Awakening Heart — 2012-05-20

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2012-05-20
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2012-05-20 – KR.mp3

UUID: 0ad3af5e-c33b-4ba9-a65e-3e8064e9deff

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2012-05-20

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 32m

Words: 3,836

Degrees. 80? So within the six preliminary practices, the first practice which has been covered elaborately in the past is to set up correctly a representation of the enlightened being’s body and you probably have such a representation in your altar room. The second is to make a nondeceitful, in other words, honesty offerings to this representation. And the third is to set one’s body on a comfortable seat in the posture of Vairochana virtuous mind.

The special here which qualifies virtuous refers to bodhicitta. The fifth limb is the offering of the seven limb prayers which has been covered in detail. War the sixth limb is the series of entreaties to the lineage masters of this tradition starting with Buddha Shakyamuni downwards through Atisha. Now regarding the sixth preliminary practice, there is no special presentation of this. However, there are some pairs of entreaties which summarize it.

Now where is the motivation generated within the six preliminary practices? It is generated at the level of the third preliminary practice when it is said seating oneself upon a comfortable cushion in the posture of Vairochana, which is the posture we are supposed to have at present. And this special virtuous state of mind which is referred to at the level of the third preliminary is the motivation which is generated at the level of the third of the six preliminaries. This special virtuous state of mind refers to bodhicitta. However, this is perhaps too advanced a motivation for us to generate.

Therefore, we will merely talk of altruism or the wish to benefit others. It is independence on such a motivation that virtuous deeds are engaged in and yield their fruits. And it is in the absence of such a motivation that non virtuous deeds are engaged in. The gateway to such a motivation of altruism is the supreme thought. Such a supreme thought can only be generated for the benefit of others.

It is impossible to generate such a supreme thought for one’s own benefit. It is a contradiction in terms. Today, the tea is rather weak. Who made the tea today? Who did make this cup of tea?

Sometimes it’s really good. But today, so so. However, we will let the tea be. So regarding this generation of the supreme thought, This can only be generated for the benefit of others. Now we ourselves claim to be Mahayana practitioners.

However, if we examine our practice in reality we must recognize that we are only verbally Mahayana practitioners in the same way as the practice of our commitments is purely a verbal practice. Now for us to generate at once Bodhicitta would be rather difficult. Therefore, what we should try to do is to familiarize our mind with the concept of Bodhicitta and implant karmic imprints within our mind so that they mature later on. Generally speaking, it is critical that we practice what we hear, that we blend the teachings with our mind. In our cases, we have, for instance, attended teachings on the totality of the path of Sutra and Mantra.

If these teachings are not put into practice, we will have wasted our time and Geshela feels perhaps it is better that we stay at home and do what Australians usually do when they stay at home, which is drink some brandy, smoke some cigarettes, have fun. There is no real point in coming to the temple at all. So if one is going to come to the temple to attend teachings, then one must have the resolve to put these teachings into practice. Otherwise, you’ll be happier with your Australian Barbies at home. Exactly.

This is exactly it. Because if you come to the temple and you don’t practice, there’s no benefit for this life and there’s no benefit for future lives. And why bother? Bodhicitta is said to be the peace and the happiness of this world. Where bodhicitta is present, there is no strife.

And therefore, this single pointed concentration on bodhicitta is of extraordinary benefit. If you are not careful, then you will end up as people who are totally inured to dharma and for whom dharma is irrelevant. In Tibet, the Buddha’s teachings have been prevalent for the last sixteen hundred years or so. However, over sixteen hundred years the final result has been that the practice of most Tibetans is purely based on faith and the true practice which is based on study and meditation only exists probably in the great seats of We believe it at that and at present will generate the motivation to be of benefit to others in any which way we can through our body, speech and mind. So as Geshe Chekawa says, take revenge in the light of dharma.

This refers to overcoming self cherishing which is the root of all our foes. Now within the context of overcoming self cherishing and generating bodhicitta, there are two main methods of generating bodhicitta. The first, the sevenfold interchange of self and others and the excuse me, the first, the sevenfold cause and effect teaching and the second, the interchange of self and others within the seven verses of mind training. These are fused in this presentation of the generation of Bodhicitta. The transmission of the sevenfold cause and effect instruction proceeds mainly from Atisha.

All the transmission of the instructions of the interchange of self and others and the generation of love, great compassion, the supreme attitude in Bodhicitta proceed mainly from Shantideva. So this is a very delicate point. When Gesheva himself was at the monastery, he did not clearly understand the difference between the cause and effect generation of seven fold cause and effect generation of bodhicitta and the generation of bodhicitta through the interchange of self and others. If one examines, one sees that all of the terms and the topics of the sevenfold cause and effect generation of bodhicitta occur within the teachings of the interchange of self and others. On the other hand, all of the terms and topics of the interchange of self and others do not occur within the sevenfold cause and effect teachings on bodhicitta.

Therefore, the interchange of self and others procedure for generating bodhicitta is more powerful than that of the sevenfold cause and effect procedure. So when we say that Atisha practiced the sevenfold cause and effect generation of bodhicitta but did not practice the interchange of self and others generation of bodhicitta, what is meant by this? What is meant is that Atisha practiced overtly, openly the seven fold cause and effect generation of Bodhicitta but he practiced in secrecy the teachings of the interchange of self and others and these were transmitted secretly from Atisha all the way down to the great Kadampa Geshe Geshe Charahua. This is in keeping with the verse in Shantideva’s Bodhisattva Charyavatara which says, the practice of the interchange of self and others is an instruction which is to be kept secret. Now it is not the case that Atisha did not practice the interchange of self and others.

Atisha was the recipient of the totality of the lineages of both the vast teachings of the path which ranged from Buddha Shakyamuni through Maitreya down to Atisha and the profound lineage which ranged from Buddha Shakyamuni through Nagarjuna and Ariadeva all the way down to Atisha as well. In addition, Atisha had received the uncommon transmissions from Shantideva. So it is definite that Atisha had received the transmissions of the interchange of self and others and practiced them. Then Gesheera asked Khensur Rinpoche why it was said in Bodhisattvacharyavatara that the practice of the interchange of self and others is to remain a secret instruction. Khensur Rinpoche said this was probably because this was an instruction which should not be observed in the self same way as the union of bliss and emptiness is a secret instruction.

So the difference in the procedure of generating bodhicitta of the sevenfold cause and effect instruction and the interchange of self and others instruction is the following. Within the sevenfold cause and effect instruction, the first three causes which are recognizing all sentient beings as one’s mothers of yore, recollecting their kindness and resolving to repay their kindness, are the uncommon causes on the basis of which love is generated. And then in dependence on love, the other results which follow in the sevenfold cause and effect procedure are generated. On the other hand, in the practice of the interchange of self and others, these first three steps are eliminated. So there is no generation of the recollection of all mother sentient beings of yore as one mother’s.

One’s mother, the recollection of their kindness and the resolve to repay their kindness. Instead, first, one reflects through numerous lines of reasoning, through numerous doors technically in Tibetan on the thoughts of self cherishing and then one reflects through numerous lines of reasoning on the qualities of cherishing others. And independence on this, one practices the interchange of self and others which becomes the gateway for generating love. The remainder of the procedure to generate Bodhicitta is the same as in the sevenfold cause and effect. In other words, after practicing the interchange of self and others, one generates love, great compassion, the supreme thought and bodhicitta.

So this practice of generating bodhicitta through the interchange of self and others is extraordinarily powerful since it includes all of the elements of the sevenfold cause and effect generation of bodhicitta. On the other hand, the sevenfold cause and effect generation of bodhicitta does not include the totality of the interchange of self and others. If you were to reflect carefully on why the seven fold cause and effect instruction generating bodhicitta does not comprise the interchange of self and others, while on the other hand, the interchange of self and others comprises the sevenfold cause and effect generation of bodhicitta in detail, then time would pass very quickly in your practice and you wouldn’t notice the need for lunch nor the need for supper. Then this is the way one studies in the great monasteries and through this intensive studies of study of great text, time flies. Then for those of you who don’t have experience, time must crawl very slowly.

And this teaching on the interchange of self and others is extraordinarily profound and beneficial as all of the teachings of Atisha of Shantideva. Since to the difference of the sevenfold cause and instruction teachings of the generation of Bodhicitta, which rest on the recognition of all sentient beings as one’s mothers of yore and therefore which rests in turn on an understanding of the existence of past and future lives and of karma and causality. Shantideva’s teachings on the interchange of self and others do not require such an understanding of the existence of past and future lives or of causality, which is very difficult for you. Therefore, those teachings are of extraordinary benefit. To train correctly the sevenfold cause and effect generation of bodhicitta, all of us must initially meditate on these three first causes, which is the recognition of all sentient beings as one’s mother of yore, the recollection of their kindness and the resolve to repay their kindness, which is very difficult to generate.

The interchange of self and others is an extraordinarily powerful instruction for the generation of bodhicitta because unlike the sevenfold cause and effect instruction, which relies on an understanding and a recognition of the existence of past and future lives, the interchange of self and other generation of bodhicitta is based exclusively on this life. It is therefore preeminently suited for Westerners. In this interchange of self and others, one generates love as a result of recognizing the faults of self cherishing and the qualities of other cherishing through the kindness of others in this life. We can see how great beings in this world of ours and specifically in India have generated certainly love through the practice of the interchange of self and others without ever being Buddhist. In the case of Mahatma Gandhi, who was of such benefit to India, it is doubtful that Gandhi generated love through practicing the sevenfold cause and effect instruction, and it is open to question what his position on past and future lives was.

However, it is undeniable that Gandhi generated great love and as a result of this was of extraordinary benefit to India. Likewise, Mother Teresa, the Christian nun in Calcutta, did not accept the existence of past lives and only one future life. Yet, it is clear that she generated great love through the practice of the interchange of self and others. Then whether they went beyond this and generated actual bodhicitta or not is another question. Very important.

Isn’t it? You have a lot of doubt suddenly, don’t you? This is extraordinary and this is a very profound point. The case of mother Teresa, think of what Gandhi accomplished for the world. Think of mother Teresa who abandoned the life of a fortunate Albanian in her family, went to Calcutta, dedicated herself endlessly for the poor, and who after her death manifested in the dreams of Christians.

Beings like these who first generated altruism within their mind stream and then not just generated the altruism but actually engaged in work for others, walked the walk. Such beings are extraordinary and they are clearly beings who are on the same wavelength as the teachings in Atisha’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara. And therefore, one engages in this practice through first reflecting on the faults of other cherishing through numerous lines of reasoning and then on the qualities of altruism or cherishing others through numerous lines of reasoning before summarizing all of this in one practice. So here, when one speaks of eliminating self cherishing, it does not mean that one abandons everything one owns and one gives up one’s house, one’s wealth, one’s family, and so forth. It does refer, however, to reflecting on the thoughts of self cherishing.

And therefore, the mind training as the rays of the sun propounds a mode of training which is mainly propounded from the standpoint of those who are ordained. However, this does apply also to us broadly speaking and it is something we should put into practice. If we put into practice what is taught here, then there is point in our attending these teachings. Otherwise, we will be in the situation as it is said of someone who embraces with admiration the marvels of cyclic existence. Self cherishing is the root of all delusions.

It is the root for ourselves, for for ourselves, for instance, of envy towards those who are our superiors, of competitiveness, towards those who are our equals, and of contempt for those who are our inferiors. These three attitudes are rooted in self cherishing. Self cherishing is perhaps not a delusion in the full sense of the term. It is the root of all delusions. Other delusions such as anger or desire which belong to different categories of delusion cannot coexist.

It is not possible to have strong anger at the same time as one has strong desire or strong desire with strong anger. However, self cherishing is the root of all in the self same way as it is said that one can lead an oxen to the field through the ring in his nostrils and one can guide a horse through the bridle. If we take an example from daily life, when we are hungry, we eat actually impelled by self cherishing. However, if we reflect really carefully on everything we engage in, in daily life, everything from the food which we eat upwards is actually provided through the kindness of others. So we shall now please meditate for two or three minutes on self cherishing and its faults.

Reflecting on this self cherishing which is also called in the Lamrim, not giving one’s body to others, as Gesheber has already explained, and on cherishing others. And therefore, we should reflect carefully on the faults of the self cherishing of which the great Kadampa Geshes such as Geshe Chekawa said, take revenge on the foremost foe. In other words, strike self cherishing on the head. And of which Geshe Bon Kungil said, I stand guard at the gateway of my mind and when self cherishing rears its head, I grasp my spear, whereas when self cherishing slinks away, I relax my guard. And let us all reflect on the fact that those of us who work for companies or who work in societies have to deal with others and all of the difficulties which arise in this context are rooted in our own self cherishing.

As Geshela said previously, and I forgot to translate this, when we see two people even in the center who are talking in low voices, immediately in our mind the thought arises, it’s about me they are muttering. Now this is a very, very strange attitude rooted in self cherishing. Very little bit little bit, I think so. Little bit little bit. So a little bit of self cherishing is very harmful to our peace of mind.

Whereas if we can create this strong motivation, then whatever we engage in is very easy to engage in. The hardship we experience, whether we are in society or in retreat, are all rooted in self cherishing. And therefore, let us reflect for two minutes on the fact that all the difficulties we encounter in life are rooted in our own self cherishing. In that mind, as Lamrim says, which refuses to give our body away. And if we find this is true, then let us pursue this kind of reasoning.

If it is not true, let us give it up. And therefore, if we understand the faults of self cherishing and keeping with Namka Pel’s, mind training as the rays of the sun, then we will see clearly that there is no benefit in putting the initiation vase thousands of times on one’s crown just as there is no benefit in putting monastic robes on an old yak. It is therefore critical for us to think of our own mind and to realize that even were a great teacher like Kenser Rinpoche to place the initiation vase over and again on our head. This would be of no benefit if from our own side there is no practice. Otherwise, anyone could do this, couldn’t they?

Therefore, if one practices in this way, blending one’s mind with the teachings, then irrespective of where one is, whether one is in a mountain retreat, in the city, on a plane, one’s mind will be fused with the teachings. We ourselves seem to feel that reciting our commitments amounts to dharma practice. Then if this were the case, if there were no commitments, there would be no dharma practice. And if we practice in this way, blending our minds with the teachings, then we will be practicing wherever we are, whether we are in a mountain retreat, on the plane or what not. However, if our studies and our practice lead self cherishing and self grasping to blaze, then they will be of no benefit.

It is very profound to engage in such a practice of interchange of self and others because it is of tremendous benefit to oneself and one should not talk about it to others unless they directly benefit from that. This is the way it is, this is not easy but it is a profound topic which is of great benefit. Even though we have talked about this already, Geshela was very happy to cover the practice of the interchange of self and others. The numerous faults of self cherishing to be understood by numerous lines of reasoning and the numerous qualities of cherishing others or altruism to also be understood through numerous lines of reasoning precisely because there is great benefit for him and he is almost 100% sure there is benefit for the students as well. If this is not the case and you have just been sitting here without thinking about things and have no particular intention to practice, then you have truly wasted your time and Geshela feels it would be wiser to spend it going on a walk or doing something else with your lives.

I wonder if all of you drink alcohol. I told him probably. Yeah. Yeah. Good.

Good. Thank you. If you first study what is taught here and then you practice it, then your study and practice will become extremely solid. On the other hand, if that is not what you plan on doing, then it is Sunday, you live far away, gasoline is no longer inexpensive, you might better stay at home. Alright.

If you have questions, I will be happy to take them at present. Few questions. A few questions. Yes, please. How to address their self cherishing?

That is quite straight forward actually. Self has understood the force of self cherishing, then when others have strong self cherishing, one should give them advice on the problems of self cherishing, the problems of egotism in other words and the advantages of altruism. This is in keeping with the four means of gathering disciples which is taught in the Lamrim which include first offering objects, tea, money, whatever pleases others, and then soothing them with quiet and pleasant talk. These are very skillful means of gathering friends or disciples. Otherwise, if you don’t do this, they won’t listen.

Buddha Shakyamuni was extraordinarily skillful in means. This practice of the four means of gathering disciples is a Mahayana practice. And then? Other questions? Can you question?

Do you have a question? Geshek has told you everything he has to say. But regarding the four means of gathering disciples, one should initially try to be as friendly and as generous as one can and then talk to them with a kind voice and proceed in this way. And then, can you call Shimmy, Toomin? No.

Really? Oh. Yeah. Do you have questions? Nonetheless, reflect carefully over and again and quietly, quietly things will improve.

So generally speaking, the suffering people experience is the result of their own past karma. Then, whatever means one engages into reduced self cherishing will reduce suffering down the line but it is difficult for it to reduce suffering at once. The practices one should try to engage in are the practices of giving and taking. Gisher can say in his own case, he had important responsibilities in the monastery and as a result of this self cherishing was very much an issue. Not so much that he was physically threatened but over and again, people would use harsh words or he had to use harsh words to restrain the behavior of others.

Then he trained himself to reduce his own self cherishing and try to speak kindly to others. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top