may not be Yes. Mistaken the wording of what you say, but then you should also check whether there is some fault in the meaning that you express. So, when you’re amongst people or a crowd, you should also always check your, language. And when you’re alone, check your mind.
There is the same, as said by Atisha. Speaking without checking your speech, like into a madman’s babbling. You should never utter lies that lack any purpose. So if there’s a purpose, it’s not about selfish motive, but then to help others. For example for example, in the Vinaya scripture, we find mention of some kind of incident where a monk sees a deer running away.
And then after that, the monk meets with a hunter who asked the bhikṣu, where did the deer go? And then the bhikṣu is advised or prescribed to us that if he told the truth, then it would harm the life of the, the life of the, animal. So the bhikṣu, when he was asked where the animal went, he said, I didn’t see an animal running here. I just saw a bird flying in the sky. So this is a kind of a lie that is for the sake of saving the life of the deer.
So there is a great purpose in saving the life rather than telling the truth. So I thought maybe it could be applied here also. Now the lack of info, they do not help you but harm others like the lies uttered by a parrot. Once you tell lie, then, of course, it’s a matter of time whether that will be revealed to others or not. One day, you’ll be found out.
People will find out. So the Chinese authorities keep telling lie even though other people know that they are lying. They don’t bother about it, telling lies. You should not turn. Those who act dubiously.
The the critical conduct will not be humble just like the queen of Maya Brahmin. So when I was once in Europe, there there was a Berlin just a day or two after the Berlin Wall was Broken. I was quite afraid at that time. Legally, the eastern part of Berlin was still Eastern Germany. I was rather suspicious if some strange people who might come and invite and take me away, what would happen?
I was afraid. So when I when I reached the wall where the wall had been fallen, the people the hosts had candles in their hands. So people were try people were trying to look for some matchsticks and match boxes. And then one of the people there took out out a lighter from his pocket. So that shows that he was smoking.
And then in Spiti, in Key Monastery, when I once visited there. One day, I just was chatting with the, caregiver of the shrines, and I he told me he was in Shigatse, Peshifimbu Monastery. And then at that time, I just happened to ask him, was which chang was tastier? Shigatse chang or the chang from Spiti? And this monk, the old monk, unaware said that the Shigatse chang was much tastier.
So this showed that he he actually drank Chang when he was in Shigatse even though he was a monk. So the not be act pretentious. And bishop Tutu, who came here last time, he used to say that I am you are his holiness. Therefore, you have to act holy. So to acting pretentiously.
It’s like if you even if you are not religious, you may act like a religious person. Or even if you may not be knowledgeable, you may act as if you are an knowledgeable person, a learned one. Perhaps this story may help you. In nineties the the first time I went to Europe was in 1973. That was the first time I was abroad outside of India.
And when I one day when I was in the reception ceremony, I met an English man. He came to me and said, I admire. He said to me that one thing that I admire about you is, you see, I don’t know. He was quite amazed with it. So what this shows is that their own people, their leaders and so forth, don’t use to say even though they don’t know something, they don’t use to say they don’t know.
This kind of thing is done in Japan also. When they ask something whether it’s right or not, they don’t reply respond rather very clearly, but they just the people just nod their heads, and the other party is confused. When I was in Mexico one time during our interreligious faith, it was long time ago. And that was the the ceremony was or the function was held in a Christian church. And there was a Japanese priest also amongst the religious, representatives.
And he was holding a huge, mala that this in his hands. And then the thread broke, and all the beads just scattered on the floor. And he still remained very, I mean, solemnly with as if the as if the bread mala didn’t break and so there are people are there are such people who really pretentious. And then in when I was in 1954 in in Beijing, the Indian ambassador came to see me, and an interpreter was there who could actually translate it from English into Tibetan between Tibetan and English. But the Chinese said he cannot translate.
But the translation has to go through Chinese interpreter. So the So the Chinese leaders stood there and said there rather solemnly. And then some people came to serve tea and the the container which had fruits on it was actually toppled. And then the Chinese who was sitting very solemnly had to go on his knees and pick up the fruits. So I was really amused with that.
So that was really he did he was really he did something really practical at that time. So pretension is not really good. Can I use a bad language? She actually farted in the assembly. Actually, if she had farted rather loudly, people everybody could have heard.
But then she farted rather in small doses of thing, nine times. And one of the servants who was there said she actually farted nine times. In one go, she farted nine times. In Delhi, there was a Jain priest who was my friend. And in his memory, the followers built another temple.
In Jainism, there are two different followers. One’s who do not wear any clothes, who are naked, and the others who cover their lower part of the body. So in one inter religious faith group meeting, there was this one, Jain master, was completely naked. He had no concern about this life, and he was just being very sincere about his own religion. So he was completely naked.
So luckily, he had a rather had a rather very thick legs and therefore I didn’t have an audience. I didn’t see his private. He doesn’t see he’s almost saying, I touched his. Although I didn’t see his private, one of my liaison officers, I mean, Indian liaison officers asked I asked him ask him. I asked him, did you see it?
And he said, yes. So does it take? No. So there was no pretension there at all? So as Jetsün Milarepa had also said, this is there with us right from birth.
So what’s need what’s the need to be ashamed of it? So you have to be really sincere. Do not listen to the words of bad friends. For if you do listen to them, you won’t fulfill your call, but it’s deceived. So from it’s verse number 16 downwards.
The second outline shows building up goal good qualities. So from the beginning up down to through to verse number 15, you have what the verses show is that you have to check before you do something. So even barbarians can be wealthy, even animals can be heroic. Those speaking in accord with reality are very rare in this world. So you have to be educated.
You have to know things well in order to not make mistakes in what you say, in words and in meaning. Strive even if you stake your life on it to acquire knowledge and good or good qualities. You should not this is not teaching us to work for wealth and money. Someone not pursuing knowledge is like a foolish beast for animals. So these verses from Dhammapada show that learning when if you if you become learned, it cannot be your knowledge cannot be stolen away by thieves.
And it’s just and your knowledge dispels the darkness of ignorance within yourself. If you so if you’re not able to use your brain very well, then you will talk anything that comes in your mind and, to me, makes no sense to others. Without knowledge and empty mouth. You should pursue knowledge or else what use is looking dignified. A cow that has no milk will not sell even if you look to tie a bell on it.
So with if you’re empty inside without any knowledge and good qualities, even if you may wear great ornaments, very expensive ornaments and and so forth, It will not help you. I saw at one time whenever I was in Amravathi in South India where I gave Kālacakra initiation there, I saw some pictures of Tibetans wearing huge, corals and, these stones on their hand and body. I thought that what is the use of all these things? These people are all ignorant without any knowledge. But so at that time after seeing those pictures, I said that these ornaments that we wear, huge ornaments, are no use if you lack a knowledge.
And could call it as empty within. And so people have actually heeded my advice. Although this they have been forced to do where such things like Chinese. You may possess all excellent things, but do not despise others. So there are people even in monastic institutions who may, in the beginning, be very humble.
But as they become more and more learned and have more students, then they tend to despise or look down upon their students and so forth. This should not be done. So even though other people may bow to you, you should always hold yourself lowly, the lowest of all. Although it’s not so good when I say this to myself about myself. When I go places, when I visit different countries and people, people really like me.
I never think that I am the Dalai Lama or I am somebody special. But it’s because I only think that I am a human person, human being like others. So in the West, I say, when I give talks to the public, I there’s always a barrier if I think that I am a Tibetan, I am Buddhist and But I always think I consider everyone same like myself as human beings. And therefore, there’s no barrier between us. And that that brings us closer and develops friendship.
The intelligent one may be small, but the rash one must not ridicule him. So the learned people should not be looked down upon. It would be like the story of a clever rabbit the ending the life of a lion. If you benefit all equally without discrimination like the sun, everybody will repay your kindness. So if you help others equally, then people will when you need their help, they will be ready to help you.
So otherwise, if you think you are somebody special and look down upon others, you will not have friends. So you this is something that you can know if you use your common sense. Even the sign from scientific, research, people say that if you consider others to be friends of yourself, then you will not have anxiety and fear. So, you know, if you give public talk, unless there are some text that are used just which I go through. But then I don’t really make any preparation to give for the talks.
So I I’m not concerned about name, fame, and so so forth. Then I can be very frank with people. If I’m some if I think that I’m somebody special, then I would have all kinds of fears and hopes. And that’s actually will put me on the losing end. At the losing end.
So in nineteen fifty four, fifty five, when I was in Beijing, I was with my two tutors, Ling Rinpoche and Trijang Rinpoche. And then Pengyi Rinpoche was also there, and then the Tibetan house cabinet ministers were there. We had all these offerings to Mao Zedong. So the day before our audience, somebody came to us and said then instructed us how to actually proceed into the room. And she said, when you enter the room, you have to then take steps, then you have to go to the right or to left, then this many steps, that many steps, and then finally you have to enter.
So this gave us lots of anxiety. And the only lady was really scared. So what’s the use of all these formalities? It didn’t help them, the Chinese authorities themselves. When I was in 1950, In Trommel, where I had to flee for some time.
And in Dromo, the Deng Jilin came, the Chinese military personnel came to see us. And my younger my elder brother, was in another room. And he said he he told me he peeped through some hole into where the the Chinese military personnel was and he came later he came to me. The Chinese military personnel was actually a human person, human being. He had this he had this idea that the Chinese might build someone looking like a giant or devil or something.
So we were rather foolish in those days. So when Younghusband invaded Tibet in nineteen naught four, who those who tried to confront him, his soldiers were killed. And people were even deceived by his soldiers. But then on their way to Lhasa, they did not destroy monasteries or did not kill monks and so forth. And when they reached Lhasa, they did not actually take advantage of their victory and caused all kinds of trouble to people.
Nothing like that was done. But in when the Chinese started invaded, And on the way to Lhasa, how many monasteries and temples did the Chinese actually destroy all the way from the eastern border? So after the Younghusband’s expedition into Tibet, the Tibetans coined the word, which means the foreigners who were the enemies of the the teaching Buddhism. But, actually, they were not enemies of Buddhism as such. So before September, there was a mister Robert Ford who was supposed to give some broadcast in the radio in English.
Was the Tibetan broadcaster, and he listens the to the news in Chinese. And he came to one of their cabinet’s ministers and about the news that he heard and said that it’s that situation is not good. The Chinese are saying all these things about Tibet. And then the captain minister told him, oh, prince, you don’t have to worry because Tibet is protected by dharma protectors. So this shows our lack of awareness about what’s going on around the world.
And we’re just satisfied with all kinds of paid so much attention to how you dress during certain functions. And if somebody had not dressed properly, they would be punished. So such silly things were done. Tibet was economically really backwards. Perhaps this word, the word wealth was started and people using these words after the Chinese came into Tibet.
Of course, I heard in Dalai Lama had done something. Trying to make innovations in Tibet, But educating people and so forth, but it was not continued. The what was going on around the world, the reality outside was not known to Tibetans, but we were just lost in our own worlds. And then the situation, when we had the power in our own hands, we didn’t use them proper. We didn’t use the opportunity.
We actually wasted it. I used to tell the elder generation that we actually covered ourselves or covered our hats with our roofs and did not look around or listen to things that was going around. And then somebody came and hit a stick on our head, and we are just we lost our consciousness. So we have to know what’s going on. We have to know how we approach things or what steps we should take, what what is the first step we are going to take in the second and the third, So and steps and so forth.
We have to have a plan. In Buddhism, we talk about reaching enlightenment with the huts and there are all these steps that we have to take to reach that goal. So in terms even with regard to administering a country and so forth, we have to know the reality. When you read some text, you should not, think that, oh, this is something really peculiar said in this, but you should use that advice for your own advantage. 29.
The oceans, Mount Meru, continents, and the like, these external worlds and lands are not my burden, but anyone ungrateful for the kindness they received. So if somebody has done something good to you, it is very important. It’s a very good moral principle to actually feel grateful about what the other has done to you and try to repay the kindness. Verse number 31, 32, 33. Even if you may be knowledgeable, you should not feel proud and arrogant.
That you’ve you don’t feel that you’re really somebody special. The greater knowledge the greater knowledge you have, you should be more compassionate and loving towards others, more humble. From verse number 23, the next outline So up to verse number 10 to two, you have you are told to build up knowledge and good qualities. And from verse number 23, the you should check what is good to do and what is not good to do. Verse number 42.
From verse number 42 on page 26. From verse number 42, it shows the distinction between holy and unholy beings. Unholy means unprincipled ones. So from this was what is shown is the law of causality. So those who follow the the four wrong views are unholy, unprincipled.
And then who those who followed for right views are the holy ones. So the right views are that things observing things as impermanent impermanent things as impermanent and the suffering nature as being the nature of suffering. And then there’s no clean self as such, and then there’s no self. So the con on the contrary, if you look at or if you observe or consider things that are impermanent is permanent and suffering as, not suffering or being happiness and so forth, then you have the wrong views. So with regard to the emptiness of clean self, it has to do with the Buddhist idea of viewing the psychophysical aggregates that we have as which are the results of common delusion as being in that being empty of any cleanliness.
Then fifty fifty six from when verse number 56, it shows that 10 they are non virtuous actions. In verse 55, therefore it says, therefore, do not think this life is endless. Remind yourself of the three unfortunate realms of existence, refrain from the bodily deeds of the killing and so forth. So from verse 55, the 10 non virtuous actions avoiding the 10 non virtuous actions are shown. And Not today.
So number 56. So if you don’t refrain from these non virtuous actions, then the result would be rebirth in the lower realms of existence. So this is the way of So while you have this human life, you have to use it to your advantage, thinking about or reflecting on impermanence, the suffering nature of life, the empty nature, and the selfless nature. Verse number 60 says that so while you have this human life, you have to be very cautious about not committing non virtuous actions. While you have this one
And then not using it properly to your advantage, but then making prayer for such a life in the future is a way of the foolish, says in verse number 60. Having found this human body now, some pray to obtain it. And in the future, they are fools. Verse number sixteen Three. If you engage well in the sacred Dharma, such things as caste, maid servants may exist, and the universal monarch reigning through the magical wheel.
But the sage declared even a maid servant may become a venerable one. So Buddha Śākyamūni himself has said that in this in his tradition, in his system, he has he he makes no distinction between people according to caste, but he is so Buddha was against the caste system. So Mao Zedong used to tell me that in the Buddhism Buddha was a revolutionary. But then in the at the end of our meeting, he says religion is opium. So in the beginning, he praised Buddha Śākyamūni and also Ārya Tārā, the goddess Tārā.
Then there is a bit of this text touches on the six perfections of giving and so forth. And then comes his complaint, at verse number 80. Now many evil people are causing the near destruction of the victorious victorious teaching. Now disgraceful, ill mannered people, evil with wrong views who are ignorant. They they have felled the tree of the blessed one’s teachings.
It is no more. Now the merciless unkind abandoned the spiritual way and devised their own systems. The desires with lust do not see what lies beyond. They have forgotten the victory banner of the Dharma. It is no more.
Now those difficult to tame, shameless, delighting in evil karma and hypocritical, these these sinners have broken the bridge of the sages’ teachings. It is no more. Now those shaven headed for not practicing the Dharma, this misbehaving despicable and physically disguised as ethical hypocrites. They have destroyed the currency of the sages’ teachings. It is no more.
So at thus Nāgārjuna is advising us, actually, to be careful. As I usually say, hope for the best, but be prepared for the worst. And to hear, Nāgārjuna is making is complaining a lot. So we have to also feel be alert. And as Tibetans are at a very critical juncture in our history, Of course, people have we we have really worked hard so far with great great dedication, and we should still continue to do so.
So with this, we have finished with the text Drops of Nourishment for People, a treatise of world wisdom. And now next, we have some questions. Those who want to ask questions, come to the so there is a development of concentration in Buddhism where you look at observe the higher realms of existence being more peaceful than the lower realms of existence. So there is development of Shamatha Vipashyana, can be developed on the basis of the non-Buddhist traditions as well. But then the liberation in terms of the liberation from all disturbing emotions has to be done through overcoming by realizing emptiness or selflessness.
So practice of love, compassion, and faith cannot overcome them. We have to develop the wisdom. So overcoming the third type of suffering, which is called the The conditioned pervasive existential sufferings, the third type of suffering. So earlier, I was when I talked about be taking interest in our own language, I was not being saying so. Edward Conze.
Edward Conze, his interest was first perhaps in thinking about who translated many of the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras into English from when he found Sanskrit rather difficult to understand, then he told me that he resorted to Tibetan because Tibetan was the best to for him to understand the meanings of the what is said in Sanskrit text. So I was not praising Tibetan language out of my attachment to it as such. That was what is on this one to say. So Tibetan has a very a great ability to express the the concepts that are in Sanskrit. So I didn’t praise I was not praising Tibetan language because of attachments because my thinking to it.
So ex to explain Buddhist philosophy, it’s in In one of her textbooks, it’s it said that Tibetan Buddhism is called Lamaism. So why is it so? So this term actually was not is not used by the Tibetans, but Tibetans are responsible for somebody coining this name, word coining this. So in Tibetan society, when you have a lama who has really learned it, but people don’t the the person is not sitting on a high throne and so forth, then people don’t respect them much. But then there are some the Tibetans who say that consider, I mean, lamas or somebody highly revere them when they have wives and children and so forth.
So I was told by some lama that in Kham, whether a lama is a big lama or a small lama is people judge them by their the number of horses and so forth in their cavalry. So people who really learn it and have real good experience of the Dharma are not paid much attention to. This is a drawback in our society. And then there is the guru yoga practice, which comes from the highest yoga, tantric. Of course, this is considered I mean, held very high practice.
And therefore, people have started delivering their, like, reincarnate Tulkus. But then other llamas who are genuine llamas were not reviewed well and highly in Tibet like Patrul Rinpoche is a case in point. So he was a great master. When he taught Śāntideva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra, it is said that whenever he taught this text, the some flowers grew, which was called the utpala flower. So one time, he left his place after giving some teaching.
It’s nice. And then on his way, he stayed at some house. And the Patrul Rinpoche’s students heard that he had left. And then they followed his paths, asking people. And he came to the house where Puchungwa Rinpoche was staying, And the students asked the host the owners the lady if the if one lama came here.
And the mother the the lady answered that the lady answered that she went out. I I no lama came here, but some traveler came here. And he has just gone out to throw my urine. He to take my urine pot to throw my urine. And then the students asked to describe this person, and the the lady described him.
And the students when the the lady describes the person and the students found out that it was actually their lama, Patrul Rinpoche. And then the the the lady was so embarrassed that he ran away she ran away from her house. This was this story was about the was told to me by my teacher, And when one time some people saw Jetsün Milarepa and said made their prayer that may we not be born like this person. I mean, Milarepa looked like a mannequin totally without anything to carry with him. He’s not a beggar.
Right? And Jetsün Milarepa replied to them, even if you worked hard, will not be born like me at all. So he was really tough guy. So typically, we have the practice of guru yoga in our religious practice, but then people have not been able to follow the practices correctly. And therefore, people from outside have coined this name, Lamaism.
So Tibetan Buddhism is a complete teaching of Buddha. So the question was about not being attached to his evil deeds and not be being close to the evil sinners. And so the this is the first part of the question. To answer this, Āryadeva said that has said in his 400 verses, the bodhisattvas should not be angry with the person who is engaging in some sinful actions and they should not be angry at they should should be angry at the sin that is being done. So when we talk about forgiveness, we’re not talking about forgetting this this the wrongdoing of somebody.
But actually, we what is forgiveness about is not having grudge at the person who’d the wrongdoer. But the wrongdoing itself has to be something. So we have to to make difference between the actor and the action. We have to forgive the actor, and we we have to confront and overcome the action. So politics, which is he’s saying that he’s quoting some lines.
Politics divide of religious principles is an empty talk, meaningless. So what religion is talking about is how to make a good person, how to be a good person, principled one. And when you are engaged in politics only for one’s own your own gain with selfish motive, then it’s not good. But when you use the principles, the good principles, moral principles that are taught in religion, then you are doing something that is mundane, but then engage in politics. You are engaging something that is politics, but it’s white politics.
So if you have politicians who are religious, it would be better. When we once we had the meeting, the one minister was there from West Bengal, Siddhartha was his name. He said in the meeting that we are politicians and we don’t know religion. And then when my turn came to talk, I said, really, the good heart or warm heartedness is something that the politicians also need. Well, because you work for people.
People who work in society with if you don’t act with a principle, then you’ll cause lots of troubles and problem in society. So someone who is living up in the hills as a hermit may not even if they don’t do some religious practice sincerely, that they may not be able to harm society as such. So since my childhood, I have found lots of drawbacks and and not liked the old Tibetan governing system. Therefore, I found that I that democratic system is the best form of governance, and therefore, I left the political responsibility last year. It’s not out of some kind of hypocrisy or anything like that.
So people who are in politics, not necessarily that it’s not necessary that they have to be religious as such, but they should be principled people with they they must still stick to some kind of secular ethics. Lighting butter lamps in Tibetan, we have this custom. But then from another angle, Lighting lighting butter lamp has causes damage to the environment and also it depletes our resources. So lighting butter lamps is not something that’s only Buddhists do, and and even the Christians do that, and Parsis do this, and also Hindus consider it very sacred practice. So since time immemorial people have found that fire gives warmth and also, the sun gives warmth to us.
And, therefore, people have, started considering them highly.
Starting them with respect. And then in India, there is also the custom of making offerings of drinking water and bathing water and so forth, lamp, incense, flower, food, and so forth. When I was in Revalsa, Rewalsar recently, there was a, one Hindu priest, and I told him I would visit his temple. And when I visited his temple, usually when you visit Hindu temples, have to remove your shoes. And there is also a Sikh temple in Revalsar where you have to do the same.
And then when I visit this Hindu temple, recently, they washed my feet my feet and then also So they make all these offerings of the and so forth. There was water for drinking, water for washing feet and so forth, incense lamp. So all of these are done. When I visited a Jain temple, very famous Jain temple in Gujarat, Just as we do during our consecration rituals, they also do the same thing. So I found what they do exactly to be the same as what we do in our rituals for consecration.
So I have great respect for Mahavir, and and then when the when they offered the crown, it was made of a very simple crown made from some silver. So whereas if Tibetans were to offer some crown to the Jowo statue in Lhasa, we would make it from we have gold crowns of So this kind of custom was there in India. So making butter lamp offering is there in all the different traditions. So when we talk about light lights, offering light, it symbolizes dispelling darkness of ignorance and illuminating the wisdom light of wisdom. So the real lamp has to be lit inside.
Wisdom that has you have to develop. But then if you make this offering, you can make your prayer also to dispel darkness of ignorance and to brightly lit the lamp of wisdom inside. So if the butter has gone bad, then it’s better to make offering rather than taking it yourself because you can’t take it. Rancid butter cannot be taken. So use butter for food, but then when it becomes rancid, use it for butter lamp.
All Tibetans say that we are Buddhist. When we when we are students and when we study for our examination, It seems that we are working mainly for studying mainly for getting good marks in our exams and not There is this mentality that people are satisfied if they pass their exams. Even if I have to live in hell being for eons for the sake of a single sentient being, may I be able to do so and perfect the practice of joyous efforts. So these are really great prayers as long as space endures and so forth. A great prayers, very profound.
But we started the Tibetan schools with a great hope. But as I said in the beginning that we have not been able to fulfill the goal as we set the goal in the beginning. Then so this is one reason. Look at the Chinese students who come to go to America to study. And then after finishing their studies there, of course, the Chinese are much more in number.
Right? So in America, if you look in the universities, there are many university professors in America, Chinese professors in America, but very few Tibetans. So this is our shortcoming. So it’s not because of Buddhism. No.
On the other hand, I mean, we may also say it’s our karma and then whatever happens is because of karma. So we should not think that whatever happens to us is because of our karma. Whatever will happen to us, it will be it will be due due to our karma. And therefore, we can’t do much with by studying. So karma means action.
So so when we talk about action agent and object acted upon, we have talking about some action there. So mere causality is there in the external world as well. But when we talk about karmic causality, then it has to do with some intentional action that we create. So what this shows is that what happens to us is is a result of what we do, our actions. So when we do something good, there is good effect.
And when we do something bad, there is bad effect from that. So we should not be complacent saying that, oh, this is out my karma. And we should not also think that when something happens, this is because of this and that deity or when something bad happens, it’s just due to such an in bad influence from spirits and so forth. Buddha himself has said that sins of sentient beings will not be washed away by the Buddhas. And Buddhas cannot take away the sins, the suffering, and nor they can transpose their own enlightened qualities into sentient beings.
But by showing the reality of things, Buddha’s help sentient beings to gain liberation. So what we have done so far is just followed Buddhism as a custom. So as I said earlier, one nurse, minister of Tibet said that nothing will happen to Tibet because we are protected by all these Dharma protectors. So this is totally wrong. So we are rather complacent and lazy.
It’s not because of Buddhism as such. Greetings to all. What is the difference between I and my my consciousness? First, his own is would like to ask him a question. Where is I?
When we were taught by our teacher in Bylakuppe that the Tibetan the religious instructor said that we when you have to point to the I, we cannot find it, actually. Buddha himself has said that these psychophysical aggregates are empty and therefore there’s no I or self. The consciousness is not the self, but it’s a basis on on the basis of which we can actually label an I. So all the Buddhist philosophical schools which say that it must be we must be able to find things when if we do analysis and of them. And Cittamātra’s talk about the as the instance of the eye, the true eye.
So apart from these philosophical systems, master Nāgārjuna and his followers We see that this self is not inherently existent, not only this self, but this aggregates, the psychophysical aggregates, which are the basis of designation of the I. An I are also devoid of any intrinsic existence. Of course, an I is designated on the basis of the continuity of the mind stream. So as your teacher has sensed, the self cannot be found if you were to check into the psychophysical aggregates and try to see where it is. But then we have this notion of an I which is a solid concrete existent entity.
So this is the root of all our love and hate kind of emotions. So one scientist, psychiatrist, I think it was Aaron Beck, he told me that when we become angry at somebody, we see the other person as totally, bad. But then he said, 90% of what we see in that person, the badness is our own mental projection. So when we similarly, when we become attached to something, 90% of the attachment I mean, the beauty that we see and the thing that we become attached is our own mental projection. Master Nāgārjuna has said, karma and delusions come from distorted view, distorted conception, which is a mental projection.
So when we see something and say, oh, this is beautiful. It isn’t said because of in relation to yourself, in relation to yourself. You find it beautiful because you find it beautiful to yourself for yourself. And therefore, it’s beautiful for you. And all these are rooted in ignorance.
So the more about this will be said tomorrow. I have two questions. The first one is according to science, the plants are they are made up made up of of the same kind of cells and building blocks. But in Buddhism, we say that that plants do not have mind. Maybe the scientist that you met was somebody not so authentic kind of scientist, but scientists that I’ve met were are really top scientists.
So the scientists that I’ve met have told me that right now, they are in a stage at a stage where Say that they do not know the complete workings that the the working of the brain and brain cells in its entirety. The the function of brain is fast, but not as fast as light. But then the the working of mind is faster than light. The scientists take the explanation that’s the light that we see that’s coming to us comes has come from a star that has already become extinct. So lights may be faster than sound, but mind can travel faster than that.
So this mind whose speed is much faster than the speed of light, the scientists have not, been able to, fathom the depth of this, so far. So they are not just beginning to study about study about minds. So, of course, we are talking about life in the plants and this the animates so we talk about animate and inanimate objects. When you go into the finest particles, of course, they are same. But the difference here is whether the the both of them have the sense of recognizing things or feeling.
So in our logical text, there’s mention of the non-Buddhist logic where they say it said that the Jains say that certain plants sleep at night because they have mind because they sleep at night, but that’s not precise. So it’s not exactly the way we described the Jain thought. They have another explanation for this. So, again, Dharmakīrti has said that if we were to if Tibetan scholars in those days were to meet with a real non-Buddhist follower, we would have difficulty holding our position. So there is an awareness or recognition, perhaps the ad the plants may not have.
It’s very difficult to tell. But then because of some chemical change that are going on in there so there’s some see that if when if you have two flowers and one flower, when in the morning when you wake up, if you talk to it rather harshly and talk about its bad
Seasons of fall. And then if you’d on the other hand, if you take care of the other flower, the flower that is taken care grows much better. That’s it. So there is the in the South, there is some plant which when you touch, it just shrinks. So this is in Tibetan.
The the the term for this pliancy the name for this pliancy is shyam pa plant or something like that. And there’s another plant which if you reach nearby, it’s kind of shoots some kind of In Arizona, there is some plant which shoots when you are you reach nearby it. And some kind of, like, thorns or something gets stuck on your body, and you suffer. So it’s difficult from even from scientific point of view to say that the boundary where you say this has mind and this has no mind. And his question is about past and future lives.
In Solomon’s in his text, is the the opening the eye of wisdom, has said that the as an evidence of past life, we can see that, children, right from their young age, are able to, do things without being taught. So if this kind of evidence alone can prove past lives So even has said some things in earlier in what he has said in earlier commentaries to Indian text were rejected later on. So perhaps I should say this. So what I have written in my book is actually said by Jetsün Jamyang Shepa in his great book on the philosophical tenets. So these these are evidence that are quoted.
I also have some doubt about them now because these maybe some have to do with our physical buildup. So it’s maybe biological. For example, if some kind kind of turtle, the mother gives birth to the children, And then the children have never have any interaction with their mother. So there is no where animals like a turtle where the where the mother and the children have no connection, physical connection with each other in terms of their mother nurturing the children. We have to check whether they can actually have love for each other if we put them together.
Where there is need for nurturing, for survival of the child, depending on the mother, there is, of course, the the biological biological connection between this I mean So it seems this kind of thing have to do with biological factors. So a child’s looking for their mother’s breast and for milk may have to do with some biological factor. If you look at the earth form, it has to survive on the soil. So it can it doesn’t survive on milk. So therefore, it eats earth.
And similarly, the birds and butterflies, if you look at where the mother lay their eggs and then where the caterpillar and then it’s when once the it grows into caterpillar, The mother lays its egg on a leaf, which the caterpillar can actually eat. So these all have to all do with biological factor. So the mother doesn’t lay an egg somewhere where the leaf that the caterpillar needs is far from it. So these may be from these evidences may be difficult to try to prove that there is past life. So if you have to use this kind of evidence that are quoted in Jamyang Shepa’s great book of philosophical tenets to prove that it’s past life, then, of course, we would have to also say that all of us have been drinking certain milk of the, you know, previous lives all the time, and that’s not the case.
But the main reasoning that should be used to prove past and future lives is has to be that consciousness cannot come from something which is not consciousness as as its substantially substantial cause. So this is the main reason to prove. So similarly, some matter has to have a substantial as its substantial cause, something which is a matter. Or So we have to make the distinction between the substantial cause and contributing factors or conditions. So scientists, so far have not been able to, recognize the mind or consciousness as such.
So we are, scientists say that we they are actually just not able to explain the whole thing about mind and our brain. So see you tomorrow. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- guru yoga lama nel jor (Tib)
- A practice in which one views the guru as inseparable from a deity or the Buddha, in order to amass the two collections of merit and wisdom and to purify negativities and obscurations. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- pandita khäpa (Tib)
- Scholar; learned person. Often referred to as pandit, (without the final a), which is the Hindi pronunciation of the Sanskrit. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.