Compendium of Valid Cognition — 1993-08-13

46 min · 2,042 words · 13 August 1993 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Compendium of Valid Cognition (Khensur Rinpoche)
Compendium of Valid Cognition (Khensur Rinpoche)
Compendium of Valid Cognition — 1993-08-13
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Kyabje Rinpoche explores how craving functions as the operative condition that drives rebirth in cyclic existence. In this 47-minute teaching, he establishes ignorance and craving as the twin roots of suffering, using vivid analogies—barley seeds that cannot sprout without moisture, and nourishing food spoiled by poison—to show why eliminating craving is essential to liberation. He explains the three types of craving, why arhats (foe destroyers) no longer take rebirth, and why renunciation is the direct antidote to attachment. Drawing on Dharmakīrti, he traces how afflictive emotions generate karma and rebirth, then turns to the antidote: meditation on emptiness paired with listening and reflection to develop the wisdom that eradicates these roots. The session concludes with questions about where animals go at death and how different Buddhist schools understand the destination of advanced practitioners upon liberation. Suited to practitioners with some Buddhist background.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 1993-08-13 – 10B – KR.mp3

UUID: 182ffd45-18ed-4995-8aef-88a60877bb82

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Compendium of Valid Cognition

Date: 1993-08-13

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,039

This is. Ignorance is the basic cause of this process which is and it is the rebirth is established through the power of karma, actions. But is driven by craving. It there that is that which is driving or actually brings it the operative mechanism is craving. There are there are three types of craving in general.

There is the craving for happiness. There is the craving to be free from suffering and the craving for existence. That is to say, this would cover the craving for re-embodiment in the future but also craving for various material things, food, clothing, etcetera. According to a verse by Dharmakīrti where he says, under the influence of the conception and grasping at an I, craving strives for future re-embodiment. Is craving, you know, craving is grasping or the movement from an unhappy state seeking a happy state, a striving for a future happiness.

This is the main cause or very basis of rebirth within cyclic existence. And Dharmakīrti goes on, but this is echoed by various other great masters that that through the abandonment of desire then we no longer need to take rebirth within cyclic existence. The cause for taking rebirth within cyclic existence has been eliminated. If we free ourselves from craving, then there will be no drive to take rebirth within cyclic existence. So someone who has abandoned cyclic existence is termed a foe destroyer, an arhat.

And though within their mind an Arhat has the karmic latencies which could bring about rebirth within cyclic existence, there is no factor which can activate these karmic latencies. That is to say, is no craving, which is the activator, because there are no afflictive emotions, that the afflictive emotions have been abandoned. Analogy would be if we had a large container, a trunk or a box in which we placed barley barley seeds. And the barley seeds have a potency whereby they are able to generate barley sprouts. They have that potency.

But if they were stored in this box and they did not come in contact with moisture, then though they have the potency to grow a sprout, that potency would never be activated. That is to say, they would never grow a sprout because the necessary condition has not been met with. Therefore, that grain could remain in that box for fifty years or however long, it would never grow a sprout since it never meets with the proper condition. Likewise, though an individual has the karma, these karmic potencies, whereby to take rebirth within cyclic existence without the necessary condition of craving, then no matter how long a time may pass, hundreds of years, thousands of years, that they will never take rebirth within cyclic existence because the condition is never met with. They no longer have craving within their mind.

So it is said that, you know, that craving is from the point of view of taking rebirth with this cyclic existence, really a tremendous fault. It’s extremely detrimental. Craving and desire are like the bars on a prison, never allowing ourselves to be free, preventing preventing our freedom. So the antidote for craving or attachment is renunciation or the determination to be free. As was mentioned in the text, The Three Principal Aspects of the Path, where it says that the essence of the Victor’s teachings is renunciation.

It is the means by which we can be liberated from cyclic existence since it overcomes craving. It is the means of bringing about an end to craving. Due to craving, the karma for the taking of rebirth, which we have not created in the past, will be newly created. Or that craving, that karma which, due to which we will take rebirth in cyclic existence, which we have already created in the past, will be brought to fruition. Craving is actually worse than ignorance.

So our mind is like a continuous stream of water from previous rebirth continuing without an uninterrupted flow. So this continuous stream of mind is from is at times negative, at times positive. So at these times, these intermittent intervals when our mind is negative, from that we create go on to create negative karma. When it’s positive, from that we go on to create positive karma. So due to the skillful actions that we create, we go on to take rebirth and happy migrations and in dependence upon unskillful actions created, we take rebirth in unfortunate migrations.

So the foundation of this continual process of taking both positive and negative rebirths within cyclic existence is ignorance. It is the root. Ignorance is analogous to poison. So under the influence of of ignorance, we generate, various positive and negative states of mind. From skillful states of mind, we generate skillful actions.

From unskillful states of mind, unskillful actions. But even in those So we are continually creating karma. Out of these karmas or actions, there is a result in rebirth. Even from those skillful states and skillful actions, the result in rebirth is unsatisfactory. The embodiment which we assume even in a skillful state of rebirth is unsatisfactory.

The place that we are born is dissatisfactory, is unsatisfactory. The companions that we have are unsatisfactory. Unsatisfactory. The possessions that we may make use of are unsatisfactory. So whatever food we might eat, if it’s mixed with poison, whatever the quality of that food might be, it’s going to bring us suffering.

If we eat it, it’s going to make us sick. Whatever we might drink, if again, whatever its quality of that drink might be, if it’s mixed with poison, it’s going to bring us suffering. So, you know, if we’re not simply talking about eating some kind of food which has gone bad and eating that and it will make us sick. You know, there’s no need to talk about that as having that result. But we’re talking about even good food.

If it’s mixed with poison, it brings us suffering. And here, you know, ignorance is being compared to this type of poison, that it always brings about a result of a level of suffering, even in the course of a human life, which in general we can say is like good food. But but because it it meets back to ignorance, it has its roots in ignorance. It is as if mixed with some type of poison. And therefore, even in the general goodness of a human life, we experience suffering.

Even also skillful actions, because when they’re mixed with ignorance, the poisoned, the poisoned mind of ignorance, That body which is a fruition of even these skillful actions is a body of suffering. And those possessions which are mixed with ignorance become possessions marked with suffering. That place that we live, since it is mixed with ignorance, is a place of suffering. And the companions that we have, because they are mixed with ignorance, meeting back to the root cause, are in the nature of suffering. So first, there is the basic cause, which is the cause ignorance, the poison of ignorance.

But then this is the basic cause. But this, it is our, it is the condition of craving which establishes establishes the result. So both of these are like poisons since they are both afflictive emotions. The basic cause is ignorance, but the condition is craving, bringing about a resultant suffering. If we would eat food which was not mixed with poison, that would be happiness.

So if we are to be free from suffering, we have to eliminate these poisons. As long as these poisons are not eliminated, we are never liberated. As long as these poisons are not eliminated, we are not liberated. If through our through our meditation, meditation on emptiness, gaining gaining realization, and when we develop generate a very powerful wisdom, then we can eliminate this root poison. So therefore, we have to meditate well on emptiness.

And to do that, we have to have strong wisdom. And that wisdom, that that powerful wisdom arises out of the activities of listening, reflecting, and meditating. So the the time is finished. We’ll take a few minutes for questions. So the four elements arose in dependence upon the karma of living beings.

And other than that, Vasubandhu says that all the varieties of the world arose in dependence upon karma. In general, there is the world which consists of the inner living being and the external environment. And both arise in dependence upon karma. The the cause of the elements is karma.

The the it is the intentional actions. And so the elements arise from intentional actions. But the mental factor of intention does not arise from the elements. Results arise in dependence upon causes. The cause of the elements is karma, and karma arises out of the mind.

Therefore, the mind is the cause of the elements. So I was, I actually appreciate the question, you know, like for example, the the when a leaf falls from a tree, what what is the cause of that? And that’s that’s from the out the natural outflow of the the the leaf having losing its ability to to remain connected with the tree. Its potency is exhausted and it drops from the tree. Then I went on to ask, well, how about when I’m walking down the street and and a a branch falls down on my head?

What what how does that come about? And so that’s a combination of two of two factors. One is the natural this natural flow of the the the within the environment of cause and effect that the the limb weakened and fell. But also, I had the I had the karma to be at that place and have that branch fall on my head. So if I didn’t have that karma, that branch could fall and it wouldn’t fall on my head.

But I had the karma and it and it was and the outflow of the natural flow of the law that cause an effect of external environment came together, these two, and therefore the limb hit me on the head. There’s a pup down the corner. Where do they go when? When they when they die? So it’s shape.

So there’s no going out of existence of one’s consciousness. One’s consciousness never goes out of existence. But as to whether what where does a pratyekabuddha go upon achieving liberation from cyclic existence? There is you know, there are different assertions with respect to this. According to one system of thought called the Mind Only school, they who assert three final vehicles.

They say that there is a an end to the continuum of the the foe destroyer. They assert there is an end to his consciousness or her consciousness. Consciousness. But those who accept assert one final vehicle. They and there is no end to consciousness that a Pratyekabuddha would go on to reside in a pure land.

Pardon? So if one resides in a in a great lotus like a room and enclosed by the petals, and one can remain there for as long as one wishes. One lives on meditative concentrations, meditative stabilizations for food.

One can fly through space. Because we in in eating food, eating the the elements and the and the evolutes, that is those materials which evolve out of the elements, we we these are very heavy, we experience a heaviness in body. But these beings, they they live on meditative stabilization. And they’re they’re they’re like very light, like clouds. And they’re able to fly.

So that would be the end of cycle. Just — they all went to a pure land? Not some? So this is the this is the goal of the Buddhism, Buddhist practice, and this is our goal. That we’re we’re all going to attain Buddhahood, and we’re all and we’re going to lead all living beings to a state to happiness in a pure land. That’s a very great that’s a great goal.

So when they were ordinary beings and not not entered in the path, then they they created vast amounts of karma. And these karma latencies have not been exhausted.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
pure land kshetra-zhuddhi (Skt); zhingdag (Tib)
A pure land of a buddha is a place where there is no suffering. LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top