Calm Abiding

2 h 7 min · 4,437 words · 24 April 2011 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 127-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche works through Maitreya’s verse on the five obstacles to calm abiding and their eight antidotes, using Tsongkhapa’s commentary to detail the practice. He establishes proper motivation—recognizing saṃsāra’s sufferings and aspiring for enlightenment for all beings—before systematically addressing each obstacle: laziness, forgetting the meditation object, mental sinking and agitation, failing to apply effort against interference, and over-applying remedies. For each, he teaches the specific antidote: aspiration, faith, enthusiasm, pliancy, recollection, vigilance, and equanimity. Enthusiasm emerges as the primary force against laziness. He emphasizes that true attainment of calm abiding is marked by pliancy—a transformative physical and mental suppleness that enables effortless virtue—and stresses these instructions serve both Sūtrayāna and Mantrayāna practitioners.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 24 Apr 2011 – KR.mp3

UUID: 216e2e2b-8731-4d2b-a5b8-6b9e6b64a1b8

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Calm Abiding

Date: 2011 (exact day not recorded)

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,425

Mhmm. What is it? Not today. So, today, there have been some very dark events in Tibet, in Kirti Gompa in Amdo. Some 300 monks after having been imprisoned in Kirti monastery by the Chinese authority and prevented from leaving the monastery were eventually arrested, and when resisting arrest, they were savagely beaten and their limbs were broken.

Secondly, we must make prayers for the improvement in the health of Lama Zopa Rinpoche, who was taken ill yesterday or yesterday evening while he was teaching a retreat at Bendigo. He had a stroke and he’s at present in the hospital. We must also make strong prayers for the improvement in the health of Geshe Lhundrup, the abbot of Kopan Monastery, one of Khensur Rinpoche’s students who has cancer and who was operating in Singapore. He is no longer able to eat, and they had to insert a tube to feed him. So to listen and to have such teachings explained to oneself, one must generate a powerful motivation, which is a motivation to transform this life from its present state of meaninglessness into a state of meaningfulness, and the only meaningful way to spend a human life is the practice of Dharma, nothing else has meaning.

And then practicing Dharma in this way, we ourselves have the privilege to have the freedom to practice, for Tibetans do not have that freedom, so we should practice, and we should reflect on the fact that we should place all countless mother sentient beings in a state of unalloyed happiness, and to do this we ourselves should attain the state of full enlightenment. But this is a motivation, we should engage in the three activities. So, we’ll meditate for one or two minutes, and then Rinpoche will explain the teachings. So, as the famous stanza runs, children sunk in this ocean of suffering again and again circumambulate. This quote refers to the ocean of suffering, using the metaphor of an ocean for suffering because in the self same way as an ocean subsumes a large amount of water, in the self similar self same way, our aggregates subsume a large amount of suffering.

And the sum total of our contaminated aggregates are cyclic existence. Ordinary sentient beings are referred to here as children because, generally speaking, children are considered to be those infants under the age of 10, or from 10 to 20 they would be considered as teenagers. Infants at that age are completely oblivious. They play and enjoy themselves, or fight without thinking of the moral. In the selfsame way, we ourselves do not think even of this life, let alone of future lives.

Finally, we are beings which do not understand our predicament. We do not understand suffering. For that matter, we view suffering as happiness. And in the self same way as this ocean is limitless, in the self same way, suffering is boundless. So what enables one to be freed from the ocean of cyclic existence?

It is dharma. When we speak of dharma, the foremost meaning of dharma is that liberation from cyclic existence. By extension, a Dharma practitioner is one who is striving for that liberation. Moreover, the means which lead to that liberation such as the grounds, the paths, and so forth are also called Dharma. They are the means which enable one to attain this goal.

So if one is a Dharma practitioner, one is someone who is striving for liberation, and therefore this is what we should strive for. Dharma in a nutshell is liberation. It is what is to be attained, and the means to attain it such as love, calm abiding, renunciation and so forth should be practiced for that. To attain liberation, one needs both calm abiding and insight. One needs the realization of emptiness.

To attain liberation, to gain that realization, one needs an insight which realizes emptiness. And to gain that insight which realizes one needs a calm abiding which realizes emptiness. So in dependence on that calm abiding arises insight, and in dependence on that arises the direct realization of emptiness. And therefore, one must strive for that liberation, which is a liberation from the suffering sufferings of cyclic existence. And for this, one needs definite emergence or renunciation.

So to attain liberation, insight is necessary. Insight falls within the category of wisdom of the three trainings and to gain insight one needs concentration. The concentration concentration referred to here is calm abiding. To gain that, one needs ethics. Ethics refers to the restraint of bodily, verbal, and mental non virtues.

Without good ethics, it is impossible to obtain calm abiding. So in dependence on ethics, one eventually gives rise to calm abiding, then on this dependence on this one gives rise to insight. in dependence on this, one is able to get freed from cyclic existence through realizing the ultimate cause of cyclic existence, which is the ignorance apprehending phenomena as truly existent and in dependence on this, the afflictions are eliminated. So we will now pass onwards to page 25 of your translation. Rinpoche will start to explain the training and calm abiding through eliminating the five faults with the eight applications.

The root quote which teaches this is Maitreya’s quote from the Madhyāntavibhanga. Generally speaking, there are two broad categories of texts which teach how to train in calm abiding. These are Asaṇga’s Grounds of the Hearers, the Shravakabhumi, which teach the Hīnayāna presentation of training in calm abiding, and Maitreya’s five treatises, which include the Abhisamayālamkāra, the Madhyāntavibhanga, the Mahāyāna Sutralamkara, of which the Madhyantavibhanga teaches the Mahāyāna presentation. That is the one we’ll focus upon here. So if you are reading the text of Lamrim, the middling Lamrim, it is on page 25 of the English translation that this quote is translated.

And this quote starts with the verse, functionality in that state leads to all goals. So that state here refers to a state of enthusiasm which dispels all of the discordant factors with concentration and enables the mind to be perfectly serviceable. The benefits of concentration have been explained before yesterday and yesterday. Therefore, this enthusiasm should arise easily. And then having attained enthusiasm for concentration, then one can be led to all goals as stated in the second verse.

So Here, moving to verses three and four of the stanza, to attain that goal, one must first abandon five faults. These are the objects of abandonment, are to be abandoned, and they are abandoned by the means of eight applications which are the eight antidotes, the means whereby the object of abandonment is abandoned. The fourth verse, it arises from the causes taught refers to concentration which arises from the causes taught. So the following stanza lists the five faults which are to be abandoned. The first verse reads, laziness and forgetting the instructions.

So laziness is the first fault to be abandoned, which was already explained by Rinpoche as being constituted of the three lazinesses, including the laziness of discouragement, the laziness of not wanting to practice and so forth. If laziness is present, then one does not even begin to engage in concentration. And the second fault is forgetting the instruction. Forgetting the instruction here refers to forgetting the object of observation of meditation. So in this context, Khensur Rinpoche explained that the object of observation is the Buddha’s body.

If while meditating, we forget that, then we have forgotten the object, we have forgotten the basis of observation. And while focusing and training and calm abiding on the image of a Buddha’s body, if actually interferences arise, these interferences are known as sinking and agitation, and here they are presented as are counted as the third fault. And then should the third fault, which is sinking and agitation arise while meditating on a Buddha’s body, these two thoughts, sinking and agitation must be expelled, must be dispelled, not expelling them, non application is a fault. Therefore, sinking and agitation are akin to a thief which has broken into one’s house, and the first thing to do is to expel this thief from the house. In other words, to expel sinking and agitation.

Then having expelled it, once one is abiding in a state of calm abiding, should one apply unnecessarily, intemperately, the opponent forces to sinking and agitation, this is unnecessary and acts as an obstacle to maintaining the continuity of calm abiding and is therefore a fault to be abandoned. So, So, I hope you understand clearly the five faults which are obstacles to developing calm abiding, which are first, laziness secondly, forgetting the instruction, the object of meditation third, sinking and agitation And fourth, non application, should sinking and agitation arise, not put effort in eliminating. And fifthly, intemperate application: should they have been dispelled, nonetheless applying the antidotes intemperately? So at present, the five faults have been presented. And in the following stanza, the eight antidotes to the five faults are explained.

Now generally speaking, the way the eight antidotes correspond to the five faults is that since laziness is the most severe of the faults, inasmuch as it prevents us from engaging in concentration, there are four specific antidotes or applications against laziness. However, this is only the case for laziness. After this, the remaining four faults which are forgetting the instruction, sinking and agitation, non application, and intemperate application each only have one antidote. So if you count, you have four antidotes to laziness, and one antidote to each of the remaining four faults, which does indeed make eight antidotes. Now these are explained in the verses, dwelling and what dwells in it.

Dwelling here metaphorically refers to aspiration. It is that aspiration which wishes for concentration. In the same same way as if we go into a shop, we go in there with the wish to buy something. And then what dwells what dwells is actually the object which is aspired to. In other words, it is concentration.

And the following verse, cause and effect refer to the following two antidotes to laziness. So as we said, there are four antidotes. And the first antidote was explained as aspiration, metaphorically dwelling. So aspiration arises through recollecting the qualities of concentration, seeing concentration as the means to attain all of the grounds and paths, as well as the limbs of magical emanation and so forth. in dependence on this recollection of the qualities of concentration, faith initially arises.

This faith being generated or this trust being generated in turn gives rise to a striving, which is aspiration. So these are the first three antidotes to laziness, I. E, respectively aspiration, striving and faith. Faith is the cause of aspiration, therefore it is referred to metaphorically as a cause. And the result of this training is the effect, which is the fourth antidote to laziness, which is pliancy.

This is both bodily and mental pliancy. It is the result of training in concentration. So there are four antidotes to laziness, which are presented here as aspiration, striving, faith, and pliancy, both bodily and mental. This pliancy is a state of extreme bliss, and as a result of it, one meditates almost powerfully. So it acts clearly as an antidote to laziness.

This is akin, as Rinpoche says, to the situation of someone who before going in a shop to buy something, must wish to buy something. So these are the four antidotes to laziness, the first of the five faults, and verse three explains the antidote to the second of the five faults, which remember was forgetting the instruction. This referred in the context of training and calm abiding to forgetting the object of observation, which we had posited as a Buddha’s body. So the antidote to forgetting the instruction is explained in the third verse as not having forgotten the object, not forgetting the object of observation. And the third fault is both sinking and agitation.

So the antidote to the third fourth is explained in the fourth verse of the third stanza at the bottom, recognizing sinking and agitation. So this recognition of sinking and agitation is performed by vigilance. It is a function of vigilance to check if you want whether a thief has broken in or not. It is not performed by recollection. Recollection or memory is just focused on the object, the Buddha’s body, and does not check.

Therefore, vigilance is what checks whether or not sinking or agitation has occurred. So it is because vigilance which checks is of the nature of wisdom that it is able to investigate whether or not sinking and agitation have arisen. And while vigilance actually recognizes whether or not sinking and agitation have arisen. Vigilance itself does not expel them, it does not extinguish them, it merely ascertains the fact. The same way as having checked whether or not a thief has broken in, you need a friend to kick the thief out.

So the friend which helps vigilance is the actual application to abandon those in verse five, which includes enthusiasm. Therefore, vigilance checks and the application and enthusiasm expel. And the final verse, when they are pacified entering into calmness, refers to the eighth antidote to the five faults. So once sinking and agitation have been recognized by vigilance, and they are no longer present, one must maintain the continuum of concentration and the continuum of concentration is maintained by not applying intemperately. This causes interferences to the practice.

So this is the root verse of Maitreya, and at the bottom of page 25, from the small two seventy three onwards, have Tsongkhapa’s own commentary on this verse, which we should read. And then we will analyze Tsongkhapa’s commentary in that quote, in other words, Maitreya’s quote, that state is that state of the beginning of an enthusiasm striving to dispel discordant situations from which a concentration of a functional mind arises. So Khensur Rinpoche explained that to give rise to calm abiding, one must first eliminate the first fault, which is laziness, and the antidote to this is generally speaking enthusiasm. This enables the mind to become serviceable. And in dependence on this, just on Tsongkhapa’s commentary reads, moreover since it is the state of the limbs of miraculous emanation which fulfill all goals, such as the attaining of the clairvoyances and so forth, it leads all goals.

Attaining means here to obtain. Concentration arises from the causes taught abandoning the five faults with the eight applications. So the causes taught abandoning the five faults refer to the antidotes which in turn act as a cause for the dawning of concentration. And then the first of the faults, while practicing the fault of laziness: since it does not connect to concentration. So two verbs are used here in Tibetan, jawa and drubpa.

One means to practice and one to attain. Here it is in the context of practicing and attaining. Then the fault of laziness prevents the attainment. It prevents one from attaining the concentration one is aiming for. And the second fault is forgetting the instruction or striving at concentration, the fault of forgetting the instruction.

Since there is no meditative equipoise of the mind on the object once the object has been forgotten. So as you remember, Rinpoche first explained the fault of laziness and the four specific antidotes to laziness, starting with striving, faith, and so forth. And at present, we pass onwards to the second fault. Here in the text, striving at concentration means attempting to engage the mind in concentration. The fault of forgetting instruction refers to forgetting the object of observation on which the mind has been placed.

This occurs through distraction, in Tibetan. Distraction means that the mind turns to something other than the object of observation, whatever it may be. And then if this is the case since one has forgotten the object of meditation, there is no meditation. What meditation could there be? So if we are meditating on emptiness and we actually forget emptiness during the meditation, there is no longer any meditation on emptiness.

And then the third and fourth faults are at the bottom of page 25, the faults of sinking and agitation: since these two make the mind non functional. So here, one of the meditative equipoise, the factor of vigilance, the mental factor of vigilance, examines carefully whether sinking or agitation occur or not. Understands that they do occur, and having identified them in turn through the force of enthusiasm, they are eliminated. Otherwise, these two make the mind non functional. Now when one meditates in this way, it is important that while recollection is focused single pointedly on the object of meditation.

Vigilance checks to see whether or not sinking and agitation occur. The fourth fault at the beginning of page 26 is when sinking and agitation have arisen, the fault of non application, since there will be no pacification of those two. Here, sinking and agitation arise, but lacking the enthusiasm of exertion, one does not make effort to expel them. Then the mind becomes non serviceable, and in dependence on this non serviceability, it is not possible to attain calm abiding. Therefore, one must put effort in the elimination of both sinking and agitation.

And the fifth fault, when free of sinking and agitation, the fault of application, correct the text from attention to application. So, this is a fault which occurs when upon eliminating sinking and agitation, one nonetheless intemperately engages in the application of the antidotes. Having eliminated sinking and agitation, one must then dwell continually in meditation. And the intemperate application of the antidotes interferes with this continuum and becomes a fault. And if sinking and agitation are counted as one in the commentary, this makes five.

However, is also said that there are six differentiating them in keeping with Kamalaśīla’s stages of meditation. So if one counts sinking in agitation as one, one ends up with five faults. However, Kamalaśīla stages of meditation separates them, and then if one counts them in that way, one has six faults. And the applications must therefore be used as antidotes to eliminate the five faults. And the eight antidotes on your root text, page 26, which are the eight applications, which are the antidotes abandoning those: the four antidotes to laziness: faith, aspiration, striving, and pliancy, and Khensur Rinpoche glosses striving, in Tibetan, as enthusiasm.

So we have the four antidotes to laziness which have just been explained, and then the four remaining of the five faults which are listed: forgetfulness, sinking and agitation, non application and intemperate application. Each one of these has its own antidote. The antidote to forgetfulness is recollection, and then each of the remaining ones has its own antidote. And we can see that the antidote to the second remaining fault, forgetfulness, is recollection. The antidote to the third of the remaining, sinking and agitation, is listed in the text as vigilance, even though in actuality vigilance is not the antidote.

It is the mental application to sinking and agitation detected by vigilance, which becomes the antidote. This mental application eliminates sinking and agitation. Then, finally, the fault of intemperate application, once sinking and agitation have been dispelled, is eliminated by an equanimity set in calmness. In other words, Rinpoche says, by non application which maintains the continuity of the flow of concentration. And therefore, since these instructions are shared both by the Sūtrayāna and by the Mantrayāna, one should not think that these are specific instructions for the Sūtrayāna In the context of Anuttarayoga tantra, for instance, calm abiding is generated at the level of the subtle generation stage from within the coarse and subtle generation stages.

So it’s not the case that these instructions on calm abiding are needed in Sutrayana and and unnecessary in Mantrayāna, they are needed in both. And our text adds, since they are explained in numerous sets of highest yoga tantra And then the following outline, in dependence on that, the stages of generation of calm abiding. This is a presentation of the generation of calm abiding or mental abiding. in dependence on the Grounds of the Hearers, which presents a lower vehicle generation of calm abiding. It’s a chart which has been handed to you.

It includes presenting the nine levels of calm abiding, the six forces, the four mental applications, and so forth. Since this is very detailed and difficult, Rinpoche would not enter into that here. And it would seem that for us, the foremost obstacle is laziness, and the foremost antidote to laziness is enthusiasm. So if we look at the four antidotes to laziness, in reality of the four, enthusiasm, striving is foremost. And the three remaining ones, which are aspiration, faith, and pliancy are merely branches or cooperative conditions of enthusiasm.

If one has enthusiasm, it is not possible for laziness to arise. They are foes. Through enthusiasm, it is possible to dispel completely laziness. Now enthusiasm arises through recollecting the qualities of concentration. These great qualities which mean that concentration gives rise to all of the the qualities of the lower and the greater vehicle.

If in dependence on these of on concentration, these qualities of the lower and the greater vehicle arise, then recollecting these qualities, we give rise in the next step to faith or trust. And in dependence on this faith or trust in turn enthusiasm will arise. In the same same way as when we want to buy something, we first convince ourselves of the qualities of what we want to buy, and then the powerful wish to buy it arises, and we give ourselves a means to do so by accumulating money. In the same same way, on the basis of enthusiasm, in turn we would engage in the practice of calm abiding, and in dependence on that we will gain pliancy. So, will jump onwards to the criterion of attaining calm abiding through having meditated on page 32 of your English translation.

So this has to be understood in terms of three subdivisions. The first is teaching the limit between not having attained calm abiding and having attained calm abiding. The second is teaching generally the manner of progressing on the path after attaining calm abiding. And the third is specifically teaching the matter of progressing on the worldly path. So regarding outline 3.1, the limit or the boundary between not having attained and having attained calm abiding is the presence or the absence of pliancy.

As is explained at the bottom of page 32, since the existence or not of the attainments of this concentration hinges on whether pliancy has been obtained or not. If one has not obtained pliancy, although the concentration is concordant with calm abiding, it is not actual calm abiding. A concentration without pliancy is a concentration which may lead to calm abiding. It is not a fully characterized calm abiding. And Rinpoche says that the quote from Kamalaśīla’s middling stages of meditation in the middle of page 33 is critical for this.

In that way, having trained in calm abiding when one’s body and mind have become pliant at whichever period, and the mind has become powerful regarding whichever object of observation it wishes. At that point, one is to be known as having attained calm abiding. So Kamalaśīla’s text seems to indicate that not only bodily but also mental pliancy are necessary as a criterion for calm abiding. And at present, we have to address the features of calm abiding. So as is said in Lama Tsongkhapa’s song of realization: place the concentration in a mountain-like fashion on the object of observation.

Once one has done this, both body and mind become serviceable, you know. Become serviceable. The serviceability means that they can be turned towards towards whatever virtue one wishes to turn them towards. There is not the slightest effort to be engaged in when the body engaged in virtue. And when this is led to its culmination, one has attained pliancy.

Pliancy is initially mental pliancy and is followed by bodily pliancy. When bodily pliancy has been obtained, one can engage effortlessly in whatever virtue one chooses to engage in. And at this point, there is a portion, a material portion within one’s brain, which opposes the body’s engagement in virtue. This is eliminated. As a result of this, a tremendous feeling of bodily bliss arises, and one’s body becomes perfectly suitable for virtuous activities.

Now there’s a famous story which is said about this in the context of Milarepa’s life. Jetsün Milarepa was in meditation, and he was helped by his sister who brought him to eat and so forth. And Milarepa had no clothing, so his sister was embarrassed for him and she brought him some rags to cover his private parts. And Milarepa laughed at her her and said, there is no reason for me to be ashamed of being in the state. This is how I was when I was born.

You, however, should be ashamed of your attitude. Said, I have been accustomed to lives as a deity, as a Gandharva. On your side, you have been accustomed to behaving as a dog in a sty. So we ourselves eat filth all the time. We eat fish, we eat swine flesh, we eat beef, we eat vegetables, we eat bread, and as a result of this, our bodies are filled with garbage and are heavy and weighed down.

However, once one has attained, like Jetsün Milarepa, calm abiding, then one no longer eats gross food, one instead nourishes oneself from the food of concentration. And as a result of this, one’s body becomes light and subtle, and it is possible to fly easily. And if we attain the bodily and mental pliancy, and pliancy comprises a syllable in Tibetan which means purification, in other words, refers to the purification of body and mind, then coarse body and mind are left behind. Behind. The body becomes of the nature of wind or of air, it is light and easy to control, the mind likewise is fully serviceable and we can remain for months or years in meditation without moving out of it.

So Rinpoche says this is really worthy to strive for. Months. So we don’t meditate. We eat pork. We eat fish.

We eat beef. Sleep. Run around dancing. Time flies. It is said that with enthusiasm, there’s nothing which cannot be attained.

And without enthusiasm, one’s wisdom is like a corpse, so we lack enthusiasm. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
generation stage kye rim (Tib)
The first of the two stages of Highest Yoga Tantra, during which one cultivates the clear appearance and divine pride of one’s chosen meditational deity. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Highest Yoga Tantra Anuttara Yoga Tantra (Skt); la na mä pä gyü (Tib)
The fourth and supreme division of tantric practice, sometimes called Maha-anuttara Yoga Tantra. It consists of the generation and completion stages. Through this practice, one can attain full enlightenment within one lifetime. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Sutrayana döi thegpa (Tib)
The Sutra Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Paramitayana; the non-tantric path that encompasses both Hinayana practices such as the thirty-seven wings of enlightenment and Mahayana practices such as the six perfections... LYWA
three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top