Awakening Heart — 2010-07-25

1 h 25 min · 6,914 words · 25 July 2010

The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2010-07-25
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 85-minute session, a Buddhist teacher guides practitioners through a Lojong (mind-training) commentary on Namkha Pel’s “Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun,” focusing on karma and the faults of saṃsāra. After setting motivation and performing a threefold purification meditation, the teacher covers the certainty and multiplying nature of actions—how even small virtuous or nonvirtuous deeds accumulate into significant results, illustrated by the metaphor of a bird’s shadow and a traveler’s provisions. Key points include that once actions are committed, they cannot fade away, and that we cannot inherit consequences from others’ actions. The session then shifts to examining the drawbacks of cyclic existence: the uncertainty of relationships (friends become enemies and vice versa across lifetimes) and the fault of never-ending dissatisfaction, demonstrated through vivid quotations about consuming oceans of milk yet always wanting more. The teacher emphasizes that true transformation depends not on external salvation but on understanding karma deeply enough to redirect one’s motivation toward cultivating bodhicitta, the altruistic mind of enlightenment. Pitched at practitioners already familiar with Buddhist foundational concepts and preparing for formal bodhicitta training.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2010-07-25.mp3

UUID: cc7618ca-2a1d-4c2b-93fe-161a5591d6c8

Teacher: the teacher

Collection: Awakening Heart

Date: 2010-07-25

Words: ~6,917

# 2010-07-25

**Collection:** Audio Recordings — Unclassified
**Duration:** 85.5 minutes
**Words:** 6,927
**Model:** Deepgram Nova-3
**Corrections applied:** 19
**Transcribed:** 2026-03-08 00:01

—

So as we do before each teaching each week, we should set our motivation so that we may receive the teachings in the best possible way. We understand that none of us want to experience suffering, and likewise, we hope that all other beings will be free from suffering. We would like to contribute to the welfare of all other beings in the best possible way that we can. And to do that, the best way to do that is to attain the state of Buddhahood. In order to attain the state of Buddhahood, the central part of the practice is to be able to generate the altruistic mind of enlightenment, bodhicitta.

And for these Lojong teachings today, which are giving us a unique opportunity to cultivate the trainings that will enable us to attain bodhicitta and ultimately Buddhahood. And so for the purposes of bringing spontaneous benefit through all our thoughts, actions, and deeds to other living beings, we set our motivation today that we may receive the teachings in such a way that this altruistic intention may quickly ripen in our mind streams. So we should just take a moment to set this motivation.

So as we do each week, we begin by doing a threefold purification meditation. And we imagine in the space above the crown of our head, a small image of the Buddha from whom light rays or nectar comes down into our bodies. And we imagine that as this nectar or light rays descend through our body, the light rays eliminate all negativities and obstacles that prevent us from being able to engage in the cultivation and attainment of Buddhahood. We imagine that these negativities, the emotional afflictions, all the obstacles and hindrances are purified from our body. And as this white light goes down, down, down through our body, each and every one of these negativities is dispelled.

And then we can imagine that the second wave of purification ascends through our body. And as it does, it enables us to cultivate all the good qualities that we have previously attained and make these qualities grow and increase in such a way that it makes us suitable to be able to attain the ultimate goal of our practices. And thirdly, we imagine that having engaged in, one, purification of negativities, two, this cultivation of all positive qualities, we imagine that from our heart, light radiates out and that it creates a perfect mind and body capable of receiving the most profound teachings, understanding them, and putting them into action.

And we finish the purification process by imagining that the Buddha that sits at the crown of our head descends down into our hearts. And from this moment, from that point on, we imagine that residing in our heart, in our very essence, the nature of our mind is in this enlightened center of our heart. And from this point on throughout the day, we can carry this feeling, this sensation with us that in the depths of our heart, our very nature is that of an enlightened Buddha. And so we begin this threefold purification practice for a few moments now.

So we begin today. Just to cover: we are studying the Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun by Namkha Pel. It is a Lojong text that has at its essence the path that enables us to cultivate within our mind stream the altruistic intention, the mind of enlightenment, or in Sanskrit, bodhicitta. We’ve covered the text through the introductions that covered the history of the practice, the teachers that were the significant teachers of the lineage who have maintained the realization and teaching of this practice.

And we have entered into the body of the teachings where we’ve begun to talk about death and the certainty of death, and we came up to the point where last week, we reached the point of actions and their consequences. We started to talk about the certainty of actions. And actions, the word action—the word in Tibetan is lä, and the word that translators translate as action—the root is the Sanskrit, which is karma. So wherever you see the word actions, you can infer that that’s referring to the Sanskrit word karma.

So we covered firstly the certainty of actions in the results so that a virtuous action creates a virtuous result. A nonvirtuous action creates a nonvirtuous result. And then we came to the section on the multiplying nature of actions where Geshe-la explained to us that every time we perform a virtuous action, this gives rise to a cause that will generate a future result. And each time we do a virtuous action, we build up a storehouse of these small virtues. What we might think is insignificant, actually, all mounts up just as if we put money in a piggy bank. We can imagine that even if we put in a tiny bit each day, eventually, it will build up and produce a very meaningful result.

Likewise, non-virtues are exactly the same. No matter how insignificant we might imagine that a small nonvirtuous act may be, the trouble is that these nonvirtuous causes that we have created, they too pile up in a savings bank of sorts. And we, therefore, will experience a result much greater than the initial cause that we created by the very fact that we’ve accumulated so many small little causes. So Geshe-la stressed that this does not refer simply to the fact that you do a great big virtuous action and it gives you a great big virtuous result. You try and avoid a great big nonvirtuous action to save yourself from a great big nonvirtuous result.

We have to be very mindful that even these little tiny behaviors that we engage in that are negative, that are nonvirtuous, they will accumulate and they will build up. And the result will be far greater than what we imagined would be the result when we did this what we thought was a seemingly insignificant negative act. So this is the nature of where it says in the English book that some of us have that calls it multiplying nature, well, the word also is accumulative nature of actions. Okay? And so that’s the point that we came up to today, and we begin to pay—today for people with the English book on page 34.

And so we’re following on from a quote from the Special Verses Collected by Topic text. And we just—as we can see a bird in the sky that flies overhead, when a bird soars through the sky with its wings outstretched, it will leave a shadow on the ground as it flies through the sky. And likewise, wherever we go as sentient beings, we accumulate virtue and nonvirtue that follow us around like a shadow. And we come to some examples that demonstrate this point.

When a person sets out to go on an adventure, and before they leave, they don’t pay mind to what it is that they need to take and what provisions they will need on their journey. People who aren’t prepared will find that at the end of their journey, they will come to moments of great suffering. But the traveler who is able to prepare well for their journey, who is able to imagine what possibilities will eventuate in the course of their trip and what it is they might need and what it is that will bring benefit to them as they go—this is an example of people, like sentient beings, who go through life trying to accumulate all the virtuous actions that they know for certain will bring good results in future lives.

And the text itself says literally: just as the shadow of the bird accompanies it in the sky, so beings follow after wholesome and unwholesome actions. Just as the traveler with few provisions will suffer on the road, so sentient beings who do not do good will come to a bad end. Just as the traveler with plentiful provisions will have an enjoyable journey, so sentient beings who have done good will go to a happy rebirth.

And the next quote refers to the way that even small negative actions accumulate in the same way virtuous actions accumulate. Repeated amounts of small virtuous or nonvirtuous acts will create an enormous result. This is what’s exemplified by these quotes where it says: Do not do even the smallest wrong thinking it will do no harm, for the accumulation of drops of water will gradually fill a large vessel. And don’t think the little wrongs I’ve done will make no difference later. For just as a single drop of water gradually fills a large vessel, so ordinary beings become filled with wrongs collected little by little. Don’t think the little virtues I’ve done will make no difference later, for just as a single drop of water gradually fills a large vessel, so the steadfast are filled with virtue collected little by little.

And, again, this is where Geshe-la stresses the point that it is these small actions that we sometimes believe to be insignificant that we think is just a little bit wrong. It’s not a major catastrophe. It’s not going to cause major harm to anyone. But it’s the very fact that because of the certainty of karma and that karma remains until it reaches its fruition, all of these small non-virtues will most definitely accumulate and bring about results that seem far greater than actually what the causes themselves were.

And in the same—but as we should be—we should feel reassured that just as negative virtues accumulate in such a way, well, so do positive virtues. And positive virtues are the ones that enable us to achieve great results in the future. So we need to be very mindful of creating whenever we have the opportunity to create a virtuous action that we take that opportunity. We don’t see any moment as insignificant. We grasp every opportunity to create a virtuous action.

Now we come to the third point of the points we’ve been going through on the topic of karma, and we come to the heading: we don’t have to face the consequences of actions we haven’t done. And the text says, if you have not accumulated the causes, you will not experience the result, whether it be good or bad. So if you have not accumulated the causes, you cannot possibly experience the result.

And we come to a little section in the text that Geshe-la and I had quite a long conversation trying to decipher the meaning of the next sentence that comes along, which I have to say I had a great deal of trouble making sense of. Geshe-la did his best to try to get it through my head what it meant, but I’m still not sure I have got it, so I’ll do my best. It says: those who enjoy the fruits of the infinite collection of the teacher do not have to collect all their causes but must collect some. Okay. Now that was my translation. The text, the English book says, those who enjoy the fruits of the infinite merits accumulated by the teacher do not have to collect all their causes but must at least do their part.

So this is a little bit confusing. I found it confusing. What Geshe-la explained it to be: when we are able to enjoy the fruits of an enlightened teacher teaching us the nature of the path—and we enjoy the benefit of the Buddha having attained the state of enlightenment and having the wisdom and knowledge to impart teachings—so even though we haven’t created the causes to be enlightened, in many ways, we are experiencing the fruits of enlightenment by being able to receive the teachings from another sentient being, that being the Buddha, who has accomplished, who has created all the causes to become enlightened and is experiencing the fruition of those causes. So here we are from our side, we’re receiving all the benefits of enlightenment without actually—well, not all the benefits, but we’re receiving a lot of benefits of enlightenment by receiving teachings without having actually created all the causes that enable us to be enlightened.

And this is where it refers to: we enjoy the fruits of the infinite merits accumulated by the teacher. So we are profiting from the hard work done by the Buddha in that we’re able to receive this incredible inspiration to practice and accumulate virtue. And with the last line where it says, but they must do at least their part. Literally in the Tibetan, it says, but they must collect some virtue. So what it’s saying is: we’re in a position where we’re able to profit from receiving the teachings of the Buddha. We didn’t have to create the causes to be enlightened before we were able to hear what it takes to be enlightened. So we had to at least create the karma to get to the point that we could receive the teachings from a Buddha to be able to understand what it is to be a Buddha even though we didn’t create the karma to be a Buddha in the first place. So that’s what it means, if that makes sense.

And we come to the section that’s headed: once committed, actions do not fade away. So once committed, an action can never be lost. And Geshe-la was saying that once we have engaged in an action, that action will leave its karmic imprint, and that karmic imprint will eventually ripen. And now there might be people who would hope that there are some magical ways in which we’re able to get these negative karmic stores deleted for us by some external power or by some great gift or some kind of magic.

And the example that’s used is that of the Brahmins in some sections of the Hindu teachings that say that virtues and non-virtues can be transferred from one mental continuum to the other and that all we have to do is align ourselves with some great being who can transfer this store of virtue into our mind streams. And in the same way, able to expunge from our mental continuum all the negative virtue we have accumulated. The example is from the Especially Exalted Praise text. The Brahmins say that the virtues and misdeeds can be given away and transferred, but you teach that actions done do not fade away, and actions not done have no consequences.

Then we come to a quote from the King of Meditative Stabilization Sūtra that says: it is impossible not to encounter the results of your deeds, but you won’t feel the results of those done by others. So that, and this again is to distinguish the teachings of the Buddha from other traditions that talk about ways that non-virtue or sins can be completely deleted by an external force or power. It is impossible not to encounter the results of your deeds means that we most certainly—and it is a fact of nature that once we create a cause, we most definitely will experience it. And we need to take the responsibility for that.

But at the same time, we need not fear that in the future, we may be overwhelmed by terrible things that could happen to us as a result of what other people have done. So this line that says, you won’t feel the results of those done by others—this addresses the fears that some people have that they might be—that somehow bad things will be inflicted upon them, bad things that they have actually never created any causes for, but they will be entirely blameless, if you will, for some great big negativity that’s going to be forced upon them. Well, this quote from the text reassures us that that simply is not possible.

The Transmission of Discipline text quote says: even after hundreds of eons, actions are not exhausted. If they meet with the assembled conditions, then embodied beings will meet with their results. So again, this is referring to the fact that when we accumulate a cause, it stays stored within our mind streams and it will not be exhausted other than by coming to fruition. And karma only comes into fruition when it is conjoined with the appropriate conditions that enable that virtuous or nonvirtuous cause to ripen. So everything depends firstly on the action being created, but it also depends on assembled conditions being such that the fruition of those actions is enabled, is empowered to ripen. So if they meet with assembled conditions, embodied beings will meet with their results.

And at this point, Geshe-la makes the point that if we have thought well about all of these things, then it should become very clear to us that our motivation will be transformed. Our motivation will change as to the way we go about things in the future. If we really understand each and every one of these points, we will—we should, on the basis of having thought clearly and deeply about these things—our motivation will change because we will be fully aware of the fact of good things following from good things, bad things following from bad things. We understand that the accumulation of virtue will create virtuous results. The accumulation of virtue once created will never dissipate and that we most definitely will experience that virtuous result when the conditions are favorable.

And this is something that really will strike very deep into the very core of ourselves, the point at which we generate our motivation of how it is that we go about doing what it is that we do in life, why we do what it is that we do in life. If we really understand these points, we will come to understand that we must definitely put great value in even small virtuous actions knowing full well they will accumulate, they will create good results. And if we’re able to understand that the very most important thing for us is this attainment of the mind of enlightenment, this mind of bodhicitta. If that is our really true aim, then we’ve been able to draw from these points that we’ve covered a very clear way in which we are actually able to make certain that it will happen. We understand that it’s not a fanciful aim or dream, but we have a very clear understanding of how it is that it can come about.

The text says quite literally: remembering these points will obstruct the motivation that gives rise to black actions. And the points are: the certainty of karma, the multiplying nature of karma, or the accumulative power of karma. Three, that an action once done will not fade away. We must earnestly strive to perform white virtuous actions. Among the virtuous actions, the precious altruistic mind of enlightenment, that being bodhicitta, is the principal and supreme.

And once again, we have these two adjectives that are used to describe the mind of enlightenment, which is a theme right through Namkha Pel’s writings where he uses these great—the great supreme and principal in such a way when he talks about the mind of enlightenment. So the precious altruistic mind of enlightenment is the principal and supreme. Considering this will bring all of them into the practice of Lojong training. And this is what Geshe-la refers to: that once we have an understanding that all actions can lead us to a definite result, then if our aim is to be able to attain the state of bodhicitta, altruistic enlightenment, we now know a way in which we are able to draw every experience into the path that will set us up to this complete and perfect attainment of bodhicitta.

So now we’ve finished the four parts that referred to the topic of causes and their results, and we come to the section that is headed: the drawbacks of cyclic existence. And where the English book uses the word drawbacks, I tend to use the word faults, I think, is probably a better word than disadvantage. A much more truthful rendering of that translation. So the faults of saṃsāra.

Now we are—having understood the nature of karma and that causes create results and that wherever we go, we are followed by or some may say propelled by the karmic store that we have created in the past. Well, we all understand ourselves as embodied beings where we are made up of the five aggregates of form, feeling, perception, compositional factors, and consciousness, and that these five aggregates—what directs the course that our embodied life takes is often done by the mental afflictions or the mental and emotional afflictions so that when these afflictive states arise in our mind, they direct the way in which us as embodied beings act, think, and behave and therefore charts a future for us.

So on the one hand, we’re propelled by karma and the karmic store that we have, and this karmic store determines the strength of the mental afflictions that arise within our mind. And that on the basis of these mental afflictions, we then go and create more actions that are going to compel us to be further under the sway of karma and the results. And so this process—this process for embodied beings where we’re continually being buffeted by previously created karma that causes the mental afflictions to arise, and then the mental afflictions themselves produce more karma that will then buffet us around. And we can see that this is like a chicken and the egg going around and around, which came first. We’re just continually buffeted by previous karma, mental afflictions creating more karma, previous karma, more karma. And we go round and round, which produces the word in Tibetan, which is khorwa, which means round like a wheel. Khorwa, round. And that is the translation of the Sanskrit word saṃsāra, which we tend to translate into English as cyclic existence.

But the value of the word in Tibetan is that it much better signifies a process of going around and around and around like a roundabout. So the word in Tibetan is more—is a better signifier than cyclic existence in some ways because it’s more like the roundabout of existence if you take the Tibetan word. And so this is the point that we’ve come to now.

So now we come to—under this topic, the drawbacks of cyclic existence—it lists six topics that we will be covering, six topics that refer to the faults of cyclic existence. And the first of these six topics is the fault of uncertainty.

So as we go through this roundabout of existence, friends and enemies—and by friends, we might say family, friends, loved ones, people that we hold near and dear, and enemies. And while the word enemies might sound a little bit severe, enemies generally just refers to people we don’t have the great love and camaraderie with that we do with our friends. So at some stage, we go through life where we believe our friends—it’s very certain who are our friends and very certain who are our enemies. But in fact, the nature of this roundabout of existence is that these two things are very interchangeable and that the very nature of this roundabout of existence is that nothing is for certain. Nothing is enduringly the same.

So no matter how justified we feel we are to say, this person is not close to me. This person is not a friend. This person is in fact my enemy. And we, in other circumstances, feel entirely justified to be able to say, this person is my nearest and dearest, and this person will always be on my side. This is someone I can always trust. What we understand from the roundabout of existence is that in this world, nothing is certain in such a way. Nothing is reliable.

And the quote from the Friendly Letter says: your father becomes your son, your mother, your wife, and your enemies become friends. The opposite also takes place. Therefore, in cyclic existence, there is no certainty at all. So we can—and, again, Geshe-la stresses the point that when we go through life and we might identify someone who we believe to be a foe or an enemy, and we might feel completely justified to identify that person as someone who has aggrieved you and someone that is your enemy. But it’s important to understand in the context of these explanations that someone who you’ve identified as your foe is not always going to be your foe. They may well—you may well feel justified in saying this person is your foe right now, right in this instant because of something that’s happened. But you can have no certainty that this person is going to remain a foe in the future. And in fact, it’s quite illogical to imagine that they will be your foe in the future.

So tying yourself to this conception that this person forever and a day and for all future lifetimes is going to be your foe is a purely mistaken way of looking at the world. And we must be very aware of this because the really only thing—the only thing we really can count on is that, as we’ve covered before, that virtuous actions will create virtuous results. And by actions, we can talk about our feelings, thoughts, and emotions. And so it is the—what is going to endure from the situation, this transitory situation where you believe you’re in the midst of an enemy, what is going to endure, what is going to last is the virtuous or nonvirtuous karma you’re accumulating in this situation. Not that that person is going to be a foe forever. All that is definite is the way you respond to it is going to be most definitely a karmic cause that will most definitely one day ripen.

So we must not think for one moment that the nature of our relationships define the way we should act. What should define the way we act is our understanding that only good things come about from the cultivation of virtuous karma. So the text literally says: at times, enemies turn out to be friends and friends turn out to be enemies. Anyone can be your father or mother, and even your parents can become your foes because friendship is changeable like this. The intelligent shun attachment. The misconceived thought that relations are pleasant is replaced by the joy of engaging in virtue.

And so Geshe-la stresses that we should understand that when we have relationships with the people who are close to us, for example, our parent, our father and mother, or whoever it is that is the very closest person to us. We understand that by treating these people well and engaging in a relationship with them will create virtue. So the argument that everyone is interchangeable and friends become enemies and enemies become foes doesn’t distract from the fact that when you engage with people who have cared for you and who have helped you and who you have respect for, when you interact with these people and you respond with respect and love, you are cultivating virtue.

So it’s not just that suddenly you eliminate and neutralize all relations with people. It’s very important that you’re able to see that when relations are good between people, that it is an opportunity to create virtuous karma at this time. And you’re not simply saying, well, these may be my enemy in the future, so I will have no—I will generate no good behavior towards them at all. It’s simply not like that at all. When we do have people who we are close to, it is an opportunity to be able to behave with great virtue.

And now we come to the second point, which is called the fault of dissatisfaction. Or, literally, the text says, the fault of knowing no satisfaction. So this point of knowing no satisfaction, Geshe-la referred to the fact that no matter what it is that we enjoy today, whatever it is that we have, whether it’s food or anything within our circumstances that we enjoy, that we like, that we’re happy to have. We always think it could be a little bit better tomorrow. Whatever however delicious the food is today, it could be a little bit more delicious tomorrow. Whatever it is that we do, we’re continually thinking that it could be just a little bit more tomorrow. And in such a way, this is exemplified by the quote from the Letter to a Friend.

Each individual has drunk more milk than the four great oceans, yet in the ordinary person’s continuing cyclic existence, there is still more to be drunk. And as Geshe-la said, this is referring to the thing that we’re continuously feeling as if we’re just not satisfied and that we always want a little bit more, and we always want a little bit more. No matter how good the circumstance is, no matter how luxurious or sustaining each and every moment is, we just feel compelled to want it to be a little bit better. And so, again, we can imagine that no matter however much pleasure we experience, we just get into the habit where it’s never enough. It’s never enough. We’re never able to feel some pleasure and think, oh, that’s good. That’s enough. I am completely sated. I’m satisfied. There’s this tendency within us to always want a little bit more, a little bit more, a little bit more, a little bit more.

And as the next quote says from Nāgārjuna’s Letter to a Friend: understand attachment to objects of desire as being like a leper seeking for comfort. When tormented by maggots, he sits by the fire but finds no relief. And so we know that in India, there are a lot of people with leprosy. And when the sores start, that the sores continually—flies land on the sores, and the sores get maggots. And sitting by warmth—the warmth of a fire kind of relieves this pain that the biting maggots cause on their wounds. But the point that we’re trying to take from this is that because we are so attached to the objects of desire, because we’re continually striving just to completely buoy ourselves up daily with this fulfillment of desire that we continually create, we tend to continually create problems for ourselves in the future.

So it is this sense of not being completely satisfied that is one of the greatest faults. And it is a fault because it makes us continually strive for things that we don’t need and to turn experiences that should be fulfilling into experiences that leave us wanting more. And then we go on to the quote from the Condensed Perfection of Wisdom Sūtra that says: obtaining everything you desire and consuming much on a daily basis, yet still to be dissatisfied is the greatest disease.

And so this again is a perfect example of how it is that this sense of not being satisfied leads us into so many nonvirtuous states of mind and so many fruitless endeavors. And if we reflect on what it is that we are consuming day by day, we see that in so many ways, we have enough of everything that we need to be able to feel completely satisfied. And yet there’s this part of our mind, this attachment to the objects of desire, which just keeps jabbing away at us that makes us not be satisfied with all the good things we’ve got. And that sense of not being satisfied with what we’ve got, that itself is what is the greatest disease. That is a disease greater than any kind of medical affliction you might experience because if you’re unable to be completely satisfied with what you’ve got, then you will always suffer.

So there is no satisfaction in sensory pleasures. Because, and as Geshe-la says, when are you ever going to feel satisfied? When is enough going to be enough? How much more do you need before you’re ever going to feel as if you’ve been satisfied? And so the Sūtra on Avoiding Sorrow gives us some good examples. And by way of example, tries to reinforce this point into our minds to understand, well, how much do you need?

The water in the ocean bears no comparison with the molten copper you have drunk again and again in hell. The amount of filth you’ve eaten when you were born as a pig or a dog—which refers in India where pigs and dogs eat filth, unlike, as Geshe-la mentioned, on farms in Australia and in Australian households, dogs certainly eat much better than this. But in India, pigs and dogs really do literally live off human waste. So the amount of filth you’ve eaten when you were born as a pig or a dog would be much greater than Mount Meru, the king of mountains. As a vessel for all the tears you have shed when parted from friends and relatives in cyclic existence, the ocean would not be big enough. If all the heads cut off in the course of mutual conflicts were to be piled up, the heap would reach beyond the realm of Brahma. Born many times as a famished worm, the amount of earth and dung you’ve eaten would fill the great ocean of milk right up to the brim.

And so, again, these quotes are just trying to get the point through to us that: how much more do you need? Over and over and over and over through life, always wanting a bit more of something, always wanting a bit more. And as we mentioned before, the very word khorwa where it refers to a roundabout, we can see just how this sense of never feeling satisfied really compels us to never turn off from this roundabout. It keeps us bound to it to keep going around and around and around. No matter how much we’ve eaten, we want more to eat. No matter how much pleasure we’ve had, we want more pleasure. And this sense of not being satisfied, therefore, is what, as the previous quote said, is the greatest disease we could experience in life.

And so now: whatever prosperity you obtain, it is deceptive. So, and as Geshe-la said, if you’re not careful, good things that you’ve got can actually end up bringing about a state of mind that will create suffering in the future. This is somewhat of a ridiculous situation to find ourselves in, whereas where we have on the basis of having a great many good things, we actually create the causes to experience negative things in the future. And this is quite ridiculous. So we must be very careful not to turn what we have, the great pleasures that we have, into something that generates within our mind stream negative karma because the next time around as we keep going around and around and around and around this roundabout, the next time we come around in another life, we may well not experience pleasures to the level that we have them in this life.

All the things that we’re able to enjoy in this life that are actually quite luxurious and on the basis of which we’ve generated this sense of just not being satisfied, we may well on our next time around the roundabout take a rebirth where there are very, very few pleasures indeed. And it is quite ridiculous that on the basis of such luxury, we’ve created the causes for more suffering. And it is extremely important to be mindful that no matter how you may feel not satisfied with what you’ve got now, you may not even have this much in the future. So if you may not even have this much in the future, how absurd is it for you while enjoying these luxuries to actually be creating the karma to suffer more? It’s quite ridiculous.

So the text says: whatever prosperity you obtain, it is deceptive, and this is what it refers to. So if you don’t strive to practice to make—these changes could happen to you. So this is what we’re referring to: these changes in a future life where we find ourselves in situations where far fewer pleasures are experienced. And so we come to the quote from the Kadampa master Sharawa who says: from the first, you must face so many ups and downs here in cyclic existence, but nothing worthwhile. Think about this until you are convinced.

And this is the final point of the section on the fault of not being satisfied. So, again, just to stress the difference between the words that appear in this English book called the disadvantage, it is more literal from the Tibetan to say fault. So we’ve just finished the section that covers the faults of not feeling satisfied. And so this is where we’ll leave the text for today.

And Geshe-la makes the point that where we have arrived in the position of the text, we’re coming to the very last couple of pages of these preliminary practices, and it is the purpose of going through these preliminary practices to establish within our mind a very clear realization of our situation and determination to generate—to want to generate the causes that could lead to the mind of enlightenment, to bodhicitta. And in the next section that we will reach, probably most certainly reach next Sunday, we begin on the actual trainings of cultivating what’s called the conventional awakening mind.

So it’s very important that having received the teachings up to this point that you think about them very clearly and that you think about them very deeply so that you truly are able to adjust your motivation and your determination to want to receive and therefore act upon the actual trainings in generating the mind of enlightenment. And because we’ve got to the point where we will, in the middle of next week’s class, start the training on the actual conventional bodhicitta, it’s very important, Geshe-la says, that up until—we must take stock of all the things that we’ve covered to this point and be prepared for when we get to this next section that within your own minds, you are most certainly prepared and ready to start to receive the actual trainings.

And so this is what Geshe-la suggests you take home with you from today’s class. Okay. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Mount Meru
The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top