Teaching Summary Podcasts

Dismantling the Illusion of the Self — Khensur Rinpoche

00:00 /

A teaching summary podcast of Heart Sutra 2000 by Khensur Rinpoche, recorded at Buddha House, Adelaide.

Heart Sutra

Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche (Geshe Lopsang Tupten)
Tradition: Gelug school of Tibetan Buddhism
Venue: Buddha House, Adelaide
Recordings: 13 teaching sessions (October–December 2000)
Source: Corrected transcripts from the Bodhi Archive

Overview

This series presents a systematic and detailed exposition of the Prajnaparamita Hridaya — the Heart Sutra — delivered by Khensur Rinpoche at Buddha House, Adelaide, over thirteen sessions spanning October to December 2000. The series was the final teaching Khensur Rinpoche gave before retiring after twelve years of teaching at Buddha House; it stands therefore as both a complete doctrinal commentary and a final gift to the community he had served.

The Heart Sutra, known in Tibetan as Sherab Nyingpo (“the essence of wisdom”), is described by Khensur Rinpoche as “the gist of the wisdoms” — the condensed heart of the entire Mahayana teaching. It is the textual distillation of the vast Perfection of Wisdom sutras taught by Buddha Shakyamuni at Vulture Peak near Rajgir, India. Khensur Rinpoche situates the sutra within the context of the entire Buddhist path and explains it according to the Prasangika Madhyamika school — the Consequentialist Middle Way school — which he consistently identifies as “the utmost school of the tenets.”

The series is suitable both for newcomers who have some familiarity with Buddhist ideas and for practitioners seeking to deepen their understanding of emptiness (shunyata). Khensur Rinpoche frequently pauses the philosophical exposition to offer practical meditation guidance, vivid examples from everyday life, and moments of warmth and humor that were characteristic of his teaching style.

Key Teachings

Motivation and Merit: Prerequisites for Understanding Emptiness

Each session opens with the generation of bodhicitta — the altruistic intention to attain enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings — as the frame for receiving the teaching. Khensur Rinpoche follows the classical Tibetan formulation: generating compassion wishing all motherly sentient beings to be free from suffering, generating love wishing them to have happiness, and then the special intention of taking personal responsibility for bringing this about.

He cites the Indian scholar Aryadeva at the outset: to genuinely understand emptiness, a practitioner must combine wisdom with merit. He then cites Chandrakirti’s description of the ideal disciple of the emptiness teaching: a person who, upon hearing the word “emptiness,” experiences tears of joy and the hairs of the body standing on end — not from sentimentality, but because the teaching activates the seeds of understanding planted in past lives. Khensur Rinpoche says to his audience: “I’m pretty sure you have this, because you are all here.”

The two main “fields of merit” are Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha on one hand, and sentient beings on the other. Making offerings and prostrations to the Three Jewels and developing love, compassion, and bodhicitta towards sentient beings both cultivate the merit that enables the mind to engage with emptiness.

The Title: Bhagavati Prajnaparamita Hridaya

The Sanskrit title is unpacked word by word. Bhagavati (Tibetan: Chomdenma) means “great destroyer” — it destroys the four maras: the mara of disturbing emotions, the mara of death, the mara of the deva (external obstructors), and the mara of the body (tiredness, sickness). Prajnaparamita means “perfection of wisdom” or “wisdom gone beyond.” Hridaya means “heart” or “essence.”

The wisdom gone beyond is explained in three senses: the path gone beyond (the five paths), the text gone beyond (the sutra itself), and the resultant wisdom gone beyond (the direct realization of emptiness). The teaching has been called “the heart” because, just as consciousness arises from and gathers at the physical heart, the wisdom directly realizing emptiness is the heart of all the Buddha’s teachings — their most essential meaning.

The Prologue: Time, Place, Teacher, and Disciples

The text begins “Thus I have heard,” spoken by Ananda, the Buddha’s cousin and attendant. Khensur Rinpoche identifies this as showing the four excellences:

Excellent time — the time when Buddha Shakyamuni was present.
Excellent teacher — Buddha Shakyamuni himself (referred to in the text as “the great destroyer”).
Excellent place — Vulture Peak (Gridhrakuta) near Rajgir, India. Khensur Rinpoche describes the hill’s shape as resembling a vulture, and notes that “on those hills there are lots of tiny little stones and each stone is in the shape of a vulture.” He describes Vulture Peak as a supremely holy place: “By visiting those holy places it is said that one will not go to the lower rebirth for once.”
Excellent disciples — the bhikkhus and bodhisattvas, including 25,000 humans and bodhisattvas as well as countless gods, smell-eaters (gandharvas), and demigods.

The “unique prologue” then describes Buddha Shakyamuni entering a meditative equipoise on the “perception of the profound” — the categories of all phenomena — specifically in order to bless Avalokiteshvara (Chenrezig) to understand emptiness clearly enough to give answers to Shariputra’s questions. “Buddha Shakyamuni arranged the teaching. Shariputra and Avalokiteshvara were like messengers — like a prime minister who writes a speech and asks his secretary to read it out.”

Why Shariputra and Avalokiteshvara?

Shariputra, a Hinayana arhat of extremely sharp wisdom, was chosen to ask the questions because his very sharpness and his status as a lower-vehicle practitioner made his questions ideal for drawing out teachings that lower-vehicle practitioners needed to hear. The reason for his exceptional wisdom: in a previous life, he had seen a painting of the third Buddha of our aeon (Krakucchanda) and made a lamp offering with great devotion. “As a result of making that offering, he attained very sharp wisdom.”

Avalokiteshvara was blessed to give the answers because he possesses extraordinarily strong bodhicitta and compassion. “If the person gives the answer with great kindheartedness, it will have more benefit to the disciples.”

The Five Aggregates and the Four Emptinesses

The core doctrinal teaching begins with the bodhisattva Avalokiteshvara’s answer to Shariputra’s question: “How should those who wish to practice the profound perfection of wisdom train?” The answer: “See that the five aggregates are also empty of inherent existence.”

Khensur Rinpoche explains each of the five aggregates (skandhas):

Form — the body and all material phenomena.
Feeling — the aggregate of pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral sensations.
Recognition — the aggregate that distinguishes what is what, identifying objects.
Compositional factors — all mental factors and volitional activity; illustrated with the example from Vasubandhu: the plate is form, the rice is feeling, the curry is recognition, the person eating is consciousness, and all the hand movements of gathering, mixing, and lifting the food are the compositional factors.
Consciousness — the mirror-like awareness in which everything appears.

On this basis, four types of emptiness are applied to each aggregate in turn. Taking form as the example:

Form is emptiness — form is empty of inherent existence. This refutes eternalism: form does not exist by its own nature or on its own side.
Emptiness is form — even though form is empty of inherent existence, it does exist conventionally. “When we say the cup is empty, it does not mean the cup does not exist. What it means is the cup contains nothing.” This refutes nihilism.
Form is not other than emptiness — form and the emptiness of form have one entity or nature, though they have different names. Like the Tibetan words metok (flower) and another word for the same flower: different names, same entity.
Emptiness is not other than form — there is nothing empty other than form itself. The emptiness is not found somewhere separate from the form.

The same analysis is then applied to feeling, recognition, compositional factors, and consciousness. “If one understands clearly how to apply the four emptinesses on the first aggregate, then applying them to the rest are easy. If one does not understand the first one, then it becomes like getting the second stick on the head.”

Selflessness of Person: The Snake and the Rope

Beyond the emptiness of phenomena, Khensur Rinpoche gives detailed instruction on meditating on the selflessness of the person — which, he explains, should actually be meditated on before the selflessness of phenomena.

The key example is the rope and the snake. Early in the morning, in dim foggy light, a person sees a black-and-white coiled rope on the floor and, because they cannot see clearly, mistakes it for a snake. In that moment:

The rope is the basis of labeling.
The person makes the sound “snake” with their mouth.
A misconceptual thought arises: “There is a snake.”
A second thought grasps the rope as a snake.

Through these three — basis, name, and grasping conception — the “snake” is produced in the person’s mind. “For that person, within his mind, he has produced one snake on the table. That snake has been produced by depending on the basis of labeling.”

Khensur Rinpoche applies this directly to the “I”: the five aggregates are the basis of labeling; the name “Lopsang Tupten” is the sound applied; the mind that thinks “this is Lopsang Tupten” is the conception that grasps. “Through these three, the eye [I] has been produced.” The “I” that exists is the nominally labeled I, which does exist. The “I” that does not exist is the I that appears to exist by its own accord, without depending on anything — inherently, from its own side. That second I is the object of negation.

“The fault of Tashi existing independently or inherently is: if Tashi exists independently or inherently, then Tashi can never grow old. We never die. If the seed exists independently or inherently, then it cannot give rise to a sprout. If virtuous action exists inherently, then there is no happiness.” The very possibility of change, growth, causation, and karma depends on things not existing inherently.

Dependent Arising as the Logical Proof

The logical proof for emptiness throughout the series is dependent arising (pratityasamutpada). Chandrakirti’s logic: because the I is dependent arising — it arises by depending on its name, the conception that labels the name, and the five aggregates as basis — therefore it does not exist inherently or by its own accord.

Khensur Rinpoche explains three levels of dependent arising across the four Buddhist schools of tenets:

Gross: things arise by the meeting of causes and conditions (asserted by all four schools for compounded phenomena).
Subtle: things exist by depending on their parts and particles (asserted by the Autonomist Madhyamika school, capturing both compounded and uncompounded phenomena).
Most subtle: things exist by depending on the basis of imputation, the name, and the conceptual thought that labels the name to the basis (asserted only by the Prasangika school, and considered the most profound).

“Buddha Shakyamuni said: whoever sees dependent arising will see the Dharma. Whoever sees the Dharma will see the Buddha. Whoever understands or realizes the dependent arising sees emptiness. By realizing emptiness, one achieves Buddhahood.”

The great master Tsongkhapa’s Praise of Dependent Arising is cited repeatedly: “Whatever teachings you have spoken begin from dependent arising, and it is for the purpose of passing beyond sorrow.”

The Prasangika’s Unique Position

A key theme throughout the later sessions is the unique philosophical contribution of the Prasangika Madhyamika school. Where the lower schools say that if something exists it must exist by its own characteristic, the Prasangika separates these two: something can exist without existing by its own characteristic. Conversely, something does not need to be non-existent merely because it lacks inherent existence.

“For the Prasangika: if something exists, it does not need to exist by its own characteristic. And if something does not exist by its own characteristic, it does not necessarily mean that thing does not exist at all.”

This is what allows the Prasangika to hold the middle way precisely: phenomena are neither truly existent (eternalism) nor non-existent (nihilism). They exist nominally, on the basis of mental imputation. “Because it exists, therefore it is empty of inherent existence. By proving this, it establishes that the thing does exist.”

An important illustration: labeling gold onto copper is an invalid fabrication, because no matter how much you label it “gold,” copper will never appear as gold from its own side. But labeling “person” onto the five aggregates is a valid fabrication, because the five aggregates do appear as a person. The basis must be suitable for the label.

The Three Doors of Liberation

At the path of seeing, where the bodhisattva directly realizes emptiness for the first time, one arrives at the “three doors of liberation” (vimoksha-mukha):

The door of emptiness (entitylessness): all phenomena are empty of inherent existence by their own entity. “The flower, by its own nature, is free of inherent existence.”
The door of signlessness: all causes are also signless, free of inherent existence. “The seeds, water, and so forth — causes of the flower — are also empty of inherent existence.”
The door of wishlessness (prayerlessness): all results are unproduced inherently. The results of phenomena are also free of inherent existence.

“These three wisdoms are like the entrance of Buddha House — if one walks in, one can quickly, within a minute or seconds, be inside. Those three wisdoms are the door towards liberation. When one reaches those, one is like sitting next to the door.”

The Five Mahayana Paths and the Ten Grounds

A major structural framework for the series is the five Mahayana paths (panchamarga) and their relationship to the Heart Sutra’s teaching structure:

Path of Accumulation: developing bodhicitta and beginning to train in the wisdom of emptiness through hearing, contemplation, and meditation. For bodhisattvas with the lower faculty, this is where the wisdom of hearing and the wisdom of contemplation on emptiness are cultivated. One uses analytical meditation (checking meditation) to establish what emptiness means through logic. At the end of the great accumulation path, one attains calm abiding (shamatha) focused on emptiness.
Path of Preparation: divided into four sub-stages: heat, peak, forbearance/patience, and Supreme Dharma (chos mchog). One realizes emptiness “via the generic image” — not yet directly. When one attains the Supreme Dharma stage, one is at the highest level of ordinary being. A single-pointed meditative equipoise then pierces through to direct realization.
Path of Seeing: the first direct realization of emptiness. This is the entrance to the ten Mahayana grounds, the first of which is called the “Joyous Ground” — joyous because the practitioner knows they are very close to full enlightenment. The path of seeing directly counteracts 112 gross disturbing emotions and 108 obscurations to omniscience — a total of 220 obscurations — through eight forbearances (which directly apply the antidote) and eight cognitions (which lock the door so they cannot return).
Path of Meditation: maintaining and deepening the direct realization of emptiness through the ten bodhisattva grounds. The duration is much longer than the path of seeing. On the side of meditative equipoise, no conventional phenomena appear — no form, no sound, no smell, no aggregates, no sense sources, no constituents, no twelve limbs of dependent arising. “It doesn’t mean these things don’t exist. What it means is they are non-appearance inside the meditative equipoise.”
Path of No More Learning (Buddhahood): the Vajra-like meditative equipoise at the end of the tenth ground abandons the final obscuration. Within a moment, one attains Buddhahood. “One has no obscuration, no fear towards emptiness, and no reversible mistakes. Within a moment, one attains paranirvana — one attains Buddhahood.”

The Twelve Limbs of Interdependent Arising

The Heart Sutra’s section “no ignorance and no extinction of ignorance, no aging and death and no extinction of aging and death” addresses the twelve limbs of dependent arising (nidanas): ignorance, formative action (karma), consciousness, name and form, six sense sources, contact, feeling, craving, grasping, existence, birth, and aging and death.

Six are causes; six are results. Khensur Rinpoche uses a vivid local metaphor: “The cyclic existence is like the Royal Adelaide Show, and the kids go in a huge gigantic wheel. We circle like that. In order to stop the wheel circling, one needs to find the main switch — cut the wire connection — and the wheel suddenly stops. Likewise, one needs to abandon the root of the cyclic existence, which is ignorance.”

The “ever-afflicted” twelve limbs produce continued samsaric existence. The “ever-purified” twelve limbs — beginning with the extinction of ignorance — describe liberation. “By realizing emptiness directly, one abandons ignorance. By abandoning ignorance, there is no more projecting karma. Like a huge waterfall: if you obstruct the main source, you protect all the cities downstream.”

The Mantra: Gate Gate Paragate Parasamgate Bodhi Svaha

The mantra at the close of the Heart Sutra corresponds to the five Mahayana paths, understood as the training of the bodhisattva with the sharp faculty:

Gate (go) — Path of Accumulation
Gate (go) — Path of Preparation
Paragate (go beyond) — Path of Seeing
Parasamgate (go completely beyond) — Path of Meditation
Bodhi Svaha (may enlightenment be established) — Path of No More Learning (Buddhahood)

Khensur Rinpoche also explains the mantra as the “mantra of protection of mind” — the Tibetan word mantra meaning “mind” and “protection.” The wisdom realizing emptiness protects the mind by purifying disturbing emotions and abandoning obscurations. “The wisdom realizing emptiness protects one’s mind.”

Dependent Arising and Emptiness are One Taste

In the concluding teaching Khensur Rinpoche gives the essence in a single teaching from Tsongkhapa’s Three Principal Aspects of the Path: “Appearance stops true existence, and emptiness stops nihilism.” Because the law of cause and effect works — good causes give good results, bad causes give bad results — this establishes that phenomena do exist. Because all those phenomena are empty of inherent existence, true existence is cut. “Emptiness is dependent arising, and dependent arising is emptiness. Just by meditating for five minutes on ‘how emptiness is dependent arising, and dependent arising is emptiness,’ one cultivates vast merit and helps to abandon the disturbing emotions and self-grasping attitude. This is the essence teaching of the Heart Sutra given by Lord Buddha Shakyamuni.”

Farewell

The final session (13 December 2000) is Khensur Rinpoche’s farewell after twelve years at Buddha House. He says: “The teachings I have given you in the last twelve years are the teachings I have practised and trained in for numbers of years, starting from the age of twenty — the five major texts of the monastery, and numbers of tantric teachings, as well as special unique instructions of the great masters. All these I have given you as the lama’s special instructions, given with very pure and good intention.”

He urges the students: “Whatever you have heard, please bring all the hearings into practice. The purpose of listening oftenly is to understand the teaching perfectly and correctly. The purpose of knowing the true meaning is to practice. The reason for practicing is that one will overcome all the negativities, become enlightened, become a Buddha, and can benefit both self and others.”

He also announces his successor: Geshe Pema Tsering, a graduate of Sera Monastery with full Geshe Lharampa degree and training at a tantric college, who will arrive from Kopan Monastery in Nepal.

Key Terms

Term	Meaning as explained by Khensur Rinpoche
Sherab Nyingpo	Tibetan title of the Heart Sutra: “essence of wisdom” (sherab = wisdom, nyingpo = essence/heart)
Prajnaparamita	Sanskrit: “perfection of wisdom” or “wisdom gone beyond”; has three senses: path, text, and resultant direct realization
Emptiness (Shunyata)	Not that things do not exist, but that they are empty of inherent existence — they do not exist by their own nature, from their own side, or without depending on others
Inherent existence	The object of negation: the mistaken appearance and grasping that things exist independently, by their own characteristic, without depending on anything else
Dependent arising	The logical proof of emptiness: all things arise by depending on causes and conditions, on their parts, and on the name and conception that label them to a basis
Selflessness of person	The absence of inherent existence of the “I” that is labeled in dependence on the five aggregates
Selflessness of phenomena	The absence of inherent existence of the five aggregates and all phenomena
Object of negation	The inherent existence that is what we refute through reasoning; one must identify it clearly before meditating on emptiness, like knowing the target before shooting the arrow
Bodhicitta	The altruistic intention to attain enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings; the “method” leg of the path
Five paths	Accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, and no-more-learning (Buddhahood) — the stages of the Mahayana path
Three doors of liberation	Emptiness (entity is free of inherent existence), signlessness (causes are free of inherent existence), wishlessness (results are free of inherent existence)
Twelve limbs	The twelve links of dependent arising (nidanas): ignorance through aging and death; the mechanism by which beings circle in samsara
Path of seeing	The first direct realization of emptiness; the entrance to the ten bodhisattva grounds
Prasangika Madhyamika	The Consequentialist Middle Way school, considered the highest Buddhist tenet system; distinguishes between “exists” and “exists by its own characteristic”
Lhaktong / Vipassana	Special insight meditation; arises from sustained calm abiding combined with analytical meditation on emptiness
Vajra-like equipoise	The final meditative stabilization at the end of the tenth ground that destroys the last obscuration and achieves Buddhahood
Three Jewels	Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha; fields of merit for developing wisdom

Practice Points

Begin every session of listening to, studying, or meditating on emptiness with the motivation of bodhicitta. This transforms the activity into a cause for enlightenment.
Cultivate merit alongside wisdom. Without merit, the mind will not be capable of realizing emptiness. Make offerings, prostrations, and cultivate compassion.
Recite the mantra of Manjushri (Arapacana) to develop wisdom.
To meditate on selflessness of person, first meditate on yourself. Take the “I” that holds itself most strongly — the I you feel when accused of something, or praised for something — as the object of meditation. Ask: does this I that appears to exist from its own side actually exist that way? Use the logic: this I does not exist inherently, because it is dependent arising. Without the five aggregates, the name, and the conception, there is no I.
Use the snake-and-rope example as a meditation aid: just as the rope appears as a snake to the mistaken consciousness, our aggregates appear to us as an inherently existing self. In reality, just as there is no snake on the rope, there is no inherently existing I on the aggregates.
Apply the four emptinesses to form, feeling, recognition, compositional factors, and consciousness in turn. Master the first aggregate fully before proceeding.
Even if you cannot realize emptiness directly, simply knowing what emptiness means and training in the logic of dependent arising “harms the samsara or ignorance very strongly.”
Meditate on how emptiness is dependent arising and dependent arising is emptiness. Even five minutes of this meditation cultivates vast merit and weakens self-grasping.
Bring all hearings into contemplation, and all contemplations into meditation. “Don’t leave the hearing as hearing. Don’t leave the understanding as understanding.”
After this precious human rebirth, in the future, even a brief teaching from the future Buddha Maitreya will be enough to germinate the seeds planted now. “It is really, really hard to attain realization in this life — but by planting imprints on the mind stream, in future it will give birth to a sprout very quickly.”

This summary was compiled from 13 recorded teaching sessions by Khensur Rinpoche at Buddha House, Adelaide, in the year 2000. The full transcripts and original audio recordings are available at bodhiarchive.org.