Awakening Heart — 2011-07-03

1 h 30 min · 3,569 words · 3 July 2011 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2011-07-03
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 90-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen begins his commentary on the 37 Practices of the Children of the Victorious Ones, a classical text by Thogme Zangpo on Bodhisattva ethics. He opens with the homage verses to Avalokiteśvara, unpacking the Sanskrit grammar and philosophical significance of each term. He then explains the foundational Buddhist concepts: the two meanings of Dharma (phenomena and teachings that subdue the mind), the three divisions of Buddhist understanding (science, view, and practice), and crucially, the Buddha nature—both composite (the mind itself) and noncomposite (the emptiness of the mind). He demonstrates how wisdom realizing emptiness and compassionate action toward all beings arise inseparably within enlightened awareness, contrasting this with the limitations of unenlightened practitioners. The session closes with audience questions on the relationship between emptiness and bodhicitta, the role of faith toward the guru, and the human basis required for generating bodhicitta. The teaching is aimed at serious practitioners studying the foundational Buddhist path.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2011-07-03.mp3

UUID: b3de1b39-1053-4ad2-8451-30e3ea009f12

Teacher: HH Dalai Lama

Collection: Awakening Heart

Date: 2011-07-03

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,566

# 2011-07-03

**Collection:** Audio Recordings — Unclassified
**Duration:** 90.6 minutes
**Words:** 3,571
**Model:** Deepgram Nova-3
**Corrections applied:** 10
**Transcribed:** 2026-03-08 00:48

—

For the sake of all mother sentient beings as vast as space, let us generate the pure motivation to attain full enlightenment, which entails a realization of the actual nature of phenomena. So today, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen will be teaching this text, the 37 practices of the children of the victorious ones. This text was composed by Thogme Zangpo, and the lineage of transmission of this text was received by Geshe-la both from Geshe Konchog Kyab and Geshe Rabten in the past, and the oral instruction, the direct transmission was also received from His Holiness the Dalai Lama. And the author of this text is known as Thogme Zangpo. Mercury in English actually refers to the name of the homeland, the country of Thogme Zangpo, who lived some 80 years of age and was contemporary with the great Nyingma polymath. And the epithet of Thogme Zangpo, child of the victorious ones, is to be understood as follows.

Child here does not mean child in the physical sense of the term, and the victorious ones refers to victory over the afflictions. This victory over the afflictions was manifested by Buddha Śākyamūni, and all of his disciples are now called children of the victorious ones. In the case of Thogme Zangpo, he is called a child of the victorious ones because, training his mind in the four noble truths which were taught initially by the Buddha and progressively accustoming his mind to them, he eventually gave rise to that bodhicitta which fulfills the welfare of both self and others. And as a result of this was called child of the victorious ones. After the title of this text, the 37 Bodhisattva practices or the 37 practices of the children of the victorious ones, this title is given in the light of the import or the subject matter of the text, which is a means of training the mind in that bodhicitta which fulfills both one’s own welfare and that of others, and this is so taught in 37 shlokas or 37 stanzas.

Geshe-la will rely—he has studied many texts on this topic, but will mainly rely on his commentary on the 37 practices of the Bodhisattvas, and he has memorized it as well. And if we now take the root text of Thogme Zangpo, which was handed out to you, the first verse of this text reads in Sanskrit, in English, homage to Avalokiteśvara. Namo here in Sanskrit means I prostrate. Lokeshvara—loka in Sanskrit is world. Lokeshvara is the ruler of the world. Avalokiteśvara is the ruler of the world. The ‘a’ here is a dative case in Sanskrit. And Avalokiteśvara is on the altar to our right. It is to him homage is paid. So the preliminary homage at the beginning of the text, homage to Lokeshvara or prostration to Lokeshvara, has two purposes.

The first is to eliminate interferences or obstructions in the mind of both the composer and the audience. And the second is for the author himself, by paying homage to his tutelary deity Avalokiteśvara, to gain realization of that deity. So we will now pass to the first stanza of this text. The order of the verse in Tibetan and in English is different. Therefore, we will now be looking at the second line.

Who, although seeing the lack of going and coming of all phenomena. Now generally speaking, there are two versions of this text. One, which is the one you have in your translation, reads, although seeing the lack of going and coming of all phenomena. The other reads, through seeing the lack of coming and going of all phenomena. Geshe-la’s text has through seeing the lack of going and coming of all phenomena. So the verse, who although seeing the lack of going and coming of all phenomena, bears in the Tibetan the term which means both phenomena and dharma. Therefore, an introduction must be given to that term. So the foremost meaning of the term translated in English as phenomena is the totality of what is perceived—in other words, phenomena.

It is not the second meaning of the term dharma from within Dharma and worldly activities. This is secondary. The second meaning of the term Dharma—Dharma from within Dharma and worldly activities—is that meaning of Dharma where Dharma is applied to tame or to subdue the mind. Now regarding the second meaning of the term Dharma, generally speaking in this world there are two categories of beings, those who accept a Dharma and those who do not. Within those who accept a Dharma, there is a subdivision between those who accept a Dharma by view and those who do not accept a Dharma by view.

Those who accept a Dharma by view include the Christians, the Jewish, the Muslim, the Hindus, and so forth. In every single case, these Dharmas can give rise to love, to compassion, and to empathy. So they are all identical in that respect. And moreover, they are all similar in generating the qualities of compassion, love, and faith. Nonetheless, they are different in understanding what these qualities arise from.

Buddhists are probably unique in understanding that these qualities arise from the elimination of self-grasping. Apart from the presentation in the Buddhist scriptures, there is no tradition which teaches that our immemorial suffering is due to a mistaken view, a wrong view, which arises through apprehending the nature of phenomena wrongly. This wrong view is to be countered by an authentic view, which is not discordant with the meaning of the sutras. One can be called a Buddhist practitioner from two viewpoints, either from one viewpoint, which is the best, which is giving rise to these qualities of faith, compassion, and empathy based on a valid cognizer which gives rise to that wisdom understanding the nature of phenomena in concordance with sūtra, or alternatively, if one is incapable of doing so, through merely giving rise to them on the basis of scripture. So when we speak of Buddhism, in Tibetan it is inner Dharma.

That is the meaning of interior Dharma. So generally speaking, there are three subdivisions of Buddha Dharma into Buddhist science, Buddhist view, and Buddhist practice. Regarding Buddhist science, Buddhist science is the explanation of the nature, the actual mode of abiding of phenomena. The Buddhist view is the generation of renunciation and so forth upon that basis, and Buddhist practice is the generation of realizations through practice upon that basis. And specifically, what is referred to after this introduction into Dharma by true Dharma is that inseparable fusion of the wisdom realizing single-pointedly emptiness with its object, which is the emptiness being realized in the selfsame way as water is mixed with water.

And therefore, the meaning of the first verse in Tibetan, which is in the middle of your English text, who although seeing the lack of going and coming of all phenomena, refers to phenomena’s fundamental unity from the standpoint of being perceived by this wisdom which single-pointedly realizes emptiness and which is fused with its object emptiness. And therefore, the conjoined meaning of the two last verses in our first stanza, who although seeing the lack of going and coming of all phenomena endeavors one-pointedly to benefit sentient beings, is that within that yogic direct valid cognizer which perceives single-pointedly the emptiness of all phenomena and is inseparably fused within that emptiness, the mind of compassion which endeavors one-pointedly to benefit sentient beings arises. It is impossible for beings who have not attained the state of full enlightenment to fuse in this way both the direct yogic perception of emptiness and the subsequent cognizer subsequent to this realization in a single-pointed effort to actualize the benefit of beings. Who is endowed with a yogic direct perceiver realizing emptiness which is able to perform the same activities as the subsequent perceiver? None other than our spiritual teacher who is seen here as identical with Avalokiteśvara or Chenrezig.

Hence, the two first verses of the stanza: I always respectfully prostrate with my three doors to the excellent teacher and protector Chenrezig. In these two first verses, always means that this is continually done throughout all three times. Prostrating with one’s three doors refers to the three doors of body, speech, and mind through which all activities are performed. So what do we mean here when we speak of prostration with the three doors of body, speech, and mind? Bodily or physical prostration is to physically prostrate as a sign of respect to Ārya Avalokiteśvara.

Verbal prostration is to utter praises to Ārya Avalokiteśvara. Mental prostration is to generate mentally veneration for Avalokiteśvara and perform offerings as well. If you could recite the tea offering.

The following stanza, the perfect Buddha is the source of all temporal and ultimate happiness. They arise from having accomplished the holy Dharma. As accomplishing that also depends on knowing its practices, I shall explain the practice of Bodhisattvas—this is the pledge to compose the text. In the first verse, the perfect Buddha is the source of all temporal and ultimate happiness. Happiness is twofold, contingent and ultimate. Contingent or short-term happiness is our happiness within this life or in future lives. Ultimate happiness refers to attaining liberation or full enlightenment. And here, these twofold happiness—contingent happiness referring to happiness in future lives and ultimate happiness referring to the happiness of liberation or full enlightenment—find their source in what? They find their source in that fully enlightened Buddha which is endowed with the four bodies. It is impossible to attain the state of full enlightenment in dependence exclusively on prayer and on faith, as is indicated in the second verse of this stanza: arise from having accomplished the holy Dharma. The attainment of the state of full enlightenment endowed with the four bodies is only possible through training one’s mind in an understanding of the four noble truths and the six perfections which the Buddha extensively and irreproachably taught.

And this verse, arise from having accomplished the holy Dharma, not only indicates that one attains full enlightenment through the practice of the Dharma. It also indicates that both oneself and all other beings are endowed with the Buddha nature. What is understood here by the Buddha nature or—with a strict translation from Tibetan—Buddha type? The Buddha nature here is twofold, composite and noncomposite. The composite Buddha nature can be understood correctly enough by positing it as that mind with which we have been reflecting since beginningless time. What precisely is meant here when we speak of the Buddha nature as none other than the mind?

We can understand that if we take the example of anger. Anger, for instance, when it arises can lead, let us say, to violence within the family. This violence within the family is a great fault and the antidote to anger must therefore be applied. The application of the antidote to anger enables a purification of anger. Many of us at present in this room meditate.

We know when we meditate that through meditating on renunciation, on bodhicitta, and so forth, progressively over time, the mind improves. This improvement of the mind is a clear indication that all of us have within us the Buddha nature. The second verse in Tibetan ends with the term in addition, which is not translated in English. In addition refers to the sum total of the teachings of the Buddha extending from the four noble truths to the six perfections and so forth. The following verse, as accomplishing that also depends on knowing its practices, indicates clearly that the realization of these states can occur easily and comfortably only if one has first studied and understood them.

In keeping with what was explained previously, inasmuch as that bodhicitta which strives to actualize one’s own welfare and that of others is fundamental to practice, the final verse of the second stanza indicates that Thogme Zangpo is going to explain bodhicitta—in other words, the practice of the Bodhisattvas. So putting to one side the practices of the beings of small and middling scope, the focus of this text is on the practice of the being of great scope. The first stanza is the homage of Thogme Zangpo to Ārya Avalokiteśvara. The second stanza formulates the subject of the treatise, which is none other than bodhicitta. So we are most fortunate to have in this temple a statue of Ārya Avalokiteśvara. This is a very favorable omen for this teaching.

Generally speaking, all of the teachings on compassion which will be expounded, we owe to the kindness of the guru Avalokiteśvara whose mind comprises these teachings, and Geshe-la will do his best to explain them in the forthcoming weeks. However, he will stop here for today since two stanzas are appropriate to begin with. So generally speaking, inasmuch as great compassion is a state of mind, it is not visible. Yet, great compassion when it takes physical shape manifests in the form of Avalokiteśvara, and in that sense, in this world we can say that we have encountered him. So this will be it for today, and Geshe-la is open to your questions, and then we will have prayers.

So if you have questions, Geshe-la will take two or three questions. Yes, Pamela.

So this verse refers to emptiness, and here the yogic direct perceiver which directly perceives emptiness is fused with the object emptiness which it perceives in the selfsame way as water which is poured into water is fused and inseparable. No difference can be posited. And therefore, in this context, at that time, there is neither conceptuality nor elaboration. It’s a question. Thank you. Then, yes.

Well, it’s because the other is although. So there are indeed two recensions. Geshe-la’s text reads because or from. Our text here reads although. Both are valid. They have, however, different meanings.

The recension in Geshe-la’s text, because or from, means that actually it is because one has realized emptiness that thereby one understands the fundamental equality of all beings in fearing suffering and wishing for happiness, and on this basis one is able to give rise to bodhicitta. On the other hand, the alternate reading which is although indicates actually it is within the context of the realization of emptiness that the state of subsequent attainment arises, and this state of subsequent attainment is the state of great compassion.

And ordinary beings, before they attain the state of full enlightenment, are unable to realize emptiness with the conventional mind of bodhicitta. It is only upon attaining full enlightenment that such a mind does indeed realize emptiness. Good question. Yes, Lily?

Please, if you have any questions, feel free to ask them. Yes.

So how to understand and how to give rise to faith in one’s root guru here is to initially reflect on our Dharma disposition before we met the spiritual teacher. And then after that, through reflecting regularly on his teachings, as we see the qualities increasing within our mind—so that’s an excellent question. Generally speaking, all teachings regarding the generation of faith, love, and empathy are present in all the religious traditions—Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, and so forth. The uncommon feature of Buddhism is that the importance given to faith initially is given because the goal of that faith is to enable that wisdom which realizes emptiness, in dependence on the teacher’s teachings, to arise within the mind. Yes?

Could you reformulate your question?

So there is no definiteness about the realization of emptiness leading to bodhicitta. For instance, we have the Pratyekabuddhas and the Shravakas who have realized emptiness and yet do not generate bodhicitta. The root of bodhicitta is great compassion, and generally speaking, there are two ways to give rise or two sequences for the realizations of emptiness and of bodhicitta.

Practitioners of sharp faculties, who are extremely intelligent in other words, initially realize emptiness and on that basis give rise to bodhicitta, while practitioners of lesser faculties, duller faculties, initially give rise to bodhicitta and on that basis give rise to the realization of emptiness. There are two roads. Okay. You are Lennus?

Very good question. Geshe-la does not know you all by name. Pamela, Sylvia, Carol, Pamela—and then he will train with your names. So if there are more questions, then he will become more familiar. So ask questions for him to know your name. Yes.

You talked about the Buddha nature being twofold, composite and noncomposite. And my understanding—So indeed, the Buddha nature is divided into two. The Buddha nature which is a composite phenomenon and the one which is a noncomposite phenomenon. The first, Geshe-la explained, is the nature of the mind. This is actually what acts as a cause for the Buddha bodies which are composite phenomena. But there is a second one which is the noncomposite Buddha nature. This gives rise to the nonabiding Nirvāṇa of a Buddha, and this is none other than the actual emptiness of our mind. That’s a very good question, because that says you have a very sharp mind, the mind of a scholar. Yes, Marvie?

Geshe-la has placed a very strong emphasis on practice in the center. You were talking about the science of Buddhism, the view of Buddhism, the practice. So what is meant by Buddhist science, the Buddhist view, and the Buddhist practice is: as far as Buddhist science is concerned, an in-depth study of the Buddhist teachings. In dependence on this one gives rise to the Buddhist view, which is fundamentally the three principles of the path—the view of renunciation, of bodhicitta, and the view of emptiness.

This, however, must not merely be something one thinks about intellectually. It must be lived, and this living within oneself occurs through repeated habituation. Very good question. Yes.

So the oath or the pledge of Avalokiteśvara is not to cease manifesting naturally his body, which is a natural manifestation of compassion for the benefit of all beings, until the lower realms—the hell realms, the realm of the pretas, and the animal realms—are completely emptied of their denizens. Therefore, we ourselves, if we practice Avalokiteśvara, will naturally eventually encounter him, experience him. Good question. You are Jasmine?

Good question. Yes.

So in the context of the twofold subdivision between worldly activities and the practice of Dharma, what is referred to in the broadest category of Dharma is anything which leads to the betterment of the trainee. He met you at Sera. He remembers when you came with—So that is a principal point in the difference between Dharma and non-Dharma. Dharma is what is focused on a future life or future lives, principally.

Any other questions? Yes, Melissa?

They are not identical within the mental continuum of a Buddha. In other words, the mind which realizes emptiness and great compassion are different. Yet, every instant of the realization of emptiness within the mental continuum of a Buddha gives rise and can give rise to great compassion. Likewise, every instance of great compassion within the mind of a Buddha can give rise to the realization of emptiness. There is a difference between the mind of a Buddha and the mind of an ordinary being. Very good question, Melissa. Thank you.

So the goal of the Bodhisattva is the attainment of full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. And the basis on which bodhicitta is generated is the bodily basis of a human being. It is very difficult to generate bodhicitta on any other basis. It is said in Candrakīrti’s Madhyamakāvatāra that to obtain the bodily basis of a human being, the pure ethics which is an abandonment of the ten nonvirtues must be practiced.

To practice this pure ethics which is an abandonment of the ten nonvirtues, one must focus on future lives. Otherwise, it is not possible to practice ethics. Therefore, the focus on future lives is not incompatible with the practice of a Bodhisattva. Geshe-la would like to thank you for your questions, which were very informative for him and led him to considerable personal reflection. So, Geshe-la, I would like to thank you, and we will meet regularly.

If we study regularly, all of us will improve. So one of my Tibetan students, Shayne Nettle, has very kindly volunteered to take notes of all of Geshe-la’s teachings on her computer during the teachings. These will be transmitted to Malvin who is in charge of transcripts, and we will have regular transcripts available for Geshe-la’s teaching every Sunday. Thanks to the kindness of Shayne and of Malvin. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
inner Dharma
The Dharma practiced by Buddhists, as opposed to "outer Dharma" which is practiced by non-Buddhists. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
three doors go sum (Tib)
Body, speech and mind. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top