1 h 46 min · 5,142 words · 2 October 2013 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 106-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche uses an extended ocean metaphor—waves of afflictions tossing us, a sea monster of suffering—to establish that cyclic existence contains no genuine happiness, only suffering. He traces this through birth, aging, sickness, and death, then explains why recognizing this fully (not just intellectually) is essential for authentic wish for liberation and true refuge. He then systematically explores the eight matured qualities of a precious human rebirth: long life, beauty, social status, wealth, noble speech, influence, maleness, and mental strength, explaining the causes for each (generosity, forbearance, meditation) and their practical benefit. The closing section addresses purification of negative karma through the four opponent powers and anger’s capacity to destroy roots of virtue. A substantive Q&A covers caste, democracy, and karma mechanics.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2013-10-02 – KR.mp3
UUID: 63c2b07b-3605-4493-b3de-eece9692c925
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Awakening Heart
Date: 2013-10-02
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~5,138
Oh, yeah. How much is it? As is said in Bless us to be delivered from the torment of floating hither and thither under the power of karma and affliction. So the ocean in which we have sunk is the ocean of the three types of suffering, the suffering of change and or pervasive suffering. Whereas the Leviathan, the sea monster which torments us is none other than the sea monster of karma and afflictions.
And therefore one entreats a spiritual teacher to bless one to give rise to the wish for liberation from such an ocean of cyclic existence which is measureless as all great oceans. So if we analyze our situation, we can see that we are indeed tossed left and right by the waves in this great ocean, the waves of what? The waves of the afflictions. For indeed if we examine our minds, we can see that our minds are awash with desire, with anger, with envy, with competitiveness and so forth. And indeed just as if we were cast in a wild ocean, we would be tossed left and right by the waves so much so that we could barely speak or even breathe.
And to be frank if one examines carefully one’s own mind one will see that qualities such as love or compassion appear so rarely we can say that they never appear in this ocean of afflictions which is our mind. And we are tormented in this measureless ocean by the Leviathan or the sea monster of the various types of suffering, the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and all pervasive suffering. Yet we do not recognize these various types of suffering as suffering because we do not identify them as suffering, we view them as happiness. And if we analyze our lives we can see that it would seem there is scarcely a moment in which we are not afflicted by one of the four general types of suffering, the suffering of birth, aging, sickness and death. After we are born, we start aging almost at once.
Then we are beset by sickness and eventually face death. Then we like to think that there are intervals of happiness between these four sufferings of birth, aging, sickness and death. But if we first look at cyclic existence in the broad sense, it is just a succession of lives marked by birth, sickness, aging and death, birth, sickness, aging and death, birth, sickness, aging and death uninterruptedly. So as a whole, we can say there is no happiness in this. But even within the intervals between birth and sickness, sickness and aging, aging and death, we find that there are numerous forms of suffering such as not obtaining what we wish, obtaining what we do not wish for, and so forth.
So if we examine this process carefully, it is doubtful that there is anything in it which can be called happiness. And then we can purely say that our existence is in accordance with the two first lines of the stanza of the Guru Puja, tossed hither and thither, hither and thither by the ocean of the afflictions. We are tormented by the sea monster of the sufferings. We are indeed tossed hither and thither by the afflictions and tormented by the sea monster of the three types of suffering, the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and all pervasive suffering. Then if we think about this carefully and meditate about it carefully, we will see that there is really nothing in this process which is of the nature of happiness.
It is exclusively of the nature of suffering. The big question which arises at this point is, is there some type of liberation from this entire process or not? And this is what we entreat for in the final line of this stanza, bless us to generate the wish for liberation. Such a liberation does indeed exist and this is why we beseech for the wish to attain it. We all are aware of the fact that when we pray for freedom from suffering, we are praying for being freed from the unwanted, but we don’t consider happiness and pleasure as suffering, do We all know that it is easy for us to put effort in something which we view as happy and pleasureful.
But when we view something as not terribly pleasureful or pleasant, then we find it much more difficult to put effort in it. For that matter, we simply do not put any effort in it. And this is the case with topics such as renunciation, bodhicitta or the correct view of emptiness which we do not see as leading to any type of happiness. And therefore we must understand the suffering nature of the entire process of cyclic existence. And to do this, we must first understand the meaninglessness and the vanity of what we call the happiness of this life.
It is precisely because of our efforts to attain the happiness of this life that we are incapable of obtaining freedom from cyclic existence and therefore understanding the vanity of the happiness of this life, we should pray to give rise to a wish for liberation from cyclic existence. And therefore, we should understand that every single virtuous deed which we perform in this life will not lead beyond cyclic existence. The contaminated virtues which we perform merely lead to rebirth as a god or as a human being and we will eventually fall from this state after death and be reborn in some other realm. Therefore, contaminated virtuous deeds cannot lead to liberation from cyclic existence. At this point, we should generate the powerful wish to attain liberation from cyclic existence since it is only on the basis of such a wish that one can put effort in meditating on the view, let alone giving rise to bodhicitta.
And then we should think that it is said that if one has taken refuge correctly in the triple gem, one will not fall in the lower realms and that if one is able to generate some type of renunciation or of bodhicitta then one can definitely hope for a higher rebirth. We are after all Buddhists. We have chosen to be Buddhists. This is something we ought to accept. However, this does not refer to mere verbal refuge but to authentic refuge.
For authentic refuge to be present within our mind stream, fully characterized causes of this authentic refuge must have been created. If they have not been recreated, our refuge is mere talk. These fully characterized causes of refuge are the conviction that cyclic existence is transitory and fearsome. If one generates the conviction that cyclic existence, in other words, what we call happiness here and now, is transitory and fearsome, one will wish to be freed from it. Otherwise one will not.
This will lead to true refuge. All of us can take refuge with folded hands, a quivering voice and tears running down our face. But this refuge is not a true refuge if it has not arisen from its correct causes. And if it is not a true refuge, it will not protect us in the future. And therefore, we must reflect and meditate on suffering.
Without reflection and meditation on suffering, there is no wish for liberation and we must therefore identify our happiness here and now as of the nature of suffering. Otherwise, if we are in the category of a prisoner who is happy in his jail, we will never wish to be as to escape from jail. Instead, as a prisoner, we should reflect on the thoughts of jail and the sufferings of being in jail. And therefore we should reflect over and again on the faults and the sufferings of cyclic existence and of the so called happiness of this life through reading great texts on the topic and fully understand how loathful, how loathsome the happiness of this life is and how loathsome cyclic existence in general is. It is only at this point when we understand the full loathsome ness of this life and of cyclic existence that we will be able to turn our backs on this life and to turn our backs on cyclic existence.
At this point, if this rejection of this life and this rejection of cyclic existence is sincere and spontaneous, it has become uncontrived renunciation. And then from that point onwards, one tries to generate the wish to attain full enlightenment for the sake of others. And therefore, let us meditate for one or two minutes on generating such a motivation thinking I myself understand fully how loathsome this life and cyclic existence in general are and give rise thereby to the wish to be freed, to be liberated from this life and from cyclic existence. Understanding fully that all others are in the same situation as me, trapped in a loathsome loathsome life and in a cycle of lives which is loathsome. I wish to free them from this state but can only do so if I myself first attain the state of full enlightenment.
May I therefore attain the state of full enlightenment to free other beings from cyclic existence? Yeah. So we have now reached a stanza 15 of the canticle of the path which begins with the line since until one has found a base which fulfills the criteria, one will not go far. Now here this is a new outline which is initiated by this stanza. The base in question is the base which enables one to attain either the state of liberation or the state of full enlightenment, in dependence on having taken refuge through fearing rebirth in the lower realms.
It is therefore an uncommon or a specific base. So in our case, we have at present obtained a precious human rebirth. But if we are unable to understand the sufferings of cyclic existence in general and our own sufferings in particular, we will be unable to give rise to a compassion which wishes to free sentient beings from such a suffering, and in turn we will be unable to give rise to bodhicitta. Therefore, it is insufficient to have a precious human rebirth as a base. One needs a precious human rebirth with the eight fully matured qualities to enable one to progress forward in one’s practice.
So these eight qualities are a long life, a beautiful complexion, high social rank, power, noble speech, a powerful background, a sharp mind, and both physical and mental strength. So the first of these is a long life and each of these eight characteristics has its own specific sets of causes which we must generate. So the first quality, a long life is to be understood as follows. The lifespan and the life force are one and the same. And it is said the life force is the basis of consciousness.
Interrupt the life force and death occurs. And the life force is the basis of consciousness since when the life force is interrupted, as we said, death occurs and the consciousness must move on. Therefore, a long lifespan is equivalent to a powerful life force. There are numerous causes and conditions for this and we must have accumulated them. The reason for which a long life is the first of the eight matured qualities is because if we reach we wish to reach our goal in Dharma practice, we must lead a long life.
If we do not, even though we intend to complete certain Dharma practices, we will be unable to do so as our lifespan will have been interrupted. Then when we are reborn, we will remember nothing of our previous life and we’ll have to start all over from scratch again going to school and so forth. So we should try to lead as long a life as possible. If possible, to live up to one hundred years of age or longer and practice during this period. Neither our body nor our mind remains stably and durably.
We can see this at a coarse level with the aging process where we wake up one day and suddenly looking at ourselves we realize we are old. This has happened because we were changing constantly. Nothing in our life remains stably. So one can say that one dies instant by instant. However, here we apply the term dying to the separation of the body and the mind of this life.
And therefore, it is beneficial to lead a long life. The second quality is to have a beautiful body. In other words to be handsome or to be beautiful. This is important because if one is handsome or one is beautiful others will naturally pay greater attention to what one says and will try to do what one says. Therefore you can see that there is considerable relevance in having a sound and beautiful body.
This is the case for all of us ordinary beings who are attached to appearances and don’t truly understand what is going on. We admire those who are handsome or those who are beautiful, wish to be like them and imitate them. We can see this for ourselves. If we meet a couple of people during the day and one of them is an extremely handsome or attractive person to whom we are personally attracted. Then at the end of the day, when we ask, so what happened today?
Who did you meet? Those two or three people who were dull and uninteresting are just left to the side, but the handsome or beautiful one sticks in our mind and we say I met so and so. What a handsome person he was. He said this to me. And this is really the way it is if we meet someone handsome or if we meet someone who is powerful or wealthy.
This is the way ordinary beings function. And this is why we have to try to be reborn handsome or beautiful. And the goal of this handsomeness or this beauty is to lead others to liberation or to full enlightenment. So that is why we try to obtain it. And the third fully matured quality we should attain is higher social status.
This is the same thing as being handsome or beautiful. People listen carefully to what someone who is higher placed in society says and will say what did he or she say? Whereas they pay no attention whatsoever to what someone at the bottom of society says or thinks. Things are a little bit different in your country in Australia but definitely in India during the age of the Buddha and very much so nowadays. Social status and caste make a huge difference.
People who are of lower social status or of lower caste cannot enter in certain buildings or sit down. Buddha Śākyamūni himself was able to see beyond this to the true nature of beings. There were four castes in ancient India and even nowadays. The highest caste was a Brahmin caste followed by the military or Kshatriya caste followed by the caste of the merchants and at the bottom of the system, the caste of the peasants followed by the untouchables. And these castes were understood in terms of their activities.
The Brahmins engaged in meditation and study. The Kshatriyas or the military caste specialized in the usage of power and war. The caste of traders in trade. The caste of peasants basically handled all of the low jobs in society and the outcasts performed the taboo jobs such as cleaning the toilets, cutting bodies and so forth. The higher a higher rebirth here refers to the two higher castes rebirth as a Brahmin or a member of the Kshatriya soldier caste.
Then obviously if one is ordained that the issues of caste no longer valid. Then clearly in terms of practice this makes no different. It is said that Tilopa, the master of Naropa was an outcast. A member of the lowest caste actually out of the caste system. And therefore this makes no difference in terms of one’s practice.
However, for the benefit of others, it is important to be reborn in the higher castes. The fourth characteristic is great power, which refers here to great wealth, the capacity to perform vast acts of generosity for others. So you can see the advantages or the dangers of great wealth with the Christian churches which proselytized throughout the world offering huge amounts of money to people and drawing them thereby inside the church. Since perhaps there’s nobody who doesn’t like money, it is quite easy to convert people. Therefore, a lot of money is necessary.
The fifth fully matured quality is noble speech. This refers to perfect honesty and clarity in one’s speech, not saying something one doesn’t mean and so forth. The sixth quality is to be powerful. To the difference of the fourth quality, this refers to power in terms of one station, being a lord, being a king, being a president who is able to influence others. Regarding the fifth quality, the previous quality in noble speech, this also refers to having initially abandoned the four non virtues of speech, lying, divisive talk, harsh words, and gossip.
Then the sixth quality, as Geshe-la said, is great power. This refers to being a lord, someone of influence in one society who can perform vast waves of deeds. The seventh quality I misunderstood is to be a male. There are definite advantages to being a man or a male and it is said that being a female presents specific obstacles. Then Geshe-la feels that Tārā and Vajrayoginī have dispelled those obstacles.
So this does not refer to the enthusiasm of women but to the difficulties they face in the light of having families and children. When a woman has a child, this takes up much of her time and limits her capacity to practice Dharma. Otherwise in terms of the Buddha nature there is no difference between men and women. The eighth quality is being strong in body and mind or physical and mental fortitude. This refers to the type of strength which Jetson Milarepa had.
The strength of somebody who when he or she has committed to do something never wavers nor turns back but continues until he or she has attained the goal. In this case, the goal of liberation or full enlightenment. This is rather difficult, isn’t it? And therefore the two first lines of stanza 15 say since until one has found a base which fulfills the criteria one will not go far, one should train in the causes lacking for its fulfillment. This refers to a human rebirth with the eight qualities of maturation.
And therefore if one lacks such a rebirth endowed with the eight fully matured causes one should put effort in acquiring these causes and one should train in the causes lacking for its fulfillment. For instance, one should acquire the causes for a long life. As Nāgārjuna says, from generosity, wealth and from ethics, happiness. Therefore, if one wants to acquire wealth, which is one of the eight qualities, one must practice generosity. If one wants to acquire happiness, one must engage in ethics.
And the verse reads onwards from forbearance a beautiful complexion and from enthusiasm increase. In other words, from the practice of forbearance, one becomes handsome or beautiful and from enthusiasm, one’s qualities increase. Then from Dhyāna or Samādhi, one gains single pointed concentration and from training the mind sharp acumen. Therefore, it is through such practices as generosity, forbearance and so forth that one attains the eight qualities of maturation on which basis one can progress to liberation or full enlightenment. And therefore, if one is able to live a long life and engage in practices such as the practice of forbearance, the practice of generosity, making elaborate offerings, fire pujas to various deities and so forth.
Over such a long life, one will accumulate the causes for such a rebirth. This is how one completes all roots of virtue. And the following two lines of Stanza 15, since it is of great import to and you have to add the adverb continually purify particularly karma and obscurations of the three doors, besmirched by sins, faults and stains. The three doors here refer to the three doors of body, speech, and mind, which are stained by sins, faults, and stains. And these are to be continually purified of karma and obscurations.
And this one should do through relying continually on the four forces. So in this context, one must apply the four forces. The first of the four forces is the force of the base. The base in this respect refers to the base with respect to which the thought has been accumulated. Faults can either be accumulated with respect to the Buddhas and the Bodhisattvas or they can be accumulated with respect to ordinary beings.
If they are accumulated with respect to the Buddha’s, the Bodhisattvas or the triple gem, they are purified through taking refuge. If they are accumulated with respect to ordinary beings, they are purified through generating bodhicitta. The second force is the force of repentance or remorse. This is particularly difficult to generate since to generate it correctly one must recollect one’s sins and one’s faults and we can recollect only a very small fraction of all of the sins which we have committed since the beginning of time since we can only recollect the sins which we have performed in this life. If we take the case of the 10 non virtues of body, speech and mind, it is extraordinarily easy to commit them.
For instance, it is very easy to rejoice upon hearing of the death of someone we dislike and in so doing, we accumulate a karma related to killing. Likewise, it is very easy to engage in the non virtues of speech and extremely easy to engage in stealing since all it takes to have stolen something is through whatever means to appropriate something which we were not entitled to and which belonged to another. Within the four forces, it is said that the second force repentance or remorse is by far the most important. Since if repentance or remorse arises powerfully, then the mind relinquishing the deed will arise as a result of this and one will have given rise to the force which relinquishes or abandons this deed. Otherwise, it will not happen.
In our cases, the situation is the opposite, let alone feeling repentance or remorse for the non virtues we have committed, we rejoice in them. And generally speaking, we rejoice in all 10 non virtues, considering non virtues as the way to attain happiness. This is the case through powerful habituation with non virtues from previous lives specifically through a mental cause which is a mental concordant cause. In other words, through having practiced non virtues in a previous life, we are accustomed to them in this life. So what we must do is to turn our minds inwards to look upon ourselves in the same way as we would look inwards upon ingesting some toxic substance and desperately wonder what we can do to liberate ourselves from that.
Therefore we should do the best we can to purify whatever toxicities we have ingested and with this as your motivation engage in whatever virtuous deed we wish to engage in to purify our mind streams whether it is trying to generate renunciation, bodhicitta and so forth. And this is why it is said one should cherish reliance on continually cleansing them by the four forces. Whatever virtue we engage in motivated by the four forces will act to purify the non virtues we have accumulated in the past. What do we mean here when we speak of the purification of sins? We have already committed sins or non virtues in the past.
When we speak of the purification of sins, we refer to preventing the full effect of maturation of the sin from manifesting. This is the purification of a sin. We will stop here for today. In the there’s a commentary on the Kālacakra, ornament of stainless light, I think it’s called. There’s a quote from a Hindu, an ancient Hindu text where he criticizes the Buddha for some of the things the Buddha said.
One of them, I think, is to do with rituals being a fetter, not having to be a Brahmin to become enlightened. So it seems that the Buddha didn’t have much regard for the caste system. Therefore, you know, these sort of primitive backward systems is quite interesting from a historical point of view, but I would have thought it would be better to pray to be born in a western democratic, democracy than worry about such primitive systems. What does Geshe-la think about that? So it is definitely true that Buddha Śākyamūni rejected the caste system and specifically the Brahmin caste.
He was actually sharply criticized by the Hindus for rejecting the caste system. But this is not what is meant here. What is meant here is that one should pray to be reborn in a high social rank in the given society one lives in, whatever society that might be since this gives one influence and power. Then as to praying to be reborn as a Westerner, that is neither here nor there. If you pray to be reborn as a Westerner who has a strong connection with the teachings, that is very good.
But if you just pray to be reborn as a larrikin in Australia, then as a larrikin has little or no hope to attain liberation or full enlightenment, that would be a meaningless prayer. And such a rebirth neither leads to liberation nor to full enlightenment. Since such a westerner has no qualities and only faults. Thank you for the teaching. I’ve just got two quick questions.
Forgive my ignorance on these. First question is, do the non virtuous deeds of this life, are they expunged, for want of a better word, by virtuous deeds of this life? Are they cancelled? I have another question. You want to?
Simple. In relation to the eight qualities of maturation, how does a woman acquire maleness? How does how does she reflect on that in this life? Then if the virtues which you have for your first question, if the virtues which you have accumulated were accumulated to purify the sins, yes, they will purify them. If indeed those virtues have been accumulated on a basis with repentance and the wish to reject the non virtuous deeds and then applying whatever antidote is required, all four forces would be present and those virtues would indeed purify whatever non virtues they were focused previously.
So regarding your second question, a woman does not have to pray to be reborn as a man. It is not a fault to be reborn as a woman since on that basis one can attain liberation or full enlightenment. However, there are greater interferences if one is reborn as a woman than as a man. Since for instance, if a woman falls pregnant for one year basically there is little she can do especially at the end of the pregnancy. Thank you for your teaching, Geshe-la.
And I have to say in response to Jo’s question that I am not particularly happy to be part of a democracy where governments at times encourage their citizens to commit one of the five heinous crimes of killing their mother or killing their father through euthanasia and where our political system allows parties such as the Shooters and Fishers party whose sole objective is to make it easier to shoot and kill wildlife. So in that sense, I’m not happy to be part of that particular kind of democracy. But in any case, my question was regarding karma, I understand there’s a number of factors involved in laying down a karmic imprint of throwing karma. And there’s a number of factors involved in purifying karma, such as the four opponent powers. Regarding extinguishing virtuous karma, for instance, by getting angry or some other non virtue, are there a number of factors that need to take place for the full extinguishment of a virtuous karma?
For example, if I created a a non virtuous karma in relation to Buddhas, then sorry. If I created a a virtuous karma in relation to Buddhas, but I then got angry at sentient beings, because the basis is different, how would I know what non virtue extinguishes what good virtue? I think I’ve confused. But my main question is, are there a number of factors involved in extinguishing a virtuous karma? All anger harms the roots of virtue.
If powerful anger arises in mind stream, it can annihilate every single root of virtue in the mind stream without exception. If the anger is of medium or lesser strength, it however will definitely damage all the roots of virtue in the mind stream. It will damage them through delaying their maturation and through making powerful maturation of roots of virtue into middling or small maturation of roots of virtue. And this is a big fault of anger. If anger is powerful, it has the potential to destroy all the roots of virtue within the mind stream without exception.
If the anger is weaker, however, it will greatly delay the maturation of all of the roots of virtue and those roots of virtue which were strong will become weak in their maturation. The way to counter this is through meditating on bodhicitta, on compassion and on the view of emptiness which actually increase the power of the roots of virtue. The meaning is that anger causes everything to blaze. Just following on from Geshe-la’s last answer that meditating or bodhicitta compassion increases the power of the roots of virtue. The preliminary practice, as I understand it, for compassion in the Bodhicitta is equanimity, meditating on equanimity.
Would that also increase the power of meditating on equanimity also increase the power of the roots of virtue? In the case of equanimity, it has no power either way. The roots of virtue will neither increase in strength nor decrease in strength. Equanimity is a neutral state of mind. Therefore, it is a powerless state of mind.
It is neither oriented towards virtue nor towards sin. Okay. Oh, yeah. Okay. There will be an email sent out tomorrow regarding the program for the weekend.
If you haven’t registered, I’m sure that we can squeeze you in. And please enjoy in a non-samsaric way, some chai. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dhyana samten (Tib)
- An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
- four opponent powers nyenpo tob zhi (Tib)
- The four practices used to purify nonvirtuous imprints on the mindstream. LYWA
- three doors go sum (Tib)
- Body, speech and mind. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- three types of suffering dug ngäl sum (Tib)
- The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and pervasive compounding suffering. LYWA
- throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
- Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Can virtuous deeds accumulated in this life cancel or purify the non-virtuous deeds of this life?
Yes, if the virtues were accumulated in order to purify the non-virtuous deeds, they will purify them. This works when the virtues are built on a basis of repentance and the wish to reject the non-virtuous deeds, and when whatever antidote is required is then applied. In that case all four forces are present, and those virtues will indeed purify whatever non-virtues they were focused on previously.
Does meditating on equanimity increase the power or strength of the roots of virtue?
No. In the case of equanimity, it has no power either way. The roots of virtue will neither increase in strength nor decrease in strength through it. Equanimity is a neutral state of mind, and therefore it is a powerless state of mind. It is neither oriented towards virtue nor towards sin, so it does not strengthen or weaken the roots of virtue.