Awareness and Knowledge

1 h 13 min · 3,542 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awareness and Knowledge
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 73-minute session, Kyabje Rinpoche unpacks Je Tsongkhapa’s verses on what the Alaya Vijñāna—the mind basis of all—actually perceives. He shows why mental objects like definite emergence, bodhichitta, and the view realizing emptiness appear only to the mental consciousness, not the dull, non-analytical Alaya Vijñāna. The core teaching explores the Cittamātra view that external objects lack independent existence, through vivid examples: a car appearing clearly in a dream yet non-existent outside it, and a bowl of water seen as water by humans, blood-and-pus by hungry ghosts, nectar by gods. Rinpoche explains how one karmic imprint produces both the perceiving consciousness and the appearance. The session moves into Q&A and debate on substantial causes and cooperative conditions. For serious philosophy practitioners.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 23052017Cittamatra – KR.mp3

UUID: d9c09876-1356-4cbb-a850-992dc2fc1cb7

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Awareness and Knowledge

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,538

So in the verse, in root text of Je Tsongkhapa, as to both apprehended factors of basis of all, since they are apprehended by the five consciousnesses, and now imputed terminologically by the sixth, they are determined in both realms. Now moving onwards to the following verse on page four of your root text, objects of the sixth apart from organs of the sixth apart from organs and entities do not become objects of the basis of all, because the sixth is the imputing subject and the basis of all is devoid of apprehending the variegated. So here, objects of the six refer to objects of the six consciousnesses. The five sensory consciousness and the mental consciousness. And the objects which, apart from organs and entities do not become objects of the basis of all, include such topics taught in the Lamrim Chenmo as definite emergence, bodhichitta, or for that matter, the view, which do not become objects of the Alaya Vijñāna, although they are objects of the mental consciousness.

So in the second stanza on page four, why is it the case that objects of the six apart from organs and entities do not become objects of the basis of all? Precisely because such topics as definite emergence, bodhichitta and the view, which are taught in Lamrim Chenmo, are topics of the mental consciousness, the sixth which is taught in the third line of the stanza. The mental consciousness is the imputing subject. It engages these objects. However, the Alaya Vijñāna does not engage these objects.

And this was clearly expressed in the previous answer which begins at the bottom of Page three, directly sense organs, entities, indirectly whatever can appear as objects of its six collections is also posited as object of the basis of all. So in brief, the stanza at the bottom of page three, beginning of page four, directly sense organs, entities, indirectly whatever can appear as objects of its six collections is also posited as object of the basis of all is a general statement. It is not the case that there is pervasion or necessary entailment. In other words, everything which appears as objects of its six collections is necessarily posited as objects of the basis of all. This is not the case.

For instance, and this is explained in the following stanza, topics such as definite emergence, bodhichitta, or the view realizing emptiness appear to the mental consciousness, but are not engaged by the ālaya vijnana. So for instance, branding very spirits are very popular in Australia. However, you cannot say that every Australian drinks. There are Australians who do not drink. This is an example.

So and this can be applied to the topic we were discussing about as was mentioned in the previous stanza. In general, everything which is engaged, appears to the six consciousnesses, also appears to the Alaya Vijñāna. It is not the case however, that everything without exception which appears to the six consciousnesses appears to the Alāyavijñāna. There are exceptions, such as for instance, definite emergence, bodhichitta, and the view realizing emptiness. And the reason for this is given in the last verse of this stanza on page four, because, and we jump to the last verse, the basis of all is devoid of apprehending the variegated.

So topics such as definite emergence and bodhichitta are apprehended by the mental consciousness through repeated analysis and investigation. The mind basis of all is unable to do this. The mind basis of all is, if you wish, dull, and therefore does not do this, and this is taught by the final verse. The basis of what is devoid of apprehending the variegated, in other words, it does not analyze. So this is something we have to reflect about.

We have to reflect about to which degree the consciousnesses which follow or which are subsequent to sensory consciousnesses appear or not to the Alāyavijñāna. So what I would like you to reflect about today is this topic. The second topic I would like you to reflect about today is a statement in sūtra, nothing appears on the outside, it is the mind which appears as exterior, and also the two verses in Je Tsongkhapa’s root text in the middle of page three, since apart from appearing as form to consciousness outside, nothing exists, their meaning is precisely the same. So therefore, listen and reflect carefully. We will Bhishla will explain this briefly during a couple minutes.

This is how one engages the Cittamātra view. So how can we understand these two statements? Fundamentally, things do appear to exist on the outside. However, according to Chitamatra, the sense consciousnesses are mistaken. This is fundamentally different from the perspective of Sautratika, for which the sense consciousnesses reflect things as they exist, they are valid cognizers.

So any debate between Chitamatrans and Sautrantikas, a Chitamatrans would say to a Sautrantikas, when you say that phenomena exist as exterior entities or established as exterior entities, what you must mean is that phenomena are constituted of a conglomerate of indivisible particles. Now here, Sautrāntika asserts the existence of directionally indivisible particles. Actually, directionally indivisible particles do not exist. And Chitamatra asserts that they do not exist. Now, the Chitamatra assertion that all phenomena of the nature of mind, or merely of the nature of consciousness arises when they point out to the Sautrantikas that these directionally indivisible particles do not exist.

So you can see how the lines of reasoning follow each other. The critical point is this debate or this junction between Sautrāntika and Cittamātra. Now here Chitamatra therefore asserts that there are no directionally indivisible particle, and therefore that phenomena cannot be established as exterior entities. Yet phenomena, forms do exist. Then what precisely is the mode of existence of forms?

This is the question Chitamatra asks, and here at present we should adopt temporarily if need be the Chitamatra stance even if it is not our own for the sake of this analysis. So, Chitamatra, therefore, asserts that all forms are of the nature of consciousness. Then this would be best understood first by means of an example. All of us in this room commonly, jointly, apprehend this table. This table is apprehended by all our visual consciousnesses.

Now, when all of us look at this table, our visual consciousness apprehends the table. At that point, according to Chitamatra, what is happening is that a karmic imprint awakens or increases, if you prefer, within the Alaya Vijñāna, and it gives rise to a consciousness, one part of which is a visual consciousness apprehending the table, and another part of which is the table being apprehended by the visual consciousness. It’s elegant, isn’t it? So here, one karmic imprint acts as a substantial cause, giving rise simultaneously to both a visual consciousness perceiving table and the aspect of a table which is being perceived by that visual consciousness. Now here, you confuse frequently memories and karmic imprints.

It’s a casual usage, but they are not the same. When this happens, since the consciousness perceiving the table and the table perceived by the consciousness have one substantial cause, they are of one substance, and Chitamatra says therefore that they are of the nature of mind. Then if this is a reality, then exterior objects probably do not exist. Then there’s an example which Geshela said I mentioned, The example of which Asaṇga gives in his the example of a dream, which is a very elegant one. Please do listen carefully.

Depending on this example, you can understand easily. Otherwise, it’s difficult. Now, let’s imagine we’re in our room and we have just fallen asleep, then we experience dreams and to take an example which is more commensurate with our experience, we dream instead of a horse or an elephant of a car. Now, we dream of a very beautiful car. This car appears in our dreams very clearly.

And I would assume every single one of us in this room dreams. Some have Kerala dreams, some have duller dreams, but I would assume you all dream. Then if we take this image of the car in the dream, this aspect of the car exists only in the dream. It does not exist on the outside because if it did, then it would appear in the room while you were dreaming, which obviously it does not. Then, in the text it is said that apart from appearing, being posited, and being observed by this dream consciousness, in this case, the car, the appearance of the car does not exist on the outside.

Then this Chitamatra example is a very powerful one. It explains how apart from appearance, there are no phenomena out there. Then, this car which appears in our dream, appears very clearly, it is a source of great happiness to us in the dream, and yet it is not established in the slightest on the outside. If it were established on the outside, then it would appear in our bedroom, obviously there’s no space. So this is the example which Ārya Asaṇga gives in the Mahāyāna Saṃgraha, where there were numerous examples which is are given.

This one is particularly helpful for us. And therefore, according to Chitamatra, apart from the mere appearance of phenomena to the sensory consciousness, form and so forth are not established in the slightest on the outside. Their appearance as being established on the outside is a result of mistaken consciousnesses. Then this the purport of this explanation in Chitamatra is from the standpoint of karma, or if some of you prefer memory, it is necessary to have a receptacle for karma.

The Chittamatrans do not use the term subtle consciousness. They speak of Alaya Vijñāna or mind basis of all. Now, as you remember, every composite phenomenon necessarily has both a substantial cause and a cooperative condition. From the standpoint of Chitamatra, if we take a form such as this table, then the substantial cause of this table is the karmic imprint within one’s mind basis of all, which simultaneously gives rise to the appearance of the table and the visual consciousness perceiving the table. But the question which arises is, what is the cooperative condition of the table?

Now because there is no table out there, it becomes complicated to posit a cooperative condition. Then there is an example given in Buddhist texts, Giuseppe was asking me if you could understand it, I think you can, of a bowl of water, which is perceived simultaneously Very important, easy for you. Perceived simultaneously by three beings. Now, the human being perceives Oh, the the bowl of water as water. Then the preta perceives the bowl of water as blood and pus.

Whereas the god from the god realms perceives the bowl of water as amrita or nectar. Now, in this example, when a god, a human being, and a preta observe at the same time, the same bowl containing a fluid. All three see that which corresponds to their own uncommon karmic imprints. The god sees nectar and experiences nectar. The human being sees water and experiences water.

The preta sees blood and pus and experiences blood and pus. Now if we take a preta seeing Geshela’s cup of tea or water, that preta does not see that fluid as tea or water, but as blood and pus, and therefore, is not able to gain the benefits of water. This is the Chitamatra example. Now if these uncommon karmic appearances did not exist, then the nature of the cup of tea, the mode of the reality of the cup of tea would be to be tea for instance, and a god would see it as such, but would not see it as nectar. Now would a preta see it as blood and pus.

So everything would then occur only in terms of the common or shared karmic imprints. So if we therefore take the case of this cup of tea and its mode of appearance to a preta, A Preta sees this cup of tea as a cup of blood and pus. Then the visual consciousness of the Preta perceiving the blood and pus, and the appearance of the blood and pus arise from one karmic imprint within the Alaya Vijñāna of the preta, which is a substantial cause of that appearance. What exactly is its cooperative condition? This is actually difficult to formulate in Chitamatra, because Chitamatra teaches that there is no exterior object to the difference, let us say, of the Prāsaṇgika presentation of the appearance of this cup of tea, which would say that it is a potency in the tea or the fluid, which is a substantial cause of this tea or fluid, and the karmic imprint is the cooperative condition.

Let us now at present meditate during a couple of minutes on these examples, analyzing them from the standpoint of substantial cause and cooperative conditions. This is very beneficial. Please open the prayer book, page one. We recite. So at present, please ask your questions, and after that we will have debate to discussion.

So firstly, why do Sautrāntika assert directionally indivisible particles rather than just simply indivisible particles? It’s the same thing. Directionless particles or indivisible particles or directionally indivisible particles are the same thing. You can pass. I’m just wondering, could the a cooperative condition be that the mind bases of all possibly?

For the the maturation of the karmic imprint. It’s difficult for the mind basis of all to be a cooperative condition here. They’re not identical. So the example of the car in a dream is a case where that dream car could not exist on the outside, since if it did, obviously, would appear in the bedroom, and that is not possible. And that is used as an example for the Chitamatra view.

Then when it comes to objects in daily life, we use them. Then the degree to which this is similar or different in the dream, that calls for analysis. Obviously, cars, tables, cups, monastic vestments, or things which we use, have usages, we cannot say that they don’t have usages. If a Chitamatra were to say this, then we would have to ask some questions. Geshela, these indivisible particles that the Sautrantika says exist and the Chitamatran says does not exist do not exist.

Are they how are they posited? Are they posited as a logical necessity by the Sautrantikas or are they posited as an apprehended phenomenon? Sautrantikas assert that partless particles are posited on the basis of sensory consciousnesses. The visual consciousness specifically, and that as this the particles are divided ever more, and the visual consciousness becomes ever more acute, there is a point where one can no longer perceive a further division of those particles. So therefore from the Chitamatra view, I must purify my karma, negative karma, generate merit so that I can see not just cars but rockets.

In other words, I cannot change the world, but I can change my mind. In so doing, I change the world. The Chitamatrans refute the Sautrāntika position that objects precede subjects, but don’t the Chitamatrans commit the inverse fault of asserting that the supporting and supported mind basis of all precedes both subjects and objects? So this is the Chitamatra position. Then obviously, positions of tenets sometimes have their faults, but that is not our focus here.

The standpoint of Prāsaṇgika, the naturally, this table for instance, would be the observed condition of the visual consciousness perceiving this table. Then what precisely its relation with consciousness is in Chitamatra is a different affair? Geshela, how do Cittamātra account for how I see another sentient being? How I perceive another sentient being? Not the mad not whether they’re good or bad.

How do I actually see them? Not what? Not whether they’re good or bad, you know, but how do physically? What do you mean by your way of seeing another sentient being? I mean, is it By the visual consciousness?

Well, is it also due to a karmic imprint in the or are they saying that people exist as exterior? So here in Chitamatra, the first thing is to see what one perceives when one speaks of another being. You’re speaking of the form aggregate here. Then when one perceives a form aggregate of another being, the visual consciousness perceiving that form aggregate arises at the same time as the appearance of the form aggregate out of a karmic imprint within one’s own ālaya vijnana. But that visual consciousness is unable to know this is hero, this is so and so, this is that and that.

Immediately after it there is a mental consciousness which designates terminologically that appearance and says this is hero and so forth. Just the same as for exterior objects. I didn’t translate that. So what the visual consciousness perceives is form, and only form. Then the visual consciousness is not able to identify that form, but immediately after that, it induces a mental consciousness which through previous experience recollects, remembers what this is, and says, this is it, this that is that.

This is clearly explained in the verse of the root text on page four. Objects of the six apart, and of the six consciousnesses, apart from organs and entities, do not become objects of the basis of all. Because the sixth is the imputing subject, and the basis of all is devoid of apprehending the variegated. I have three questions. Three?

No. No. No. Just one. Just one.

So could it be that the clistamanas the afflicted mind and the mental consciousness, could they be cooperative conditions to the arising of karmic imprints in the mind or the result or the appearance of a visual object and visual consciousness? Let me rephrase that. If you’re going ask a complicated question, have to think first and ask clearly. Are the cooperative conditions the appearance of the visual consciousness and the visual object, the and the mental consciousness. We’re gonna think about it.

Very good. Geshela, I just want to go back to last week. When you actually argued that hero’s body is not the appearance to your visual consciousness. To me, and then today you’re talking about the karmic imprints is the substantial cause for anything that appears to mind basis of all. And I just want, I just find it really hard to imagine that it is my karmic imprints that creates hero’s body in my consciousness.

Certainly my karmic imprint doesn’t determine that. So what is being said is that when you look at hero’s body, what appears to your visual consciousness, that appearance to your visual consciousness of hero’s body or hero’s form aggregate, arises at the same time as a visual consciousness perceiving it from a karmic imprint in your own Alaya Vijñāna, which is a substantial cause of both. And this is similar to your experiencing a dream in which you see here. The way you should look at it is as is as follows. When you are looking at hero’s body, the appearance which appears to your visual consciousness, the aspect which appears to your visual consciousness, is that hero’s body or not?

Hero’s body is form, it’s matter. Then you have to ask yourself, does that thing exist on the outside or not? Then that appearance of Hiro’s body to your visual consciousness when you look at Hiro’s body could appear to you as pleasing or unpleasing. That appearance as pleasing or unpleasing, do you think it appears also to others who are observing Hero’s body at the same time or not? If it does not, that means it comes from your own side, from within your own karmic imprints.

I understand that part. Before you actually make a judgment, before you actually Mhmm. Before you have the preference, that appear via visual appearance to your consciousness, what is that? Here you are connecting with Sautrāntika. Sautrāntika says this exists out there.

Chitamatra says it does not exist out there. That is what we have to think about. We won’t be able to decide rapidly. So you see the Chitamatha, the excuse me, the Sautrāntika view asserts that before the perception of hero’s body, hero’s body exists. Sautrāntika says that before the perception of hero’s body, hero’s body does not exist.

Then if you accept the Sautrāntika view, then you have to go back to the ultimate constituents of hero’s body, the indivisible particles. Chitamatra says they don’t exist. So at present debate or discussion, and the topic Geshela would like you to debate is the important topic of substantial cause and cooperative condition in Chitamatra. Taking the example either of the car in a dream or perhaps better of the table of Geshela from the standpoint of Chitamatra. This is a school of tenets we should adopt.

The substantial cause of this table is a karmic imprint within the Alaya Vijñāna of the observer of the table. What is a cooperative condition? Okay. Please please, by And this is on page 21 of the auto commentary of and page 34 onwards of commentary.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
preta
Hungry ghost, or spirit. The preta realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Do the Sautrantikas posit partless particles as a logical necessity, or as an apprehended phenomenon?

The Sautrantikas assert that partless particles are posited on the basis of sensory consciousnesses, specifically the visual consciousness. As the particles are divided ever more finely, the visual consciousness becomes ever more acute. Eventually a point is reached where one can no longer perceive any further division of those particles. So the posited partless particle rests on what sensory perception can reach, and not simply on a logical necessity.

How does the Cittamātra school explain how we see another sentient being?

What is perceived when one sees another being is their form aggregate. The visual consciousness perceiving it arises at the same time as the appearance of that form, which comes from an imprint within one's own alaya vijnana (basis of all). The visual consciousness perceives form, and only form. It cannot identify who the person is. Immediately afterwards, it induces a mental consciousness, which through previous experience recollects what this is, designates the appearance terminologically and says "this is" so and so.

Scroll to Top