47 min · 2,418 words · 13 August 1993
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues an earlier session on past rebirth by presenting reasoning for future rebirth, drawn from Dharmakirti’s verses: once causes and conditions (karma and afflictive emotions) come together, a result must follow, illustrated with planting a crop and baking a cake. It then explains the process through the twelve links of dependent origination, from ignorance grasping at a truly existent self, through karmic potencies and craving at death, to the intermediate state and conception.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1993-08-13
Duration: 48 min
UUID: 4cdb05e2-1b45-4621-930f-63f9fd0b3e9b
Words: 2,414
Quoting from a verse by Dharmakīrti which sets out the reasoning establishing future rebirths. So previously, we have discussed the reasoning establishing past rebirth. And now briefly, we’re going to discuss reasoning which establishes future rebirth. So out of the various reasons that were set forth in establishing the existence of past rebirths, these indirectly — or by the way — establish the existence of future rebirths. So how is this establishment presented?
Previously, in establishing past rebirths, we took as an example the knower or the consciousness of the baby infant immediately upon birth. And that consciousness of that just-born child has a previous consciousness of a similar type in a continuum to itself. And this previous consciousness was the consciousness of the fetus in the womb. And working backwards, proceeding backwards, that this consciousness also had a preceding consciousness in the continuum, and that this consciousness was the consciousness of the continuum of that being within a previous life.
And this consciousness had a previous moment of consciousness in the same continuum, and this consciousness was that of a previous life. And going backwards, that consciousness had a consciousness that was the consciousness existing within the previous life of that life. And backward — three or four reversals — and so we can go infinitely backwards without beginning. So we can take ourselves as a basic illustration and establish that previous to our present birth, we took a previous rebirth.
And from that previous rebirth, we took the present rebirth. And just as we took a subsequent rebirth relative to our previous rebirth, we will again take a subsequent rebirth relative to this life. So we said that rebirth is assumed in dependence upon two factors — that of causes and conditions. The causes are karma or actions. The conditions are the afflictive emotions. So from a previous rebirth, we took rebirth in the present life as humans, under the influence of karma and afflictive emotions.
And likewise, under the influence of the causes and conditions of our present karma and afflictive emotions, we will take rebirth in our future life. So we have taken rebirth in the present life in dependence upon simply these two factors — the factors of karma and afflictive emotions. Nothing more is needed than these two factors in order to take rebirth; our present embodiment was assumed under the force of karma and afflictive emotions.
And likewise, our future rebirths will be assumed under the force of karma and afflictive emotions. As we were previously reborn under the same forces, nothing more is needed to bring about rebirth. We have at present karma and afflictive emotions. So once these two causes and conditions are complete, then the result will definitely arise — that is to say, future rebirths.
We can understand this quite readily. So the text actually states in explaining this as follows: that we will take a future rebirth through the joining of our present consciousness, extending it into a future state of rebirth — that there will be a joining of our present consciousness with a future state, just as there was a joining of our present consciousness from a previous rebirth. And what is the reasoning which supports this? We were presently born from a previous rebirth due to the complete aggregation of causes and conditions — karma and afflictive emotions.
Likewise, in the course of this life, once those causes and conditions are complete and aggregated, there is no reason why we will not take rebirth. So if we present an analogous type of reasoning: that last year, a field was planted, and in conjunction with the causes and conditions being present, a crop arose, a crop grew. Likewise this year, if we were to bring about the complete aggregation of similar causes and conditions to what we did last year in the planting of the crop, then there’s no reason why a crop should not again grow. The only reason it wouldn’t grow again is if there were not present the same types of causes and conditions which were relied upon last year to grow a crop.
So upon the aggregation of those complete causes and conditions, just as last year’s crop grew, this year’s crop will grow. So this same reason can be applied to anything. Just as in the case where if we bake a delicious cake — that delicious cake came about through bringing together a complete set of causes and conditions, and dependent upon that aggregation of causes and conditions, we had a delicious cake — so if we did that today, there’s no reason why tomorrow again, if we aggregate the same types of causes and conditions, we cannot bake another delicious cake.
So the quality of the result is dependent upon the quality of the cause. As Dharmakīrti says in the text: upon the aggregation of the causes, a result will definitely arise. Once the causes and conditions are complete and there is an aggregation of these causes, there is nothing which can prevent the arising of the result. So again, quoting a verse by Dharmakīrti where he says: once the necessary causes and conditions are complete, then in the coming together — in the one aggregated — there is no preventing the mind of ourselves as ordinary persons from connecting with the mind of a future rebirth. There is nothing which can prevent this arising of such a type of result.
So I think it would be extremely useful, in coming to an understanding, to explain this in terms of the twelve links of dependent origination — this is an extremely profound means to understand this. So in the explanation of the twelve links of dependent origination, it describes how we are continually taking rebirths as living beings in this continual circling within cyclic existence — this continual revolving and repetition of the taking of rebirth. So we all have a conception of “I,” a grasping at an I. We say “I do” or “I go,” “I eat,” “I am making offerings,” “I am stealing,” “I am lying.” This is a continual conceiving of “I, I, I” — a grasping at the I.
So in general, the I exists. It is conventionally existent. But we consider the I as being other than merely nominally existent — we conceive it as being intrinsically existent or truly existent. The I arises in dependence upon parts, in dependence upon causes and conditions, in dependence upon being imputed by names, by terms.
But the I appears to ignorance in a different manner. It appears, under the influence of ignorance, to not rely upon causes and conditions, not rely upon its parts, and not rely upon terms or language. It appears to exist independently. So we adhere to this appearance, and this is ignorance. If someone were to call us a bad name and we say, “You can’t call me that!”
And at that moment, in thinking this, one is grasping under the influence of ignorance to a truly existent I. Motivated thereby — with this ignorance as a basis — there then arises anger. Out of anger, we are motivated to think, “I’m not going to let him get away with this.” And we return — we say some kind of hurtful word in return, creating karma, a negative action.
And that is to say it’s a negative karma. And karma is a mental factor. Having created this negative karma, it produces a potency which is then implanted on the mind. It’s like printing on paper — the potency is the print or the ink, and the paper is like the mind.
So this karmic potency is imprinted on the mind. So if we were to present a metaphor for what we’ve just talked about, we can compare the farmer — the farmer is the planter of the seeds — and this is comparable to ignorance.
The field in which the seeds are being planted is comparable to the mind. And the actual planting of the seeds in the field is comparable to the karma latencies being impressed or implanted in the mind itself. So this person, having had this action potency placed upon their consciousness, eventually reaches a moment of death. And at the time of their death, the thought arises that now I am being separated from my body, and fear arises. So at this moment, the mind begins to consider what type of rebirth it’s going to take.
There arises a craving to take rebirth, to re-embody. The attachment to re-embody arises at this point. So at this point, there rises in the mind craving. And this craving acts to increase the potency of the latency which has been previously planted in the mind. We said that this potency was implanted like the imprinting of ink upon paper.
The craving acts as a condition increasing the potency of this latency — just as if there was a seed planted in the earth and we watered it, that moisture would increase the potency or begin to bring about the germination of that seed. Likewise, this craving acts as a condition to increase the potency of that previously implanted latency. So if one again and again waters the seed, there would arise a moment when the sprout was just about to burst forth — just about to grow. So likewise, due to the increasing desire or craving at this moment, there is increased potency which will seek to assume a re-embodiment; it is becoming increased and one is just about to take such an embodiment, just about to take rebirth.
When the potency is increased to the point where one is just about to take a re-embodiment, then this is the moment of death. So upon death, one becomes an intermediate state being. One has separated from the body of that life and assumes an intermediate state body, becoming an intermediate state being. An analogy would be: just as in the case where we were going to travel to India — upon leaving Australia, there is a time interval before we arrive in India, a time gap between leaving and arriving in India. And likewise, one was an Australian and one died and was going to take rebirth in India.
Before the actual taking of rebirth, there is a gap. This gap is the intermediate state. So the intermediate state being is searching for a place to take rebirth. The place of taking rebirth is going to be governed by the type of action. If it was a negative action, then perhaps — just by way of example — we could say that the result would be taking rebirth as a dog.
And the intermediate state being would arrive at the place where the future parents were coupling or having intercourse. There would have to be some relationship — there would exist a relationship between the intermediate state being and these particular parents. Then the consciousness of the intermediate state being would enter into the union of the sperm and egg of the two coupling parents. So having the intermediate state being having entered into the union of the sperm and ovum of the parents, then begins the gestation period.
Initially, this combination is very much the consistency of water. But then it slowly begins to firm and begins to take shape. And after approximately three weeks, one can begin to discern the formation of limbs. Three months — after three months —
Then the faculties begin to be developed after about the fourth month, and then presently it begins to gain the sense powers. And then it’s born, and then it proceeds to age, becoming old, dying, and then again the same process occurs — the taking again of rebirth. In dependence upon — under the influence of — ignorance, conceiving of the “I, I, I,” we generate various afflictive emotions. We engage in various types of unskillful actions: lying, stealing. We engage in all the ten unskillful actions, and due to which we take an unfortunate type of rebirth.
But again, under the same I-conception of I, we go on — “I meditate” or “I do prostrations” or “I make offerings,” “I practice generosity.” And even though it is under the influence of ignorance, we still are able to generate skillful actions. So under the influence of this skillful action — which has been imprinted on our minds, just like the imprinting of ink upon paper — at the time of death, upon the separation of the consciousness from the body of this life, there arises a craving — that is to say, a striving for re-embodiment — which activates a potency of a type of karma. And this karma, upon death, draws us into an intermediate state rebirth, attracted — due to the force of this karma — to, in this case, human parents, and we enter into the union of the sperm and ovum of these parents.
And then gradually, serially, developing through the gestation period, we are born once again. So ignorance is extremely powerful. It is always with us until we have directly realized emptiness. It is always abiding within us. And it in itself is unspecified.
It is neither positive nor negative. But under the influence of ignorance, we are motivated to create actions. If the motivating consciousness is of a positive type, then the action flowing forth from that motivation will be a positive action and create positive karma. If, on the other hand, the motivating consciousness is negative, then the action flowing from that will be negative and we will create negative karma.
So ignorance can act as a means to create both positive and negative types of karma. So our mind is continually generating various types of consciousnesses, both positive and negative. These various consciousnesses are continually arising within our mind. Sometimes it’s negative — we think in terms of wanting to hurt somebody, think in terms of speaking harsh words, or stealing, or fighting — harmful intentions.
These consciousnesses are always arising. Also, from time to time, positive states of consciousness are arising — beneficial states such as altruism, or compassion, generosity, or tolerance. And out of these we create positive types of actions and thus we create positive types of karma. So we are continually involved in creating — out of these various types of states of mind — both negative and positive karmas.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
- twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
- Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.