Bodhisattvacaryavatara — 2017-09-03

50 min · 2,531 words · 17 September 2003 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Bodhisattvacaryavatara (Khensur Rinpoche)
Bodhisattvacaryavatara (Khensur Rinpoche)
Bodhisattvacaryavatara — 2017-09-03
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 50-minute commentary on patience from the Bodhisattvacaryāvatāra, Kyabje Rinpoche teaches why attachment and hatred bind us to worldly concerns, and how abandoning these eight worldly preoccupations is foundational to practice. He presents three types of patience: willingly enduring suffering, not retaliating when harmed, and cultivating discriminative awareness of the Dharma. The core teaching is counterintuitive—suffering is beneficial because it motivates renunciation, the wish to free ourselves from cyclic existence. Unlike beings in higher realms who experience no hardship, humans in our world have abundant opportunity to practice precisely because we encounter real suffering. This human realm, Rinpoche explains, is where the Buddha taught most extensively because the conditions here support genuine transformation. A Q&A follows on the nature of physical and mental experience.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2017-09-03 – 3B – Patience – KR.mp3

UUID: cb73e406-eb68-4df1-afde-ca35f22307f8

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Bodhisattvacaryāvatāra

Date: 2017-09-03

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,531

Neutral person, if they receive happiness or if they receive harm, we don’t get any anger. And the reason this all happening in our life is we have so much attachment and hatred. And due to those two afflictions, and, you know, and and we’re living in a very much life that worldly eight worldly Dharma. And therefore, Rinpoche said, it is very important to us to try to to If we less use eight worldly Dharma or the if we try to abandon eight worldly Dharma, then, you know, the there will be a less generate those two afflictions, say, like attachment and hatred. And is it would be good if we understand what it means, what it might mean.

And said that due to our we’re living in such We have a great attachment towards the food and clothes and home. And the what is that? And and if you gain something, then you have so much craving. And and at first, I can tell you that gain, loss, and pleasure, and misery, and praise, and degradation, and fame, the reputation, and infamy. And and if somebody says some good things towards and you’re liking so much, and if somebody says some nasty things towards and you dislike all the your misery, all that, I remember that this we have to try to abandon, you know, try to not leave, not engage on those.

And great the Mañjuśrī said that one of the Sakya Pandita’s teachings is about the four separations: Parting from attachment. Sorry? Parting from yeah. For attachment. And if you attach on this life and you’re not Dharma practitioner.

If you attach on the cyclic existence, then you have no renunciation. And if you have self-cherishing, then you will never be able to generate bodhicitta. If you have If you have a self grasping, you know, towards self grasping, then you will never gain realization of selflessness. And this four is very important, therefore, if you engage your practice, then you have to give up worldly practice. If you give up your life for the Dharma, then you are engaging in all the Dharma practice.

If you’re engaging a a a role in Dharma, then no matter what whether somebody say nasty towards you, you will never rise anger. Or the either way, the if you if your enemy if somebody says towards a good thing towards the enemy, then you don’t have a rise any anger. And if you are an authentic practitioner in Dharma, then if we give up, you know, our life into Dharma practice, then, you know, in it will prevent so many falls in our life. And due to we don’t able to give up that this life, then, therefore, we have so much create negativity. And when we say give up our the life, that doesn’t mean we to go naked like Milarepa or in a staying in a in a cave in a naked.

And if you but we can do practice, you know, if you have less attachment and towards your life and livelihood and and content, you know, if you have those two and and we can practice that. And these two words, if we can engage those two words in a very authentic way, said this great precious two words are like the less attached and contentment whatever you have. And here we have to talk about today how we can practice patience towards when we raise anger. And in a patient, there is three types of patience. And patience of willingly enduring suffering, and patience of not retaliating against someone who harms you and patience of discriminative awareness of the Dharma.

And we have experienced happiness and the suffering. And the happiness that we experience is very minor. And the sufferings that we have experienced are more than the happiness. And the reason that is we have less creating a cause of happiness, and we are creating a most causes of suffering. Therefore, we experience more suffering and than happiness.

And happiness and the suffering is dependent on how much causes that we have. And because we don’t have get much experience on happiness, because we don’t have enough causes of happiness, and but we have again, we experience more in suffering. That is the reason because we have created lots of negative karma. There is more cause of negative karma, which is cause that created through the body, speech, mind. And definitely we will we do experience more into suffering.

Reason because we have so much causes of suffering and therefore we have to experience. But here what we have to do is we tolerate or the tolerate or the we patient towards the suffering. And here that the first, there is the three types of patience, and the first one, patience of willingly, enduring suffering. And because Rinpoche said that we have so much causes, therefore we will, you know, we have no chance to escape away from, you know, experience suffering. Therefore, it is what we have to do here is to use patience as the antidote.

And be happy. And when you experience the suffering, we have to enjoy or to say grateful. And reason why we have to say that, you know, grateful? Because due to suffering and said, we have to when we experience suffering, we have to meditate on it. And if we meditate, you know, contemplate again and again into that suffering and to see you can more interest the why the suffering’s coming and and the faults of the sufferings. When you see the faults when you meditate on the sufferings and what happens, then you there’s some generate mind that you have a wishing to free from that.

When you have To wish free from something. There will be a rise or the wanting or wish to free from suffering. And through that, you have to generate renunciation. And the renunciation We call it nge jung in Tibetan. And the renunciation is one of the three principal aspects of the path, and one of the precious one.

And if you have that renunciation, then you have the mind that generates to free from cyclic existence. And if you have that, then of course you have gain the liberation. What I mean is the Wishing or the desire to be free from cyclic existence and then the wish to have the liberation. That is renunciation, and it is like if you those gods in the high realms, and the reason they can’t generate renunciation is because they have no suffering at all. And very much like all the other continents like Eastern Continent, East Continent, and North Continent, those beings, they have no suffering like like us, you know, in this world.

And therefore, they find it very hard to generate renunciation. And our the present world that is we consider it is the greatest place to practice in Dharma. The reason that there is a difference in society, we’re living in some of the higher class and the lower class, and the, you know, it’s not even. And therefore, and this present world that we’re living is one of the greatest, great place to practice Dharma. And this why we’re saying this greatest place to practice Dharma is a reason that this world, we have much, much suffering, and therefore, we have a great opportunity to practice renunciation.

And and through that, we can, again, you know, free from suffering and then gain renunciation and then the wish to be free from cyclic existence. And through that, we can achieve the liberation. And he’s the Śākyamūni Buddha himself also giving more Dharma into this world than any other places. And reason because there’s more opportunity to practice all this and not only the sūtra, and he’s also given the Tantrayāna and all these various teachings he’s given into this world. And but we are here opposite.

We dislike when we have suffering. But if some really practitioner, in Dharma practitioner, if there is suffering arising within their mind, they’re more grateful, more happy. And one other reason why we’re grateful is when we have experienced suffering in you can see this. Those who have not much suffering in their life, they are more proud and more they’re into living in a very proudness in their life. And when you have experienced suffering, your proudness is a little bit go down, and you’ll be more become a little bit more humble.

Again, And when we experience suffering that diminishes all the get rid of our proudness, we become more humble. And not only that, also, we can generate renunciation. And that’s the benefit rising suffering in our mind. And when this generates renunciation, and when we see sufferings for others, also it is good for we can generate compassion. And not only that, we understand where the suffering arise from and understanding the causes of, and cause are all the the afflictive emotions, and then you have begin to to try to remove all the afflictions.

That the happiness that you’re liking and that you understand the word cause of the happiness and then you towards your to to to work towards and to create a more cause of happiness. And and again, under this. Oh. And all the Bodhisattvas, they work towards, you know, the the benefit of sentient beings. Reason they they see the sufferings of the sentient being, and then they work towards to bring happiness and to And they work towards, you know, to create merits and accumulate accumulate merits and to remove all the, what’s the word, yeah, negativities.

Therefore, we have to understand the benefits of the suffering. Now you have to understand, you know, the the suffering bring something goodness, which is all the those to renunciation and even achieve achievement of liberation. And we stop here. If you have any questions, we leave a few minutes. Just in relation to mental and physical suffering and happiness, how how is physical defined?

What do you mean? In Western philosophy, for example, one definition of physical is something that takes up space. Okay. That’s an example. Physical takes up space?

Yes. Something that is physical takes up space. Okay. Is there a similar definition for physical in in, say, Abhidharma? Okay.

Space. Yeah. So the emptiness. You can you can the physical is very easy. You can’t, you know It’s all the collections of, you know, the meat and bone and blood and all this.

So it is similar to something that takes up space that you can feel that you can touch that is like a book or No. Like this? Oh. Body. Oh, body.

The body cannot think about, but the the death, the physical, and And the said the the mental is that, you know, that wandering in our mind. That’s kinda like more into a mental, the, what do you do you call? The the consciousness. And and I asked Rumi, say, you know, when we have pain, what are those signals in the mind? Then Rinpoche said, because feeling is in the sense of touch, you know, feeling is covered in a whole body.

Mhmm. Then when we have some very minor pain, it gives signals in the mind Because there’s a feeling that gives a signal into our mind. So is the feeling actually mental or physical or both? Yeah. In the the feeling is actually not the physical, but it is what’s we call the no.

No. The subtle consciousness. Yeah. secondary mental factor. Sorry.

Yeah. Secondary consciousness. Yeah. Right. Okay.

The same kind as And the Wherever mind is, there is a secondary con mind as well. It’s very much like the the the the way, you know, boss and his servant, and boss is more like a mind, and the servant is like a secondary mind. And each each mind has five servants of the secondary minds. When those secondary minds, you know, experience of, you know, the pain, and then that signals to the the the the mental mental consciousness. Those servants when the the entourage or the Yes.

When the boss goes around, you tell the things to towards your boss, you know, all the entourage or the the servants, they tell things towards the boss. It’s very much acting like that way. Yeah. Can you repeat that again? What’s the difference between Different.

Between the world in our mind and this the real physical world Yeah. The universe. Yeah. Are we What’s the difference between our mind and the physical universe? Physical world and the universe.

Alright. And are we living in our mind, or is the the universe ourself? The our world is we call in different words, the universe as well, isn’t it? Yeah. Yeah.

It’s a it’s a synonymous universe and the world. Yeah. Is there a difference between the world we experience inside our head and the world that appears outside? Oh, okay. Is there a world outside?

There is a relationship between the universe or the for our mind or the our physical body, and but it’s not one oneness. This physical universe is arise or the came out of due to the the sentient beings karma. Therefore, that’s create the physical universe is created by the sentient beings karma. Sentient beings karma. All And so It it is like the the it is not one, but it is like the world, the universe is contained.

And what do you call inside? a container. Is a container. A container and the container. Yeah.

That’s right. Container and the container. Container and the container. And if you ask how it create the world, then because it’s due to the the the sentient beings’ karma that create this world. But there is a relationship, you know, but it’s not one.

Or is that the universe ourselves? You can say that, but it’s not one. It’s depend how you interpret the universe. You know? Depends on your your how you think or No.

There is a relationship. You know, the the world is arise out of due to sentient beings. And in karma, there is two results. You know, the the the primary result is the the the beings that generate it, and then the secondary result is like the wall that generate home. She’s what?

You clear? Not really. Not really? And great master Vasubandhu and also mentioned this, you know, in a karma, in a sentient being’s karma, there’s a result out of that that karma, and there’s a two results. Primary result is the the sentient being themself, and the the secondary result is like the universe where they have to live in it.

And this to arise from the sentient being’s karma. And you can look at the seed. Alright? Seed is the karma. And out of that seed, you produce a result.

And the result that if you it germinates. And the primary result is the actual result of that tree, the fruit itself. Then the branches.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
pandita khäpa (Tib)
Scholar; learned person. Often referred to as pandit, (without the final a), which is the Hindi pronunciation of the Sanskrit. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top