47 min · 2,090 words · 28 February 1989
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the nine grounds of the three realms of cyclic existence: the single ground of the desire realm, the four concentrations of the form realm, and the four formless absorptions. It describes how rebirth in each realm arises from different levels of positive or negative karma, and distinguishes contaminated from uncontaminated karma. It also explains how renunciation relates to calm abiding and special insight, and how the afflictive emotions of the desire realm cause a fall from the upper realms.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 47 min
UUID: 965fd5a9-bc68-442f-a40d-eb519eba6c37
Date: 1989-02-28
Words: 2,086
So in general time exists. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It was my confusion. Was yeah, was just checking up. The way I phrased it was the time spent in these realms about how long that’s what it came out as.
In general So they don’t have wristwatches. He said in the the upper realms they don’t have night and day as we do. Because their bodies radiate out light and it’s always light. They don’t have darkness. They don’t they the only time it becomes dark is when they close their eyes to sleep and then they get there and then they, when they get up.
But they don’t, there’s not the passing of night and days as as there is here. So the body radiates from the the light radiates out from the body. So it’s generated by karma and they consider it’s considered that stars, moon, and sun are are gods radiating out light. So it’s brighter and greater than the the the the Brighter. The Yeah.
That’s the name, man. Think see what you see what you see see have having once attained this actual level of concentration or absorption in the upper realms and due to the exhaustion of the karma. Then they do there arises there arises the rebirth in hell realm due to the force of the afflictive emotions within desire realm. And so there all this karma that they created to was exhausted. Actual level is deteriorated and their calm abiding and special insight deteriorates.
So they really don’t have much power. They you know once they just fall you know these beings they just fall down and then they develop the desire of afflictions. And they’re just like anyone else. So they such beings have really no power. So it’s not quite the same situation because the desire afflictions of the afflictions of desire realm act as an example is given that if you close the door then the thief can’t come in.
If the door is open the thief can come in. The afflictive, the desire afflictions act as if closing the door to the calm abiding and the special insight of the upper realm gods. They develop that due to exhaustion of the potential these they ripen the afflictive emotions of desire are able to overpower, able to act as a doorway to block them. Block their type of calm abiding and special insight which caused them to be reborn in the upper realms. So that blocks that.
But in that case it’s not like blocking the door. If we develop renunciation, awakening heart then these may go up and down but there’s nothing which actually it’s not like closing the door. You know we have in the past developed meditative equipoise and we can regain this ability. The door is not closed closed while we’re in this situation as we are now. But that situation of the God’s calm abiding and special insight is closed once they develop afflictive emotions of the desire realm.
They cannot, you know, it’s likely close the door on that possibility. But the door is not closed for us to keep regenerating these states. So renunciation is like the tap which turns off the water, the flow of the afflictive emotions of desire realm. Renunciation is like turning the tap and once the tap is turned then the afflictive emotions of desire realm are no longer able to flow arise. But if we don’t have renunciation then they’re able to continually flowing.
What? The afflictive emotions of the desire realm. Yes. They don’t block calm abiding. So calm abiding and special insight of themselves cannot block the flow, the rise of the afflictive emotions of the desire realm.
But the is able to to to block this flow. I just asked Rinpoche, to attain calm abiding, if you need renunciation. He says you don’t need renunciation because with non-Buddhist schools, non-Buddhist practitioners attain calm abiding. But from the Buddhist perspective they don’t have renunciation since they don’t have the determination to emerge from the three levels of suffering. The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change, but most importantly the third the suffering of conditioned existence that one must have the definite thought to emerge out of conditioned existence to have fully qualified renunciation.
Therefore, any type of simply having renunciation of desire realm would be a coarse renunciation and it depends upon that you could attain a calm abiding, but you could it wouldn’t be actual renunciation. So Rinpoche was thinking that it would a great advantage for us if we were to meet in between actual teachings and to have discussions and debate back and forth what was said and clarify doubts that this would be very beneficial that we have a teaching then we have a long break and then another teaching. It’s very difficult to keep in mind the ideas and the points that if there was something occurred between the teachings with some discussion then it would stimulate us and help us to understand and develop ourselves. We we we should we can have debates. So we can through this process we can we come up with new questions, you know, and can explore them.
So it’s necessary initially to adjust our motivation such that we’re going to listen to this teaching on the great vehicle in order to put into practice what we learn, what we understand, and thereby to achieve highest complete Buddhahood whereby to place all sentient beings equal to space in complete bliss and peace. So, by adjusting our motivation in this way, to developing a positive state of mind in order to listen to the teachings, it becomes a cause for the attainment of awakening heart which is the main cause for attaining Buddhahood. So it’s extremely hot tonight and it’s very uncomfortable physically and mentally but the uncomfortableness or the difficulty that we endure in body and mind, listening to the teaching acts as a method for purifying the negative karma that we’ve created which would cause us to be born reborn in hot hells. Last time we were talking about we were discussing the three realms. There was the realms of desire, the form and formless realm.
So the three realms represent the place in which the abiding place of cyclic existence. If we say where is cyclic existence, exists within the three realms. So if we were to further divide the three realms, then we would divide them into the nine grounds. So, dividing up the three realms amongst the nine first, with respect to the desire realm there is the single realm, the single ground within the desire realm. With respect to the form realm there are the four grounds.
That is the first is the the first concentration, the second concentration, the third concentration, and the fourth concentration. So these four concentrations are referred to as the four grounds. Then further into the formless realm there are again four grounds. There is the ground of limitless space, and limitless consciousness, and nothingness, and finally peak of cyclic existence. So, there’s limitless space, consciousness, nothingness, and peak of cyclic existence, the four grounds of the formless realm.
So the nine grounds of the three realms of the the one ground in the desire realm, the four grounds in the form realm, and the four grounds in the formless realm. We begin to an explanation of these nine grounds, first within the desire realm, the desire realm is divided into two parts itself. It has the realm of the bad migrations and happy migrations. So, if we ask you know how are these realms brought about there, they are brought up by the causes of karma and more specifically the constructive actions and destructive actions. So, as a fruit of constructive actions we take rebirth in a happy migration as either a human or a desire God, a God within the desire realm.
And as a result of destructive actions we take rebirth in a bad migration as a hell being hungry ghost or animal. So just as if as there are various degrees of quality, of sizes amongst humans, amongst things in general, there are great sizes, middling sizes, and small sizes are degrees. Likewise, with respect to destructive actions which are causes of bad migrations, there are the three levels of their quality or their degree of destructiveness. That is, and as a consequence, we take rebirth in either of the three bad migrations that as a fruit of extremely negative actions we take rebirth as a hell being for middling negative actions as a hungry ghost and for light destructive actions as an animal. Likewise, with respect to constructive actions, are three levels.
Three degrees of the negativity, the positive quality of the constructive actions due to the force of light actions. The fruit the effect is being reborn as either a human or a desire realm god. The effect of middling level of constructive positive actions would be taking rebirth as within the form realm and the greatest, most positive types of positive actions, most, the greatest, most, the strongest positive actions would have is their effect being born in the in the formless realm. Beings and this is a result of the light positive karma that we’ve created created in the past. Human and desire realm gods have as a result have as a cause light positive actions created in the past.
Now we are familiar with the human realms but they’re also within the happy migrations, the realm of the gods and there are the various realms and there are various beings. For example, examples of Indra and the various heavens. For example, the heaven of 33 Tuśita with the type of the desire realm Tuśita. These are all the various levels. The six Brahma realms are all levels within desire realm, divine desire realms.
So I think objects such as sun, moon, stars, these are desire realm gods. So these desire realm happy migration is result of the lightest types of positive karma created. Then with the middling level of positive karma the result is rebirth within the form realm as a form realm God and this are the various concentrations that are first concentration, second concentration, third and fourth concentration. So then the greatest positive result of the greatest types of positive karma are taking rebirth in the formless realm and these are the four grounds of limitless space, limitless consciousness, nothingness, and peak of cyclic existence. Now there are these are all all the various karmas that we’ve listed to this point are contaminated karma of the two contaminated and non contaminated.
Non contaminated karma would be a cause not for taking rebirth and cyclic existence but for example gaining Buddhahood. So, how does what kind of actions do we have to perform in order to create the light positive karma which take which has as a result taking birth as a human or additionally as a desire realm God. For example, in our case, we’ve in the past through the actions of ethics, patience, doing prostrations and doing our various aspirations, these are causes for achieving a human rebirth. And also abandonment abandonment of the 10 non virtue the 10 unskillful actions or on a virtue on virtuous actions, non virtuous actions such as killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, lying, etcetera. These are also also causes for taking human rebirth.
Then the the form realm is is a result of middling level of positive actions and what types of actions is it necessary to engage in order to achieve this level of rebirth. And as we’ve explained previously, that first by having accomplished having accomplished calm abiding, one then goes on to cultivate the preparations for the concentrations and then goes on to achieve an actual concentration. So the calm abiding and the meditation on the preparations are the cause for achieving rebirth in a form realm. So as we, you know, the relatively speaking the desire realm consciousness is very coarse. As we move up through the realms into the form and formless realm the mind becomes more and more subtle.
Now beginning to explain this, there are the for each of the concentrations and the absorptions of the formless realm. The concentrations pertain to the form realm, the absorptions are referred to the formless realm. For each of these there is the preparation and the actual achievement.
Key terms in this teaching
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
- The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
- The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA
- upper realms
- The three higher realms in samsara of human, asura and sura. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Do you need renunciation to attain calm abiding?
Renunciation is not needed to attain calm abiding, because non-Buddhist practitioners attain calm abiding. From the Buddhist perspective, however, they do not have renunciation, since they lack the determination to emerge from the three levels of suffering: the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change, and most importantly the suffering of conditioned existence. Fully qualified renunciation requires the definite thought to emerge from conditioned existence. Simply renouncing the desire realm would be a coarse renunciation. Calm abiding could be attained in dependence on that, but it would not be actual renunciation.