Awakening Heart — 2014-06-03

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2014-06-03
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 111-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche examines whether bodhicitta — the aspiration to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings — is a main mind or a mental factor. Working through the sevenfold subdivision of awareness and knowledge, he concludes bodhicitta cannot be included in most categories, though it may relate to conviction. He then analyzes bodhicitta within minds and mental factors, detailing its association with the five determining factors (aspiration, belief, recollection, concentration, wisdom) and five omnipresent factors. He extends this framework to authentic love and compassion, then presents the 11 virtuous mental factors that counter non-virtuous states. The session concludes with Q&A on memory and valid cognition—including questions about dementia and whether love and compassion provide valid reasons for bodhicitta’s generation. Pitched at advanced students of Buddhist epistemology.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014-06-03 – KR.mp3

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Unclassified

Date: 2003-06-14

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,773

So as usual, we will generate the motivation to receive these teachings. Then I think there would be benefit in presenting the teachings on awareness and knowledge as well as those on minds and mental factors in terms of instances or examples. Then we attempt to generate love, compassion and bodhicitta and have some understanding of bodhicitta. So I think it would be of benefit to try to see where bodhicitta fits within the sevenfold subdivision of awareness and knowledge, as well as within minds and mental factors. Generally speaking, there are a multitude of positions regarding whether bodhicitta is a main mind or a mental factor among Indian scholars.

And there are scholars of repute supporting both positions. However, if we rely on Haribhādra’s Abhisamayālamkāra Aloka, , then bodhicitta should be considered as a main mind. However, irrespective of whether bodhicitta is a main mind or a mental factor, this mind which benefits other others is of great importance. Then within the six fold collection of consciousness ranging from the visual consciousness all the way through the five sense consciousnesses to the mental consciousness, bodhicitta appears within the mental consciousness. Then this intent to benefit others arises within mental consciousness.

Generally, for ourselves, we know that what arises is a mind focused on our own welfare. Without succumbing to the mind which is obsessed with oneself, in other words, self-cherishing, when we are able to generate a mind which is preoccupied with the benefit of others, such a mind probably shares a component with bodhicitta. Setting aside the situation of ordinary beings who are under the sway of their mind, and whose mind in turn is under the sway of afflictions, when we are when we are able to generate a bodhicitta which wishes to benefit others, we are then under the sway of others. Then what is referred to as bodhicitta is the wish to set mother sentient beings as vast in numbers, as space is vast, into a state of stable and durable happiness. And therefore, this main mind which is focused on the durable welfare of all sentient beings without exception, this is bodhicitta.

Such a state is attained at the level of full enlightenment. The aspiration which wishes for liberation from our present condition and the attainment of full enlightenment is a mental factor. Then we posit a bodhicitta whose object is utter enlightenment and whose aspect is the infinite number of sentient beings. Then if we examine whether bodhicitta can be included within the sevenfold subdivision of awareness and knowledge, the answer is probably not. bodhicitta is clearly not a direct valid cognizer since it is a conceptual mind.

It is not an inferential valid cognizer since there is no particularly cogent reason for the generation of bodhicitta. Then the issue of the inclusion or not of bodhicitta within the sevenfold subdivision of awareness and knowledge depends obviously on one’s understanding what the sevenfold subdivision is. If you do, you have a chance of finding where it might fit in. If you don’t, it seems difficult. Then if we pass on to the next subdivision of the sevenfold subdivision of awareness and knowledge, subsequent cognizers, bodhicitta has no particular relationship to subsequent cognizers.

We can neither really say that bodhicitta cognizes its main object, which is full enlightenment. As you remember, its main object is full enlightenment in the aspect of countless mother sentient beings. Because if that were the case, it would become incommensurably more powerful than it is. Nor can we truly say that it does not cognize its object. So it does not seem to have a particular relationship with subsequent cognizers.

Then if we pass on to the subsequent category of the sevenfold subdivision of awareness and knowledge, which is conviction, we could indeed set bodhicitta within conviction, as an instance of conviction. Yet, when we examine the definition of conviction, which is a factually concordant conceptual knower, which is certifiable through conceiving its object, this does not seem to fit bodhicitta that well. It is definite that bodhicitta is not an instance of an inattentive mind, a mind to which a phenomenon appears, but by which it is not ascertained, since all inattentive minds are non conceptual. Then the remaining two categories, doubt and wrong consciousnesses do not fit either, bodhicitta is clearly not a doubting consciousness, nor can it be a wrong consciousness, since its object, which is full enlightenment is attainable. So this is the situation regarding the sevenfold subdivision.

Now regarding mind and mental factors, as I mentioned, there are numerous debates between scholars, and scholars have taken positions on both sides, but we shall consider here that bodhicitta is a main mind. Then clearly, bodhicitta has both the five omnipresent mental factors and the five determining mental factors. For instance, if we take the five determining mental factors, there is aspiration, belief, recollection, concentration, and wisdom associated with bodhicitta. I would suspect the process through which the five determining factors can be said to be present in the case of a main mind such as bodhicitta is that, first, aspiration is necessarily present since whatever we wish to attain, we must aspire to attain. And this powerful aspiration gives rise to a belief, möpa, which is of the nature of delight.

This in turn entails a presence of recollection or memory, and when recollection or memory is powerful, concentration must be present. The presence of concentration leads to that of wisdom. Then clearly conventional bodhicitta has a strong connection with aspiration. It is asserted by some scholars to be aspiration, since it is that aspiration or that wish for full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. Then in dependence on that aspiration, which is striving for full enlightenment, clearly a belief, which is a form of delight in that activity arises.

Then in dependence on this belief, clearly, a recollection which is of the nature of non forgetfulness of the object of observation, which is utter enlightenment arises. This in turn, when it is powerful enough, generates a concentration on its object. A stable concentration in turn naturally generates wisdom. We can thereby see how the five determining mental factors would be associated with bodhicitta. Then, obviously, these five omnipresent mental factors would be associated with the main mind of bodhicitta.

If we view them in the following sequence, clearly initially the omnipresent mental factor of mental application is present since there is mental application focused on utter and full enlightenment. And this in turn gives rise to intention, which is a mental factor of the nature of motivation, which gives rise to discrimination, which gives rise then to contact, which finally gives rise to sensation. Then oddly enough, little is really said in Buddhist scriptures regarding main minds. They are subdivided, generally speaking, into the six subsets of main minds, at times into the eight or the nine subsets, but that which performs most of the mental activities are the mental factors, such as the 51 mental factors. For instance, the six perfections, generosity, ethics, forbearance, enthusiasm, concentration and wisdom are all mental factors.

Likewise, the various mental factors such as recognizing all mother sentient beings as one’s mothers, recollecting their kindness, repaying their kindness, love, compassion are mental factors. These 37 factors of enlightenment are also mental factors, whatever performs the activity of a mind is a mental factor. The main mind is merely focused on the nature of the object, The moment the mind wavers from this, we are dealing with the mental factor. There is much food for thought here, since not only do the sevenfold subdivisions of awareness and knowledge enter within minds and mental factors, but for that matter, a variety of topics. For instance, calm abiding is a mental factor, so are the nine stages of training leading up to calm abiding, since these are all concentrations and so forth.

More than whether bodhicitta realizes its object of observation, which is full enlightenment or not, What really matters for us is to be able one day to generate such a bodhicitta which wishes to benefit others within our mind stream. Likewise, regarding love and compassion, what is referred to as love and compassion in Buddhist scriptures are authentic love and compassion. Then it would be ideal or excellent if one could include fully characterized love and compassion within the sevenfold subdivision of awareness and knowledge. Then if we consider fully characterized love and compassion, the object of observation of fully characterized love and compassion is all sentient beings. And a fully characterized love is merely the wish for them to be endowed with happiness, and fully characterized compassion is a wish for them to be separated separated from suffering.

Clearly, is a relationship between biased love and biased compassion on the one hand, and unbiased love and unbiased compassion on the other hand. And in as much as love is the thought which wishes for beings to be endowed with happiness, and compassion is the thought which wishes for beings to be free from suffering, both as mental activities can be included within mental factors. Then if we take the case of biased love, biased compassion and biased empathy, which are present within our mind stream, these biased mental factors are biased because they focus upon those who are close to us, such as for instance, our children, our parents, or our husband or wife. And for instance, when we experienced biased empathy, it is a wish with, for instance, as object one’s partner, that one’s partner be bereft of suffering. The suffering which is referred to here, in our case, will not be mental suffering, but most probably a wish that they be bereft of physical suffering.

Then, if we take the case of biased or partial love, is present within our mind stream, it would be for instance, in the case of our children, a biased love whose object is our children, and whose aspect is the wish that our children have happiness, in this this case specifically material happiness, not mental happiness. Now we can clearly see that such biased love, compassion and empathy are present within our mind stream, and if we were to try to include them within awareness and knowledge, probably they would have to be put in the category of subsequent cognizers. And therefore, if we were to try to include love, compassion, and empathy within the sevenfold subdivision of awareness and knowledge, they would probably have to be included within subsequent cognizers. Whereas, if we try to identify their position within the subdivision of consciousness into main mind and mental factors, they are obviously mental factors. Then if we are able to extend the biased love, compassion and empathy we have for relatives in such a way that it eventually encompass encompasses all sentient beings, it becomes authentic love, empathy and compassion.

Now, we analyze authentic love, empathy and compassion, its object is all sentient beings, which would imply that one would have to realize all sentient beings, whether this is possible or not is open to debate. Its aspect would be in the case of love, the same, the wish that they be endowed with happiness. Then in the case of authentic love and compassion, most probably they could not fit in the category of subsequent cognizers, but would have to be convictions. Now whether or not these instances of love and compassion have associated minds must be analyzed. Definitely, there would be the five omnipresent mental factors.

Whether or not the five determining mental factors are present or not is something one must investigate. Then there is no particular relationship between bodhicitta and valid cognizers, either direct or inferential valid cognizers, since these are minds one tries to fall under the sway of for the benefit of others. And from within the twin division of the path into method and wisdom, these are minds from the method aspect of the path. Then it is very helpful to think about this in these terms. When we rise in the morning, it is in dependence on our motivation that the flow of our mental consciousness, the sixth of the collections of consciousnesses, the five sense consciousnesses and the mental consciousness, as you remember, depends.

If our mind is saturated with afflictions, then our mental consciousness will be directed in one direction towards non virtue. On the other hand, if our mind is saturated with virtuous mental factors, then our mental consciousness will be directed in another direction towards virtue. Then to pass briefly to the presentation of the 11 virtuous mental factors, these can largely be understood in contraposition or in opposition to non virtuous mental factors. So we will adopt the following order starting with faith. Faith can be understood as the opposite of non faith or faithlessness, and the following mental factor of heedfulness can be understood as the opposite of the non virtue heedlessness which interferes with the generation of concentration.

The third virtuous mental factor is pliancy, which is subdivided into physical and mental pliancy. Now here, we shall focus on mental pliancy, which is the opposite of that experience we all have of difficulty when we try to engage in virtuous activities. The following of the 11 virtuous mental factors is equanimity, which really is a mental virtuous factor which arises in the context of training and calm abiding, when one no longer falls under the sway of sinking and agitation. The following virtuous virtuous mental factor is shame. Shame is compared in Buddhist scriptures to or the instance which is given of shame is what one experiences when one thinks of what others would endure through the harm we inflict on them.

Whereas embarrassment is the mental factor which arises when one thinks, what will the triple gem, my holy teachers and the Buddhas think if I engage in such behavior? The following two virtuous mental factors are the absence of desire and the absence of hate, And this is connected to a question which was asked last time. The absence of desire and the absence of hate are negations. Now from within the twin division of negations into affirming negatives and non affirming negatives, these must be affirming negatives, since they are not permanent phenomena. If the absence of desire and the absence of hatred were non affirming negatives, they would be permanent phenomena, in which case they could not be mental factors, which they are.

Then the question which was asked last time is how is it possible for such affirming negatives, such as for instance, the absence of desire or the absence of hatred to counter non virtuous states of mind. Then in your opinion, since the absence of desire is a non affirming negative, what would you posit as its object of negation, and what is its object of abandonment? You understand? Since Since the absence of desire is a non affirming negative, what would you posit as its object of negation and what would you posit as its object of abandonment? Absence of desire, it would be the mind that wishes to accumulate.

Object of desire. Sorry. What is the object of negation of absence of desire? Sorry, the object of negation would be the mind that wishes to accumulate. Are you saying it is desire?

Indeed, the object of negation of absence of desire is desire, then the object of that desire are whatever objects of the five senses. What I would like to ask you, because otherwise it’ll get very difficult, is what do you understand by countering in this context? When we say that the absence of desire counters desire, what do you understand by the term countering? One harms the other, is that what you’re saying? So when we say that the absence of desire, desirelessness literally, counters desire for the objects of the five senses, clearly, there must be an uncommon relationship between the two, mustn’t there?

So what are these related with? Clearly, if we are contented with little happiness, which really leads to a form of renunciation, then this contentment and this renunciation is what is being referred to here, isn’t it? So when we observe an object of desire, and desire does not arise in our mind stream because it is countered, then this is this experience of contentment which is of the nature of renunciation. Do you understand? Really?

Good. So I have explained at present the absence of desire or desirelessness, its object of negation, and how its object of negation is countered or refuted. Now we will pass onwards to the absence of hatred or hatredlessness. Could you give me the object of negation, of hatredlessness, and its mode of negation? Yes, indeed.

So its object of negation is hatred, and the method or the means of negation is empathy, compassion and love. Then the following virtuous mental factor is nonviolence, ahimsa. Its object of negation is anger, and the method of negation is forbearance. And the last of the eleventh of the 11 virtuous mental factors is enthusiasm, which is a mental factor which delights in the performance of virtue. And this completes the present My apologies.

There is one last virtuous mental factor, I didn’t keep count, which is the absence of benightedness, which simply refers to understanding. When bewilderment is present, we are in a state of misunderstanding of the object. These 11 virtuous mental factors are presented from the standpoint of countering 11 non virtuous mental factors. Obviously, there are far more than 11 virtuous mental factors. Then I will not cover any further this topic, we have finished the presentation of the 11 virtuous mental factors, and I will take at present three questions.

Chris? Just going back to earlier teachings, the example of a cup and a person who has dementia. This person might see the cup, or they would see the cup but, so they can’t sensory consciousness is engaging the object but they cannot they might not be able to remember the actual function of the cup. So my question is, so the scientists would say that this is due to brain damage, but from the perspective of Lorig, what is the connection between valid mental cognition and memory because they have forgotten the function of the cup? You’re saying they have a valid mental cogniser realizing the cup but no memory, that’s what you’re saying?

Yes, hang on, what is the connection between? Because they’ve forgotten the function of the cup, but they can see the cup and they recognize it as, they recognize it as a cup, but they can’t, they don’t know what the function is of it. It’s specific to dementia as an interesting I suspect that they must understand something of the function of a cup, because if they didn’t understand the function of a cup, they would be unable to distinguish where to pour water and whether to pour water in a cup or not. I’d like to point out in apart that Alzheimer’s is unknown among the Tibetans. It’s a western disease to my knowledge.

There’s not a single case I know of among Tibetans. You understand? In your opinion, what’s the function of the cup? Function is in other words that if you pour water inside, it doesn’t go outside. Right?

Yes. Yeah. Sam? I pointed out there’s a lot of literature on Alzheimer cases which shows that at the time of death, clear memory can and does return. I suspect there’s first a big difference, says Geshe-la, in cases of Alzheimer’s between those who have studied extensively and who have not.

Now this is confirmed scientifically, people have studied have Alzheimer’s much later. In addition, I suspect that the mode of study makes a big difference. If it is a study of a manual skill over an intellectually acquired skill, there would be a big difference in the memory decay. We have clear examples both with Khensur Rinpoche and with how clear his mind was. Does that lead towards answering your question?

The last part of it was sort of wanting to know the connection between valid mental cognition and memory and just a couple of things about people with dementia. The doctor that lived opposite us had dementia by the time he was 60 and he was a pediatric specialist in cancer treatment for children. And there are many, many instances of people who are highly educated getting dementia. In Adelaide, in South Australia alone there are one hundred and twenty five new cases diagnosed every week. So in the West it’s becoming, it’s considered an epidemic.

But I really wanted to understand that connection between valid mental and if there is a connection between valid mental cognition and memory. The big question is do they recognise when seeing a cup that it is a cup or not? That’s the question. Okay, so you can say to that person go and pour some tea into that cup and they go to the cup but they can’t remember what to do with the cup. So they’ve recognized the cup but they can’t remember what to do with the cup or what it’s for.

Though this is clearly the result of disease, I suspect that the eye consciousness perceiving the cup would qualify as an inattentive mind, a mind to which a phenomenon appears, but by which it is not fully ascertained. If one had authentic love and great compassion, would not that be a valid or correct reason for bodhicitta to be considered as an an inferential cogniser. In the same way as smoke, there’s an uncommon connection between smoke and fire. There’s an uncommon connection between bodhicitta and enlightenment. Geshe would have said there is no cogent reason for the development of bodhicitta and I would have thought that authentic love and authentic compassion are essential for bodhicitta.

So therefore, and bodhicitta is the aspiration for, to lead all beings to full enlightenment. So I would have considered those as valid, a correct reason hence would come under the category of inferential cognizance. So, undeniably, is an an uncommon connection between love and compassion on the one hand and bodhicitta on the other. As Maitreya said in the Mahayānasūtrālamkara, I assert its root to be compassion. It here refers to bodhicitta.

However, if we were to assert that bodhicitta is an inferential valid cognizer, then it would realize its object. The object of bodhicitta is full enlightenment. So that would imply that bodhicitta realizes full enlightenment, one would therefore be fully enlightened, which one is not. Very good, very good idea, but Very good idea, but I must give a commentary. If bodhicitta were an inferential valid cognizer, then there would have to be a reason which warrants the attainment of its object, which is full enlightenment.

Don’t understand? Yeah, yeah. Thanks. Chris asked the same question that I had about tonight but if I go back a little further I just wanted to clarify something. For conceptual minds, is it the case that the appearing and apprehended object is a meaning generality and the determined and engaged object is a generally characterised phenomenon?

So appearing and apprehended. Appearing and apprehended has meaning generality and determined and engaged as a generally characterized So your second question is first, the determinate object of determination and the object of engagement of a conception are not necessarily specifically characterized phenomena. The first question is a good one. If something is the appearing object and the object of engagement of a conception, is it necessary a meaning generality? Generally speaking, only the appearing object of a conception is a meaning generality.

The object of engagement of a conception is never a meaning generality. However, in practice, if one examines how the mind functions, there is some sort of a connection between the appearing object and the object of engagement of a conception. Yes. Stop. Okay.

Today is supposed to finish Lorig. And I would like to say, Geshe-la and Ilya, and, of course, all of you, how it’s really wonderful that, you know, it’s a study group that is going. And please come again with Dharma, with determination. And it’s Tenets. Tenets.

Tenants. Sorry. Tennis. Tennis. Tennis.

Tennis. So it is a really wonderful, enjoyable study group to encourage your dharma brothers and sisters to come along. Know, Geshe-la and Ilya, their effort and work. And we are very fortunate, so continue to engage this way to his holiness and our beloved Rinpoche. They wish, you know, that we should carry our study.

It’s a it’s is fantastic, all right? And I just encourage that. Other thing I would like to Some of you may be not able to come for the commemoration day. So, however, I have some very special, precious statues, Tsongkhapa, Yamāntaka and Vajrayoginī statues. If you do whichever practice you do, please come after the teaching and take care.

And of course, a very precious sacred pill. And Tsa-tsas are the statues made out from dung, which is relics and ash and the precious bones, you know. And the purity is the same, you know. And there is file. It’s got three thing, thing, His Holiness and the Rinpoche’s discussion or talk.

And it’s very fortunate that Ilya translated and Geshe-la and myself, we were there at the time. We tried to remember everything what His Holiness and Rinpoche talk about. And then there is a very special, we did launch Rinpoche’s scholarship for study. So that there is a brochure there. And of course, is another one is Rinpoche’s Enlightenment stupa that is going to be placed in Sera and is under the process to craftsman working.

If my suggestion and to look at the brochure scholarship that we launched yesterday, it is a Lharampa Geshe study. And I just like give quick and some maybe you already heard this one, maybe a bit boring, this is how Rinpoche always talk about, you know, you know, I did ask in the past, when I was with Rinpoche, you know, what Rinpoche would like to be me to do. So he said, making things and make sure look after the few good monks so that, you know, I’m looked at and thought about and which way is the best way to how Rinpoche’s wish to achieve. So I come across this scholarship for Lharampa Geshe study so that it’s a tremendous benefit. And without good Lharampa Geshe in in in the world, you know, it is difficult for us in the center even like here.

Today, we benefit. That’s also that we have a really tremendous teacher, you know, which who studied the Lharampa Geshe. And it’s like the same. You know, many centers rely on the good Geshes, so we need to help for that so that I thought about this and which way to how to I can to fulfill Rinpoche’s wish and come up this scholarship for Lharampa Geshe study. So there is a brochure.

Please read. And if you have any queries or if you like to help to be a part of the scholarship, contact me. And we can achieve all the the Rinpoche’s wish and to try benefit for all sentient beings. And and, again, the the future, there will be a a great Lharampa Geshe good Geshes we need in this world to bring in to dharma to life and to to alleviate all these sufferings that so much, you know, going around in the world. And so we need more of them.

So there was a good asked me, you know, then they look after the maybe eight, nine good monks. So this I put up there and we can I can only achieve this with your help and your involvement? So thank you very much. And after the teaching, I have Tsongkhapa statue and Vajrayoginī and Yamāntaka. And please come forward and I’m happy to pass these precious pills and statues.

Thank you. Then next Tuesday, we will start studying tenets together. Tenets are extremely important. It is true that it is a little bit difficult as a topic, but they present the view, the wisdom aspect of the path, and there is an English translation available which is made at the center.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
virtuous mental factors kushala-chaitta (Skt); ge wä sem jung (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, the virtuous mental factors are positive qualities of the mind that counteract the non-virtuous mental factors - the root delusions and secondary delusions. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top