46 min · 2,205 words · 6 August 1993
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk opens with a brief bodhicitta motivation, then presents Dharmakirti’s reasoning that a newly born being’s consciousness must arise from a previous consciousness, supporting the existence of previous lives. It rejects the claims that consciousness comes from the mother’s senses, subtle matter, her consciousness, or the brain, and argues consciousness is non-physical.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1993-08-06
Duration: 46 min
UUID: b9c43673-5b56-4642-9cd7-efbb33efddd1
Words: 2,201
We can take ourselves as examples and understanding how we are all troubled individually by unwanted sufferings. Likewise, all living beings are troubled by unwanted sufferings. And that in the context of holding others more dear than ourselves, developing the two attitudes of love and compassion as a prerequisite or preliminary to the development of the awakening heart. The attitude which is expressed in the words, it’d be wonderful if myself and all living beings were free of suffering and all the causes of suffering — compassion — and then love: it would be wonderful if myself and all living beings had happiness and all the causes of happiness.
In order to lead myself and all living beings to a state where they’re free from suffering, where they have complete happiness, I myself must first attain such a state — a state where I have eliminated all my various faults and brought to consummation all my excellent qualities. Having done that, then I will lead all living beings to that state. In order to achieve that end, I’m going to listen to, reflect upon, and meditate well upon the profound Dharma of the universal vehicle. According to a verse from the commentary by Dharmakīrti, which seeks to establish the existence of previous lives.
So this is discussing the verse which was mentioned last week, in which the reasoning runs as follows: that the awareness, sense powers, and respiration of the newly conceived fetus do arise in relying upon a previous type. Why? Because they are awareness, sense power, and respiration. So essentially, the reasoning is as follows.
That the baby, immediately upon birth, having a faculty of knowing, that faculty of knowing must have had a previous similar type preceding it. Why? Because it is a knower. If we an analogy would be in the case of various types of grains, whether rice or wheat or lentils, that in the case of rice that upon the growth of rice, there must have been a preceding similar type because it is necessary that there had been a previous similar type to the rice which is grown. Likewise, with having grown wheat, there must have been a previous similar type to the wheat preceding the growth of this wheat.
And likewise with the lentil, there must have been a preceding similar type which preceded the growth of this lentil. So applying this to the example that we have mentioned — the newly born infant, the knower of the newly born infant — there must have been a preceding similar type of knower having gone before. And this preceding similar type was the knower within the same continuum, but in the course of while it was in the womb — the knower within the fetus of the womb.
The knower within the fetus in the womb must again have had a previous similar type to itself preceding it, and this is the knower within the continuum of that being existing previously in the intermediate state. That knower in the intermediate state also had a preceding similar type which preceded it, and that was the knower at the moment of death of the preceding life in the continuum of that being. And this can be proceeded backwards, beginlessly. We can expand on that and take the case of an older child who has a memory of where they played as a small child. And that is to say that there was a continuity of the knower from the time of being a small child, which proceeded in a continuum up to the present of being the older child.
Why? Because the older child has a remembrance of having played as a small child. Then this can be proceeded backwards in this way. There has to have been this preceding knower gone before if one is to have a memory of past events. One cannot have memories of past events if there were not a preceding knower at a preceding moment.
So what is being asserted here is that the knower present within the newly born child arises in dependence upon a previous knower. And that was — now, where does this previous knower come from? This is where we can have some dispute. Now, if we were to examine the situation, we have the child consisting of two factors: that of form and consciousness. So if an adversary were to assert that the consciousness present in the newly born child does not come from a previous knower, but comes from form — that is to say, matter — that it has arisen from the various elements, if they were to assert that position.
So then if we were to investigate this further, as asserted by the adversary — that the knower of the newly born infant arises from matter — now there are two possible places where we could trace this matter back to, this form: the matter coming from the mother or the matter coming from the non-sentient environment, the inanimate environment. So either the form which generates the knower arises either from the mother or from the non-sentient environment. If consciousness were to be generated by non-sentient matter within the environment, then we should be able to examine the external environment and find cases where consciousness is arising within the environment from various elements — things that could arise from the soil or from the stones — that these insentient, non-sentient matters would have some type of consciousness.
They would have some type of feeling. They would experience pain, for example. And that doesn’t seem to be the case. If these non-sentient external elements, the various physical matters, did generate consciousness, then they would be living beings. They they would we we define living beings as that which possesses consciousness.
So all of these insentient matters would in fact be living beings. So if we were to say, well, the consciousness of the newly born infant does not arise from non-maternal elements, then it must arise from the maternal elements — that is to say, the matter within the mother’s own body — that is to say the consciousness of the newly born baby arises from the matter or form or material which comes from the mother. So if the consciousness of the newborn baby is said to arise from the matter or form of the mother, now there are two levels of form: there is gross and subtle.
If we look at gross first, then with respect to gross form arising from the gross form of the mother, there are again two possibilities. The gross form of the mother is constituted of the five sense powers. Now either the consciousness of the newly born baby arose from the aggregation — the combination — of these five sense powers of the mother, or from individually one of the five sense powers of the mother. The five sense powers being eye, ear, nose, tongue, body sense powers. Either the consciousness arose from one of these individually, or it arose from a combination of these five sense powers of the mother.
Now if we say that the newborn baby’s consciousness arises in dependence upon a combination of all five of these sense powers of the mother, then there would be many instances of newborn babies not having consciousness, because there are many instances of mothers not having all five complete faculties. There are mothers who are missing an eye sense faculty or an ear sense faculty. So if it took all five sense faculties coming together to generate a baby’s consciousness, and one of those five was missing, then a consciousness would not be generated because it requires a combination of all five. And therefore there would be babies born without consciousness, because there are many mothers missing one of the five sense faculties or powers. If on the other hand we say that the mind of the newly born infant arises in dependence upon individually one of the five sense faculties, then only in dependence upon an eye sense power, only eye consciousness arises.
In dependence upon ear sense power, only a hearing consciousness arises. Each of them has a specific sphere of knowing: an eye sense faculty is able to generate eye consciousness which knows forms, colors, and shapes; an ear consciousness knows sounds; a nose consciousness smells odors; a tongue consciousness tastes flavors; and a body sense consciousness experiences objects of touch. There would be no — for example, the eye consciousness is not a reasoning consciousness. It is a non-thinking consciousness.
It does not reason in terms of “this is this” or “that is that.” It doesn’t think, “Well, I did this in the past.” It does not have a memory of doing such things. So there are these faults which accrue if we assert that the consciousness of the newly born infant arises in dependence upon the gross matter — that is to say, the five sense powers of the mother. Now, the other possibility was that the consciousness is generated by the subtle elements, the form or elements of the mother.
So here, the same two alternatives present themselves. If this is the case, does the consciousness arise dependent upon each of these subtle elements, or is it necessary that it be generated in dependence upon a combination of the subtle elements? If we say that the consciousness is generated in dependence upon a combination of all of these subtle elements, then the same fault would accrue as was previously designated to the combination of the sense powers — in that if one of the elements were not present, then there would be occasions when consciousness would not be generated. If we were to assert that the consciousness arises in reliance upon — is generated in reliance upon — a single subtle element, then because there are infinite numbers of elements within the mother’s womb, there will arise infinite consciousnesses within her womb.
But on the contrary, with respect to mental consciousness, there is only one. If the consciousness is generated in dependence upon form, then it must be either gross form or subtle form, and it has been demonstrated it arises in dependence upon neither. And if it was necessary that consciousness be generated in dependence upon form, then consciousness would not be generated. But then if we were to investigate further — say it is the case that the consciousness is not generated in dependence upon form, but it is generated in dependence upon consciousness — so it is being asserted that the consciousness does not arise dependent upon form from the mother, but in dependence upon the consciousness of the mother.
And if this were the case, then if the mother were a genius, having a genius consciousness, then the consciousness of the newly born baby would be that of a genius. Or on the other hand, if the mother were intellectually handicapped, then the consciousness of the baby would be intellectually handicapped. But we know that this is not the case. There are mothers who are geniuses who give birth to intellectually handicapped infants, and there are intellectually handicapped mothers who give birth to children who are geniuses. Therefore, the the consciousness of the newly born infant does not come from the mother’s consciousness.
Then from where does the consciousness of the newly born infant arise? The consciousness of the newly born infant arises from the consciousness previous within the same continuum of that being — the consciousness previous to the consciousness of the newly born infant. It is generated from a previous moment of consciousness of the infant. There are many who assert that the consciousness arises in dependence upon the nervous system or brain.
But there are many types of sentient beings who do not have nervous systems or brains, and still they have consciousness. Celestial beings have neither brains nor nervous systems, but they have consciousness. There are many types of sentient beings who are formless, but on the contrary they have minds, they have consciousness, they have life force. Therefore it is not necessary that consciousness arise in dependence upon brain or nervous system. The brain and nervous system are physical.
They are composed of an aggregation of various particles — the earth, water, fire, and energy particles — and they are not of the same nature as the consciousness, which is non-physical. So consciousness can be cultivated. It can be developed. We can bring it to the state where it has removed all its various faults and has brought to consummation all its excellent qualities, such that it can realize objects such as emptiness and selflessness. Through reasoned analysis we can develop our wisdom to the extent where the potency of the consciousness is such that it can have direct realization of such subtle phenomena as emptiness and selflessness, whereas the nervous system and brain do not have such an ability. If the brain and nervous system were the consciousness itself, then even a dead person would have consciousness.
That is to say, a corpse would be a living being because it has consciousness, and that constitutes a living being.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.