Awakening Heart — 2010-09-05

1 h 21 min · 6,529 words · 5 September 2010

The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2010-09-05
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 81-minute teaching, a Buddhist instructor guides students through Nam Kha Pel’s commentary Training the Mind Like Rays of the Sun, focusing on developing compassion toward those who cause us harm. Building on previous sessions on bodhicitta and cherishing others, the teacher explores how sentient beings provide the essential conditions for practicing patience and the six perfections. The core teaching emphasizes that people who harm us are actually spiritual friends, offering rare opportunities to cultivate the mental strength needed for enlightenment. Using quotes from Śāntideva and Nāgārjuna, the teacher explains how self-cherishing leads to suffering while protecting others generates virtue and merit. Crucially, the teacher clarifies that this compassion-toward-enemies practice occurs in meditation and inner reflection, not in worldly conduct: practitioners must still skillfully limit harm in daily life while internally generating loving-kindness and patience. The teaching is pitched at serious students already familiar with foundational Buddhist concepts and previous sessions of this commentary series.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2010-09-05.mp3

UUID: 7836c8b0-b0fa-4cc1-8b0a-3d85117b78ad

Teacher: the teacher

Collection: Awakening Heart

Date: 2010-09-05

Words: ~6,527

# 2010-09-05

**Collection:** Audio Recordings — Unclassified
**Duration:** 81.3 minutes
**Words:** 6,525
**Model:** Deepgram Nova-3
**Corrections applied:** 17
**Transcribed:** 2026-03-07 23:53

—

You truly wish to hear, understand, and put into practice these teachings for the ultimate aim of eliminating the suffering from other living beings and attaining the state of Buddhahood for the purpose of doing so. So just take a moment and set your motivation. So we begin as we do each week by doing the threefold purification practice whereby we imagine at the crown of our head a small image of the Buddha. And from this image of the Buddha descends light rays or nectar as you choose. It comes down into us through the crown of our head and descends down our body.

As it does that, we imagine that we are eliminating from our mental continuum all the obstacles and obscurations that we have, all the mental and emotional afflictions, all the limitations that constrain us and compel us to not be able to cultivate pure virtue. We try in this first process to imagine that all these negativities are cleansed from our body through this downward sweep of light or nectar. And secondly, we imagine ascending, coming up through our body, that this light or nectar in the place where we once had limitations and obscurations. Now we imagine that all good qualities are arising within our mind and that all the virtue, accumulation of virtue, and all the insight and the loving compassion, wisdom that we seek to generate within our mind all grow and become stronger within our minds. And the third part is where we imagine from our heart, the light rays are like turning a light on in a dark room where we think that we have been able to accomplish and therefore perform the task of a bodhisattva who is dedicated to bringing loving kindness and compassion into their relations with all living beings.

And finally, after you’ve done the threefold purification process, imagine that the Buddha, just pleased by the practice that we’ve performed, descends down into us through our crown and into our heart and resides at the very deep center of our heart. And from this point onwards throughout the day, we imagine that our nature and the nature of a Buddha are inseparable and that the nature of our mind is the nature of a Buddha’s mind. And this is the threefold purification practice, and we can spend a few moments in our own time going through this process. So just to—we are studying the text by Namkha Pel called Training the Mind Like Rays of the Sun. We’ve started this text some time ago and you remember that at the beginning Namkha Pel first went through the lineage of teachers and students who engaged in the various forms of Lojong training and the way in which the Lojong practices changed and were modified by different teachers and in the way that they passed on their realizations to their students.

We remember that we followed the story of the great Geshe Chekawa who first studied Langri Tangpa’s Eight Verses for Mind Training and became very passionate about understanding and learning the Lojong techniques. We remember that we followed the doubts that he had about the practice and the clarification that he sought from other teachers. And by so doing, Namkha Pel demonstrated for us the importance of seriously analyzing everything that is taught in relation to Lojong and satisfying ourselves that it is the practice that it is said to be. After we went through the lineage of teachers, we came to the preliminary practice for Lojong. We remember we went through step by step understanding all the benefits we have as free and fortunate human beings and the need that we had to take the essence of our good fortune and put it to the best possible purpose.

We went through the limitations and faults of cyclic existence. We went through all the various meditations that it is suggested that we must train in before we begin the actual practice. Then we came to the point where we began the cultivating of the conventional awakening mind or bodhicitta. And we started off by going through by saying that there were two techniques for being able to abandon self-cherishing and cultivate cherishing of others. There was one school of thought and there’s another school of thought of Śāntideva.

And Śāntideva’s method was the one that Geshe Chekawa practiced, was most closely related to. And so we then went through all the various aspects of understanding that what is at the root of our problems is self-cherishing. And we went through all the various faults and problems that arise from self-cherishing. And we covered the importance of why we should develop cherishing of others in place of cherishing ourselves. And we came up to last week, we reached a point where people have the English book. I think we’re up to page 454 in that book. And we’re talking about now that it is on the basis of all other living beings that we are able to engage in the practices that enable us to generate the mental qualities to advance in our practice. And for that reason, remember we left with the words last week: Since all sentient beings have a portion of the Buddha’s supreme qualities, for this reason alone, sentient beings are worthy of respect, and that’s the point from which we’ll continue on today.

So the text continues by saying, it is said that having the attitude of cherishing others and accomplishing benefit and happiness for other living beings causes us to attain elevated status and definite goodness. We understand that it is on the basis of other living beings that we are able to engage in the practices from which we accrue the most personal benefit in terms of the development of our practice. And on the basis of the behavior of other living beings, for instance, we’re able to cultivate patience with sentient beings, and patience is one of the virtues that enable us to not only generate loving kindness and compassion within our mind stream, but also elevates our accumulation of virtue that will affect our future rebirths and the kinds of enjoyments and personal qualities that we are likely to have as we take future rebirths.

The text goes on to say that by neglecting or abandoning living beings gives rise to all manner of troubles. And so this part of the text implies that if we neglect and abandon living beings, then invariably we are privileging our own agency and perceiving ourselves to be the center of the universe by which all things should be directed and judged, and it is in that state of self-cherishing that we invariably give rise to a vast array of mental and emotional afflictions that come and inhibit our ability to accumulate virtuous merit. And from this store of virtuous merit, we’re not going to be able to attain pleasurable rebirth. We, in fact, will not enjoy those rebirths and will be afflicted by unfortunate rebirths.

Therefore, when we say that cherishing ourselves at the expense of cherishing others gives rise to all manner of troubles, it refers to this point that on the basis of our own self-centered attitude, we are very unlikely to be able to accrue the virtue, the wisdom, the loving kindness, and the compassion that we need to be able to advance ourselves and cultivate our mind. And there is a quote from Nāgārjuna in his Commentary on the Awakening Mind that expresses this in verse. It says, in this world, pleasant and miserable existences are the desired and unwanted results that arise from helping or harming sentient beings.

And once again, the point is made. When we engage in practices that are motivated by the desire to bring benefit to living beings, it brings pleasant results. The virtue that we accumulate will bring good results for us. But if we are motivated by self-cherishing and do not privilege the needs of others above ourselves, then we will experience a lot of unfortunate or miserable rebirths and experiences. So we continue with the quote that says, should you rely on other living beings, you will gain the unsurpassable fully awakened state.

There is not a single person in the three realms who has not taken birth as Brahma, Indra, or Vishnu, the protectors of the world, solely through helping sentient beings. What could be more marvelous than that? So once again, it establishes that in terms of all these rebirths as a human or as a god, we’re able are all dependent on accumulating the virtue that gives rise to such enjoyable rebirths, and that these rebirths, by being dependent on this accumulation of virtue, rely on sentient beings, we rely on other sentient beings, other living beings to be able to practice in such a way that we will accumulate this virtue. And once again, so not only is it possible that we can attain the fully awakened state on the basis of our relationships with other living beings, but all the other states of gods and humans, all these other pleasurable rebirths too are dependent on the nature of our relationship with other living beings.

And the quote goes on: The many types of sufferings experienced by sentient beings as hell beings, animals, and hungry ghosts arise from harming sentient beings. The miseries of hunger and thirst, eating one another, and being overwhelmed by pains that are unrelenting and difficult to avoid are the result of harming sentient beings. So just as we’ve established that the nature of our relationship with other living beings is the basis upon which we will generate vast amounts of virtue or non-virtue. We’ve established that on the basis of if we make the nature of our relationship with other living beings guided by the principle to bring benefit to them and enjoyment to them, that we are likely to attain higher rebirths. But conversely, if the nature of our relationships with other living beings is driven by a sense of neglect towards the happiness and welfare of other living beings, the only possible result that will come about on the basis of those actions is that the rebirth that we experience in the future will be characterized by suffering. They’ll be suffering to even extreme levels of the hell realms.

So all of these virtue and non-virtue results depend on the nature of our relationship with other living beings. One depends on us being motivated to bring benefit to other living beings and the unfortunate rebirths where we are motivated not by cherishing others, but by being indifferent or in fact causing harm to other living beings. So Namkha Pel goes on to say, a person training in the lesser vehicles cast off their concern for other living beings. Therefore, no matter how successful they are in their practice, they will only ever retain a very small portion of what the complete enlightenment is like.

So a person of the lesser vehicle who is not motivated by concern for other living beings, even whatever great success they have in their trainings, they will never fully achieve the most complete state of enlightenment. However, when a person trains in the practices of the Mahāyāna great vehicle that revolves around this idea that it is crucial to cherish other living beings. The person who is able to base their practice on this motivation to cherish other living beings is able therefore to accrue the benefits and the supreme results of unsurpassable enlightenment.

And there is another quote from Nāgārjuna from the same text, Commentary on the Awakening Mind. Nāgārjuna says, you should vigorously reject as if it were poison, a lack of affection for sentient beings. Since hearers lack such a feeling, won’t they attain an inferior enlightenment? So again, on this point Geshe-la reminds us that just as it is abhorrent and distasteful to us to imagine taking poison, then so too should our sense of not cherishing others. Every time we feel ourselves not motivated by the desire of cherishing others, then it is like the taste of poison that’s being introduced into our bodies.

And it’s referred to again that in the lower vehicle trainings where this motivation to bring benefit to all living beings, this motivation to cultivate the greatest possible compassion and loving kindness for all living beings, where this is absent, then it is simply not possible to attain the kind of enlightenment that is described in the Mahāyāna teachings because the Mahāyāna teachings all base their version of enlightenment on the basis that one is able to bring spontaneous and perfect benefit to all living beings.

Nāgārjuna goes on to say, as those who never completely forsake sentient beings will attain the enlightenment of complete awakening, how could those who examine the results of harming or helping others remain attached for a single instant to their own welfare? Again, Geshe-la comments on this by saying that it is a process of investigation that we ourselves should make in terms of the possible outcomes of practice. If we see two different versions of practice, won’t we investigate what the best possible result or fruit of these practices is to help us determine which is the one worth devoting ourselves to. And if we understand that the complete enlightenment is by its very nature driven by the great compassion that wishes to bring benefit to all beings. Isn’t it quite obvious when we make that investigation that when it comes down to us making a decision in terms of our relationship to other living beings, when it comes down to the decision we make whether we should harm or bring help to others, isn’t it obvious given our investigation of the possible results, the possible fruits of our actions, isn’t it impossible for us to imagine that doing anything other than benefiting others is what is most beneficial not only to ourselves but ultimately to all living beings?

And this is the point that Nāgārjuna explains in verse and Geshe-la stresses this process of examining the results for us to be satisfied on what the nature of our relationship with other living beings should be. So Namkha Pel continues. And for people with the English book, we come to another part where there’s a little bit of an issue I have with the grammar of the translation of this first piece. And I spent a lot of time going through with Geshe-la to try and just pin down the point on which the meaning changes a little bit from what is written in the English, but how pedantic I’m being, I’m not sure. But other than to say, the harm other living beings now appear to be doing to us is fundamentally caused by the mental and emotional afflictions in living beings’ mind streams occurring since beginningless time.

Now the English as it appeared in this book says presently appear to be doing us is fundamentally caused by the disturbing emotions in our own mind streams. And it’s at that point that I have a little bit of difference that I think what the Tibetan really is saying is that it is in the mind streams of all living beings that there is this, that the reason that harm is being done is fundamentally caused by their mental and emotional afflictions. Okay? So it’s kind of a small point, but I think it makes a difference to what follows.

The cooperative conditions are the imprints from the harm we have done to others since beginningless time. So we ourselves have engaged in doing harm to others. Therefore, we will find ourselves being the cooperative condition in which the imprints in another person’s mind stream are going to be able to come to fruit. We understand that when someone accumulates karma, then for that karma to come to fruition depends on cooperative conditions. So we are providing the cooperative conditions in which someone else’s potential for doing harm is able to flourish. Okay. So we ourselves are creating the cooperative condition in which another person who has the karmic potential for doing harm is going to actually experience the fruit of that potential.

So due to the activation of such causes and conditions, those who harm us are motivated by bad thoughts, they then engage in various harmful and misguided behaviors towards us. So in general throughout the endless cycle of existence, the blame for our experience of suffering, in particular, the sufferings of the three bad rebirths stem from self-cherishing. So this is what Namkha Pel says, and he uses a quote from Śāntideva to express this. He says, having been provoked by my actions, harm befalls me. If by their involvement sentient beings are thrown into hell, am I not destroying them?

So therefore, this goes back to the first sentence of that section which says that it is within the mind streams of other living beings the potential to be able to do harm to others. And we, creating the cooperative conditions, are enabling that potential to come to fruition and to flourish and therefore they accrue more negativity. Right? So in that light, we see that the quote from Śāntideva that says, am I not destroying them? This is where we bear responsibility—where it is not true that we can say that we’re causing another person’s—no one will experience the fruit of an action they haven’t created the cause for.

But by creating the cooperative conditions, we’re actually participating in the activation of this potential other beings have for doing harm. And by creating these cooperative conditions, are we not, as Śāntideva says, am I not destroying them? Am I not creating the circumstances by which their negative potential is able to flourish? So Namkha Pel goes on to say, especially now as we are entering the door of the Mahāyāna great vehicle teachings, these beings can harm us in many different ways. They therefore create great obstacles for themselves to ever enter the great vehicle teachings and so they will suffer in saṃsāra and experience the three bad rebirths.

So while it is that we are trying to devote ourselves to a virtuous path, there are people who make it very difficult for us to be able to maintain the trajectory that we would like to set ourselves upon and people causing us various kinds of harm along the way. Now at the point of experiencing this harm, it’s important to remember that if they are causing harm to us at this time as we’re trying to engage in great vehicle practices, surely they are creating the causes that will make it very difficult for them themselves to enter into such trainings, to enter into the great vehicle path. And not only is it going to be difficult for them to enter into the great vehicle path, they are also going to experience a lot of suffering on the basis of the harm they are doing. They’ll experience suffering within cyclic existence as we know it, the round of births that we take for good and for bad.

But people who continually engage in causing harm to others invariably will experience the three, what are called the three bad rebirths or the three lower rebirths where it is very difficult to enjoy any happiness or to be able to practice any virtue. So when we are in the throes of experiencing the harm other beings cause to us, it’s vitally important that at that time our response to that harm should be compassion because we understand that since ever they engage in a process of causing harm, they are setting themselves on a journey that will only end in unhappiness and suffering. As they take on all the negativities associated with causing harm, they themselves will have no other result but the negative results that come from negative actions.

Therefore, when we feel ourselves in a position of receiving harm rather than react against those people in any other way, it’s important to bear in mind what ultimately will be the consequences of the harm they are doing. It’s not specifically to us here and now. The harm will really come for them later on, and that’s at that point that we should generate great compassion towards the people who are causing us harm. Namkha Pel goes on to say, moreover, the ones who harm us, so where he says the ones who harm us, of course, we take from that human and nonhumans in terms of the harm we experience. Moreover, the ones who harm us have been our mother in previous lives countless times.

So we remember back earlier in the preliminaries where we talked about the nature of all the various permutations and combinations of social relationships that we experience over this enormous period of time since beginningless time in fact. So throughout this history, we’ve had numerous relationships, and the nature of our relationships have been very different in all of our different rebirths. So we’ve probably eaten their flesh when they’ve been reborn as animals. We’ve drunk their blood. We’ve gnawed their bones and worn their skins, okay, in terms of, you know, clothing derived from animals and so forth.

So from this, we understand in all the different permutations and combinations of social relationships throughout beginningless time, we have been in the position of causing harm and in the positions of receiving harm. And all these beings that we might perceive in this life are doing us harm. We bear in mind that in past lives, we may well have been eating them, drinking their blood, gnawing their bones and so forth. And in all these previous lives, invariably, have been our mother countless times. And if we were to gather from all these rebirths, the mother’s milk that we have received from all these living beings, no vessel could contain it. Okay.

So again, this is a point out to us that the number of rebirths that we have had is limitless. The nature of our relationships with other living beings goes through a great many different variations. The ones who harm us now are perhaps the people we have harmed in the past. The ones who harm us now perhaps have been our mothers who have shown us great kindness in the past. Namkha Pel says, the times we have killed, beaten, and robbed others can’t be counted.

So again, if we go back through our previous rebirths, it is impossible to believe otherwise that we have not engaged in all kinds of misdeeds towards other living beings. So on every occasion through our history, we have taken the kindness for granted of other living beings, and we should remember our debt to them thinking, it is my duty to remember your kindness. And you imagine that we have accumulated all kinds of karmic potentials and that in a situation where karma is ripening and we are on the receiving end of harm, then that is the nature of karma and that is the nature of our karma being exhausted and we should be thankful that these beings are participating in us being able to reduce all our karmic debts.

And in such a way we can imagine that we remember this as a moment where we can generate some kindness and appreciation that, you know, karmically there are many situations where, to put it in the colloquial, where we had it coming so to speak. And that we understand the relationship that other living beings have to us throughout all these different permutations and combinations of social relationships. So identifying those we see as our enemies or the people—and by enemy, we understand that it is anyone that we feel is doing us harm. So identifying those we see as our enemies by means of Tonglen, we should enhance our capacity for loving kindness and compassion.

Now Tonglen is the practice whereby we imagine that the happiness that we’re able to experience, we give over to another living being. And from that other living being, we take from them the suffering that they are experiencing. And this is a practice that we are able to do when we’re engaged in a transaction with an enemy because it’s very glaring that suffering is occurring and that there is a lack of compassion and loving kindness. So in particular, we can rely on those who harm us as they provide the basis for us to practice patience. Even the six perfections of practice in dependence on them.

So people who harm us are the objects we can meditate on when we are practicing patience. So remember that when we engage in a meditation practice, we always have an object of focus in our practice. And so sentient beings are able to be that object of our meditational focus when we are meditating on patience. And it is on the basis of the people doing us harm that we have to draw on the greatest psychological strength we have to engender this feeling of patience. Okay.

Now when I went through this with Geshe-la during the week, I had some questions about this point. And what Geshe-la said was that we must not confuse the process that we go through in seeing our enemies as being of great benefit to us for our practice with allowing people in our daily life who seek to harm or curtail us as being people we should allow to flourish and assume great power and control over us. So in as applied to daily life in worldly affairs, we can’t be weak or allow ourselves to be manipulated or trampled by others who seek to cause us harm. What Lojong is focusing on, what Lojong focuses on is deep within our minds, the mental state that we have in response to these situations, deep down within our mind.

It is not telling us in terms of our worldly affairs to be weak. It is saying that deep within our minds, what we harbor deep within our minds as a result of the harm other people cause us is where we should be practicing this process of compassion, loving kindness, and patience. We need to deal with people who cause us harm skillfully and not allow them to flourish and have excessive power or control over us. But deep down within our practice, when we’re doing our meditation practice, this is where we are having the most profound effect on the future of our own mind, and it is at that time that we need to be not harboring any grudges or sense of revulsion to this harm. It is at this point that we are generating this practice of compassion, loving kindness, and that ultimately these six perfections and the practice of patience are all best done on these people who cause us harm.

But again, Geshe-la stressed. This is not to confuse with the way we conduct our normal social interactions. This is deep within our minds when we are in a state of reflection and meditation. Namkha Pel goes on to say, if we have patience, the two perfections—and we’re remembering he referred previously, in the previous paragraph, to the six perfections—that if we have patience, the two perfections of generosity and ethics will have proceeded to that state of generating patience. And then on the basis of having generated patience, the other perfections will be practiced, that is, for example, effort, meditative stability, and discriminating intelligence.

So when we think deeply on the meaning of this, it means that on the basis of someone doing us harm, we are in fact able to engage in a great number of virtuous mental states. And if we fully understand the significance of this, we understand that every time someone causes us harm, every time an enemy or a foe, as you choose to describe them—since ever someone is causing us harm, they are in fact, and Namkha Pel says, it’s like them placing complete enlightenment in the palm of your hand. It’s like them giving you the fruit of our Dharma activities because it’s on the basis of that harm that they’re doing that we are able to generate a very strong practice of patience.

To be able to practice patience really properly, it means that first, we have to think of generosity and ethics. Then we engage in the practice of patience. And on the basis of that, effort, meditative stability, discriminating intelligence, all these come as a consequence of this engagement of practicing patience towards an enemy. And this is an extraordinary opportunity by which we’re able to do a very profound practice. And this is why Namkha Pel says it like that—that every time they do you harm, it’s like them putting enlightenment in the palm of your hand.

So now we come to a quote from Geshe Chekawa who says, whether they are our enemies or dear ones, all are objects of disturbing emotions. Seeing everyone as a spiritual friend will bring happiness even when you are alone. So we understand that the basis of all behavior that is causing harm are the mental and emotional afflictions. Okay? Now whether someone is an enemy or a dear one, we’re able to generate great loving kindness and compassion which we have previously established is the aim of our great vehicle training that we wish to develop loving kindness and compassion to its absolute ultimate potential.

And this was another point that during the week I discussed at some length with Geshe-la. Geshe-la made these points that when we have our nearest and dearest, our loved ones around us, it is not so hard to generate loving kindness and compassion for them. It almost comes by nature. It just rolls out of us. But on the basis of people doing us harm, it requires much more effort, much more mental effort and commitment and concentration. And as we’ve covered these within the six perfections, it requires such a range of skills to be able to perfectly meditate firstly on patience and then loving kindness and compassion on people who are causing us harm.

Within the Geshe Chekawa quote, it says that we can see everyone as a spiritual friend bringing us happiness even when we’re alone. And Geshe-la referred to this point by saying that we remember back to the beginning of our studies here where we determined that it was loving kindness and great compassion that distinguished the Mahāyāna path from all other practices and that required the cultivation of great compassion for all living beings. Every time we’re able to generate it, we move forward on our path towards accomplishing our ultimate aim of complete enlightenment. So when dear ones are around us, then we understand that we can roll out our loving kindness and compassion. And that is a good thing.

We want to experience that loving kindness and compassion. We’re not trying to neutralize the loving kindness and compassion we have to our nearest and dearest. We’re not trying to reduce our intensity of loving kindness and compassion to them in relationship to the feelings that we have for people who harm us. What we’re actually trying to do is think of the loving kindness and compassion we have for our nearest and dear ones and match it. Match that degree, that level of loving kindness and compassion with our feelings towards the people who do us harm.

And because that takes enormous amount of effort, we can see that those people who are causing us harm are actually giving us a helping hand, are giving us great benefit and able to generate a very strong and committed sense of loving kindness and great compassion within our minds. It goes on to say, for example, a spiritual teacher or preceptor is very kind to his students by being the preceptor for the vows that practitioners take in order to gain liberation and complete enlightenment. So we can see it’s quite easy to see a preceptor as being someone who is very kind and someone who is able to set us upon the path for complete enlightenment.

But living beings who cause us harm, are like that too because on the basis of the harm they cause us, we cultivate patience, and patience is extremely hard to do when we are being harmed by others. And it is because patience is so difficult to really do well, the more harm that’s being done, the more patience we have to generate, the greater the mental strength and resolve we require. And that is what ultimately becomes the basis of our attainment of enlightenment is our conviction and our strength of our practice. So as Namkha Pel says, living beings who cause us harm are like that too because on the basis of their harm, we cultivate patience and that practice of patience, the perfection of patience is one of the causes of enlightenment.

And so there’s this Tibetan saying that Namkha Pel uses is don’t spit out delicious food once it’s in your mouth. And when I was speaking with Geshe-la, I thought it’s similar for us to say don’t look a gift horse in the mouth. Here is someone giving you an opportunity to do exactly what you need to be able to do to attain enlightenment. Who’s someone giving you that great opportunity? So when someone causes you harm, actually, it’s a great opportunity for practice.

We come to a quote by Śāntideva from The Bodhisattva’s Way of Life. Therefore, like finding treasure in my house without any effort on my part, I should be delighted that my enemy becomes my friend in my efforts for enlightenment. And so again, this is the point whereby thanks due to the harm being caused to us, are engaging in the practices that are the basis of attaining enlightenment. And so therefore, the person who causes harm is in fact a friend or a colleague, peer in us striving for enlightenment.

Another quote from Śāntideva is: When anyone abuses me or even when others do me harm, when they afflict me in such ways as these, may they all have the fortune to gain enlightenment. So Geshe-la said, just as we can derive from that situation the basis upon which we will attain enlightenment, we should also have the sense that they themselves should be so lucky as to be able to have this opportunity to put to practice the actual causes for enlightenment. And once again, I just refer you to the previous points that Geshe-la made. These are advices that are not meant to color the way you go about your worldly relationships and social relationships. These processes of seeing someone who’s causing you harm as a friend and is benefiting you. This all happens deep within your mind during your meditation training. This is not a direction as to how to go about your life in your worldly affairs.

In fact, we must develop the skillful means whereby we’re able to limit another person’s capacity to do harm, not just to ourself, but to others. We must be forever mindful that people who are motivated by causing harm shouldn’t be allowed to flourish and have free reign and gather power in this world. But when we as practitioners having gone through the preliminary practices, having gone through all the meditations, when we sit in our meditation session and decide what is it to be imprinted on my mind from this experience. I will imprint on my mind from this experience loving kindness and compassion. Even if from your mouth, you had to repel someone, you had to constrain them, you had to admonish them, scold them, do whatever was necessary to protect yourself and others in an adverse situation. Even if that’s what you’ve had to do from your mouth in that situation, in your practice, as you’re guarding over the imprints that that experience is going to imprint on your mind, that is the point at which you’re engaging these thoughts.

That is the point at which you’re engaging these ideas that that harmful person has actually been of great benefit to us in our practice. And again, Geshe-la to stress this point over and over again throughout the teachings. This is in relation to our meditation practice and not the way to conduct ourselves in our worldly affairs. And so and this is where we’ll leave it for today. And, again, if you have any questions, you can either leave them up here with me or email them to me at [email protected].

So if you email questions to me, then I’ll give them to Geshe-la during the week, and we can answer them next Sunday. Okay. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top