49 min · 2,284 words · 22 November 1988
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Explains the ten non-virtuous actions as paths of action, classed with virtuous actions as dharmas that are positive, negative or neutral. Covers the three doors of body, speech and mind and the five branches needed for a complete action, using killing and stealing as examples. Also describes desire, hatred and obscuration as the three poisons that motivate harmful acts.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 49 min
UUID: 646b3638-2ec0-4d5f-a394-25b565d8bed0
Date: 1988-11-22
Words: 2,280
So initially, adjust your motivation such that you’re going to listen to this profound teaching within the context of the great vehicle, whereby to put it into practice in order to attain Buddhahood for the sake of bringing happiness and peace to all sentient beings. So the master Vasubandhu in his text, Treasury of Knowledge, sets forth the verse, Collected from those, the major ones are set forth as the 10 paths of action, either virtuous or non virtuous. So the meaning of this is that the various types of actions that we engage in can be subsumed under actions which are either good actions or skillful actions or bad actions, that is negative actions. When we talk about skillful actions or positive actions, we’re talking about the division into the 10 virtuous actions, or the 10 skillful types of actions. When we talk about the negative types of actions, where they are divided into the 10 unskillful types of actions, or the 10 non virtuous actions.
So the word in Tibetan, is translated into Sanskrit as ‘Dharma’. And this is the general word that the Buddha used. It was a word that was in common coinage in his time. And it has a diverse number of meanings. Is synonymous with such terms as existence, objects of knowledge, objects of a valid cognition.
So when we talk about a Dharma, we’re talking about all the various objects which are recognized or identified or realized by a prime cognition, a valid mind. You know, all the various objects such as flowers, books, houses, money, these are all being identified, realized, recognized by a valid mind, a prime cognition. These are all dharmas. So all the various dharmas, that is we can say phenomena, can be divided into three types either positive, negative, or neutral. There are no phenomena or dharmas which lie outside of these three classifications.
So the way in which we classify the various dharmas into these three types is that those type of actions of the various beings of the world, which are positive, we call positive dharmas, positive dharmas, we call positive. Those are the various types of actions. The various beings of the world, which are negative, we call negative actions, we call negative dharmas. Those other, such as flowers, houses, tables, etcetera, are neutral phenomena. So, the actions of negative and positive are negative and positive Dharma.
And the various phenomena which lie outside of actions, you know, the various objects such as flowers, tables, houses, etcetera, are neutral. So in making distinctions between the various phenomena into negative, positive, and neutral. When we talk about the various types of actions as to whether they’re negative or positive actions, positive actions are by their entity or their nature, have been specified by the Buddha. The actions of whether the actions of body, speech, or mind. And the results of these various types of actions having been specified as positive have a ripening effect of happiness.
So, is when we say positive action, it is that which has been specified as positive and has as its ripening result of happiness. And likewise, when we talk about a negative Dharma, it is first by way of entity, has been specified by Buddha as negative, and has a ripening result of unhappiness. Neutral dharmas, we’re talking about phenomena which have not been specified by the Buddha as being either positive or negative. And in the case of actions, the actions, the result, the ripening results are not specified as either happiness or unhappiness. So initially we’re going to discuss the various types of negative dharmas.
And when we’re talking about those types of unskillful actions which have as their result unhappiness. Therefore, are said to be unskillful actions, since they result in unhappiness. And we can classify them into 10 types. 10 types. Out of these 10 types, they are engaged in by means of three doors.
Just as a house can have various number of doors, it is said that a person has three doors by which he engages, enters into actions. We enter into physical actions through the door of the body. Therefore, all the various physical activities are classified as bodily, as physical actions entered into by way of the body. So the first of these unskillful actions by way of body is killing. So the, there are three actions, there are three unskillful actions entered into by means of the body.
The three unskillful actions the three negative actions of body are killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct. So in order for an action to be a complete path of action, there has to be five branches present. And the first of these five branches is the basis. And this, in the case of killing, is that there has to be a basis, that is, another being to be killed. So this can be any type of sentient being, whether it’s a person, a horse, an animal, a goat, a sheep, etcetera.
So then the second branch is the intention or the motivation to kill. So after the intention, there must be a proper identification of the sentient being to be killed. You know, we are intending to kill a person, we must identify the object as a person. And the object identified as a person must be a person. If it’s a sheep, it must be actually a sheep.
If we want to, if we’re going to kill someone, if we’re going to kill John, must not be mistaken as to who it actually is. It must be actually John. So there must be a proper identification of the object. Then the fifth branch is the actual execution of the action. This is that we actually engage in the killing whether it’s by a weapon or poison or using mantra, etc.
And it can be, these branches can be either completed by oneself or by ordering another person to do it. And then the fifth branch is the branch of completion. This is that life force of the object ceases upon, that is to say, that the being dies, and then the act is a complete action. So, there are these five branches which constitute a complete path of action. That is there is another being in the case of killing.
There is another being which is to be killed. There is a negative motivation initiates the action. There is a proper recognition of the object being killed. There is actual execution of the action, and then there is complete completion of the action, that is, the being actually dies. And Rinpoche was wondering if you understand that in the case of killing, having completed these five branches of a complete path of action, whether you think this is a negative action or a positive action.
So, I mean, such a type of action is not particular to spiritual practices. It’s in the world that we it’s well known in the world that or it’s popularly conceived by even worldly people that such a type of action as killing is in some way wrong and people who engage in it are not nice people. So in a sense it’s properly conceived in the world that such a type of action is negative, what to say of those who are engaged in spiritual or seeking to engage in spiritual actions? The Buddha said that such types of actions were negative, and therefore he prohibited such types of actions. That prohibition is what we mean by Dharma.
The prohibition from engaging in such types of negative actions bringing about harm to others is Dharma. The active engagement in such types of actions, such as killing, what we mean when we say a negative Dharma. Yeah, negative Dharma. Generally, one of the three poisons. Now these are, in general, are many afflictive emotions, but we can subsume them all under desire, hatred, and obscuration.
Desire, hatred, and obscuration. And these are known as the three poisons. In the case of, you know, if we give examples of how these different three poisons could motivate us to engage in killing if you thought that this animal had delicious meat. So in order to eat that meat, kill this animal out of desire for that delicious meat. This would be an action of killing motivated by desire.
So then the poison of hatred acting as a motivating force for killing would be when when we don’t like an enemy and due to our anger toward him, kill that person. This would be a motivation of killing of hatred for killing. So then a motivation out of obscuration for killing would be in the case of, in some traditions, non-Buddhist traditions where they make use of animal sacrifices to various gods and such, that there are cases where a member of a particular sect might say to one of his disciples that in order to attain a human body in the future that you have to sacrifice so many animals or in order to have wealth in the future that you should sacrifice animal to this particular god. And this is a case where the priest who is giving these instructions is actually obscured or misunderstands the nature of his actions and misunderstand this obscuration would be a motivating force for killing. So these are the three motivating forces behind killing.
The main three motivating forces behind killing the three afflictive emotions of hatred, desire, and obscuration. And these were, these all these actions can only lead, are only negative, and only can have a consequence of suffering, of unhappiness. This is, therefore the Buddha spoke of these as negative dharmas. And therefore since they were negative dharmas he prohibited them. And if we are going to try to engage in spiritual path then we have to use as our standard not the worldly measure or worldly standards, but the spiritual standards such as those set forth by the Buddha in determining what types of actions are skillful and what types of actions are negative or unskillful.
You know, just as a loving parent would instruct their child as to what would be of benefit to them and what would be of harm to them. Likewise, the Buddha instructed what types of actions would bring us happiness and what types of actions would bring us suffering. So there are different degrees of the negative consequences of various actions. And those which bring about the most severe consequences, negative consequences as far as killing, as far as killing, are such acts as killing a foe destroyer that is an arahat. An arhat is someone who has completely abandoned all the afflictive emotions.
Killing one’s spiritual teacher, killing one’s parents, killing a monk, or a renunciate. These are the most severe types of negative actions of killing. So then the second physical negative action. The second of the negative physical non-virtuous actions is stealing. And the basis of stealing is an article which is not one’s own, but belongs to another or is dedicated to, for example, the Three Jewels. So, it’s an article which is not one’s own but is owned by another or is dedicated in some way to the Three Jewels.
And this would not include articles which are held in common, such as articles of a family that are generally owned. It has to be owned by another. So then the the thought is the intention an article not having been given, the thought or the intention arises to take that article for oneself. So then the third is the the third branch is identification. That is to say, you know, that you properly identify the object.
There’s no mistake. If you were going to if you were going to steal, you wanted to take some article which belonged to John, but you accidentally took something which belonged to George. This would be, in general, would be stealing, but it would not have the full force of actually having properly or having properly identified the object. Even though it’s still a negative action of stealing, it does not does not have the same degree of negativity as properly of having properly identified the object. And then the execution is, you know, is acquiring an object by, you know, for example, stealth or you know, sneaking up and taking it or by robbery, by robbery and actually forcing a person to give you something for example.
So when and having this is the actual whether by stealth, by force, by robbery, thieving, and then having acquired that object for oneself. Then this would be the completion, having actually acquired it. Then this would be the actual fifth branch. So stealing can be motivated by any of the three main afflictions. We talked about desire, hatred, and obscuration.
So motivation by desire would be, you know, thinking that, you know, not having some kind of desirable object that this other person has, some kind of this person has a good possession and developing an envy or wish that you would really like to have this, and then acting upon this in some method to actually acquire it for yourself. So this would be an example of stealing motivated by desire. Stealing motivated by hatred might occur when two people were fighting, and in order to get back at another person, the stronger might forcibly take something which belonged to the weaker person out of anger, out of anger depriving him of some of one of his possessions and stealing it from him. This would be a stealing motivated by hatred.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- ripening result
- One of the four ways we can experience the results of an action; the ripening result is the actual realm we are born into when we take rebirth. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- three doors go sum (Tib)
- Body, speech and mind. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.