Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012-06-03 – KR.mp3
UUID: 564cc7c0-ebda-49c5-9b0e-89865bd02b29
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2012-06-03
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 42m
Words: 3,401
It is excellent that all of us have assembled here to receive teachings and commentaries on what is the foundation of the path which is these three principles of the path. In other words, renunciation or definite emergence, bodhicitta and the correct view. It has become somewhat more difficult to practice the Buddhist teachings since there has been a clear decay or degeneration in the Buddhist teachings between times of yore and the present day. Likewise, there are fewer volunteers who wish to engage in the Buddhist teachings and among those there are even fewer who are able to study and blend the teachings with their mental continuum or their mental stream. Therefore, you are all the more to be praised for engaging in such activities and as a result of this you will definitely experience great waves of merit.
There is no doubt to be have in the fact that the teachings are of benefit for our mind stream. This was clearly taught by Buddha Shakyamuni and all his successors through Atisha and they are non deceitful. They not only taught that the teachings are of benefit to our mind stream, but that we are able to engage in them. There are, as has been explained in previous teachings, two aspects to renunciation, Limited renunciation, which is a renunciation of this life focusing on attaining happiness and welfare in future lives. In other words, a striving for welfare in future lives.
And actual renunciation, which is the renunciation or the abandonment of the totality of psychic existence. Likewise, there are two types of liberation. There is liberation from cyclic existence and ultimate liberation which is none other than the state of full enlightenment. You are all the more to be praised for studying these topics in that in this world of ours nowadays most do not believe in what cannot be seen, what is not visible. And in the case of Buddhadharma, since the focus of Buddhadharma is or starts with future lives, this is obviously not something which is visible and therefore it is open to doubt.
These doubts must be entertained and analyzed. If we reflect back on the past, we can see that one thousand or fifteen hundred years ago, much of Asia was Buddhist. China, Japan, Vietnam, Mongolia, all these countries were Buddhist. The Buddhist teachings had spread throughout almost the totality of Asia. This is no longer the case nowadays.
The Buddhist teachings have declined very sharply. Therefore, you are all the more to praise for having an interest in the Buddha’s teachings. And when we refer to the Buddha’s teachings, we have to understand that we are referring to a practice of study and practice combined. It is very difficult to call the mere practice of prayers Buddhism. It is almost impossible.
If we take the case for instance of Vietnamese Buddhism, Geshela is aware of the existence of Vietnamese Buddhism, but he himself does not speak Vietnamese and the Vietnamese Buddhists do not speak Tibetan. Therefore, it is very difficult for him to assess what precisely Vietnamese Buddhism is. He wished he had ten or twelve years to spend to study the Vietnamese language so he could actually study Vietnamese Buddhist teachings in detail and teach himself in Vietnamese Shantideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara and so forth. But this is unfortunately not possible. And Geshela had many doubts when he was in Melbourne.
He was invited to a Vietnamese temple. And while the temple itself was magnificent and huge, there were only two monks. Then he had he couldn’t really understand what precisely the monks were doing in such a huge temple. Perhaps rituals, it wasn’t quite clear that any study was involved. He was unable to communicate with them and them with him except through English.
And therefore there is a passage in verse which says whatever one has listened to, literally whatever one has studied, one should then integrate it within one’s mind. It is not sufficient to study something. One has to actually integrate it. One has to cause the material to penetrate one’s mind. However, you should not focus on study alone.
If you were to study constantly, the Buddhist teachings are almost infinite. Not only do we have the teachings on Madhyamika and Pramana, we also have the huge ranges of teachings on Tantra. It would be impossible if one were to live 1,000 lives to exhaust the variety of topics in Buddhist studies. The goal of Buddhist studies is to transform one’s mind and it’s therefore this key point, this critical point we have to keep in mind and train our minds. As the Buddha has said, discipline is the foundation of practice.
Here discipline refers to ethics and ethics is none other than the ground on which our practice is constructed. It is on the basis of ethics that we can pacify our minds. Having pacified our minds, in turn our bodily sufferings will be reduced, specifically diseases will be reduced and in turn progressively peace and harmony will spread in our world. Then ideally one should set a clear and powerful motivation and if one can, one should try to help others. If one is unable to help them, at least one should not engage in physical or verbal actions which are harmful to others.
And in so doing, we ourselves and others will be at peace. It is also extremely honest, important to be 100% honest, 100% straight in one’s dealings with others. An honest, straightforward and good motivation and way of thinking is not something which is specific to the Buddhist teachings. It is present in worldly affairs too in Geshela’s opinion. Then we should try to practice these three principles of the path.
In other words, try to practice renunciation, Bodhicitta and the correct view. The practice of renunciation and of Bodhicitta is somewhat easier. Here renunciation, a definite emergence, refers to renunciation from rebirth, from the actual birth process which is seen as an object of fear. Bodhicitta is not as difficult to generate because we have within our mind streams both compassion and love at present. This compassion and love is a partial, a biased compassion and love which has been present within our mind stream since beginningless time, but it is possible to enhance it.
It is however substantially more difficult to generate the correct view of emptiness with which we have no prior acquaintance. Now within the context of renunciation, the main motor of renunciation is an understanding of the shared problem all of us in this world have. Geshela asked the question last Wednesday, what is our biggest problem in this life? Then he was quite surprised by the answers. Some said self cherishing, some said money, some said have, some said practice and so forth.
Your way of thinking and Geshela’s way of thinking of a different Geshela feels that whether one is a Buddhist or a non Buddhist, for that matter a non religious practitioner, the biggest problem all beings in this world share is death. Looking at it in this way, we can reflect on Shantideva’s quote in the Bodhisattva Acharya Vatara, if there is something do about it, why worry? On the other hand, if there is nothing to do about it, why worry also? In this case, the way for us to handle death is to become progressively trained and accustomed to the concept of our own death. And therefore one of the aphorisms of the Kadampa Geshe of yore was why fear death?
It is a place of rebirth which is to be feared. This was the crux of their practice. Death is not to be feared since fundamentally it is unavoidable. What is to be feared is the place of one’s future rebirth which could potentially be in the lower realms. The main gateway for us ordinary beings into a generation of renunciation is fear of death.
And therefore reflecting on death and its possible consequences for us, therefore reflecting on death and impermanence, we in turn generate the wish for a higher rebirth. This is mere or simple renunciation. Fully qualified renunciation is a renunciation to the totality of cyclic existence. Then in addition to this, we must generate Bodhicitta which is rooted in both compassion and love. And then in the case of bodhicitta, if we can generate incontrovertible spontaneous bodhicitta, the amount of merit accumulated is inconceivable.
But even if we generate contrived, artificial bodhicitta, nonetheless, as Shantideva says, the merit which is generated is beyond that of any worldly activity. And therefore, let us generate such a motivation reflecting on how fortunate we are to have received such teachings and let us try to generate a motivation of bodhicitta which is rooted in both great compassion and love. The foundation on which Bodhicitta is generated is the pre existence within our mind stream of both empathy and love. It is on this foundation that Bodhicitta can be generated. Now we talked in great detail in the previous teachings of the various types of self cherishing.
Without entering in detail into them again, we can say in keeping with Lamrim that self cherishing amounts to not giving one’s own body away. And therefore one must reflect through many lines of reasoning on the faults of self cherishing and through numerous lines of reasoning on the qualities of cherishing others wishing to give to all sentient beings in this world of ours ranging from animals upwards everything which they wish for. Now regarding empathy or compassion, what is empathy or compassion? It is a wish that all sentient beings be free from suffering and here the suffering we wish to free them from is all pervasive suffering. Likewise, what is love in this context?
Love is the wish that all sentient beings have happiness. All sentient beings as vast in number as space. Happiness in this context is not the transient happiness of worldly experience, it is permanent happiness. It is the happiness to which Je Tsongkhapa refers in the last verse of the three principles of the path when he says, child, go forth in solitude and realize durable happiness. This durable happiness is what is referred to here.
Now from your standpoint you should analyze carefully the relationship between love and compassion. Geshela himself believes that love and compassion are present together when they are generated within a continuum. That they are, in other words, one given substance but of different counter positives or counterparts. And therefore reflecting on the relationship between the four immeasurable equanimity, immeasurable compassion, immeasurable happiness and immeasurable joy, we can see that most probably immeasurable equanimity is of a different substance or a different substantial continuum from the other three immeasurables. Regarding the other three, you should analyze from your own side.
Geshela himself feels that immeasurable compassion, immeasurable love and immeasurable joy are actually one substance. They are therefore one substantial continuum and none of the three can ever be present within a mental continuum without the other two being present as well. They are however what are known as different counter positives. In other words, there is a mere nominal differentiation between them. It is however up to you to analyze this.
It is precisely this sort of analysis which is engaged in in the great seats when one studies Buddhist philosophy. One would analyze for instance with one’s debate partner what precisely is immeasurable joy? What is a substantial continuum of immeasurable joy? Is it of the same substantial continuum as immeasurable compassion or not? This is of tremendous benefit for the mind since as a result of this the concepts are deeply rooted within the mind stream.
So this is similar to the situation within the 12 links of dependent origination in which it is actually the increase in strength of the eighth link, the link of existence which causes the generation of the ninth link. Now regarding love within the twofold division of main minds and mental factors, love is a mental factor. And from within the subdivision of happy and unhappy minds, love is a happy mind. Love is as you know the wish for certain beings to be endowed with happiness and the causes of happiness. The question is, what happiness are we talking about here?
Is it the normal happiness which we refer to in ordinary existence, which is part of the feeling aggregate, or is it another type of happiness? Most probably it is another type of happiness since the happiness which is referred to here is immutable or unchanging happiness. This immutable or unchanging happiness is on par with the experience of happiness which a being which is engaged in meditative equipoise on a cessation experiences. It is said that there is no greater way of accumulating merit in the impure field in which we exist at present that would generate even for one instant such a feeling of love for other sentient beings. Generally speaking from within the two categories of Sutras, Sutras which are of definitive and Sutras which are of interpretable meaning.
Definitive referring here to Sutras which can be accepted literally. The passages which are found in the works of Buddha Shakyamuni and his main disciples, all the way down through Asanga and so forth, referring to the generation of love and on its basis to the generation of Bodhicitta, clearly indicate the extraordinary benefit in generating love for a short period of time even. Should one generate it for one hour, one day, one week or even one month, the benefits are inconceivable. It is therefore important for us to try to generate it now for just a minute or so to try to get a taste of its benefits. It is of tremendous benefit for us to think in this way since we are for the first time thinking of others and not merely of ourselves.
Our scope has therefore become much broader. Now here, these are not states, the states of love, of compassion, of Bodhicitta, which we can generate at once or in a couple hours. This takes years and years of practice and over the years, over time, quietly our attitude will change. Otherwise, as is said in the Essence of Nectar Lamrim, we are forgetting the fact that the power of non virtuous karma is extremely great, whereas that of virtue within our minds is extremely weak. And here, when we are meditating on love, we are meditating on giving beings immutable, invariable, unchanging love.
We are not planning on giving to sentient beings transitory happiness or worldly happiness, which all of us have and which is not terribly important. Otherwise, just to give beings temporary happiness is meaningless. This is something all of us have and which is of no real benefit. What is meant in the practice of immeasurable love is to give sentient beings immutable happiness and the immutable happiness referred to here is the happiness of the truth of cessation from within the Four Noble Truths. And therefore this love which is referred to is a love which wishes to place all sentient beings in the state of happiness of the dharmakaya.
This is what is meant by immutable happiness. And to do this through dedicating the totality of the roots of virtue which one has accumulated in the past and the present and those which one will accumulate in the future from the smallest deeds such as giving a mouthful of food to an animal up to the great deeds such as generating bodhicitta, great compassion and love to this goal. And the doubt which might arise at this point is what precisely is the benefit of such a love? An example of the benefit of such a love would be donating one’s body to others after one’s death. Donating one’s body to others after one’s death causes no hardship whatsoever to oneself, yet it is of great benefit to others.
As Ariadeva, the foremost disciple of Nagarjuna said in one of his Tantric treatises, therefore at present one trains in great love to be able to practice it eventually. The meaning of this passage is that at present we train in visualizing, offering our body, our possessions, our happiness to others so that eventually down the line we are able to do so in reality. Through becoming accustomed to doing this in visualization, it is definite that eventually we will be able to do this in reality. You remember that Sunday a week ago, two Tibetans, Geshela believes they were monks from Amdo, traveled all the way from Amdo to Lhasa and committed suicide by fire, immolated themselves by fire on the Bakur, burning alive for some fifteen minutes. This is a clear illustration of giving one’s body for the sake of others.
Not everyone is able to do this. We can only imagine the pain they experience for fifteen minutes, but through habituation their minds were able to do this for the benefit of others, for the benefit of the Buddha’s teachings and of this world. Therefore, through the transformation of one’s mind through love and through great compassion, there definitely does the capacity to give one’s body for the sake of others. You might think just through reading these scriptures in these texts, well, these things are talked about but it doesn’t exist in reality. That is false.
In Lhasa, there is living proof or there was proof of two human beings who were able to give their lives for the sake of others. Therefore, whatever we do under the power of the afflictions of the delusions, irrespective of whether we think it is virtue or not is non virtue. Whatever we engage in with the motivation of helping others through altruism is virtue. For this reason, the teachers have have said that in general when one is ordained, one must be very careful about the motivation with which one wears monastic robes. If the motivation is good, it is virtuous.
If it is not good, it is non virtuous. Likewise, when we engage in worldly activities such as dressing, eating, whatever, as long as the motivation which is generated for this deed is good, the deed becomes good. This motivation must obviously be generated before engaging in the deed. Having completed the presentation of the nature of love and of its benefits and here we are not referring to the love within our mind stream, that love which is altruistic and which is to benefit others. At present, Geshela will start presenting compassion.
And we will stop here for today. If you have one question, Geshela will take it at present. Mainly because their objects of observation are different. The object of observation of love is endowment with happiness. The object of observation of compassion is freedom from suffering.
The object of observation of joy is rejoicing in endowment with happiness. If we take for instance the mental factors of aspiration, recollection and concentration. These mental factors have the same aspect. They actually are of the same substance with the main mind which they accompany. Yet they are given different names in terms of their mode of apprehension.
Does that answer your question? To understand this, you have to study a little bit the difference between minds and mental factors. And the fact that one main mind is accompanied by numerous mental factors which have the five criteria of similarity with that main mind. Otherwise it’s difficult to understand this. The difference of equanimity, the first of the four mental factors with the remaining three, comes from the fact that equanimity’s focus is extremely different.
The focus of equanimity is non discrimination between those towards whom one is partial, in other words one’s friends, one’s relatives, and those towards whom one is hostile, in other words one’s enemies and one’s foes and so forth. Alright. Did you understand? The result seems the same in my mind if I look at it. You have study LORC.
Loric Without Loric, it’s difficult to understand this. Little bit difficult for you. Bit. Another question? This is just a point for debate which Geshela cast in your path.
It is open to question whether all three immeasurables can be present simultaneously in the developmental factors for one main mind.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.