48 min · 2,220 words · 29 November 1988
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This teaching continues a discussion of the three non-virtuous actions of the mind: covetousness, harmful intention and wrong view. It explains each one’s basis, motivation, execution and completion, and the three types of each. Wrong view is identified as the heaviest of the three because it leads to harmful conduct, and the talk then begins the general outline of the ten non-virtuous actions.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 48 min
UUID: 2da51a3d-1c87-4121-ab8a-526c4bc2f029
Date: 1988-11-29
Words: 2,216
So we should initially adjust motivation such that we’re going to listen to this profound teaching within the context of the great vehicle whereby to achieve perfect, complete, peerless enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. So in the last session we discussed the various unskillful actions of the three doors. The three doors being the door of the body, the door of speech, the door of mind. And we reviewed the roughly the three non-virtuous actions of the body and the four of speech. And now we’re going to begin the discussion of the three non skillful actions of the mind.
So the three non skillful actions or three three negative actions of mind are covetousness, harmful intention, and wrong view. covetousness, harmful intention, and wrong view. So if we just give the the meaning of covetousness very briefly, then it’s simply the attachment or desire to others’ valuables. So So the and with as the same as we’ve in going through the previous seven negative actions, there is a basis, a thought, the execution, and finally the completion. With respect to the basis of harmful covetousness, the basis is the property or the possessions, the valuables of another sentient being, another person.
So with respect to the thought, that is the intention or motivation, upon seeing someone else’s valuable, thinking how beautiful this object is, and that I should have this object, thinking again and again, Oh, I should have this, I should have this. Then this becomes the motivation for covetousness. And then the execution. This is simply making effort toward gaining the article that that valuable that which you wish to have. So then the the affliction that is the afflictive emotion which is involved can be either of the three poisons.
And then the completion would be actually engaging in the action without any sense of shame or embarrassment. This would be the completion. There are three types of covetousness. There is covetousness, which is an attachment to one’s own, literally it means lineage or family. In the sense that if one were in the East we would use the example of a Brahmin, or one is a royal family, or a Brahmin family, a priestly family.
I don’t know what we use in the West. One has a great family name, perhaps. Rockefeller or something like that. I don’t know what the equivalent is. Attachment to one’s lineage or family name or type, then this would be a covetousness.
This would be the first type of covetousness. So this is quite prevalent in India, where, for example, a Brahmin, the member of the priestly caste, he would covet his own lineage, his own particular caste, and would hold himself above others. He would not even want to be with anyone of another caste in himself, he holds himself very high, and this would be covetous to one’s own lineage, coveting one’s own lineage. So they, I mean, do they go to the extent that they would first, the outcasts would not be allowed to use the same doorway.
Brahman would not use the same doorway that was used by an outcast as someone of the lowest type of caste. Maybe it’s something like segregation in the the West. The second type of covetousness is owning articles or things, factors owned by another person, some property of another person, and thinking again and again, Oh, I should have it. I’d like to have it again and again, with a very powerful thought. I must have it.
I should have that thinking this again and again. Then this is the second type of covetousness, which is desiring others’ property. Then the the third type of covetousness would be a type of attachment or desire for properties and articles which are neither of these above two. That is types of property which do not have any owner, specific owner. But there is still a great desire to have them.
This, for example, in Tibet, you know, was a great deal of gold in the earth and the Chinese came in. They had a great desire to mine this wealth, extract the gold from the earth. And so, this would be, this great desire to own, to attain, to get property, which has no owner, neither your own nor others, would be an example of the third type of covetousness. So just a general type of covetousness that we all experience would be when we go downtown to the movie or something like that or just walking around window shopping and we saw all these nice things in the windows, Oh, isn’t that beautiful? Oh, isn’t that beautiful?
Exaggerate the quality of it. And through this exaggeration, projecting on qualities that in fact these articles don’t have, developing attachment. So this attachment is to all these things that we’re viewing in the shop the shop windows is covetousness. So the afflictive emotion, which is the attachment for the various property of others, it doesn’t need to be the property of others. This attachment toward when you’re thinking, Ah, isn’t that a beautiful man or a beautiful woman?
Isn’t that a beautiful horse? Oh, I should have that horse. Developing a desire for it. Property, people, animals, articles, these are all types of covetousness. So we can almost say that covetousness is synonymous with attachment.
And the second of these three negative mental actions is harmful intention. And this is simply the wish or the thought to hurt someone, to bring someone harm. So the thought or the motivation behind harmful intention, now we first begin with the basis. The basis is, or that is to say the object, is any sentient being. It doesn’t have to be a person.
And then the thought or the motivation is that is to bring harm to the sentient being. That is, thinking in one’s mind to kill or to strike or to say some harsh words. That is, some type of thought which is seeking to, in some way, harm that being is the motivation. So the the execution is is the the action of actual occasion of such an intention whereby one is motivated by any of the three poisons, that is through desire, hatred, or obscuration. Due to there exists the intention to kill, to hurt, to, for example, shoot someone.
There is some intention, the actual occasion of the intention to bring harm is the execution. So the actual completion is the thought that having thought this, thinking this would be good to do, that to kill with a gun, hurt somebody, to stab someone with a knife, in some way to bring harm, thinking having thought this thought, executed the thought, having this intention, thinking, oh, this would be a good thing to do. And this would be the completion. So there can be three types of harmful intention from the point of view of the three types of motivation. For example, the first would be, you know, harmful intention motivated by hatred, whereby one in the case of, for example, war, thinking to go into battle to destroy one’s enemy, to bring harm to one’s enemy.
In the case of just being with another people, getting angry at someone and developing the intention to hurt them, it’s a cause of some dispute. So these would all be occasions of harmful intentions motivated by hatred or anger. Then there could be harmful intention motivated by jealousy. And during the thinking of the that in the context of some competition, understanding that the other person may be better than you and developing jealousy and wishing to be motivated by this jealousy of superior qualities in this competition, developing the intention to harm them. Then the third type of motivation for harmful intention would be would be, for example, enmity.
Enmity. Enmity. I think e n e n m I t y. Something like, the example is, when even though at present there may be no overt competition or enmity between two people, that because of something in the past that has happened, like a grudge, holding a grudge. Keeping this in mind, and though you’re not overtly hurting, expressing any harmful intention, you’re just waiting for the opportunity to arise to get back at this person.
You know, keeping this grudge in your mind. This grudge motivating your harmful intention to do something when chance arises. This is enmity, holding some kind of spite or grudge. So the harmful intention rising out of grudge or enmity enmity. So the third negative action of mind is wrong view.
And this is simply to hold the mistaken mistaken view of the non existence of such things as negative and positive actions, the Buddha, the Dharma, the spiritual community, that negative actions do not give rise to suffering, whereas, and also that positive actions do not give rise to happiness, that such things as the two truths and the four truths do not exist. So this mistaken view of the nonexistence of what in fact exists as nonexisting. Then the, so the basis would be any type of the various things which we’ve just listed such as negative and positive actions, the law of cause and effect, Buddhadharma, Sangha, etcetera. And then the intention, that is to say, the motivation, would be the So the motivation would be the assertion of the view of nonexistence.
The execution would be the occasion of thinking that, in fact, these things do not exist. So then the the completion would be the firm determination that in fact these things do not exist. Coming to a firm decision in your mind that these things do not exist would be the completion. Then there are three types of wrong views. The first would be, is exemplified by the wrong view which holds that from skillful actions happiness in fact does not arise, and from unskillful actions suffering does not arise.
Then the second would be exemplified by the wrong view with respect to the four truths. And the Buddha taught the four truths, that is the true sufferings, true sources, true cessation and true paths to the cessation of suffering. Coming to the decision that true sufferings do not arise from true sources and one cannot attain true cessations in dependence upon true paths would be wrong view with respect to the Four Noble Truths. Then the the third wrong view would be exemplified by deprecating the Three Jewels, that is to say, to assert the nonexistence of the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Really, to assert the view of the nonexistence of a flower or book or table, when in fact it may exist, is not wrong view.
The object which is being deprecated or that which is the non existence of something which in fact exists. It must be of something of significant value. It must be something, for example, of spiritual value such as the four noble truths, the law, the cause and effect, the Three Jewels, things things of this nature. So, you know, all of these three negative actions of mind can be motivated by any of the three afflictive emotions of desire, hatred, and obscuration or confusion. But if we talk about what is the main motivating force among these three, for each of these, then the main motivating force for covetousness is desire, that for harmful intention is hatred, and that of wrong view is obscuration.
So if we talk about these three from the point of view of their degree of harm or their negativity. Then among these three, wrong view is the worst. And then after that, harmful intention. And the least of these three would be, in their degree of their negativity, be covetousness. So the reason why wrong view is the heaviest has the heaviest negative consequences of these three is that by asserting the non existence of such objects as the Three Jewels, the two truths, the law of cause and effect, then this will have an extremely negative influence on conduct. Not accepting the law of cause and effect, will naturally engage in negative types of conduct, harmful types of conduct.
Same would be true of the other objects which are deprecated, such as the Three Jewels and two truths. Due to the type of harmful conduct which would result from such a view, it makes it the heaviest of these three. By engaging in wrong view, then one will not be inspired to, in one’s conduct, to enact generosity or to try to develop love and compassion. One will not have any aspiration to practice Dharma. And this brings about harm not only to oneself but also to others.
So these are the 10 negative actions which are divided by way of three of physical negative actions, four of verbal, and three of mental. So in with respect to the the physical and verbal negative actions, the degree of heaviness of their negativity, the heaviest is the first of each of these two categories. For example, with physical negative actions, the order from heaviest would be killing, then stealing, then sexual misconduct. So now Rinpoche, he he studied all the various great texts and treatises at at his
Key terms in this teaching
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- three doors go sum (Tib)
- Body, speech and mind. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.